Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:51

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:50

Separate from British people? Many BAME individuals are British.

Edited

I meant white British people. Yes i am bame British myself. It's not me that's separating the groups.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:52

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:51

I meant white British people. Yes i am bame British myself. It's not me that's separating the groups.

You should write to the government then.

Londonwelshie · Yesterday 17:53

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:53

painswick · Yesterday 17:40

So you have given an example of the diagnostic net simply being widened, which is not what I was asking. You have also not shared the objective testing that you maintain is used that does not rely on patient report or subjective clinical observations

Those are not examples of widening. Ffs, you would say a diagnostic net is widening if I wrote how scientists discovered men can have breast cancer too and so added diagnostic symptoms and criteria to id breast cancer in men.

AuDHD is how they discovered it is possible to have both. First in boys. Then on girls. Then for adults because adults present differently from children.

Nice, you said it is “based entirely on self reported internal phenomena” and now you are admitting you were wrong because it is also based on clinical observation. All observations have a degree of subjectivity. A doctor often diagnoses appendicitis or psychosis with clinical observations, the surgery or antipsychotic medication is applied, and the patient gets better.

Observation is the bedrock of science.

But anyway, they have both done genome sequencing and neural pathway mapping for ADHD, ASD, AND AuDHD which show distinct differences from each other and neurotypical genetic profiles and neural pathways. So if you like your science to come from a scan or a test, they have that too.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 17:55

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:44

Probably partly due to cousin marriage..

Consanguinity can be a factor in several genetic disorders, but that doesn’t explain the much higher rates of diagnosis in white children.

marblyarch · Yesterday 17:56

LucieO · Yesterday 16:22

I work in education and have known several students from Asian families where the mother would be receptive to some support for their child with suspected SEN but absolutely not to a formal
diagnosis and the school were instructed to not let the father know under any circumstances. I imagine this sort of situation may be impacting statistics.

This is interesting, my son is autistic anecdotally there was one other little boy in his class, Asian, who exhibited all the same symptoms as my son and had severe learning difficulties, he had an ehcp and full-time TA support but his mum told me they would not be perusing a diagnosis for anything.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:56

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:52

You should write to the government then.

I'm just contributing my arguments on this thread about it? I'm saying I think statistics grouping all "BAME" people are useless because they include such separate groups of people.

Saying "the government does it" is not an argument, that's not how debate works. It is common and justifiable to criticise government decisions occasionally. If you think it IS a good idea to group everyone who isn't white, why not explain why

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:57

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 17:55

Consanguinity can be a factor in several genetic disorders, but that doesn’t explain the much higher rates of diagnosis in white children.

sigh, it is white privilege. White people at the whole population level have better access to healthcare.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:57

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:56

I'm just contributing my arguments on this thread about it? I'm saying I think statistics grouping all "BAME" people are useless because they include such separate groups of people.

Saying "the government does it" is not an argument, that's not how debate works. It is common and justifiable to criticise government decisions occasionally. If you think it IS a good idea to group everyone who isn't white, why not explain why

You were disputing factual statistics by disagreeing with the naming of a category our government use in their statistics. If you’re that bothered take it up with them. No one on MN has control over whether BAME is used or not.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:57

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:50

They are not "a population"! They have zero in common except for not being white. I'm not offended, I'm exasperated. But yes now you mention it, it is offensive to all those separate communities to lump them together and separate from British people.

They are not all separate from British people. Black British fall within the BAME grouping and the British grouping. They are overlapping categorisations. White British is an ethnicity hence why it is separated from White Irish and White European.

If you dislike the grouping that is perfectly valid. However my point was based on data that used that categorisation… I cannot change my wording because that wouldn’t apply to the same data so the stat would be invalid.

Thistoo2023 · Yesterday 17:58

@FriggadyDiggady Interested to hear your take on the explosion in dyslexia diagnoses since the 1980s? “Cultural phenomenon” or improved diagnostics/awareness? Might be a more meaningful comparator.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:59

What do all non white people have in common, except literally just their skin not being white?

Answer - absolutely nothing at all. We have different cultures, backgrounds, economic profiles, employment trends, even crime profiles vary within different ethnic groups.

Grouping us all together makes zero sense. There's nothing magically different about white people compared to everyone else.

Unless you think...there is?

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 18:01

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:57

They are not all separate from British people. Black British fall within the BAME grouping and the British grouping. They are overlapping categorisations. White British is an ethnicity hence why it is separated from White Irish and White European.

If you dislike the grouping that is perfectly valid. However my point was based on data that used that categorisation… I cannot change my wording because that wouldn’t apply to the same data so the stat would be invalid.

Edited

Sure, I meant white British. Separating white people from everyone else in one's statistics is meaningless. I have tried to explain why I think so.

If you'd like to discuss this, why not explain why you think it is helpful to separate the population into white vs everyone else when doing research?

painswick · Yesterday 18:02

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:53

Those are not examples of widening. Ffs, you would say a diagnostic net is widening if I wrote how scientists discovered men can have breast cancer too and so added diagnostic symptoms and criteria to id breast cancer in men.

AuDHD is how they discovered it is possible to have both. First in boys. Then on girls. Then for adults because adults present differently from children.

