Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
Piggywaspushed · Yesterday 18:12

Haven't read all the comments. Can't bear to.

I am a film teacher. It is an academic A level ( as in not vocational). I have a degree from a Russell Group University, and everything! As do many of my ex students.

It is nothing like dance or drama as I did see stated in a few comments.

It is heavy on essay writing. Its closest bedfellow is English Lit, which many of my students also do.

I do agree those choices are narrow in focus.

OP, you would have got better, perhaps less unfocused traffic on HE or FE boards.

Piggywaspushed · Yesterday 18:14

Botheredbewildered26 · Yesterday 17:48

That’s crap- I know a kid who went to Oxbridge with Lit and Film. To do a Lit degree at a ‘Russell group’ university these would be fine.
also, ‘Russell group’ universities- such a load of rubbish. My DS went to one where he had black mould on his halls walls, hundreds of kids in his lectures. They’re sacking lecturers left right and centre

Two of my current year 13 have Oxbridge interviews next week, indeed.

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 18:17

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 18:03

Stepped away for a bit as I was getting a bit stressed thinking I'm doing him a disservice by letting him make these choices but have come back to a few more people thinking these choices are absolutely fine. I feel a bit better now so thanks 😊

I never made a connection between psychology and the others but basically any science even social sciences just don't interest him in terms of a subject to study at a level.

You're absolutely right not to push psychology. A good chunk of the psychology A level is comparing research methods, understanding how to analyse data, understanding how to design a research study. It's not a discussion of the human condition, or abstract notions of consciousness. It's an experimental science. If someone enjoys humanities study - which broadly involves analyzing text and making arguments as a result - it may not be for them.

Letsgonowthen · Yesterday 18:20

My friend went to a full time ballet school and got no other qualifications, then 20 years later did A levels by correspondence followed by an excellent degree. There is not just one path through life.

I also know people who chose GCSE dance thinking it was a soft option, which it very much was not.

Having said that, I do think his choices have a lot of overlap. But if he's planning on dropping one, and is applying to performing arts colleges anyway, maybe it won't matter. I'd probably let him crack on!

I'm also gobsmacked that English and History clash.

Berniestavern · Yesterday 18:24

I think it looks like a pretty unserious set of alevels. One of fs, drama or dance and then 2 academic subjects. V odd school won’t support his original combo as it seems a good mix. 7s and 8s he’s a capable student.

Berniestavern · Yesterday 18:26

Piggywaspushed · Yesterday 18:14

Two of my current year 13 have Oxbridge interviews next week, indeed.

I thought interviews were in Jan?

Piggywaspushed · Yesterday 18:26

Next week was shorthand for soon but, no, they are in early December.

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 18:27

Berniestavern · Yesterday 18:24

I think it looks like a pretty unserious set of alevels. One of fs, drama or dance and then 2 academic subjects. V odd school won’t support his original combo as it seems a good mix. 7s and 8s he’s a capable student.

Why should someone who is academically intelligent not also want to study drama and dance? Why is Dance inherently less serious than History?

senua · Yesterday 18:45

Wanttobeok · Today 14:54 I would rather he was doing more traditional subjects but I don't think it's as career ending and dire as many of these responses make out.
I've only read OP's posts so sorry if repeating somebody else.
I'm not sure that "traditional subjects" will necessarily be that useful in a world where AI has scraped all the jobs. What we will need in the future is to have skills that AI doesn't - namely human skills and soft skills.
On that basis, arts students may yet come out tops!

MarzipanPotatoes · Yesterday 19:15

Ok, you’ve got a choice to make - favourite location, second choice subjects, or prefered subject choices and a second choice location.

We made the second choice - and went for the prefered subject choice.

It sounds like youve made the location choice, and are stuck with crazy option blocks.
So, make the best choices for the options youve got. Love 6th form. Have blast. Ace the exams. And see where life's journey takes him.

Pinkissmart · Yesterday 19:17

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:10

These choices will rule out many careers and Russell Group unis.
Take more traditional subjects.
It's not snobbery. It's good sense.

Edited

Don’t be ridiculous.

RG unis don’t do creative subjects?

Thepeopleversuswork · Yesterday 19:24

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:42

He doesn't want to do the STEM subjects and would therefore drop them or not get a good grade.

