Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
stuffedanimalsandchocolate · Yesterday 15:18

I think it would be a good idea to do one artsy/"fun" A Level. But not two and certainly not three.

It's such a shame he can't do history or politics as well as English lit. It's crap scheduling from the school. I did English Lit and History A Levels and a hell of a lot of people did both, it's a popular combination.

Is there really no way around it?

Tell him to pick one of Drama, Dance or Film Studies and then two more serious topics to go with eng lit.

I actually worked in book publishing and my history A Level came in surprisingly useful.

bababamama · Yesterday 15:21

I wouldn’t suggest thus combination, most colleges wouldn’t allow them due to overlap and they are too narrow focused. I’d suggest swopping one applied subject out for history. One (or two if 4 a leveks) applied subject max to keep options open

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:26

Not come across one 6th form in the whole (big) city that stipulates what A Level combination you have to choose.

Maybe it's different where you are but as for not "allowing" a combination that has never been the case here. Student choose what they want to study.

OP posts:
BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 15:34

FWIW OP... my DD might not be allowed to do A levels, just BTEC and V Levels, including in subjects shes predicted 9s in, due to her spiky profile meaning she is struggling to get a 5 in English language. (On the 4/5 boundary)

But... she can still go to university!!! As they have confirmed, Merits/Distinctions in BTEC are still extremely good qualifications.
Not every child is going to be a doctor or a lawyer. In DDs case... she wants to be a Nurse or Teacher and she will be brilliant at them.

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 15:49

Maybe it's different where you are but as for not "allowing" a combination that has never been the case here. Student choose what they want to study.

Except that they can't study Eng Lit and History - one of the most popular combinations?

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:53

Due to (admittedly stupid) option blocks.

That's not the same as a student choosing 3/4subjects and the school saying no you can't do those, they don't go together or they are too narrow. That's doesn't happen here

OP posts:
taxi4ballet · Yesterday 15:56

Glowingup · Yesterday 13:52

OP why would you go to mumsnet, arguably one of the snobbiest places online, to ask this question where you absolutely know what the answer will be?

Maybe because some of us will answer differently based on our own dc's career pathways.

@Wanttobeok He won't need to have done ballet, but A-level dance has a massive contemporary dance element, so it would be useful if he could have some training in that before next September.

What about psychology instead of film studies? If he does English lit, drama, film studies and dance, he's going to spend a heck of a lot of his time doing much the same thing - interpreting the works of others. Psychology could help with that.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:59

I wondered about psychology but he's not remotely interested.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · Yesterday 16:01

Very odd to say people are advising you against these subjects for snobbish reasons. Why do you think that? Puts me off wanting to help you a bit-frankly.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 16:01

We know a few dance teachers who do contemporary so I've already suggested to him that we get him a few private lessons for technique purposes. Good point

OP posts:
Dahli · Yesterday 16:08

I work in colleges, these A-Level choices are great. If he’s passionate and he likes them, perfect choices for him. We have to do a lot of work to dismantle the snobbery usually from well meaning parents. Most Unis care more about grades than actual subjects studied (unless of course something mega specific like medicine). Even if your son decides to do a different degree after college and picked the ‘wrong’ subjects, there’s always the option of a foundation year or a higher or degree apprenticeship. For education or law, you do not need anything specific but English literature is a great choice for this and highly sought after. For lots of graduate programmes nothing specific is needed just a good final degree classification. Honestly from someone who actually works with students every day he will be fine!

taxi4ballet · Yesterday 16:09

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:59

I wondered about psychology but he's not remotely interested.

How is he going to read literature, watch films, dance works and plays, interpret the creator's intentions and the meanings behind them, and then use that knowledge to creat his own original works if he's not interested in the human condition and why people think and behave the way they do?

seahorsessky · Yesterday 16:11

I don't really feel I learned anything more valuable in English Lit or Politics than I would have in Dance/Drama. Basically analysing and writing about things.

taxi4ballet · Yesterday 16:11

@Wanttobeok If he's interested in all those subjects then he is interested in psychology, he just doesn't know it!

EppingIsFun · Yesterday 16:13

I think the combination is great, if it's what he wants to do. If he would prefer a different combo, he should look at different colleges.

taxi4ballet · Yesterday 16:13

Studying politics would drive me screaming to the gin bottle.