Nice, you said it is “based entirely on self reported internal phenomena” and now you are admitting you were wrong because it is also based on clinical observation. All observations have a degree of subjectivity. A doctor often diagnoses appendicitis or psychosis with clinical observations, the surgery or antipsychotic medication is applied, and the patient gets better.

Observation is the bedrock of science.

But anyway, they have both done genome sequencing and neural pathway mapping for ADHD, ASD, AND AuDHD which show distinct differences from each other and neurotypical genetic profiles and neural pathways. So if you like your science to come from a scan or a test, they have that too.

Your post clearly identified that they widened the net by removing one of the criteria.
I didn't at any point say that it was 'based entirely on self reported internal phenomena' that was a different poster so I have remained consistent in my position. Please do check my posts.

Of course clinical observations are part of medicine, as you identified in the case pf appendicits or psychosis the appication of appropriate medication shows that the diagnosios is correct. Please let me know what is the medication regime for Autism that resolves the symptoms in the same way as say appedicitis or psychosis I assume there is one as you appear to be drawing an equivalence.

With regard to the genome sequencing and neural pathway mapping, please correct me if I am wrong but I am not aware of either of those being used for the vast vast majotiry of diagnoses which is what this thread is talking about. Of course if it is the case that all these diagnoses are backed up by genome sequesncing and neural pathway mapping then I am happy to stand corrected,. but professionally I have probably seen thousands of diagnostic reports and I have yet to see one that contains either other than where there are multiole very complex co morbidities.

JHound · Yesterday 18:04

Neither of those seem relevant to OP? One is about waiting lists and the other about the impact of premature birth on development disorders?

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:05

painswick · Yesterday 17:21

Tell us more about this improved diagnostic testing over the last say 5 years? If you could identify how the diagnostic process has been upgraded and improved as opposed to widened that would be useful.

Changes were made in the DSM-5 (2013). Until then, autism and ADHD couldn’t be diagnosed together. ADHD's childhood symptom-onset threshold changed from before age 7 to before age 12, so more people were referred for diagnosis. In 2024 NICE recommended QbTest as an option to support ADHD assessments for children aged 6–17, but it’s not essential for a diagnosis. There is no blood test or genetic test for autism.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 18:06

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 18:01

Sure, I meant white British. Separating white people from everyone else in one's statistics is meaningless. I have tried to explain why I think so.

If you'd like to discuss this, why not explain why you think it is helpful to separate the population into white vs everyone else when doing research?

It depends on the level of research and the area. In Healthcare it can allow you to see racism and bias to separate white people from BAME people as if all the BAME people face worse outcomes then you can say racism may be at play. If you are looking at things like obesity, black Caribbean, African, South Asian, Middle Eastern and other Asian groups are all more at risk of health issues at a lower weight and lower waist size than white British people.

Of course it would be good to have stats on each minority from there however some sample sizes are so small that they are not comparative and so the method falls apart.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JHound · Yesterday 18:07

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 17:40

In my experience living and working in an area with a large Asian and Black population, its cultural taboo and stereotypes which lead parents to ignore their children’s issues and demonise SEND.

Culture taboo where? There are multiple different culture within various black and asian groups?

lightlower · Yesterday 18:07

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

Please share, would love to know your thoughts

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:09

JHound · Yesterday 18:04

Neither of those seem relevant to OP? One is about waiting lists and the other about the impact of premature birth on development disorders?

OP said “from looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports)”

There is a search engine called Google, you might like to give it a try.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:09

JHound · Yesterday 18:07

Culture taboo where? There are multiple different culture within various black and asian groups?

Specifically in my area it is Ghanaian, Jamaican and South Indian communities. Coming from early years and primary education I saw it frequently with those communities and less often with White British or other minority groups. Of course, as I said in my first post you replied to, this is my experience.

JHound · Yesterday 18:09

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

“Both”?

OP said black and Asian. Black is not synonymous with African and there are many black and Asian cultures.

Mummyoflittledragon · Yesterday 18:10

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 16:39

I have known a few diagnosed despite no evidence submitted from school.

I don’t think that always means a child shouldn’t be diagnosed. Dd’s school failed to respond. Teachers simply didn’t see anything. I obtained evidence from credible sources and a CAMHS psychiatrist suspected autism, so the diagnosis didn’t come out of thin air. Dd masks so heavily and I managed dd’s life so seamlessly, that no one at school suspected SEN. Yet she has severe ADHD, ASD and demand avoidance. There is a lot going on below the surface with dd.

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 18:10

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:48

I do agree but sometimes the symptoms are traits that we all have and aren’t actually ND.

Sometimes it’s MH or just kids being kids but their parents see them struggling, see they have a few autistic traits and so assume they’re autistic.

Most of the time it’s not coming from a bad place but it can look like parents are trying to force a diagnosis, when in fact they are just trying to support their child but who isn’t actually ND.

Or because people have failed to teach their kids important skills that perhaps came easier in previous generations. Things like downtime or as my dad would say, how to be bored.

I think that is why younger people today struggle with monotony of any kind in the workplace. They are accustomed to feeling inspired and stimulated by whatever tasks they're doing. The best schools nowadays find ways to individually motivate each student as the unique beings they are. We pay for that. It's a great goal in one sense but in another, it discourages a level of conformity you need to get by in the wider world.