Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Yesterday 13:49

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:35

He knows what HE wants then. Despite what orhers nay think, they are proper qualifications. (As are T Levels, V Levels and BTECs).

I agree with this TBH. I mean, it's leading to a specific path and that's fine if that is his passion.

My DS is mad about film but sadly his school doesn't offer it and for many reasons we can't actually choose another one. So he is doing set of 'safe' subjects that he is just enduring, but doing a cinema-related EPQ.

I think the drive that everyone should be aiming for a Russell Group or standard sort of degree in something traditional like law is limiting and lacks imagination- and I say that as someone who is a solicitor and who did History, Politics Economics for my first 2 degrees then switched to Law.

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:49

This is the table from the FOI request showing subject success rates for law at a sample of Russell Group universities.

mindutopia · Yesterday 13:52

I think they’re great, but very focused on a performance focused path going forward. I’m an academic and I do admissions to our programmes (though not in the arts and humanities). He needs to work out what he wants to study at uni and work back from there to see if they are a good fit. I think they’re great complement each other nicely, but only if they set him up for the degree he wants to do. Don’t even think about careers yet. You can build a career from any degree if you’re insightful enough. But he does need to think about what he wants to do in uni.

Glowingup · Yesterday 13:52

OP why would you go to mumsnet, arguably one of the snobbiest places online, to ask this question where you absolutely know what the answer will be?

fairylightsroundthefire · Yesterday 13:52

Meh, I’d say let him do what he wants. Most unis bar the very very top ones will let virtually anyone in these days, so with decent grades in subjects he enjoys he’ll be fine. For example, DD’s friend got into Cardiff to do bio chem with BCD this year (may not be the best RG, but it’s still RG!) and another into Lancaster (not RG but considered high ranking) with BDE. I’d imagine 3 As, regardless of the subjects, would be fine if he wants to do an arts/ humanities degree. Times have changed.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:53

Glowingup · Yesterday 13:52

OP why would you go to mumsnet, arguably one of the snobbiest places online, to ask this question where you absolutely know what the answer will be?

I've not been in this site for a while. I forgot 🤣

OP posts:
twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:55

Glowingup · Yesterday 13:52

OP why would you go to mumsnet, arguably one of the snobbiest places online, to ask this question where you absolutely know what the answer will be?

Such a good point!

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:55

It didn't post. It is from the now defunt Centre for Education and Youth

Drama 100%
Further Maths 92%
MFL 90%
Maths 85%
Classics 83%
English Lit 83%
HIstory 83%
Economics 81%
RS 79%
Biology 76%
Chemistry 76%
Psychology 74%
Geography 72%
Law 68%
Govt & Politics 68%
Art 67%
Philosophy 67%
English Lang 66%
Physics 60%
Sociology 54%
Business Stud 50%

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:57

I do appreciate everyone's opinions.

I just want him to be happy and actually want to get out of bed in the morning and go to 6th form. I'm not worried about him getting into a University.

Right now he is set on a degree in English Literature, possibly joint with Theatre Studies or Film.

So his choices are fine for that.

I think it's highly unlikely he will wake up one day in 5 years and think "Crap! I wish I'd done medicine" Unless he gets a personality transplant of course!

OP posts:
Glowingup · Yesterday 13:59

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:49

This is the table from the FOI request showing subject success rates for law at a sample of Russell Group universities.

I teach law at an RG. Some law schools, eg Leeds and Manchester do have a limit on how many non traditional subjects they will accept. We don't have any such limit and would take the OP's son with those subjects if the grades were high enough.

ZippyKoala · Yesterday 14:00

All I think you need to do here is check with him that he understands where the choices naturally lead. If he wants to do a degree in performing arts and has no particularly university preferences (or an apprenticeship, or straight into job) then great! The most important thing is that he is excited about what he is doing and it sounds like he could do really well at these subjects.

But if he wants to study English Literature at York then it is less likely (though certainly far from impossible!) with these choices. Similar for other leading universities / traditional essay subjects. If he knows that, and is comfortable with that, no problems!

Career paths - might he enjoy teaching? Publishing/journalism definitely an option as you mentioned. Lot of local government grad schemes don't care much about degree subject.

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 14:03

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:55

It didn't post. It is from the now defunt Centre for Education and Youth

Drama 100%
Further Maths 92%
MFL 90%
Maths 85%
Classics 83%
English Lit 83%
HIstory 83%
Economics 81%
RS 79%
Biology 76%
Chemistry 76%
Psychology 74%
Geography 72%
Law 68%
Govt & Politics 68%
Art 67%
Philosophy 67%
English Lang 66%
Physics 60%
Sociology 54%
Business Stud 50%

What is the specific question this table answers?
Presumably its not suggesting that a 100% of students do drama A level and it definitely can't be 92% do FM which is very much a minority subject?

If the OP's son wants to keep his options open the problem is not Drama its the balance of the choices. English and Drama/Theatre is fine as a degree subject - there will be quite a few possible career paths but its also a subject where the awarding school does matter.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:03

I agree that he needs to make sure he understands the potential limitations, and I think he does.

OP posts:
GardensBooksTea · Yesterday 14:06

If he would still like to do history (& I appreciate he's fed up with it at the moment, but I think most things lose their attraction the closer to GCSEs you get), I think this is a complain-to-school scenario about their ridiculous option blocks. Not allowing anyone to do English Lit and History is total madness - it's one of the most common combinations of subjects in many places! Look at the complaints policy and escalate to governors if you don't get a reasonable response.

