Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Hagr1d · Yesterday 21:55

I am of South Asian descent and work in a school where 95% of the children are South Asian..I have been teaching for years (secondary) There are HUGE amounts of asian kids with SEN, sometimes undiagonosed, sometimes extreme to the point where the child should not be in mainstream education. Here are some thoughts:

  • The concept of 'shame' is huge in this community. We have had mothers actually REJECT a place in a special school for their kid out of fear of what others may say. IMO they have done their children a massive disservice in sending those children to a huge academy like the one I work in. The child is often overwhlemed. Many parents also are unwilling to get official diagnoses and fear the stigma.
  • Safeguarding context - This is is a school in a very deprived part of England. Many of our children suffer from poverty, abuse etc. If foster care placements are breaking down or a parent is on trial for serious offences or the family simply don't have enough food, then getting a diagnosis for SEN won't be a priority. I'm also thinking about the children who have at least one parent with severe mental health issues so they are unable to parent generally and meet the basics, let alone explore how their child could thrive via a proper diagnoses and potential support.
  • Lack of Education amongst the parents - Even if the parents want what's best, they are often wholly ignorant of SEN and either through ignorance or denial cannot see it in their own child. Language barriers can also prevent a family from getting/pursuing support. Often a lack of understanding (combined with the fear of stigma) results in minimising and issues not being diagnosed.

This is all obviously a generalisation and anecdotal. It is also very specific to my local community. I don't have any data to hand and this is my own personal inisght as someone who grew up in a similar community and now works in one like it.

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:56

To clarify, do you think most cases of neurodivergence are not real and the children don't usually have these conditions? Or do you think most cases are real, but that diagnosis and professional support are not helpful? Or something else?
I think it's irrelevant. Whether a child is diagnosed or undiagnosed, the need to adapt to society as much as it is possible should be the focus, rather than it becoming how society should adapt to those diagnosed.

Adaptability is subjective and it's not a white or black status. However, any support should aim at teaching the skills to do so rather than encouraging a position of avoidance and dependency on others.

ThreeLocusts · Yesterday 21:57

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

That's sad. I'd be curious to hear why you don't want to elaborate.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:57

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:47

You can’t claim something as fact “assessments were done more in depth”- for example- when it’s not a fact , just an assumption/opinion, and an uninformed assumption/opinion at that.

ETA You did the same when claiming there were fewer NEETS. They weren’t a thing!! No one counted them. Or fewer exclusions , again , officially they didn’t bother to keep track much.

Edited

Try reading the NHS ADHD task force which confirms that ADHD is significantly under recognised, under diagnosed and under treated across England that with disproportionate barriers affecting women, girls and marginalised ethnic groups.https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/report-of-the-independent-adhd-taskforce-part-1/

Re autism in women and girls and people of colour Fonagy has just noted that historical sex gaps in autism diagnosis largely reflected lower clinical recognition rather than true differences in how often the condition occurs. Diagnostic criteria were historically shaped around male presentations, meaning girls and women who "mask" or camouflage traits were frequently overlooked or diagnosed much later in life. Evidence cited around the review and related UK population studies highlights persistent ethnic disparities in identification pathways. For example, data shows that children from South Asian and other minoritised ethnic backgrounds are significantly less likely to receive a timely autism diagnosis compared to White British children, despite showing comparable developmental needs. [Females from minorities ethnic backgrounds face compounded barriers. Research points out that autistic Black and South Asian girls are especially likely to experience delayed identification, misdiagnosis, or exclusion from support pathways.

NHS England » Report of the independent ADHD Taskforce: Part 1

April 2025

https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/report-of-the-independent-adhd-taskforce-part-1

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:59

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:57

Try reading the NHS ADHD task force which confirms that ADHD is significantly under recognised, under diagnosed and under treated across England that with disproportionate barriers affecting women, girls and marginalised ethnic groups.https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/report-of-the-independent-adhd-taskforce-part-1/

Re autism in women and girls and people of colour Fonagy has just noted that historical sex gaps in autism diagnosis largely reflected lower clinical recognition rather than true differences in how often the condition occurs. Diagnostic criteria were historically shaped around male presentations, meaning girls and women who "mask" or camouflage traits were frequently overlooked or diagnosed much later in life. Evidence cited around the review and related UK population studies highlights persistent ethnic disparities in identification pathways. For example, data shows that children from South Asian and other minoritised ethnic backgrounds are significantly less likely to receive a timely autism diagnosis compared to White British children, despite showing comparable developmental needs. [Females from minorities ethnic backgrounds face compounded barriers. Research points out that autistic Black and South Asian girls are especially likely to experience delayed identification, misdiagnosis, or exclusion from support pathways.

why do you keep telling me this? I know all about it! Professionally and personally. It’s other posters that need educating, not that they’re actually willing to listen.

