Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:40

In my experience living and working in an area with a large Asian and Black population, its cultural taboo and stereotypes which lead parents to ignore their children’s issues and demonise SEND.

painswick · Yesterday 17:40

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:27

Well for starters, they did not think AuDHD existed until 2013 and people with both would be told they had neither. Then they based it on a male presentation, so girls were missed. Then they realised the offset that masked usually until puberty so they dropped the must have struggled your whole life requirement to be diagnosed. Because it was thought AuDHD was impossible until 2013, you have loads of adults born before 2005 that were missed and now they are catching up by research into the common work around that AuDHD sufferers have had to invent themselves to get along in life (some succeed, most fail, all work harder for less success).

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/health/article/what-is-audhd-adhd-autism-overlap-adults

So you have given an example of the diagnostic net simply being widened, which is not what I was asking. You have also not shared the objective testing that you maintain is used that does not rely on patient report or subjective clinical observations

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:41

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 17:27

Old mothers are getting crucified on here today.

I don't want to insult older mothers, I come from a line of them.

But it is factually true that mothers AND fathers being older does seem to increase the risk.

Another factor is probably the survival of premature babies who previously they could not save.

I also think it's possible things like endocrine-disrupting hormones & microplastics could have prenatal effects though I know microplastic effects are now being questioned by some.

I do think there are reasons genuine SN may be more common now. I don't think it's just overdiagnosis.

OP posts:
OneNewLeader · Yesterday 17:43

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

I’ve never met a child or adult who expended time, money and energy on a diagnosis despite having no symptoms.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:43

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 17:27

Old mothers are getting crucified on here today.

There have been studies linking older parental age at conception to increases in autism.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 17:44

Freshrain · Yesterday 16:45

I'd like to see the data you are reading too, as, working in this area in a very multicultural City, this is not what we see, at all.

From the Born in Bradford study (2025) the recorded autism diagnosis rate was approximately 2.7 times higher among White British children, and the ADHD diagnosis rate was six times higher.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:44

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:03

A combination of things:
1 - most research and studies are on the white male presentation. This doesn’t necessarily mean more white boys have autism but that the classic presentation is based on them so autistic women and BAME people still have autism but it isn’t necessarily recognised or diagnosed as such.
2 - culture: many different cultures apply more shame to such a diagnosis, or blame the parents or view it as more of a stigmatised diagnosis and so do not seek help or diagnosis for themself or a child. This could include some white cultures (travellers, Easten European) but generally white westerners don’t think this way as much.
3 - access: BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived. As such fewer can afford to seek private diagnosis so they may be sitting on long NHS waiting lists.
4 - Bias: health professionals with bias may be more likely to diagnose autistic BAME individuals with BPD, EUPD or similar.
5 - community and support: children are more likely to live with their parents well into adulthood and even beyond in some BAME cultures. This may mean they see less need for diagnosis as support needs are better met.
6 - Distrust. BAME individuals are less likely to trust healthcare professionals in the UK so may not seek support outside of their community.

Edited

BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived

Sorry to be blunt but I hate bollocks like this. Hong Kong Chinese first gen immigrants living in St Albans are not more likely to be deprived. Refugees from Afghanistan (say), are more likely to be deprived.

All this BAME nonsense just lumps together everyone who isn't white, in a way that becomes totally unhelpful and is borderline indirectly racist against white people by drawing a line between them and everyone else.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:44

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

So your parents kept the same expectations, did not use external support & this worked well? I suppose white parents may be more likely to worry about burnout etc. Can I ask : do your siblings feel this approach served them well/made their symptoms milder than they would otherwise?

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:44

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 17:44

From the Born in Bradford study (2025) the recorded autism diagnosis rate was approximately 2.7 times higher among White British children, and the ADHD diagnosis rate was six times higher.

Probably partly due to cousin marriage..

OP posts:
LoisGriffinskitchen · Yesterday 17:45

Black and Asian children grow up….I’ve referred loads for assessment as adults.

