Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Ormally · Today 08:54

I don’t disagree with the intensity, but why are children allowed them for a significant amount of time? Why are they allowed to have all these apps?

Here is an example from yr 10-11: the ones that are required by school for viewing homework in a to-do list, submitting and ticking off the homework are numerous. The only lesson I can think of that still uses books and hand-in is art. There is also a school calendar and timetable app. Then there are the mini practice 'quiz' apps that build language and science skills. You can miss days on them (weekends included), but if you keep going in a streak then the period you need to give to using them the next day gets shorter. Some science teachers have also insisted on Teams channels by which a lot of files are sorted and stored. Very good resources but not an app that is designed to protect under-18s in the way that school apps should do. Some of the homework on the list is set with 12 midnight deadlines on a Friday (presumably a default due to the way the calendar and clock works, but not a pupil-friendly message).

This year, the locked phones in a pouch while at school system came in. The timetable and calendar 'grasp' has been quite hard (still) for my DC, because they are now all used to being able to refer to their apps when needed, to know where and who they have. They can all be disciplined heavily in a lesson because one phone still goes off in a pouch - but this is often because it is an alert for a music lesson or similar that comes from the school systems itself, so the 'culprit' is not initially aware of this feature being the reason for sanctions.

The teachers have also been quite ticked off about the amount of photocopying of resources they suddenly had to do and had no budget for.

I am on the side of not being pro-phone, but this is more like what is now expected in a workplace for an adult to be able to access the time-sensitive stuff you need to do, yet there are about 12 apps required to be able to juggle the balls, and they are now primarily accessible while out of school hours. It may be efficient but it is not doing much for stress or parental assistance that goes beyond a small screen.

Passaggressfedup · Today 08:57

This has been shown to be harmful. It’s teaching masking, not adaptation, and it leads to burnout. People with undiagnosed autism and ADHD have been trying to adapt for decades without success, usually resulting in mental health issues that could have been avoided. Society eventually got used to making adaptations for wheelchair users, visually impaired people and Deaf people. That’s how society evolves
Masking IS learning to adapt. It's just a new emotionally loaded word to explicit sympathy. Same with burnout!

It's hard to take some posts seriously when it just resort to using this sort language to make a point. Language that ultimately discuss totally normal emotions! It's normal to mask. Masking IS being adaptable. It's normal to feel exhausted by adapting to norma ranger than saying and doing what you feel like with no worry about consequences. It's normal to experience variable emotional states through those experiences.

How do people manage to live a normal life in spite of these. By learning to be resilient and not making it an individual experience. By learning that you can't feel good about yourself and your environment all the time. By accepting that life demands efforts all the time.

This thread is yet another one on the matter that shows that society has become spoilt, entitled and lazy. Spoilt because it expects life to be easy and self centered. Entitled because it expects others to make it all better for them. Lazy because they will do anything to avoid making an effort to make changes.

BarbieinBloom · Today 08:59

Ormally · Today 08:54

I don’t disagree with the intensity, but why are children allowed them for a significant amount of time? Why are they allowed to have all these apps?

Here is an example from yr 10-11: the ones that are required by school for viewing homework in a to-do list, submitting and ticking off the homework are numerous. The only lesson I can think of that still uses books and hand-in is art. There is also a school calendar and timetable app. Then there are the mini practice 'quiz' apps that build language and science skills. You can miss days on them (weekends included), but if you keep going in a streak then the period you need to give to using them the next day gets shorter. Some science teachers have also insisted on Teams channels by which a lot of files are sorted and stored. Very good resources but not an app that is designed to protect under-18s in the way that school apps should do. Some of the homework on the list is set with 12 midnight deadlines on a Friday (presumably a default due to the way the calendar and clock works, but not a pupil-friendly message).

This year, the locked phones in a pouch while at school system came in. The timetable and calendar 'grasp' has been quite hard (still) for my DC, because they are now all used to being able to refer to their apps when needed, to know where and who they have. They can all be disciplined heavily in a lesson because one phone still goes off in a pouch - but this is often because it is an alert for a music lesson or similar that comes from the school systems itself, so the 'culprit' is not initially aware of this feature being the reason for sanctions.