SillySeal · Yesterday 16:16

If he is truly artsy, it is difficult to get an artsy person to do a law degree or eant to go to a Russel group Uni, its just not who they are.

Has he looked at potential career paths? If he doesnt necessarily want to stick to performance, what are his other interests? Does he like writing, stage management, lighting, photography/ film etc.

Helping to narrow that down may give him more ideas about wether the choices he makes will work.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 16:33

CurlewKate · Yesterday 16:01

Very odd to say people are advising you against these subjects for snobbish reasons. Why do you think that? Puts me off wanting to help you a bit-frankly.

Edited

Mumsnet is horribly snobby about A level subjects (and GCSEs), it’s quite comical really and just doesn’t translate in real life.
Its usually:
pushing maths A level above others that the student would actually enjoy, to the point where people claim employers will look down on those without it.
insistent that a MFL is needed at GCSE and unis will not accept those without it.
PE GCSE isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.
adamant that sociology is looked down upon by RG universities and is not a proper academic subject.
steering away from “traditional” academic subjects is setting a child up for failure.
Predictably looking down on subjects like media, film etc.
Warning parents that unless their DCs get 8/9s in their GCSEs then A levels aren’t for them (any of them, not just maths where you absolutely do need to be very able to get good grades).

There’s more, too. All threads are pretty predictable.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 16:39

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 16:33

Mumsnet is horribly snobby about A level subjects (and GCSEs), it’s quite comical really and just doesn’t translate in real life.
Its usually:
pushing maths A level above others that the student would actually enjoy, to the point where people claim employers will look down on those without it.
insistent that a MFL is needed at GCSE and unis will not accept those without it.
PE GCSE isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.
adamant that sociology is looked down upon by RG universities and is not a proper academic subject.
steering away from “traditional” academic subjects is setting a child up for failure.
Predictably looking down on subjects like media, film etc.
Warning parents that unless their DCs get 8/9s in their GCSEs then A levels aren’t for them (any of them, not just maths where you absolutely do need to be very able to get good grades).

There’s more, too. All threads are pretty predictable.

If such is the case, OP is better off not starting two threads on MN for advice, no? Best to let her son be happy and choose what he wants. We are a nest of vipers completely out of touch with real life.

I don't see anyone suggesting maths, MFLs or 8s and 9s at GCSE on this thread though.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 16:49

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 16:39

If such is the case, OP is better off not starting two threads on MN for advice, no? Best to let her son be happy and choose what he wants. We are a nest of vipers completely out of touch with real life.

I don't see anyone suggesting maths, MFLs or 8s and 9s at GCSE on this thread though.

Edited

I was just trying to give a general flavour of what comes up on threads like these, typically, as you well know.

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 16:54

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:45

And to echo a previous poster one thing I do know is that Law degrees LOVE drama A Level.

I was going to say this and I know lawyers with Music degrees too. It doesn't matter what degree you did.

However, I do agree with keeping options open. English lit and Drama, sure. But get him to choose one more traditional subject. And he does not need to do four. Much better to concentrate on three and extra-curricular.

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 16:57

VickyEadie · Yesterday 14:30

I'm astonished that this school puts English literature and history in the same block - they're a very common combination. But drama and dance are in different blocks!

I'd be looking at other schools, frankly.

Agree, I think it's mad not to allow English lit and History too and would be wondering what the sixth form's teaching and results are like.

History, English lit and Drama would be a great combination.

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 16:58

I also don't understand why people look down on politics and media studies.

We'd be in a much better place if more people did them!

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 17:01

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 15:26

Not come across one 6th form in the whole (big) city that stipulates what A Level combination you have to choose.

Maybe it's different where you are but as for not "allowing" a combination that has never been the case here. Student choose what they want to study.

You do get some combinations that are't allowed.

I think my son's school didn't allow GCSE geography and BTEC in tourism together and at sixth form you couldn't do ancient history and classical civilisation. There may have been others.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:02

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 16:58

I also don't understand why people look down on politics and media studies.

We'd be in a much better place if more people did them!

It's unis who do. Not us 'snobby' people. They may say ' we accept any a- levels". on their websites. In reality, many prefer traditional subjects, or at least two traditional subjects. That's all some of us are saying.

Swipe left for the next trending thread