Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ClockworkChocolate · Yesterday 17:02

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

As someone who genuinely has ADHD, I find this really worrying. Someone I know has recently been diagnosed with ADHD and autism whilst in their first year of University. I've known them since they were a toddler and I'd put money on her having neither.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:03

A combination of things:
1 - most research and studies are on the white male presentation. This doesn’t necessarily mean more white boys have autism but that the classic presentation is based on them so autistic women and BAME people still have autism but it isn’t necessarily recognised or diagnosed as such.
2 - culture: many different cultures apply more shame to such a diagnosis, or blame the parents or view it as more of a stigmatised diagnosis and so do not seek help or diagnosis for themself or a child. This could include some white cultures (travellers, Easten European) but generally white westerners don’t think this way as much.
3 - access: BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived. As such fewer can afford to seek private diagnosis so they may be sitting on long NHS waiting lists.
4 - Bias: health professionals with bias may be more likely to diagnose autistic BAME individuals with BPD, EUPD or similar.
5 - community and support: children are more likely to live with their parents well into adulthood and even beyond in some BAME cultures. This may mean they see less need for diagnosis as support needs are better met.
6 - Distrust. BAME individuals are less likely to trust healthcare professionals in the UK so may not seek support outside of their community.

painswick · Yesterday 17:07

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

This is incredibly naive. There has been an explosion in private providers of diagnosis, a large number of whom do not fully comply with nice guidelines and whose diagnostic process is questionable to say the least. It's one of the reasons many GPs are now reluctant to take on shared care. Equally there are plenty of professionals out there who will diagnose withouit any triangulating evidence from school etc.

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 17:07

ClockworkChocolate · Yesterday 17:02

As someone who genuinely has ADHD, I find this really worrying. Someone I know has recently been diagnosed with ADHD and autism whilst in their first year of University. I've known them since they were a toddler and I'd put money on her having neither.

It is an uncomfortable topic because understandably a lot of people feel defensive about it.

I know two people who have pushed for their child to be diagnosed. I think one of the problems is that clinics obviously rely on primarily the parent(s) to describe the child’s behaviour and the parent can say pretty much whatever they want.

Then online communities can be a force for good but can also feed into this culture. My ds in particular has been diagnosed on here numerous times! I do think conclusions can be jumped to too early.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 17:08

ClockworkChocolate · Yesterday 17:02

As someone who genuinely has ADHD, I find this really worrying. Someone I know has recently been diagnosed with ADHD and autism whilst in their first year of University. I've known them since they were a toddler and I'd put money on her having neither.

I find these attitudes very concerning.
You having ADHD and not having researched it enough to realise that no 2 people with ADHD are the same doesn't say much for your understanding of your own diagnosis. It worries me far more than someone you know not having your exact issues being diagnosed. Maybe she thinks the same of you!

Wes Streeting touting the idea that SEN rises are all down to mothers pandering to kids has a lot to answer for. I suggest mothers club together and get another report that shows genetics and geriatric sperm are the 2 biggest causes in the rises. Actual biomedical proof rather than some old psychologist wanging on about "harms of perception".

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:13

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:03

A combination of things:
1 - most research and studies are on the white male presentation. This doesn’t necessarily mean more white boys have autism but that the classic presentation is based on them so autistic women and BAME people still have autism but it isn’t necessarily recognised or diagnosed as such.
2 - culture: many different cultures apply more shame to such a diagnosis, or blame the parents or view it as more of a stigmatised diagnosis and so do not seek help or diagnosis for themself or a child. This could include some white cultures (travellers, Easten European) but generally white westerners don’t think this way as much.
3 - access: BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived. As such fewer can afford to seek private diagnosis so they may be sitting on long NHS waiting lists.
4 - Bias: health professionals with bias may be more likely to diagnose autistic BAME individuals with BPD, EUPD or similar.
5 - community and support: children are more likely to live with their parents well into adulthood and even beyond in some BAME cultures. This may mean they see less need for diagnosis as support needs are better met.
6 - Distrust. BAME individuals are less likely to trust healthcare professionals in the UK so may not seek support outside of their community.

Edited

community and support: children are more likely to live with their parents well into adulthood and even beyond in some BAME cultures. This may mean they see less need for diagnosis as support needs are better met.- yes, I was thinking this. Stronger extended families and communities in some cases also may mean more support.

OP posts:
Voneska · Yesterday 17:13

I'm not an expert, but just a lay person and other people might have a different opinion than mine but the first thing that comes to mind is that Asian have a more secure family support system and so The Offspring feel more secure and are thriving without various health issues. My views may differ from others but I accept that.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:15

It's possible also that ND men, if in some communities they marry earlier and have their wives do the housework etc, may have some of their needs masked by that.

