Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:34

Hagr1d · Yesterday 22:21

Overwhelming Majority Pakistani, some Bengali, a few Indian and a handful of Arabs. There are some black children in the school too but not enough for me to feel like I could comment on a general trend.

Thank you. From what I've read British-Pakistanis are more likely to be poor than some other Asian groups and as you said this with other combined issues mea diagnosis might not be prioritised. Also, I was thinking maybe that in more stable families, as well as ones with more resources, there may be more support so perhaps the symptoms are less evident when are child is ND.
Also intergenerational cousin marriage among Pakistanis would probably be another factor making rates higher.

OP posts:
FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:36

VioletsTale · Yesterday 22:33

No one “invented “ autism, just like no one invented diabetes, asthma or cancer.

Ugh. Discovered then. Did you have a look at the article?

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:38

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:23

Where do you get these ideas? I was at school with Indian children in the 1970s. Their parents were bus drivers or factory workers. The children are neither more or less intelligent than anyone else of our generation and class.

The parents may have had more education and better jobs in their countries of origin sometimes, though. Min Jin Lee, the author of Pachinko, had parents, middle class educated people in Korea, who ran a laundry in a working class area of NY after emigrating. That's America but different demographics of Asians have similar stories here sometimes.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:42

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:29

This article is quite interesting. Basically the people who invented autism are moving towards being in favour of distinguishing between the seriously impaired and those who just aren't. Hopefully this view will gain traction.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/the-term-is-becoming-unrecognisable-have-the-experts-who-believed-in-a-single-autism-spectrum-changed-their-minds

Edited

Yes, I think you'd find Uta Frith's recent statements interesting.

I think there are genuine reasons it's increasd but there may be some degree of overdiagnosis going on.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Age-Diagnosis-Sickness-Health-Medicine/dp/1399727648

OP posts:
Lis947 · Yesterday 22:53

redbullsurvivor · Yesterday 16:16

I would say culturally there is still shame and non belief in this type of SEN. So Asian families will either deny and move forward and survive without a diagnosis.

I think that also mixes with White British having a tendency to over diagnose and want there to be a label / excuse for everything.

100% agree, I do think it's cultural and there is some shame attached! A friend worked in a nursery with a beautiful child who very clearly had quite serious special needs. The Father, who was African wouldn't have it, no way way there anything "wrong" with his child.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:56

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:29

This article is quite interesting. Basically the people who invented autism are moving towards being in favour of distinguishing between the seriously impaired and those who just aren't. Hopefully this view will gain traction.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/the-term-is-becoming-unrecognisable-have-the-experts-who-believed-in-a-single-autism-spectrum-changed-their-minds

Edited

Uta Frith didn’t invent autism. The word was first used in 1911 by Eugen Bleuler. Leo Kanner established autism as a distinct clinical condition in 1943. Hans Asperger described a subtype of autism in 1944. Infantile Autism could be diagnosed from 1980. Autistic Disorder from 1987. Before that, it could only be diagnosed as childhood schizophrenia. Uta Frith edited a book called Autism and Asperger Syndrome in 1991. So no, she didn’t invent autism, although she was part of research into autism for decades, and the majority of autism researchers disagree with her latest work. I have a Master’s degree in ASD. If you’re interested, as it seems you are, there is a free course on the Open University called Understanding Autism that you can access. No ChatGPT was involved in typing this post.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:59

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:29

This article is quite interesting. Basically the people who invented autism are moving towards being in favour of distinguishing between the seriously impaired and those who just aren't. Hopefully this view will gain traction.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/the-term-is-becoming-unrecognisable-have-the-experts-who-believed-in-a-single-autism-spectrum-changed-their-minds

Edited

Frith didn't discover autism. Kanner & Asperger laid foundation work & it widened with Lorna Wing & later researchers, including Frith. Frith is definitely one of the top experts on it, though.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:59

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:56

Uta Frith didn’t invent autism. The word was first used in 1911 by Eugen Bleuler. Leo Kanner established autism as a distinct clinical condition in 1943. Hans Asperger described a subtype of autism in 1944. Infantile Autism could be diagnosed from 1980. Autistic Disorder from 1987. Before that, it could only be diagnosed as childhood schizophrenia. Uta Frith edited a book called Autism and Asperger Syndrome in 1991. So no, she didn’t invent autism, although she was part of research into autism for decades, and the majority of autism researchers disagree with her latest work. I have a Master’s degree in ASD. If you’re interested, as it seems you are, there is a free course on the Open University called Understanding Autism that you can access. No ChatGPT was involved in typing this post.

Sorry, thank you for this! This explains the history much better.

