Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 14:28

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:24

Modern language is definitely out. It's not his thing and one of his lower predicted grades for GCSE.

Other options in those blocks are

For film...

Criminology
Biology
Sport
Chemistry
Computer science
Maths

For Dance

Art
Sciences again
Economics
Religious Studies
PE

The only one he would consider is Religious Studies instead of dance but that would be the one he would drop anyway.

You’re going to get a heap of posters telling you now that he should chose maths or a science, I’d put money on it 😂

VickyEadie · Yesterday 14:30

I'm astonished that this school puts English literature and history in the same block - they're a very common combination. But drama and dance are in different blocks!

I'd be looking at other schools, frankly.

CraftyNavySeal · Yesterday 14:30

Glowingup · Yesterday 13:52

OP why would you go to mumsnet, arguably one of the snobbiest places online, to ask this question where you absolutely know what the answer will be?

It’s not snobby it’s just acknowledging how the world actually works.

When I did my a levels I had no one to advise me and I made daft choices that took me years to fix.

Make good choices whilst education is free and it’s your full time job because it’s never going to be as easy again.

Oggysfavouritecockroach · Yesterday 14:31

OP, my son did A level English literature, drama and music. (He could have done history but chose music instead.) He got A stars in all of them. He then got a First in English and drama from a Russell Group university and is now doing a Masters in writing at one of the London drama schools.

So if English with theatre studies or film is what your son wants to do, then it's a great combination. The main thing is that he wants to do those subjects and is motivated and he's therefore much more likely to get the grades he needs.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:33

Oggysfavouritecockroach · Yesterday 14:31

OP, my son did A level English literature, drama and music. (He could have done history but chose music instead.) He got A stars in all of them. He then got a First in English and drama from a Russell Group university and is now doing a Masters in writing at one of the London drama schools.

So if English with theatre studies or film is what your son wants to do, then it's a great combination. The main thing is that he wants to do those subjects and is motivated and he's therefore much more likely to get the grades he needs.

Thank you.

It's great to hear of someone succeeding with similar choices.

OP posts:
GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 14:34

Credittocress · Yesterday 14:27

Well if you’re so convinced he’s doing the right thing why ask.

For what it’s worth I’ve recently recruited people in marketing and social media roles and unless they had really strong work experience i wouldn’t touch someone with these A-levels, I’d assume they were the sort to pick easy options and be looking for a bit of a doss

My DD works in comms and marketing. She had AAA in Eng Lit, History and Geography and a first class degree from LSE.

Still had trouble finding a decent job. It's tough out there.

StandFirm · Yesterday 14:36

The 'issue' with those subjects, I would add (confirmed by some of the ill-informed responses on here), is that they're not valued for what they are and what they bring to the students. In order to stand out, the amount of work and the breadth of reading required is really high. The bar to achieve an A* is also high because over the years, the focus has been put so much on STEM that it's almost like kids are being discouraged from pursuing arts subjects. So, great if he's determined to have a career in the creative industries, otherwise steer clear... STEM has a much safer risk/labour/reward ratio.

TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast · Yesterday 14:40

I would question the quality of any sixth form setting that doesn't allow for the very common English/History combination. It's a bit like making it impossible to do maths and physics together.

Bramshott · Yesterday 14:41

xmasisacomingpart57 · Yesterday 14:19

I know lots of kids who have done Theatre Studies and English Lit but their 3rd subject has been History, Politics, RS, Maths etc. It’s total madness they won’t allow anyone to do English Lit and History. At DCs school there’s about 40 of them
doing English Lit A level and about 35 are also doing History. I would actually question whether I’d want my DC to go to a school that didn’t allow it as it just seems bizarre.

Hard agree with this. The college DD2 went to initially tried to tell us English Lit and History couldn't fit together but had so many students and parents unhappy that they moved things around and made it possible. It's insane to limit this when it's such a common combination.

Like a PP we were starting to look at other colleges alongside trying to get this sorted out and were strongly considering going elsewhere. You can bet they wouldn't let Maths and Physics clash, so why do it with humanities subjects!

Bramshott · Yesterday 14:42

Cross-posted with @TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast making the same point!

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:42

He doesn't want to do the STEM subjects and would therefore drop them or not get a good grade.

How is that a better bet than doing subjects he enjoys and should get good grades in?

That's what I don't get.

Is there any Uni or employer out there who would think a D in Maths is better than an A In film studies.

