Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

534 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:38

Ohthatsabitshit · Yesterday 16:36

I think it would be more interesting to look at what the outcomes where for those growing up without diagnosis from different cultural backgrounds.

Yes, this would definitely be interesting

OP posts:
swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 16:39

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

I have known a few diagnosed despite no evidence submitted from school.

JHound · Yesterday 16:41

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:35

I think this would vary a lot. Possibly in some more strictly religious communities, also divides based on education level sometimes, how long someone's family have lived in Britain also etc

That’s why I asked that PP this covers so many different communities and I don’t think it’s accurate that the men are financially in charge across them.
But then I have not seen any of this SEN data so don’t know.

Needmorelego · Yesterday 16:42

My daughter's SEN secondary (specialist for autistic children) is probably about 85% black children.

MaltesersDeath · Yesterday 16:42

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

Good investment financially though if it leads on to DLA and carers allowance.

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:45

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

I don't think the Sencos at the two schools I work with would agree - they have strong views about the way these diagnosis are achieved, but even if that's true it will absolutely be a factor in the prevelence of ADHD among white British children compared to other groups.

Freshrain · Yesterday 16:45

JHound · Yesterday 16:31

Is there a link to your data?

I imagine it would have to control for things such as parental age, socio-economic status and getting tested in the first place to make any meaningful comparison though.

Edited

I'd like to see the data you are reading too, as, working in this area in a very multicultural City, this is not what we see, at all.

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:47

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:36

It's worth asking also if at least some may have less screen time. I don't think screens cause SN of course, but excess screen time from a younger age may make it more visible.

Excess screen time can definitely present the same symptoms as true ASD.
It requires a solid professional to be able to separate two.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 16:47

The problem with these kinds of stats is that "Asian" covers a huge land mass and a huge diversity of cultures. Eg Japanese cultural norms are quite different from Pakistani and so on, and first generation immigrant families are often very different from families that have been British for 100 years. It's basically impossible to make conclusions when you compile stats with such a broad brush categorisation.

It's easy to say "Asian families promote self-reliance and aspiration" as a reason for these stats, and that may well be true in many cases. But I come originally from a big Asian city and I promise you, over there we have our fair share of young men NEETs who spend all night gaming, just the same as here.

alcovecupboards · Yesterday 16:47

Medical racism is a huge issue. A friend of mine has three SEN boys, all of whom it's been an absolute battle for her to get diagnosed despite anyone who spends any time at all with them knowing full well that they are SEN. Her eldest in particular was treated as naughty and a problem child for so long. They're black.

SenSupporter · Yesterday 16:47

Absolutely not the case in Harrow and Brent schools (I work in them) , SEN numbers are high and predominantly non white uk. Asian parents particularly are extremely engaged with getting support in place.

theveryhungry · Yesterday 16:49

Shame

WhitebaitLane · Yesterday 16:50

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:34

Very interesting. Re church :does this mean autism etc might be seen as a spiritual fault and treated harshly ? I hope not. I have read about very strict US Christian groups who see mentally illness as a sign of demons to be fought with 'spiritual warfare'.

All the Pentecostal churches I’ve been to were very big on the spiritual warfare and deliverances. Unfortunately had to witness im my family, it obviously doesn’t work and worsens severe issues like schizophrenia

I think more obvious autism is ‘accepted’. If your child is e.g. non-verbal, you don’t really have a choice but to accept they were born different… extra discipline isn't going to work. Depends on the parent overall though, I think autistic/disabled chidlren are more at risk of abuse generally.

More subtle diagnoses like ADHD are definitely seen as behavioural and not neurological, and will be handled at home or in church. It’s unsurprising from a more religious/conservative/patriarchal community.

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 16:51

I believe there are at three black children with autism and SEN at the school my son goes too. I know that because my son is sending too.

I do wonder also if autism is more common in white families or as someone else said it is hidden.

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 16:52

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:47

Excess screen time can definitely present the same symptoms as true ASD.
It requires a solid professional to be able to separate two.

My son is so obviously autistic and it definitely not screens.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 16:52

Culturally issues such as mental health, sexual orientation and ND are not often topics families from various countries will engage in. When it comes to sex ed for example, these are the families most likely to object to the government deciding what their child understands and will remove their consent. The shame felt for various reasons around it is often mis-read by these communities as "not something that happens in our culture". It is usually mostly down to lack of accurate reporting. We know of course that as these children get older and have autonomy they are likely to be diagnosed (for example with mental health problems) and will keep it to themselves, often not mentioning it even to parents and siblings for fear of stigma. It therefore perpetuates generationaly.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 16:52

Asian children generally do very well without any type of special pleading or concessions.

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 16:55

This is going to vary significantly within as well as between ethnic communities. Eg a third gen British Indian family with professional parents living in a posh bit of London, is not the same as recently arrived immigrant parents on minimum wage in a deprived ward of a small town.

If it is the case that rates of diagnosis are growing more slowly in non white populations, then it's going to be a combination of cultural resistance, cultural distrust of authorities, economic access to diagnosis, knowledge of ND, medical/institutional racism, ability to advocate in English, and other factors. Not all will apply in every case. I doubt screens are anything to do with it - is there a stat for ethnicity Vs screen time?

I'd also be interested to see the data itself on which this post is based.

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 16:56

Racism- unequal access to SEN assessment, diagnoses and provision.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:57

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 16:52

Asian children generally do very well without any type of special pleading or concessions.

SN isn't a 'special concession' anymore than a physical condition is.

OP posts:
sussexman · Yesterday 16:58

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:47

Excess screen time can definitely present the same symptoms as true ASD.
It requires a solid professional to be able to separate two.

That's a claim that needs backing up, not least because "the same symptoms as true ASD" rather suggests that "true ASD" has a single set of symptoms .

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 17:00

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 16:52

Asian children generally do very well without any type of special pleading or concessions.

Pakistani and Bangladeshi rates are on par with white British children, which strongly points towards a cultural lack of desire for diagnoses by other Asian groups rather than absence of ND.
I don't think you have much experience of SEN if you think these kids get "special pleading or concessions".

OutsideLookingOut · Yesterday 17:00

Many reasons but one I will give is that we may not present the same (like not as many girls were not diagnosed in the past).

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 17:01

Cultural.

  1. less recognised and more stigma in some communities

  2. kids who probably do meet the diagnosis threshold are more likely to be resilient and skilled in other ways which lessens their need for formal support and diagnosis itself.

  3. white parents are more likely to fight for a diagnosis to excuse "explain" mediocrity or poor behaviour.

OneCanWonder · Yesterday 17:01

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

I went private, for myself, and didn't get the diagnosis I'd suspected.
I will add that my assessment was carried out by an NHS Consultant Psychologist who also works privately.
I also didn't seek a diagnosis for anything other than to understand myself. It was suggested that I seek and alternative diagnosis which I did and was given.