OP posts:
grindergirl · Yesterday 23:02

To be blunt, I think that children who cannot cope in a mainstream school without all these extra supports should not be there at all. I doubt that there would be so much clamour for diagnoses if it meant the child being sent to a special school.
Lived experience. I went to a grammar school in the last 60s/early 70s. It had its share of oddballs, but nobody was expected to fit in the same one-sized straitjacket. However, rules were expected to be obeyed. Bad behaviour had consequences---usually the cane.
I only ever encountered one child with special needs, and that was in junior school. People might not like it nowadays, but he was sent to what was then called a school for the educationally subnormal. Some children, you just can't educate in mainstream schools. My view is that the rest need to learn to fit in. It should not be down to society to fit in with them
I can't be arsed to get a diagnosis, but I suspect I would be on the spectrum with what used to be called Aspergers. I have very little empathy, no wish to socialise, enjoy routine and abhor small talk. It doesn't bother me.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:02

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:56

To clarify, do you think most cases of neurodivergence are not real and the children don't usually have these conditions? Or do you think most cases are real, but that diagnosis and professional support are not helpful? Or something else?
I think it's irrelevant. Whether a child is diagnosed or undiagnosed, the need to adapt to society as much as it is possible should be the focus, rather than it becoming how society should adapt to those diagnosed.

Adaptability is subjective and it's not a white or black status. However, any support should aim at teaching the skills to do so rather than encouraging a position of avoidance and dependency on others.

This has been shown to be harmful. It’s teaching masking, not adaptation, and it leads to burnout. People with undiagnosed autism and ADHD have been trying to adapt for decades without success, usually resulting in mental health issues that could have been avoided. Society eventually got used to making adaptations for wheelchair users, visually impaired people and Deaf people. That’s how society evolves.

user1492757084 · Yesterday 23:04

Wow! That is interesting information.
I suppose it is in cultural differences, mainly the level of self discipline practised and taught by Asian Tiger parents.

I am generalising .. but Asian children I know get homework done. Their parents expect their kids to work hard and achieve their best. Excuses might not be tolerated.

Also a structured schedule might help children cope and effectively hide social and learning problems. Thus, not highlighting the need to investigate.

Do the statistics reflect levels of assessments? More research is needed. The nuture versus nature needs exploration.

YouareJustApreciousLittleGem · Yesterday 23:07

well, perhaps they just want to live and let live and have their kids as they are , without any superficial and useless labels thrown at them by a white host culture

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:07

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:36

Ugh. Discovered then. Did you have a look at the article?

I’ve recently been spending considerable time reading what Uta Frith has written and the responses of academics in the field of autism. I like to go to the source rather than read an opinion piece by a journalist, although it is part of my actual job to research and understand the latest developments.

YouareJustApreciousLittleGem · Yesterday 23:11

grindergirl · Yesterday 23:02

To be blunt, I think that children who cannot cope in a mainstream school without all these extra supports should not be there at all. I doubt that there would be so much clamour for diagnoses if it meant the child being sent to a special school.
Lived experience. I went to a grammar school in the last 60s/early 70s. It had its share of oddballs, but nobody was expected to fit in the same one-sized straitjacket. However, rules were expected to be obeyed. Bad behaviour had consequences---usually the cane.
I only ever encountered one child with special needs, and that was in junior school. People might not like it nowadays, but he was sent to what was then called a school for the educationally subnormal. Some children, you just can't educate in mainstream schools. My view is that the rest need to learn to fit in. It should not be down to society to fit in with them
I can't be arsed to get a diagnosis, but I suspect I would be on the spectrum with what used to be called Aspergers. I have very little empathy, no wish to socialise, enjoy routine and abhor small talk. It doesn't bother me.

lol, my cuddos for the night go to this post

painswick · Yesterday 23:16

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:07

I’ve recently been spending considerable time reading what Uta Frith has written and the responses of academics in the field of autism. I like to go to the source rather than read an opinion piece by a journalist, although it is part of my actual job to research and understand the latest developments.

Of course there is now a very large and profitable industry of experts and advisers and researchers on Autism of which you appear to be one, who seem very put out by Uta Frith daring to suggest that things may not be only going in one direction. They undoubtedly all have a vested interest in ASD continuing to maintain its extremely high profile and increased levels of diagnosis.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 23:18

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:42

Yes, I think you'd find Uta Frith's recent statements interesting.

I think there are genuine reasons it's increasd but there may be some degree of overdiagnosis going on.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Age-Diagnosis-Sickness-Health-Medicine/dp/1399727648

Edited

The trouble is people think different things are over-diagnosis being proven.
So for some because my dd is able to go to school and likely to get great grades, that means she isn't autistic "enough" and must be an example of a pushy parent who just wants a label. For others because she has a remarkably high IQ that "proves" autism, alongside her hyper focus and special interests. However if you mention her high anxiety that leads to selective mutism or zoning out, people seem to be on the fence as to whether that means she is allowed to have support, to help her get say MFL and be able to do her speaking exam, or if she should be penalised because it is one of the "needy" parts of her diagnosis and we should not be making exceptions. She is unlikely to ever need PIP, I hope but I do also want to know a workplace isn't going to make her job for them harder and lead to her crashing because they don't recognise she will literally just keep working and crash.