Urgentbiscuitrequired · Yesterday 22:01

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

I am sceptical like you, but if you are going to pay 1k plus for an assessment I think it's highly likely you are convinced your child will tick many of the boxes. Why would you pay such a large sum for something you think your child has a slim chance of having?

My child has a lot of friends from ethnic minorities. They have very high ambitions for their children in terms of career, so think that is part of it, maybe worrying about the impact on that. Their parents were all lovely when my other child was diagnosed with severe ASD though, unlike the other white parents who just avoided me because they didn't know what to say.

Arran2024 · Yesterday 22:02

LucieO · Yesterday 16:22

I work in education and have known several students from Asian families where the mother would be receptive to some support for their child with suspected SEN but absolutely not to a formal
diagnosis and the school were instructed to not let the father know under any circumstances. I imagine this sort of situation may be impacting statistics.

Same. And some families would move abroad rather than accept a diagnosis.

Redpaisley · Yesterday 22:09

Anonusernameforthispost · Yesterday 21:24

South Asian here. 2nd gen, almost 3rd gen. So have watched grandparents who were very old fashioned and preserved their way life, parents who were more integrated and me who feels British and culturally assimilated. And now my kids who live the same trials and tribulations that their white counterpart Gen Z and Gen Alpha face.

There is generally a ‘pull yourself together and crack on’ attitude in our culture.

And d’you know what. It works. I’m sorry to say that the over indulgence of even the slightest neurodivergence and turning your kids into victims really does them a disservice. It is not kind and it is not helpful. I am not saying neurodivergence is t real or impactful but in western cultures it is made into people’s entire personality. The cult of victimhood is setting us back. Let’s stop this.

BS. My mother has some learning difficulties. If her parents didn’t have the attitude you have, she would have done better in life. She never received any support because of this uncaring pull yourself and crack on attitude.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:11

Hagr1d · Yesterday 21:55

I am of South Asian descent and work in a school where 95% of the children are South Asian..I have been teaching for years (secondary) There are HUGE amounts of asian kids with SEN, sometimes undiagonosed, sometimes extreme to the point where the child should not be in mainstream education. Here are some thoughts:

  • The concept of 'shame' is huge in this community. We have had mothers actually REJECT a place in a special school for their kid out of fear of what others may say. IMO they have done their children a massive disservice in sending those children to a huge academy like the one I work in. The child is often overwhlemed. Many parents also are unwilling to get official diagnoses and fear the stigma.
  • Safeguarding context - This is is a school in a very deprived part of England. Many of our children suffer from poverty, abuse etc. If foster care placements are breaking down or a parent is on trial for serious offences or the family simply don't have enough food, then getting a diagnosis for SEN won't be a priority. I'm also thinking about the children who have at least one parent with severe mental health issues so they are unable to parent generally and meet the basics, let alone explore how their child could thrive via a proper diagnoses and potential support.
  • Lack of Education amongst the parents - Even if the parents want what's best, they are often wholly ignorant of SEN and either through ignorance or denial cannot see it in their own child. Language barriers can also prevent a family from getting/pursuing support. Often a lack of understanding (combined with the fear of stigma) results in minimising and issues not being diagnosed.

This is all obviously a generalisation and anecdotal. It is also very specific to my local community. I don't have any data to hand and this is my own personal inisght as someone who grew up in a similar community and now works in one like it.

Thank you for this, very sad there are these problems. Can I ask which Asian community this is? I understand if you'd rather not give more detail.

OP posts:
TheCappyEffect · Yesterday 22:13

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:55

Or rather, the women in the family have to manage it themselves...

I care for an elderly relative myself but she is luckily mentally healthy. I think it's good to do so if possible but we shouldn't underestimate the stress it can cause women (usually women) especially if it's culturally expected.

That’s pretty much what I said

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:13

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:52

Spot on in what sense? Because it certainly isn’t a compelling argument based on any meaningful research.

NICE is cautious about diagnosis and treatment in under-fives, recommending parent-training programmes first and requiring a second specialist opinion before ADHD medication can be prescribed. I haven’t heard of anyone under five being diagnosed with ADHD, but there’s no minimum recommended age as there is for dyslexia.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:16

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:59

Assessed for being well behaved?

Girls with ADHD are often exceptionally well-behaved, helpful to teachers etc. It’s one reason so many aren’t identified at a young age.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Yesterday 22:19

I think one reason is that a lot of white parents, especially where white MC child have SEN, are much more likely to push for a diagnosis

Hagr1d · Yesterday 22:21

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:11

Thank you for this, very sad there are these problems. Can I ask which Asian community this is? I understand if you'd rather not give more detail.