The teachers have also been quite ticked off about the amount of photocopying of resources they suddenly had to do and had no budget for.

I am on the side of not being pro-phone, but this is more like what is now expected in a workplace for an adult to be able to access the time-sensitive stuff you need to do, yet there are about 12 apps required to be able to juggle the balls, and they are now primarily accessible while out of school hours. It may be efficient but it is not doing much for stress or parental assistance that goes beyond a small screen.

When I said, children I meant primary school aged children maybe pushing early secondary. I don't like the lack of IT skills being taught at primary school level especially, over reliance on iPads. At 15/16, there's only so much you can realistically do at that point especially as near 18 technically an adult.

Ormally · Today 09:01

BarbieinBloom · Today 08:59

When I said, children I meant primary school aged children maybe pushing early secondary. I don't like the lack of IT skills being taught at primary school level especially, over reliance on iPads. At 15/16, there's only so much you can realistically do at that point especially as near 18 technically an adult.

It doesn't get less stressful at that age though. If anything, expectations are higher for them to sort their stuff out. They're not the cute maths games and avatars of primary.

MeshMesh · Today 09:08

Passaggressfedup · Today 08:57

This has been shown to be harmful. It’s teaching masking, not adaptation, and it leads to burnout. People with undiagnosed autism and ADHD have been trying to adapt for decades without success, usually resulting in mental health issues that could have been avoided. Society eventually got used to making adaptations for wheelchair users, visually impaired people and Deaf people. That’s how society evolves
Masking IS learning to adapt. It's just a new emotionally loaded word to explicit sympathy. Same with burnout!

It's hard to take some posts seriously when it just resort to using this sort language to make a point. Language that ultimately discuss totally normal emotions! It's normal to mask. Masking IS being adaptable. It's normal to feel exhausted by adapting to norma ranger than saying and doing what you feel like with no worry about consequences. It's normal to experience variable emotional states through those experiences.

How do people manage to live a normal life in spite of these. By learning to be resilient and not making it an individual experience. By learning that you can't feel good about yourself and your environment all the time. By accepting that life demands efforts all the time.

This thread is yet another one on the matter that shows that society has become spoilt, entitled and lazy. Spoilt because it expects life to be easy and self centered. Entitled because it expects others to make it all better for them. Lazy because they will do anything to avoid making an effort to make changes.

Suella (or is it Kemi?) has joined the thread people!

LumberPainJackie · Today 09:13

BarbieinBloom · Today 08:59

When I said, children I meant primary school aged children maybe pushing early secondary. I don't like the lack of IT skills being taught at primary school level especially, over reliance on iPads. At 15/16, there's only so much you can realistically do at that point especially as near 18 technically an adult.

With regard to this, dd who is 15 was in primary when Covid hit and all lessons went online. Suddenly all the kids who had been given a phone and ipads had a huge advantage as they knew how to use it and put on filters, mute themselves etc. A generation doesn't forget things like that as their only way to interact with peers daily.

LumberPainJackie · Today 09:20

Passaggressfedup · Today 08:57

This has been shown to be harmful. It’s teaching masking, not adaptation, and it leads to burnout. People with undiagnosed autism and ADHD have been trying to adapt for decades without success, usually resulting in mental health issues that could have been avoided. Society eventually got used to making adaptations for wheelchair users, visually impaired people and Deaf people. That’s how society evolves
Masking IS learning to adapt. It's just a new emotionally loaded word to explicit sympathy. Same with burnout!

It's hard to take some posts seriously when it just resort to using this sort language to make a point. Language that ultimately discuss totally normal emotions! It's normal to mask. Masking IS being adaptable. It's normal to feel exhausted by adapting to norma ranger than saying and doing what you feel like with no worry about consequences. It's normal to experience variable emotional states through those experiences.

How do people manage to live a normal life in spite of these. By learning to be resilient and not making it an individual experience. By learning that you can't feel good about yourself and your environment all the time. By accepting that life demands efforts all the time.

This thread is yet another one on the matter that shows that society has become spoilt, entitled and lazy. Spoilt because it expects life to be easy and self centered. Entitled because it expects others to make it all better for them. Lazy because they will do anything to avoid making an effort to make changes.

Masking is not adaption.

Being adaptable is not having to scrutinise why people find some frankly rubbish humour funny, learning how to laugh along at the right time so you don't stick out. Understanding why only people with certain clothes are allowed to hang out in certain groups. Why some kids don't want to learn or find fashion or boys more important than the lesson so talk through it but if you object and tell them to shut up you are the one thrown out for being rude. Or how your face might look when you are thinking might be laughed at by some ND peer so you had better figure out what everyone else looks like when they are doing exams and pull that throughout. Fitting in to a very narrow minded society who let people who are clearly perverts like Brand and his cohort become famous for clearly being perverts. Life as ND people live it simply doesn't make sense to a lot of us.

Adaption is seeing AI is coming for the lower tier jobs and getting the government to make damn sure the billionaires are still going to pay the same amount in taxable wages to those left in work because otherwise our economy is screwed.

NattyKnitter116 · Today 09:48

ClockworkChocolate · Yesterday 17:02

As someone who genuinely has ADHD, I find this really worrying. Someone I know has recently been diagnosed with ADHD and autism whilst in their first year of University. I've known them since they were a toddler and I'd put money on her having neither.

the criteria has widened so much in the last 30 years. Back then kids would be diagnosed with language disorders, global delay and so on, whereas now they will get an ASD diagnosis. 30 years ago they were either diagnosed with Kanners type autism or with Asperger - the latter was seen as the middle class diagnosis and usually given later after they’d started primary. Whereas Kanners was apparent almost from birth, certainly by 18 months and would be diagnosed around 3.

but earlier it was also called childhood autism because kids would often ‘emerge’ around 5 yrs and be able to engage and learn and somehow make it through some kind of educational programme.

I think it’s worth remembering that autism is an umbrella term and largely diagnosed on behaviour and ability.

It’s a very different landscape now and education is a box ticking, data driven process. It was a battle then but I’d hate to be in that position now (single parent, benefits, disabled child) as everything that helped me and my son no longer exists.
him and I have been able to contribute to society directly as a result of govt help.

if it was our time now there is a good chance he’d be out of school and quite possibly in care because the breakdown I had would end up more serious and long term and we’d both end unable to contribute at all.

I think the saddest thing in the last 16 years has been the race to the bottom and the overt xenophobia and racism since Brexit is something I never thought I’d see again in my part of the world.

It seems that the old tactic of divide and conquer is being used successfully once again.

what has happened to human empathy? (Rhetorical really)
Oh and my son was always a racial minority at school as a white boy - never stopped him or I making friends as thankfully the mixture of new immigrants and 2/3 gen were supportive and inclusive in a way that my white ‘mainstream’ peers never were.

We need more love and understanding and less judgement on all sides.

painswick · Today 09:50

LumberPainJackie · Today 09:20

Masking is not adaption.

Being adaptable is not having to scrutinise why people find some frankly rubbish humour funny, learning how to laugh along at the right time so you don't stick out. Understanding why only people with certain clothes are allowed to hang out in certain groups. Why some kids don't want to learn or find fashion or boys more important than the lesson so talk through it but if you object and tell them to shut up you are the one thrown out for being rude. Or how your face might look when you are thinking might be laughed at by some ND peer so you had better figure out what everyone else looks like when they are doing exams and pull that throughout. Fitting in to a very narrow minded society who let people who are clearly perverts like Brand and his cohort become famous for clearly being perverts. Life as ND people live it simply doesn't make sense to a lot of us.

Adaption is seeing AI is coming for the lower tier jobs and getting the government to make damn sure the billionaires are still going to pay the same amount in taxable wages to those left in work because otherwise our economy is screwed.

You are literally describing life as a human being in society. It's not clear why you then started on about Russell brand.

Passaggressfedup · Today 09:55

Suella (or is it Kemi?) has joined the thread people!
Typical MN response! Well done, very funny!

Being adaptable is not having to scrutinise why people find some frankly rubbish humour funny, learning how to laugh along at the right time so you don't stick out. Understanding why only people with certain clothes are allowed to hang out in certain groups. Why some kids don't want to learn or find fashion or boys more important than the lesson so talk through it but if you object and tell them to shut up you are the one thrown out for being rude. Or how your face might look when you are thinking might be laughed at by some ND peer so you had better figure out what everyone else looks like when they are doing exams and pull that throughout. Fitting in to a very narrow minded society who let people who are clearly perverts like Brand and his cohort become famous for clearly being perverts. Life as ND people live it simply doesn't make sense to a lot of us
This is EXACTLY what adaptability is! All the above is so meaningless in the spectrum that is life. You don't understand people's humour, so what! Learn not to analyse it and stick to I don't get it but I'll just smile. You don't care about fashion or boys? So? Many others don't. Learn to listen with interest without needing to agree with it. Indeed, learn there is no need to react aggressively. Wondering how you fit in our society? Like the vast majority of people?

Honestly, all the above is just navel grazing. You don't need to question everything and pass judgement on everything that you don't agree or understand. There is so much more to life to focus on.

If indeed, the above qualifies as being autistic and deserving of special treatment, I really despair!

LumberPainJackie · Today 09:56

painswick · Today 09:50

You are literally describing life as a human being in society. It's not clear why you then started on about Russell brand.

Well, if you thought he was hilarious maybe that is the point.

LoopyLoo1991 · Today 10:03

Perhaps not in the UK, but it is a major problem now in Japan and South Korea. They have only recently acknowledged the issues. A mum in our international department is from South Korea and her son born here in UK is eight now with SEN requirements.

JHound · Today 10:20

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:58

Because frequently they are. I have a background within Asian family life and women are very much second place.

“Black and Asian” covers many different communities. Seems fairly lazy to state men are in charge of the households across all of them.

NightHeron · Today 10:23

NattyKnitter116 · Today 09:48

the criteria has widened so much in the last 30 years. Back then kids would be diagnosed with language disorders, global delay and so on, whereas now they will get an ASD diagnosis. 30 years ago they were either diagnosed with Kanners type autism or with Asperger - the latter was seen as the middle class diagnosis and usually given later after they’d started primary. Whereas Kanners was apparent almost from birth, certainly by 18 months and would be diagnosed around 3.

but earlier it was also called childhood autism because kids would often ‘emerge’ around 5 yrs and be able to engage and learn and somehow make it through some kind of educational programme.

I think it’s worth remembering that autism is an umbrella term and largely diagnosed on behaviour and ability.

It’s a very different landscape now and education is a box ticking, data driven process. It was a battle then but I’d hate to be in that position now (single parent, benefits, disabled child) as everything that helped me and my son no longer exists.
him and I have been able to contribute to society directly as a result of govt help.

if it was our time now there is a good chance he’d be out of school and quite possibly in care because the breakdown I had would end up more serious and long term and we’d both end unable to contribute at all.

I think the saddest thing in the last 16 years has been the race to the bottom and the overt xenophobia and racism since Brexit is something I never thought I’d see again in my part of the world.

It seems that the old tactic of divide and conquer is being used successfully once again.

what has happened to human empathy? (Rhetorical really)
Oh and my son was always a racial minority at school as a white boy - never stopped him or I making friends as thankfully the mixture of new immigrants and 2/3 gen were supportive and inclusive in a way that my white ‘mainstream’ peers never were.

We need more love and understanding and less judgement on all sides.

No, I disagree. DD1 was diagnosed with a language disorder thirty years ago. She was in special speech and language provision from age four - sixteen. Around 40% of the children in her class all the way through, were diagnosed with autism and a language disorder; but clinicians could tell the difference between language disorder and autism.

friedaklein · Today 10:23

JHound · Today 10:20

“Black and Asian” covers many different communities. Seems fairly lazy to state men are in charge of the households across all of them.

Edited

Agree. BAME is a wide church. I am S Indian. Every woman in my family is a high earning doctor, lawyer, accountant or engineer. Every single one has multiple degrees and is financially independent. My mum had a medical degree and made her own money in the 60s!