How is that a better bet than doing subjects he enjoys and should get good grades in?

That's what I don't get.

Is there any Uni or employer out there who would think a D in Maths is better than an A In film studies.

I think the issue is that these particular subjects narrow his options down so much.

If he is 100% sure he wants to go into the performing arts AND he is talented (and this is important), it is a gamble worth taking and if he’s committed it could be a rote to an incredible career.

But if he is just flirting with it or thinks it is an easy option he is being unwise.

I don’t think he has to go to the other extreme and do STEM but having one humanities course in there broadens his options significantly.

WearingBeautifulShoes · Yesterday 19:54

Mossyfox · Yesterday 17:12

I don't think that is a good choice at all. He needs to do 2 serious subjects.

He's doing English Lit and Drama which are both pretty "serious"

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 20:21

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 14:03

What is the specific question this table answers?
Presumably its not suggesting that a 100% of students do drama A level and it definitely can't be 92% do FM which is very much a minority subject?

If the OP's son wants to keep his options open the problem is not Drama its the balance of the choices. English and Drama/Theatre is fine as a degree subject - there will be quite a few possible career paths but its also a subject where the awarding school does matter.

100% of applicants with drama A level were offered a place to study law at the sample RG universities.
etc etc

senua · Yesterday 20:37

If he is 100% sure he wants to go into the performing arts AND he is talented (and this is important), it is a gamble worth taking and if he’s committed it could be a rote to an incredible career.
But if he is just flirting with it or thinks it is an easy option he is being unwise.
It could be a route into communications, presentations, training, teaching, persuading, PR, etc, etc.
The best salespeople (who are few and far between) make a lot of money.

newrubylane · Yesterday 20:49

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 13:36

English and History is such a common combination (and accepted by good unis) that it seems odd to have them in one block. Does the school offer more than one syllabus with the second being in a different block? Its not snobbery to recommend at least two trad subjects if going for an RG.

York may not specify the subjects outside of English Lit but check what they actually accepted in recent years - they may be simply making their offers to more traditional subject combinations. York used to have a good rep for media studies and related but don't know about it in recent years.

Publishing is still largely the domain of the wealthy and connected - do you have connections? If not keep him looking at a wide range of options. I know at least one young adult who found their way into performing arts via the business route - being able to run a business with knowledge of arts organisations opened a few doors.

I know lots of people in publishing - including myself! - and they are not all rich and connected. I absolutely wasnt.

It is still highly competitive and if he's at all serious about it I'd consider looking at the available masters degrees in publishing and the routes to get onto those courses. Also get some relevant work experience if possible - easier said than done, of course. Publishing needs people with a variety of specialisms and interests, so an arts background at A-level or even as a degree isn't necessarily going to be limiting for him at all.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 22:53

Well he has put in his 6th form application at school today and is sticking with his new choices.

It's been interesting to hear different viewpoints.

My initial reaction was the same as many of you but since I've looked into it more I realise how much those choices and the (many) associated career paths make sense for him.

OP posts:
Littlepigeon · Today 06:24

I studied similar subjects to him at A level and have had a successful well paid career. My friends that let their parents sway them to more traditional subjects ended up miserably doing degrees they weren’t interested in. He’ll have an amazing 5 years studying subjects he’s passionate about at school and uni, what a gift

Restlessinthenorth · Today 06:37

I'm an academic and admissions tutor. Not in an area your son is interested, but recently had a student with dance lol to come on our programme so mapped the content rather than just assumed the kids were prancing around all day. Ultimately there was a good degree of critical analysis/writing that satisfied me and I was happy to take the student. I was actually delighted to have someone on the programme who had done their own thing, rather than follow the crowd. Creatine arts produces creative thinkers. I'd just let your son do what he enjoys. He will work it out

HardShoulders · Today 06:48

Littlepigeon · Today 06:24

I studied similar subjects to him at A level and have had a successful well paid career. My friends that let their parents sway them to more traditional subjects ended up miserably doing degrees they weren’t interested in. He’ll have an amazing 5 years studying subjects he’s passionate about at school and uni, what a gift

But the OP’s child isn’t passionate about film studies and dance. He wanted to do history and politics. He’s only contemplating film and dance because he can’t take the subjects he actually wanted at his current school/college. I think that’s a reason to change setting, not A-levels.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread