Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 17:24

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

That's because you have to do a load of pre-qualifying work for them to assess you, it's not the case you just hand the money over. Our pediatrician (a very senior NHS consultant) required a lot of presassesments to be completed which included school and supporting evidence in order to go ahead with the assessments. Presumably because she's in demand and there is no point spending her time on a child she doesn't think has it.

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 17:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

As someone who is married into a Black Caribbean family, I have to agree. It isnt unlike my Irish family. They have progressed. They do accept neurodiversity as a spectrum and realise that many challenged or "different" people they did not see as having special needs, or saw as having mental health issues, were likely just autistic or something.

The same goes for sexuality. If anything, the issues around gender identification hsve pushed people into being more accepting of non-het sexualities.

We aren't with this thing where we raise our kids to be a certain way and then try to get a diagnosis when that certain way gets them nowhere.

Waitingfordoggo · Yesterday 17:26

Having children younger on average?

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 17:27

Old mothers are getting crucified on here today.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:27

Waitingfordoggo · Yesterday 17:26

Having children younger on average?

That's interesting - do you have stats to back it up though?

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:27

painswick · Yesterday 17:21

Tell us more about this improved diagnostic testing over the last say 5 years? If you could identify how the diagnostic process has been upgraded and improved as opposed to widened that would be useful.

Well for starters, they did not think AuDHD existed until 2013 and people with both would be told they had neither. Then they based it on a male presentation, so girls were missed. Then they realised the offset that masked usually until puberty so they dropped the must have struggled your whole life requirement to be diagnosed. Because it was thought AuDHD was impossible until 2013, you have loads of adults born before 2005 that were missed and now they are catching up by research into the common work around that AuDHD sufferers have had to invent themselves to get along in life (some succeed, most fail, all work harder for less success).

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/health/article/what-is-audhd-adhd-autism-overlap-adults

Scientists are starting to understand how autism and ADHD can overlap

Studies reveal a complex interplay of traits, genes, and brain structure behind the dual diagnosis—raising new questions about how we define and treat both conditions.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/health/article/what-is-audhd-adhd-autism-overlap-adults

MrsKateColumbo · Yesterday 17:28

DS went to a special school for nursery year, there were maybe maybe 2 white kids in a class of 10. This is london though, and it was private so 90% of the kids were pretty middle class so maybe better educated parents were more open minded

painswick · Yesterday 17:28

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 17:24

That's because you have to do a load of pre-qualifying work for them to assess you, it's not the case you just hand the money over. Our pediatrician (a very senior NHS consultant) required a lot of presassesments to be completed which included school and supporting evidence in order to go ahead with the assessments. Presumably because she's in demand and there is no point spending her time on a child she doesn't think has it.

Again that is certainly not true across the board. ASD diagnosis can and are given off the back of a single 45min consultation with a single medic. they are also given after a diagnostic process only involving a SALT and and OT with no involvement from paediatrics or psycholgists. ADHD diagnosis can be given after a 30 minute online meeting with an ADHD assessor who then gets it signed off by a supervsing psychologist who has never met the patient and is signing off tens of dianoses a day. It's like the wild west out there

MaltesersDeath · Yesterday 17:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So true

ForGreyDog · Yesterday 17:29

Is it the case? Proportionally?

We are members of a local autism meet up group. I would say that proportionally the mix is largely the same as the wider population, black Asian and Middle Eastern are all well represented in the group, but we are in a pretty affluent area so maybe parents are proactive across the board because they have the financial resources to be so. I also live in a place where people are first generation immigrants with no previous generations living here and so families are not influencing parents decisions, I wonder is that part of it. My own parents were absolutely against my sons diagnosis initially

I wonder in poorer communities across the board is this an issue.

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:29

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:20

Which only works on white people.

This is another very valid reason.

The statistics for boys vs girls getting diagnosed is massively different because the diagnostic tests have always been aimed at white males (like most healthcare).

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:29

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:27

Well for starters, they did not think AuDHD existed until 2013 and people with both would be told they had neither. Then they based it on a male presentation, so girls were missed. Then they realised the offset that masked usually until puberty so they dropped the must have struggled your whole life requirement to be diagnosed. Because it was thought AuDHD was impossible until 2013, you have loads of adults born before 2005 that were missed and now they are catching up by research into the common work around that AuDHD sufferers have had to invent themselves to get along in life (some succeed, most fail, all work harder for less success).

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/health/article/what-is-audhd-adhd-autism-overlap-adults

I think that @painswick was making the point that it's entirely based on self-reported internal phenomena (particularly the idea of "masking") and is not very scientific.

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:31

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:29

I think that @painswick was making the point that it's entirely based on self-reported internal phenomena (particularly the idea of "masking") and is not very scientific.

No it is not entirely based on self-reported internal phenomena.

LiteraryBambi · Yesterday 17:31

I'm S. Asian. It's not as stigmatised as perhaps it once was, so I don't think that explains most of the difference.

The rise in SEND nationally is driven largely by autistic spectrum diagnosis and social and emotional mental health.

Unless quite acute, these are issues which we don't seek to label. Through routine, good parenting and aspirations, our parents and our generation tend to rely less on the need for a label.

It's the same when we look at the issue of white working class kids. No one is stating the obvious that the reason why ethnic kids tend to do better, even when we control for poverty, is largely down to parenting and aspirations. We weren't allowed to just sit at home and do nothing.

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 17:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I would swap the extra cash for a child that talks and who is not autistic.

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 17:32

Autistic people are marrying autistic people. Parents are getting older including older dads who are a risk factor.

Timeforanothernamechange3 · Yesterday 17:32

There is, without a doubt, a child at my son's school who fits this profile and desperately needs an EHCP but is currently without one. I imagine language barrier is a factor.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:33

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 17:31

I would swap the extra cash for a child that talks and who is not autistic.

It sounds like you've got a non-verbal kid - that must be really tough and I don't begrudge you a penny of any support you're receiving.
But don't you think there is money being wasted on less seriously impacted kids?

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 17:34

Hollowvoice · Yesterday 16:20

From my time working in education there were quite a lot of parents who did not want to explore any diagnosis for their children, as they didn't accept any sort of "difference"
Mostly those parents were not white British.

I’ve worked in SEND since the 1990s and very few families have refused further assessment of identified needs, equal numbers of White British parents and ethnic minority parents in my experience. So the issue may be with identification of needs.

Dexternight · Yesterday 17:36

I think there are a number of factors. Firstly, cost. A private diagnosis can cost around £3,000, which is beyond many families.
Secondly, in some BAME families, particularly South Asian ones, there can be a very strong emphasis on children achieving academically, getting good careers and ultimately doing well in life. There is often considerable family involvement, support and encouragement towards those goals, alongside high expectations.
There may also be different attitudes towards neurodevelopmental conditions. Many dont accept or buy into the idea of diagnoses such as ADHD or autism, and may instead see difficulties as something the child needs to overcome.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:36

seahorsessky · Yesterday 17:22

There are more people with ADHD from broken homes, and there's less divorce/separation in general than in white families. Obviously I know Black children with ADHD and have family who have.
ADHD cases are linked to children from broken homes-Times

A lot of people with AuDHD thrive in calm, structured environments, and friends who went to schools with higher numbers of pupils from certain backgrounds, or with a particular ethos, say the schools were calmer and the parents supported teachers/made sure their children had learned basic tasks such as potty training/listening skills before Reception. They are also, according to teachers, more likely to support their child's learning and behaviour (Townsley/Parliament etc). Obviously that doesn't mean they can't have ADHD, but like it or not, it is often when a child is seen as "misbehaving" or melting down that someone is going to pay attention and help get them a diagnosis or support.

Interesting.

'Examining a survey of 65,680 children aged between 6 and 17, the American research found that those who had suffered hardships such as poverty, parental divorce or bereavement had a much higher chance of being affected by the disorder.

The researchers found that more than a tenth of under-17s in the US had ADHD diagnosed, and there was a strong link with a range of hardships, including neighbourhood violence, racial discrimination and mental illness in the family.

In a paper presented last week at the annual meeting of the Pediatric Academic Societies in Vancouver, Nicole Brown, assistant professor of paediatrics at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York, said that stress could be the uniting factor.

“A growing body of evidence suggests that exposure to trauma at the child and family levels may increase toxic levels of stress, which may cause disruptions in brain development and other organ systems, leading to chronic impairments in behaviour, learning and overall physical and mental health,” she said.'

  • the mention of racial discrimination suggests they may have found higher rates in some ethnic minority groups. This is US so we have to account for differences but there may be similarities to results here
OP posts:
aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 17:37

painswick · Yesterday 17:28

Again that is certainly not true across the board. ASD diagnosis can and are given off the back of a single 45min consultation with a single medic. they are also given after a diagnostic process only involving a SALT and and OT with no involvement from paediatrics or psycholgists. ADHD diagnosis can be given after a 30 minute online meeting with an ADHD assessor who then gets it signed off by a supervsing psychologist who has never met the patient and is signing off tens of dianoses a day. It's like the wild west out there

But for not for everyone. It just beyond belief to keep talking to everyone who has Audhd child because we are trying to live a life on benefits. We didn't go RTC with my son, because actually I agree, teams is a terrible place to do the assessment. My son doesn't stop moving his legs or his feet which is in his report. How would this be seen in teams. He was also seen by the same assessor after adhd for ASD which is the correct order to do the assessments in and consistent with how they should be done.
However, I was replying to someone who was saying that all we had to do was pay for it when in actual fact I believe more RTC diagnoses are done via teams.

Londonwelshie · Yesterday 17:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

HedgerowD · Yesterday 17:39

We have a family member who pushed for a diagnosis for all 4 of her children. The school were involved and she received advice from some professional but I cannot remember the full details. They advised her that the childrens unstable home life was a contributing factor to the behaviour they were seeing. She was rather upset about this and went through a private company for a diagnosis. The assessment for all 3 children was done within 2 hours. All have autism, ADHD or both. She hasn't changed her parenting or home life.

I do wonder if a stable homelife with decent boundaries and expectations means that children with SEN learn better coping strategies.

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 17:39

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 17:37

But for not for everyone. It just beyond belief to keep talking to everyone who has Audhd child because we are trying to live a life on benefits. We didn't go RTC with my son, because actually I agree, teams is a terrible place to do the assessment. My son doesn't stop moving his legs or his feet which is in his report. How would this be seen in teams. He was also seen by the same assessor after adhd for ASD which is the correct order to do the assessments in and consistent with how they should be done.
However, I was replying to someone who was saying that all we had to do was pay for it when in actual fact I believe more RTC diagnoses are done via teams.

My son has his assessment face to face in a room with us and two professionals.

Swipe left for the next trending thread