But we are in a large bucket marked '"oppressed depressed suppressed" along with women who can't leave the house.

Passaggressfedup · Today 10:27

I think the saddest thing in the last 16 years has been the race to the bottom and the overt xenophobia and racism since Brexit is something I never thought I’d see again in my part of the world
You are referring to two different issues.

When it comes to SEN, It's not a race to the bottom. Its an increasing number of people getting fed up with the expectation of giving sympathy and make special allowances to some people who ultimately experience the same issues as everyone else.

SorrelSeaglass · Today 10:38

Passaggressfedup · Today 08:57

This has been shown to be harmful. It’s teaching masking, not adaptation, and it leads to burnout. People with undiagnosed autism and ADHD have been trying to adapt for decades without success, usually resulting in mental health issues that could have been avoided. Society eventually got used to making adaptations for wheelchair users, visually impaired people and Deaf people. That’s how society evolves
Masking IS learning to adapt. It's just a new emotionally loaded word to explicit sympathy. Same with burnout!

It's hard to take some posts seriously when it just resort to using this sort language to make a point. Language that ultimately discuss totally normal emotions! It's normal to mask. Masking IS being adaptable. It's normal to feel exhausted by adapting to norma ranger than saying and doing what you feel like with no worry about consequences. It's normal to experience variable emotional states through those experiences.

How do people manage to live a normal life in spite of these. By learning to be resilient and not making it an individual experience. By learning that you can't feel good about yourself and your environment all the time. By accepting that life demands efforts all the time.

This thread is yet another one on the matter that shows that society has become spoilt, entitled and lazy. Spoilt because it expects life to be easy and self centered. Entitled because it expects others to make it all better for them. Lazy because they will do anything to avoid making an effort to make changes.

Masking is exhausting and can’t be maintained, ask any parent of a child whose child is “fine in school” and can drop the mask at home. I take it seriously because I’ve seen the consequences for people who have been trying to mask for years, decades in some cases. It’s really not that difficult to make adjustments, and people saying “well you’ll just have to adapt” is one reason why so many autistic adults are economically inactive.

NattyKnitter116 · Today 10:45

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:16

Rather uninformed post.

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on.

The other thing to understand is that in the 1970s it was in some ways easier to forge a path through the teenage years and into adulthood without requiring support. Someone could leave school at 16 with few qualifications and pick up labouring work, factory work, or possibly an apprenticeship. Rent was more affordable. Less focus on office work. Less requirement to attend college or uni. We also now have less flexible, more exam focussed (vs the 1990), more measured schooling regime which exposes the issues for some kids who previously would have drifted through the system.

There are almost certainly just as many SEND kids in Black and Asian families. It’s unlikely ‘resilience’ and ‘aspiration’ help these kids overcome these issues per se, although one can see why people like to use this explanation. What’s far more likely is that shame and use of community/religious/family support mean fewer diagnoses are made and more muddling through and masking occurs.

Also the situation with NEETS isn’t simply the result of ‘labels’ being too readily adopted. It’s to a far far greater extent the result of structural changes to work and the economy, lack of opportunity etc. In fact, in the late 1970s and early 1980s there was also mass youth unemployment and a great deal of anxiety about a “lost generation” which led to the creation of new training schemes.

Edited

Absolutely agree with this. I can remember our general astonishment that Marks and Spencer were recruiting graduates as trainee store managers, simply because they could. Less jobs than people to fill them.

You really do not need degree level education to be successful in retail or the majority of office work.

Basic literacy, numeracy and decent manners is the main requirement. Although probably no need for much numeracy in retail now.

As you say, more factory work which often really suited many people.

Our loss of manufacturing has had huge impacts on society.

while I think Blair’s aim with degree education was admirable, I don’t think it’s helped overall.

JHound · Today 10:46

friedaklein · Today 10:23

Agree. BAME is a wide church. I am S Indian. Every woman in my family is a high earning doctor, lawyer, accountant or engineer. Every single one has multiple degrees and is financially independent. My mum had a medical degree and made her own money in the 60s!

But we are in a large bucket marked '"oppressed depressed suppressed" along with women who can't leave the house.