From personal experience, feelings about what to do next can change so much during 6th form. In yr 11 (and for years before), I was 100% sure I wanted to go to music college, and was steered away from the music & sciences A level combo I wanted to do and towards other arts / humanities. By the end of lower 6th, I knew I didn't want to perform for a career, so didn't want to go to music college. I did an academic music degree at university, but I have always regretted not doing the science A levels I really wanted to alongside my music. A lot can change at that age, so I do think keeping options open whilst doing things you genuinely enjoy is important.

StandFirm · Yesterday 14:07

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:43

He will drop either Film Studies or Dance by Christmas of Y12.

If he were my son, I would advise him to keep film studies as there are obvious crossovers with literature and so much of it will be looking at adaptations.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Yesterday 14:11

My understanding is that the GCSE History course is SO labour-intensive that it puts alot of students off. DS did it last year and he was a total History obsessive and he found it exhausting and it turned him away from it very comprehensively. His school (independent) goes from 8.20 to 16.45 daily and even they had to put on extra classes and from the GCSE boards on MN and talking to friends who were at other schools it seemed that some schools didn't even get through the curriculum by the end. So, he might be fed up with it by now, and that's not surprising.

cantkeepawayforever · Yesterday 14:12

I have a child who has done the ‘performance’ route post A level, and been very successful in their niche. It’s worth pointing out that no truly performance-related route (dance / drama / music colleges & conservatoires) cares about A level grades or subjects above the minimum - it is all about portfolio and audition.

So although DC did do their ‘thing’ as 1 of their A levels, the others were all about evidencing a secure general academic background & capability for backup purposes, either at degree level or for future work. Started with 4, dropped on of the ‘backup’ courses and ended up with a basket of very good A levels that they both enjoyed and closed no doors.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:13

GardensBooksTea · Yesterday 14:06

If he would still like to do history (& I appreciate he's fed up with it at the moment, but I think most things lose their attraction the closer to GCSEs you get), I think this is a complain-to-school scenario about their ridiculous option blocks. Not allowing anyone to do English Lit and History is total madness - it's one of the most common combinations of subjects in many places! Look at the complaints policy and escalate to governors if you don't get a reasonable response.

From personal experience, feelings about what to do next can change so much during 6th form. In yr 11 (and for years before), I was 100% sure I wanted to go to music college, and was steered away from the music & sciences A level combo I wanted to do and towards other arts / humanities. By the end of lower 6th, I knew I didn't want to perform for a career, so didn't want to go to music college. I did an academic music degree at university, but I have always regretted not doing the science A levels I really wanted to alongside my music. A lot can change at that age, so I do think keeping options open whilst doing things you genuinely enjoy is important.

I actually complained to the head of sixth form at the open evening. It will not be changing.

I agree it sucks

OP posts:
GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 14:14

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:53

I've not been in this site for a while. I forgot 🤣

Ok. If that's how you feel, do what makes you happy.

SayDoWhatNow · Yesterday 14:18

What are the other options in the Film/Dance blocks?

Given that he does a lot of dance out of school and that he's very into performing arts, these do sound like reasonable options.

That said, if there was a slightly more "academic" option he could swap one of them for, that could keep more options open. Some ideas:

  • English language
  • Psychology
  • a modern language - A level usually involves reading plays or novels in the language, so more interesting and quite a good fit with drama/eng lit
xmasisacomingpart57 · Yesterday 14:19

I know lots of kids who have done Theatre Studies and English Lit but their 3rd subject has been History, Politics, RS, Maths etc. It’s total madness they won’t allow anyone to do English Lit and History. At DCs school there’s about 40 of them
doing English Lit A level and about 35 are also doing History. I would actually question whether I’d want my DC to go to a school that didn’t allow it as it just seems bizarre.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 14:20

I think it's brilliant if he wants to go down one of those routes and carry on in performing arts, writing etc. I loved drama and wish I'd carried on in something like that post 16.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:24

Modern language is definitely out. It's not his thing and one of his lower predicted grades for GCSE.

Other options in those blocks are

For film...

Criminology
Biology
Sport
Chemistry
Computer science
Maths

For Dance

Art
Sciences again
Economics
Religious Studies
PE

The only one he would consider is Religious Studies instead of dance but that would be the one he would drop anyway.

OP posts:
Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:26

xmasisacomingpart57 · Yesterday 14:19

I know lots of kids who have done Theatre Studies and English Lit but their 3rd subject has been History, Politics, RS, Maths etc. It’s total madness they won’t allow anyone to do English Lit and History. At DCs school there’s about 40 of them
doing English Lit A level and about 35 are also doing History. I would actually question whether I’d want my DC to go to a school that didn’t allow it as it just seems bizarre.

I do and have questioned it but it's his choice at the end of the day.

OP posts:
Credittocress · Yesterday 14:27

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:57

I do appreciate everyone's opinions.

I just want him to be happy and actually want to get out of bed in the morning and go to 6th form. I'm not worried about him getting into a University.

Right now he is set on a degree in English Literature, possibly joint with Theatre Studies or Film.

So his choices are fine for that.

I think it's highly unlikely he will wake up one day in 5 years and think "Crap! I wish I'd done medicine" Unless he gets a personality transplant of course!

Well if you’re so convinced he’s doing the right thing why ask.

For what it’s worth I’ve recently recruited people in marketing and social media roles and unless they had really strong work experience i wouldn’t touch someone with these A-levels, I’d assume they were the sort to pick easy options and be looking for a bit of a doss

Swipe left for the next trending thread