Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Arran2024 · Today 15:40

grindergirl · Yesterday 23:02

To be blunt, I think that children who cannot cope in a mainstream school without all these extra supports should not be there at all. I doubt that there would be so much clamour for diagnoses if it meant the child being sent to a special school.
Lived experience. I went to a grammar school in the last 60s/early 70s. It had its share of oddballs, but nobody was expected to fit in the same one-sized straitjacket. However, rules were expected to be obeyed. Bad behaviour had consequences---usually the cane.
I only ever encountered one child with special needs, and that was in junior school. People might not like it nowadays, but he was sent to what was then called a school for the educationally subnormal. Some children, you just can't educate in mainstream schools. My view is that the rest need to learn to fit in. It should not be down to society to fit in with them
I can't be arsed to get a diagnosis, but I suspect I would be on the spectrum with what used to be called Aspergers. I have very little empathy, no wish to socialise, enjoy routine and abhor small talk. It doesn't bother me.

I'm 65 and even when I was a kid, SEN schools round my way were not called "schools for the educationally subnormal".

In fact, many children were sent to SEN schools just for having disabilities which mainstream schools decided they didn't want to, or couldn't (due to lack of resources) cope with.

I never knew children with significant SEN because they were sent to specialist schools from the beginning. Then we were streamed, even in my comprehensive.

I then adopted two children with SEN so it has all been a real eye opener for me. I also worked on supporting parents applying for ehc plans for a few years. This was in a very well off LA - still had a lot of deprivation, but anyway it means I saw a wide range of families. There were many wealthy Asian families as well as poorer ones. The big issue in certain communities of course is the marrying of cousins and the learning disabilities this can create. It affects wealthy families too. Like I said earlier, parents would often go back to their homeland if faced with a diagnosis they didn't like.

It wasn't just Asian families - i remember one Eastern European father exploding and throwing chairs as he didn't want his daughter given an ehc .

Arran2024 · Today 15:50

lxn889121 · Today 02:29

I live in Asia... and there is 100% an under-diagnosis of SEN conditions...

However, every time I go back to the UK, I feel like there is an over-diagnosis...

We like to imagine that diagnosis are black and white and objective, but that isn't how they work or are actually assessed, by medical professionals or teachers and parents.

From what I've seen working in education in both Asia and the UK. Both places recognize the "extreme" end of the needs spectrum, but Asian countries have a much higher bar for the grey areas in the middle of diagnosis. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.

A friend of mine has a don diagnosed with autism. He is a graduate now with a very good job in engineering, lives with his girlfriend. He went under the radar at primary - He kept his head down, was academically able. To his parents' astonishment, in year 6 his teacher told them he wouldn't cope at the local comp and suggested they go for a small private school which was known for taking asd kids.

So they sent him there. Then dad was offered a job in Dubai and they visited and looked at some schools. And none of them would take him! Dad had to turn down the move.

This is pretty typical experience.

Newname26 · Today 15:59

Arran2024 · Today 15:40

I'm 65 and even when I was a kid, SEN schools round my way were not called "schools for the educationally subnormal".

In fact, many children were sent to SEN schools just for having disabilities which mainstream schools decided they didn't want to, or couldn't (due to lack of resources) cope with.

I never knew children with significant SEN because they were sent to specialist schools from the beginning. Then we were streamed, even in my comprehensive.

I then adopted two children with SEN so it has all been a real eye opener for me. I also worked on supporting parents applying for ehc plans for a few years. This was in a very well off LA - still had a lot of deprivation, but anyway it means I saw a wide range of families. There were many wealthy Asian families as well as poorer ones. The big issue in certain communities of course is the marrying of cousins and the learning disabilities this can create. It affects wealthy families too. Like I said earlier, parents would often go back to their homeland if faced with a diagnosis they didn't like.

It wasn't just Asian families - i remember one Eastern European father exploding and throwing chairs as he didn't want his daughter given an ehc .

Where on earth are you?
I don't believe schools were ever called that?

Special Schools maybe but not that title. Or even Anytown School for Handicapped children

Arran2024 · Today 16:15

Newname26 · Today 15:59

Where on earth are you?
I don't believe schools were ever called that?

Special Schools maybe but not that title. Or even Anytown School for Handicapped children

That's what I said. Did you mean to respond to the person i quoted?

Additup · Today 17:28

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

This. Anyone who thinks that parents are getting a diagnosis for the lols know nothing about the process and the cost. You wouldn't do it unless you AND school were reasonably sure as there has to be good strong evidence from 2 sources to reach a clinical diagnosis.

CombatBarbie · Today 17:32

I remember a post on here where a black african was sent back to the ancestral home to have the devil taken out of him. I wont go into details, however it was horrific.

The child had autism which one of the parents refused to acknowledge.

Jane3212 · Today 18:43

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:58

Because frequently they are. I have a background within Asian family life and women are very much second place.

Can I ask what kind of Asian? I understand if not.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Today 18:45

Arran2024 · Today 15:40

I'm 65 and even when I was a kid, SEN schools round my way were not called "schools for the educationally subnormal".

In fact, many children were sent to SEN schools just for having disabilities which mainstream schools decided they didn't want to, or couldn't (due to lack of resources) cope with.

I never knew children with significant SEN because they were sent to specialist schools from the beginning. Then we were streamed, even in my comprehensive.

I then adopted two children with SEN so it has all been a real eye opener for me. I also worked on supporting parents applying for ehc plans for a few years. This was in a very well off LA - still had a lot of deprivation, but anyway it means I saw a wide range of families. There were many wealthy Asian families as well as poorer ones. The big issue in certain communities of course is the marrying of cousins and the learning disabilities this can create. It affects wealthy families too. Like I said earlier, parents would often go back to their homeland if faced with a diagnosis they didn't like.

It wasn't just Asian families - i remember one Eastern European father exploding and throwing chairs as he didn't want his daughter given an ehc .

Yes, I'm part Polish and I think in Eastern Europe generally attitudes to SN can be worse, though it is improving and varied based on country. Legacy of communism doesn't help which brought mass institutionalisation (most extreme case being Romania)

OP posts:
LumberPainJackie · Today 18:49

That is interesting as a male in my family is often jokingly called Putin. He has a diagnosis of aspergers and frankly doesn't give a shiny shite about anyone other than his own needs and wants! The "right kind" of SEN would likely be a very good comrade, I should think.

LumberPainJackie · Today 18:57

I should clarify that; Russian culture places immense value on academic excellence, mathematics, chess, and scientific achievement. When a neurodivergent person displays high intelligence or intense focus, society often embraces the talent while actively rejecting or hiding any clinical SEN diagnosis. I think the same would happen in some Asian countries FWIW.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page