Edited

It’s such a lazy stereotype. A lot of Asian households, especially with adults my age (mid 40s) have a more gender egalitarian approach. A lot of Caribbean households are matriarchal. It just seems to be the lazy stereotype of all black and asian households living under a domineering male boot.

Passaggressfedup · Today 10:50

Masking is exhausting and can’t be maintained, ask any parent of a child whose child is “fine in school” and can drop the mask at home. I take it seriously because I’ve seen the consequences for people who have been trying to mask for years, decades in some cases. It’s really not that difficult to make adjustments, and people saying “well you’ll just have to adapt” is one reason why so many autistic adults are economically inactive
I've masked all my life. Still do so almost every day in my 50s! It can absolutely be maintained. The more you do, the more it becomes second nature. Dropping the hat at home is again perfectly normal behaviour. You go home and you let go of the stress of the day. You learn ways to do so that don't negatively impact on others but allow you to let it out and recharge. Again, NORMAL part of life!

People can have breakdowns down the line, but it's not because they had to adapt in the first place, it's because they were never given the chance to learn how to. They have grown up avoiding triggers as much as possible, and to expect others to make allowances for them.

Of course it is also normal for everyone to make some adjustments to help. However, those adjustments should come at free will with no expectations and judgement when not automatically given.

painswick · Today 11:14

LumberPainJackie · Today 09:56

Well, if you thought he was hilarious maybe that is the point.

Now you are just making things up! Personally i don't think he is or ever has been remotely funny. It appears that according to you that would make me ND.

SorrelSeaglass · Today 11:22

Passaggressfedup · Today 10:50

Masking is exhausting and can’t be maintained, ask any parent of a child whose child is “fine in school” and can drop the mask at home. I take it seriously because I’ve seen the consequences for people who have been trying to mask for years, decades in some cases. It’s really not that difficult to make adjustments, and people saying “well you’ll just have to adapt” is one reason why so many autistic adults are economically inactive
I've masked all my life. Still do so almost every day in my 50s! It can absolutely be maintained. The more you do, the more it becomes second nature. Dropping the hat at home is again perfectly normal behaviour. You go home and you let go of the stress of the day. You learn ways to do so that don't negatively impact on others but allow you to let it out and recharge. Again, NORMAL part of life!

People can have breakdowns down the line, but it's not because they had to adapt in the first place, it's because they were never given the chance to learn how to. They have grown up avoiding triggers as much as possible, and to expect others to make allowances for them.

Of course it is also normal for everyone to make some adjustments to help. However, those adjustments should come at free will with no expectations and judgement when not automatically given.

I’m not sure if you’re aware, but the Equality Act is a law that says reasonable adjustments have to be made. Do you apply the same “free will” principles to other laws, like using traffic lights or paying for things in shops?

FriggadyDiggady · Today 11:26

painswick · Today 11:14

Now you are just making things up! Personally i don't think he is or ever has been remotely funny. It appears that according to you that would make me ND.

I think they're trying to say that non-autist society produces evils like Russel Brand, so we should all learn lessons from the autists, or something like that.

Passaggressfedup · Today 12:30

I’m not sure if you’re aware, but the Equality Act is a law that says reasonable adjustments have to be made. Do you apply the same “free will” principles to other laws, like using traffic lights or paying for things in shops?
I'm very aware of the law. I also recognise that it stipulates the word 'reasonable', which many seem to ignore. Demanding for example to work from home, when it's been denied to everyone else, claiming that the light, noise, travel is a trigger, when they did it for years and main drive for the request is to avoid paying before and after breakfast clubs is not reasonable.

Free will applies in personal life.

Hallopeone · Today 12:55

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

There can be so much stigma around mental health issues in certain cultures that people will claim to be in physical pain rather than explain it as an emotional/ mental issue. Health professionals will be familiar with the “all over body pain syndrome” where people will show up and say they have pain everywhere, all over. Really it’s that they are depressed or it’s some other mental health issue. Where is the pain? - “all over” - so your eyelashes hurt? - “yes” - everything hurts. So it’s termed the “all over body pain syndrome.”