OP posts:
witheringrowan · Yesterday 14:45

It's unlikely that's the comparison employers or universities will be making. It will be weighing up an A in Film Studies versus an A in History or French or Religious Studies. And I think, rightly or wrongly, most will go with the A in a more traditional subject, and particularly so when he's already got a relatively similar A level in Drama alongside that Film Studies choice.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:46

He's gone off history now anyway so there's no point me pushing the school to change the blocks.

He would still do Politics if available but would never drop Drama so that's out too.

Do I have doubts about this school? Yes

Do I wish he wanted to go somewhere else and do "better" subjects? Yes

Do I think his happiness and wellbeing and the resulting likely higher grades is more important? Also Yes

OP posts:
TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast · Yesterday 14:48

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:42

He doesn't want to do the STEM subjects and would therefore drop them or not get a good grade.

How is that a better bet than doing subjects he enjoys and should get good grades in?

That's what I don't get.

Is there any Uni or employer out there who would think a D in Maths is better than an A In film studies.

Maybe not, but plenty would prefer a B in maths to an A in Film Studies. I agree there's no point doing subjects he won't enjoy, but the question in your OP was is the swap of History and Politics for Dance and Film a good idea. I don't think it is, and I think a sixth form that doesn't allow English and History together is of questionable quality.

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 14:48

STEM has a much safer risk/labour/reward ratio.

But not everyone is capable of doing STEM subjects at A Level. I couldn't have. There are maths teachers who post here every year telling parents not to encourage their dc to do maths if they haven't got top grades at GCSE.

MichaelmasDaisiesAndAutumSunset · Yesterday 14:51

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:39

So I keep using Uni of York as an example but for Law there the entry requirement is AAA - No specified subjects.

I really do think that apart from some obvious Maths or Science based degrees Unis, even the good ones look more at Grades than subjects. Things have changed.

Better to get an A in dance than a D in Spanish for example.

Yes but better to get an AAB offer for Lit, Spanish and politics, and get a B in Spanish, but get no offer with dance.

Why do you assume that a subject other than dance will be a much lower grade?

You say that things have changed but I suspect any uni seeing those choices might be concerned about how someone who has predominantly performance-based A levels would cope with the workload on an essay based subject. It’s not just the subject but whether the skills learnt in taking it are useful for the subject at uni. Dance and drama both seem to contain far lower levels of the skills needed for a Lit degree than politics and history. Traditionally arts subjects haven’t specified subjects to the same extent as science ones, but they generally still want academic subjects. I’d also be concerned his essay and analysis skills were not as developed as his classmates with traditional a levels, which would leave him catching up - not great first year of uni when so much else going on.

But you seem convinced they’re fine so not sure why you asked. Hopefully someone at his school will be more realistic than you and tell him it like it is.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:54

Why do you assume that a subject other than dance will be a much lower grade?

The schools results in dance, his natural affinity for the subject and lack of interest in other subjects.

See my previous response. I would rather he was doing more traditional subjects but I don't think it's as career ending and dire as many of these responses make out.

OP posts:
MichaelmasDaisiesAndAutumSunset · Yesterday 14:56

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:33

Thank you.

It's great to hear of someone succeeding with similar choices.

But they’re not similar. Music has a reputation of being brutally hard to excel at, and requires a high degree of literacy and mathematical ability (if well disguised). The same cannot be said about film studies’ reputation, even if that is unfair and wrong (I have no idea. It might be)

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:58

Film studies is an analytical, essay writing subject, similar to English Literature. It's not a practical one. Very little to no actual filmmaking.

It's not an easy option but sounds like Universities still view it as such.

OP posts:
MichaelmasDaisiesAndAutumSunset · Yesterday 15:02

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:54

Why do you assume that a subject other than dance will be a much lower grade?

The schools results in dance, his natural affinity for the subject and lack of interest in other subjects.

See my previous response. I would rather he was doing more traditional subjects but I don't think it's as career ending and dire as many of these responses make out.

So why aren’t you explaining the reality to him? Yes, you’d rather do that but do something safer with an open mind. If you don’t like it it’s only two years. Put your back into it to achieve a longer term goal even though you’d rather be doing something else. My A in chemistry a-level was produced following such a tough-love talk from my Dad.

I don’t think anyone is saying it’s career-ending; it’s worse than that - it’s risking preventing him starting a number of careers - including one he says he wants. It’s only fair to warn him - even if you think people shouldn’t think this way about it, you have fairly good evidence here that they do. Reality isn’t what it should be.

MichaelmasDaisiesAndAutumSunset · Yesterday 15:05

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:58

Film studies is an analytical, essay writing subject, similar to English Literature. It's not a practical one. Very little to no actual filmmaking.

It's not an easy option but sounds like Universities still view it as such.