OP posts:
FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:17

ClockworkChocolate · Yesterday 17:02

As someone who genuinely has ADHD, I find this really worrying. Someone I know has recently been diagnosed with ADHD and autism whilst in their first year of University. I've known them since they were a toddler and I'd put money on her having neither.

You should read about AuDHD because they can mask each other. The ASD can offset the ADHD and the ADHD can offset the ASD. It is a complex presentation that would look nothing like your ADHD. The pp point that ADHD is not identical is also true.

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:18

1 it’s cultural due to stigma

2 because they are not taken seriously

There are lots of studies showing black or mixed race children/people are much more likely to be labelled as naughty and get into trouble at school (or police etc).

The exact same behaviours exhibited by a white person is seen as MH, ND or just ‘not as bad’ as those exhibited by a black or brown person.

Hollowvoice · Yesterday 17:18

ClockworkChocolate · Yesterday 17:02

As someone who genuinely has ADHD, I find this really worrying. Someone I know has recently been diagnosed with ADHD and autism whilst in their first year of University. I've known them since they were a toddler and I'd put money on her having neither.

I'm quite sure the SENCO at DDs primary school would have made the same bet about her.
DD masked hugely in school then completely fell apart at home. She was "fine when she's here" so obviously it was a parenting issue....
Diagnosed ASD with PDA profile. But yeah, "fine"

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:18

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:17

You should read about AuDHD because they can mask each other. The ASD can offset the ADHD and the ADHD can offset the ASD. It is a complex presentation that would look nothing like your ADHD. The pp point that ADHD is not identical is also true.

Very convenient and completely unfalsifiable.

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:19

Can we not stop denying reality and admit that the sharp rise in AuDHD kids in recent years is basically a cultural phenomenon?

I think you are the one with a problem in denying reality. The rise in AuDHD is not a cultural phenomenon, but due to improved diagnostic testing.

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 17:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I don’t think it is as cynical as this. In many cases, it’s more complex than that. I don’t doubt many parents believe their children have ADHD and / or autism, and it isn’t to try to access money, it is deeper rooted than that. But I don’t disagree that it is rooted in cultural norms.

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:20

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:18

Very convenient and completely unfalsifiable.

You cannot fake AuDHD.
There is nothing convenient about assessing a patient with multiple NDs.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:20

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:19

Can we not stop denying reality and admit that the sharp rise in AuDHD kids in recent years is basically a cultural phenomenon?

I think you are the one with a problem in denying reality. The rise in AuDHD is not a cultural phenomenon, but due to improved diagnostic testing.

Which only works on white people.

Dexternight · Yesterday 17:21

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

Why?

painswick · Yesterday 17:21

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:19

Can we not stop denying reality and admit that the sharp rise in AuDHD kids in recent years is basically a cultural phenomenon?

I think you are the one with a problem in denying reality. The rise in AuDHD is not a cultural phenomenon, but due to improved diagnostic testing.

Tell us more about this improved diagnostic testing over the last say 5 years? If you could identify how the diagnostic process has been upgraded and improved as opposed to widened that would be useful.

Pigriver · Yesterday 17:21

I work in the SEN field and I'd actually say those communities are hugely represented in our SEN schools and bases.
We also have lots of families who don't want a diagnosis but will accept support.
We have families that believe their child absolutely does not have SEN and refuse support.
White British families are usually more open to support/diagnosis.

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:22

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:20

Which only works on white people.

So the diagnostic process needs more improvement. Initially it did not work on anyone with AuDHD, then it did not work on girls/women, now it is not very good for ethnic minorities.

seahorsessky · Yesterday 17:22

There are more people with ADHD from broken homes, and there's less divorce/separation in general than in white families. Obviously I know Black children with ADHD and have family who have.
ADHD cases are linked to children from broken homes-Times

A lot of people with AuDHD thrive in calm, structured environments, and friends who went to schools with higher numbers of pupils from certain backgrounds, or with a particular ethos, say the schools were calmer and the parents supported teachers/made sure their children had learned basic tasks such as potty training/listening skills before Reception. They are also, according to teachers, more likely to support their child's learning and behaviour (Townsley/Parliament etc). Obviously that doesn't mean they can't have ADHD, but like it or not, it is often when a child is seen as "misbehaving" or melting down that someone is going to pay attention and help get them a diagnosis or support.

AnneLovesGilbert · Yesterday 17:22

Nothing to add but interesting thread.

painswick · Yesterday 17:23

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:20

You cannot fake AuDHD.
There is nothing convenient about assessing a patient with multiple NDs.

Please clarify this statement. What are the objective tests that don't rely on either patient/parent report or clinical observation that cannot be faked? I am presuming some sort of scan or other objective metric? Please confirm what this is and how widespread its use is.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:23

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:22

So the diagnostic process needs more improvement. Initially it did not work on anyone with AuDHD, then it did not work on girls/women, now it is not very good for ethnic minorities.

It's true that if we diagnose 100% of kids as having AuDHD then we won't miss any.