Overwhelming Majority Pakistani, some Bengali, a few Indian and a handful of Arabs. There are some black children in the school too but not enough for me to feel like I could comment on a general trend.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:22

I'm actually quite encouraged by this thread. I thought that I would be roundly shat upon for daring to question the validity of the massive increases in SEN, but, despite the deletion of my posts, it seems that actually it's quite a popular view.
Are there any organizations campaigning against this overmedicalization? I don't really care if people want to have loads of special labels, but I resent the waste of public money, which is in short supply at the moment.
I'm not applying any of this censure to genuine cases.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 22:23

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:22

I'm actually quite encouraged by this thread. I thought that I would be roundly shat upon for daring to question the validity of the massive increases in SEN, but, despite the deletion of my posts, it seems that actually it's quite a popular view.
Are there any organizations campaigning against this overmedicalization? I don't really care if people want to have loads of special labels, but I resent the waste of public money, which is in short supply at the moment.
I'm not applying any of this censure to genuine cases.

How do you differentiate between genuine cases or not?

Ilovecrispytofu · Yesterday 22:23

WhitebaitLane · Yesterday 16:27

My experience of this (African) is a lot of parents are in denial regarding SEN or MH. It’s not necessarily teachers labelling black boys as defiant, it’s parents also seeing it as a discipline thing. Likewise MH is a spiritual thing to be handled in the church. As above, also seen as shameful compared to white Brits.

I’m sure there are other reasons as well, but this is certainly my experience.

This is my experience too.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:23

CrispySquid · Yesterday 21:17

Oh yes, don’t worry, I completely agree with you. Many with SEN, especially autism have incredibly high IQ.

I just meant it might explain why current Chinese and Indian children in UK who are descendants of 1960s, 70s and 80s immigrants (who were a very different demographic and skill-level to immigrants nowadays) have both very low levels of SEND AND very high levels of things like academic attainment, literacy, contentiousness (and also low levels of behavioural issues). Selection effect of high-skilled, highly aspirational immigrants compounded by a huge heritability effect,

Where do you get these ideas? I was at school with Indian children in the 1970s. Their parents were bus drivers or factory workers. The children are neither more or less intelligent than anyone else of our generation and class.

Floatingdownriver · Yesterday 22:26

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Surely you can see that if making the very costly decision to go private this is generally based on a fair amount of evidence to say a neurodivergence is highly probable?

MeshMesh · Yesterday 22:27

Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:41

I don't think your post is unreliable, sorry, I meant ChatGPT generally can be unreliable. I've had cases before where it recommended films to me that turned out not to exist!

But no, I think it made relevant points in your post & I agree that IQ of parents is probably not a big factor in whether a child is SN. Pp is right about immigrants then being more educated on average etc when they came, though. I don't think that's 'eugenic' : it's factual that IQ is to some degree heritable and so is SN, as she claimed.

Edited

Yes, overall on average. But, it’s only a 12% difference between those born outside UK and those born in UK in terms of % with HE. So, not a huge difference.

Plus, fewer people born in Pakistan and Bangladesh have HE vs UK born people, so not always useful to talk about foreign-born as a whole.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 22:27

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Yesterday 22:19

I think one reason is that a lot of white parents, especially where white MC child have SEN, are much more likely to push for a diagnosis

They are in a better position/better resourced to push for a diagnosis.

First of all, they won’t have to deal with racial or poverty prejudice and assumptions that can delay access.
Then they are more likely to be educated and articulate enough to make themselves heard , jump through all the hoops, fill in and understand the paperwork, chase schools etc.
Then if still no luck, they are more likely to afford going private and access various types of support privately. Even the free support that might be available requires time, understanding, resources, and a general awareness and knowing where to look , who and what to ask etc.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:30

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · Yesterday 21:28

My son had a computer test for ADHD alongside school and parent reports. They were actually on the fence about giving him an ADHD diagnosis until they got the test results. It's not an exact science / cannot be used in isolation.

Yes, the Qb test. It’s been used by some CAMHS services for years.

MeshMesh · Yesterday 22:32

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 22:23

Where do you get these ideas? I was at school with Indian children in the 1970s. Their parents were bus drivers or factory workers. The children are neither more or less intelligent than anyone else of our generation and class.

You are correct. In 1977, 57% of Indian born immigrants in the UK were working as manual workers. Only 10% were professionals.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 22:33

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:29

This article is quite interesting. Basically the people who invented autism are moving towards being in favour of distinguishing between the seriously impaired and those who just aren't. Hopefully this view will gain traction.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/the-term-is-becoming-unrecognisable-have-the-experts-who-believed-in-a-single-autism-spectrum-changed-their-minds

Edited

No one “invented “ autism, just like no one invented diabetes, asthma or cancer.