I don't think it is all just about if these children claim financial benefits, we need to understand that for them to be productive in society, figuring out how to get the best out of them is key to everyone benefiting.

Ginflinger · Yesterday 23:18

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:47

Excess screen time can definitely present the same symptoms as true ASD.
It requires a solid professional to be able to separate two.

Interested to know what you're basing this on? Is there data?

FoxtrotPapa · Yesterday 23:23

This is my experience. Some south Asians won’t accept or are not interested in a diagnosis as they don’t wish to label their child whereas the white middle class will pay privately for diagnoses and push for EHCPs taking them to appeal to get/force what they want. The latter is what happens at our primary. The SEN lead can’t cope with the sheer numbers. Some of those children are absolutely SEN but some of them are clearly not. Messing around in class, not listening and fidgeting are not automatic signs of SEN but try telling some of the parents that. The huge increase means the support services are buckling, meanwhile the quiet kids with non-SEN needs such as anxiety and worries are ignored. The system is broke because some people (not all) play that system to the max.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:24

painswick · Yesterday 23:16

Of course there is now a very large and profitable industry of experts and advisers and researchers on Autism of which you appear to be one, who seem very put out by Uta Frith daring to suggest that things may not be only going in one direction. They undoubtedly all have a vested interest in ASD continuing to maintain its extremely high profile and increased levels of diagnosis.

With all due respect, you have no idea of my income and there’s no need for you make a personal attack. Uta Frith is 85, I hope to be long retired if I get to that age.

Fluffyblackcat7 · Yesterday 23:29

We sought a private ASD diagnosis for DS because the NHS waiting list in our area meant that despite having been referred in Y1, he wouldn't get an assessment until after he started secondary school which we felt would leave him at a considerable disadvantage.

He was assessed using evidence from school, parental questionnaires and three in-person assessments with two clinicians covering three disciplines between them.

I think his diagnosis is correct.

painswick · Yesterday 23:30

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:24

With all due respect, you have no idea of my income and there’s no need for you make a personal attack. Uta Frith is 85, I hope to be long retired if I get to that age.

Ok weird response. Do you dispute that there is a large and growing industry of ASD experts and researchers? Apologies if you interpreted my post as meaning I thought you were financially motivated that wasn't my intention. it was a broader point about vested interests as a general principle.

PosyFossilsShoes · Yesterday 23:32

I'm dubious as to these statistics, because "SEN" covers a really vast array of needs. At one end you have a child who is getting half an hour a month drama therapy because his parents are having a difficult divorce and he is on the SEN register for SEMH due to anxiety, or a child who has SEN needs for mild dyslexia and is getting intensive reading support, both of whom will no longer need intervention next year. At the other you have a child who is never attending a mainstream school due to a severe learning disability.

My DC has been in mainstream and is now at specialist. Where we live, at mainstream there was definitely a difference in terms of willingness to accept that the child has needs / might need support. My experience - which is not universal - was that white parents were more willing to accept or even request an assessment for a child who was apparently coping okay, while parents from some BME backgrounds would be insisting that their child had "perhaps a touch of dyslexia" but would not countenance that there was anything else going on unless it was really severe.

Interestingly at DC's specialist school (if we're using the general drop-down menu) the class is 40% white British, 40% black British and 20% Asian. So it seems on purely anecdotal evidence that while the "SEN register" in mainstream might be overrepresented in white British families, the need for actual specialist provision is not.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:32

YouareJustApreciousLittleGem · Yesterday 23:07

well, perhaps they just want to live and let live and have their kids as they are , without any superficial and useless labels thrown at them by a white host culture

'Host culture' - when you move to a country to stay, they aren't simply your host. You become part of their people- that should be your aim.

ASD and ADHD are not simply 'useless labels'. They are real conditions and lack of diagnosis can cause real harm. Otoh overdiagnosis does also exist.

OP posts:
FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 23:33

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:07

I’ve recently been spending considerable time reading what Uta Frith has written and the responses of academics in the field of autism. I like to go to the source rather than read an opinion piece by a journalist, although it is part of my actual job to research and understand the latest developments.

The question wasn't directed at you, but if you're going to pull rank by referencing your professional understanding and knowledge of these issues, can you let us know what your job is please?

Twinkeeyes · Yesterday 23:36

It does seem many children are being over diagnosed because of the high number of recent cases

Many families have pride and do not want to rely the society to pay for their children