Ftm7 · Yesterday 17:45

Adultification bias is interesting to consider here particularly in relation to the over representation of black children and SEMH needs.

painswick · Yesterday 17:45

OneNewLeader · Yesterday 17:43

I’ve never met a child or adult who expended time, money and energy on a diagnosis despite having no symptoms.

That's nice

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:46

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:44

BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived

Sorry to be blunt but I hate bollocks like this. Hong Kong Chinese first gen immigrants living in St Albans are not more likely to be deprived. Refugees from Afghanistan (say), are more likely to be deprived.

All this BAME nonsense just lumps together everyone who isn't white, in a way that becomes totally unhelpful and is borderline indirectly racist against white people by drawing a line between them and everyone else.

It’s statically correct that BAME communities in the UK are more likely be of lower socioeconomic status. Of course as with all statistics there are outliers.

NorthXNorthWest · Yesterday 17:46

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

Can you change your name and share them. Would love to hear them (genuinely curious :))

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 17:47

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 17:39

My son has his assessment face to face in a room with us and two professionals.

That's good to hear.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:48

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:44

BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived

Sorry to be blunt but I hate bollocks like this. Hong Kong Chinese first gen immigrants living in St Albans are not more likely to be deprived. Refugees from Afghanistan (say), are more likely to be deprived.

All this BAME nonsense just lumps together everyone who isn't white, in a way that becomes totally unhelpful and is borderline indirectly racist against white people by drawing a line between them and everyone else.

I’m sorry you are offended. We are discussing things on a population level and in general. On a population level, BAME individuals in the UK (which is what OP is discussing) are more likely to be deprived than White British people. That doesn’t mean all of them are.

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:48

OneNewLeader · Yesterday 17:43

I’ve never met a child or adult who expended time, money and energy on a diagnosis despite having no symptoms.

I do agree but sometimes the symptoms are traits that we all have and aren’t actually ND.

Sometimes it’s MH or just kids being kids but their parents see them struggling, see they have a few autistic traits and so assume they’re autistic.

Most of the time it’s not coming from a bad place but it can look like parents are trying to force a diagnosis, when in fact they are just trying to support their child but who isn’t actually ND.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:48

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:46

It’s statically correct that BAME communities in the UK are more likely be of lower socioeconomic status. Of course as with all statistics there are outliers.

The point has gone whoosh hasn't it. You're compiling a mega-group of completely separate "communities" that have zero in common except for not being white.

Boorip · Yesterday 17:49

Many will have recently moved from countries where there’s still a lot of stigma around Sen, skewing the statistics.

Thats not rocket science tbh

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:49

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:48

The point has gone whoosh hasn't it. You're compiling a mega-group of completely separate "communities" that have zero in common except for not being white.

I understand that you are confused but the statistics are based on the ONS data. I don’t make them up myself. BAME is a recognised term in this country. I suspect it doesn’t align with your political beliefs.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:50

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:48

I’m sorry you are offended. We are discussing things on a population level and in general. On a population level, BAME individuals in the UK (which is what OP is discussing) are more likely to be deprived than White British people. That doesn’t mean all of them are.

They are not "a population"! They have zero in common except for not being white. I'm not offended, I'm exasperated. But yes now you mention it, it is offensive to all those separate communities to lump them together and separate from British people.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:50

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:50

They are not "a population"! They have zero in common except for not being white. I'm not offended, I'm exasperated. But yes now you mention it, it is offensive to all those separate communities to lump them together and separate from British people.

Separate from British people? Many BAME individuals are British.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:51

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:49

I understand that you are confused but the statistics are based on the ONS data. I don’t make them up myself. BAME is a recognised term in this country. I suspect it doesn’t align with your political beliefs.

I know it is not you personally. It was a general "you". I am not confused love but thanks for being patronising. I am used to it as a deprived BAME person eh

NorthXNorthWest · Yesterday 17:51

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 16:52

Asian children generally do very well without any type of special pleading or concessions.

What a bizarre thing to say.