Is it though? Most people will not accept that it is, whatever is the case in reality. It might be intellectual snobbery, but your son still needs to know how people think, however wrong they are. If it could stop him getting on the first rung he won’t get the chance to explain how it’s a proper subject honest. He won’t be speaking to anyone in the first place.

Everything you say might be correct but that doesn’t change perceptions. Which is with what he has to contend.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:09

Yep that's fair. Annoying but fair.

OP posts:
Bigtrapeze · Yesterday 15:13

OP, A levels are a slog. Do what you are passionate about would be my advice. Do what you enjoy rather than what you are good at. I think it's a good plan in life generally.

I had no interest in going to a Russell Group uni myself and don't mind whether DD bothers with university at all but some parents see this as a badge of success which will ensure their kids will always be okay. There are many ways to flourish.

I think Dance, Drama, English Lit and film studies sounds great. We'll be stuck as a country if everyone studies law. The competition for training contracts is huge as it is. He's well off out of all that, I reckon. It's a pretty congested pathway.

These are his choices, not yours, and from my experience, there can be a bit of wiggle room in the first few weeks, plus he will have the capacity to drop one, from what you said.

I did a primary PGCE and one of my classmates had a degree in Dance. It was much easier for her to argue degree relevance than me as it is a National Curriculum subject. You also don't need maths A level to be an accountant, for example. A few of my creative degree mates went in that direction after uni. He isn't limiting access to 'serious' jobs if he wants one in the future. Round our way the owners of dance schools must be doing better than the accountants given all the young people participating and the cost of lessons.

I think he should do what feels right for him now. Lots of university courses are disinterested in the other A level subjects but want grades. He isn't limiting himself here, I don't think.

There are going to be lots of graduates with very similar 'serious' A' levels and an English degree. He might stand out. The drama might mean he can hold a conversation, make a phone call and do a decent presentation. It actually might make him more employable than his peers.

Encourage him to make his own decisions, work hard and enjoy himself. You sound like you are and he is lucky to have that rather than a parent instilling fear about missing some kind of imaginary A level boat to lifetime job satisfaction and 6 figure earning potential via a particular university. I still haven't failed to get a job at interview because someone from Oxbridge got it, despite what we were repeatedly told at school.

The job market has never been harder to second guess. He should do what brings him joy not what someone else thinks would be sensible.

user47639820987 · Yesterday 15:14

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:29

Quite standard to pick 4 and drop one

My kids went to a pretty academic school, only the very very brightest carried on with 4 after Christmas and they tended to be doing maths/further maths/physics that had a big overlap.
One of mine did history/eng/politics, it was a tremendous amount of essays and they were sick of writing by the time they finished so definitely a good plan to mix some drama/arts in there if that’s their interest. Our school was very firm on only choosing stuff you enjoy.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:17

Bigtrapeze · Yesterday 15:13

OP, A levels are a slog. Do what you are passionate about would be my advice. Do what you enjoy rather than what you are good at. I think it's a good plan in life generally.

I had no interest in going to a Russell Group uni myself and don't mind whether DD bothers with university at all but some parents see this as a badge of success which will ensure their kids will always be okay. There are many ways to flourish.

I think Dance, Drama, English Lit and film studies sounds great. We'll be stuck as a country if everyone studies law. The competition for training contracts is huge as it is. He's well off out of all that, I reckon. It's a pretty congested pathway.

These are his choices, not yours, and from my experience, there can be a bit of wiggle room in the first few weeks, plus he will have the capacity to drop one, from what you said.

I did a primary PGCE and one of my classmates had a degree in Dance. It was much easier for her to argue degree relevance than me as it is a National Curriculum subject. You also don't need maths A level to be an accountant, for example. A few of my creative degree mates went in that direction after uni. He isn't limiting access to 'serious' jobs if he wants one in the future. Round our way the owners of dance schools must be doing better than the accountants given all the young people participating and the cost of lessons.

I think he should do what feels right for him now. Lots of university courses are disinterested in the other A level subjects but want grades. He isn't limiting himself here, I don't think.

There are going to be lots of graduates with very similar 'serious' A' levels and an English degree. He might stand out. The drama might mean he can hold a conversation, make a phone call and do a decent presentation. It actually might make him more employable than his peers.

Encourage him to make his own decisions, work hard and enjoy himself. You sound like you are and he is lucky to have that rather than a parent instilling fear about missing some kind of imaginary A level boat to lifetime job satisfaction and 6 figure earning potential via a particular university. I still haven't failed to get a job at interview because someone from Oxbridge got it, despite what we were repeatedly told at school.

The job market has never been harder to second guess. He should do what brings him joy not what someone else thinks would be sensible.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread