Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jane3212 · Today 00:21

BarbieinBloom · Today 00:17

I think with iPads, isn’t there a child account you can get with security and password etc? Can you put timer on it and restrictions? Can the email be set to the parents iCloud account? Tbh, I haven’t set up a child account recently so I’m unaware?

I don’t disagree with the intensity, but why are children allowed them for a significant amount of time? Why are they allowed to have all these apps?

If it were me, I can see this happening I would have sold the iPad etc. Get rid off the source. If they have a tantrum, tough. They can save up and buy one.

With a phone, I would buy them the most basic phone with no internet. Only phone call and messages, so they can contact me. Basically, a brick. If they want an iPhone, they can buy and save up themselves.

Edited

There definitely are things that can be done. I suppose I was thinking more of older children where iPhones and social media apps until recently were a big form of socialising and children without them were left in a difficult position often.

Re younger children and iPads I think they simply shouldn't have them, or very little if at all. News can exaggerate but there does seem to be a worrying issue with Gen Alpha being given iPads etc at really young ages by parents who don't seem to want to enforce proper boundaries. Parents now should know more of the risks than , say, in 2007 when the iPhone came out.

OP posts:
BarbieinBloom · Today 00:26

Jane3212 · Today 00:21

There definitely are things that can be done. I suppose I was thinking more of older children where iPhones and social media apps until recently were a big form of socialising and children without them were left in a difficult position often.

Re younger children and iPads I think they simply shouldn't have them, or very little if at all. News can exaggerate but there does seem to be a worrying issue with Gen Alpha being given iPads etc at really young ages by parents who don't seem to want to enforce proper boundaries. Parents now should know more of the risks than , say, in 2007 when the iPhone came out.

I’m not sure really because I haven’t been put in that position, to be honest. Depending on how old the child is, especially if they’re 16+ they’re going to do what they want to do at that point. There’s only so much you can do, especially if they’re nearly 18. I was thinking more towards primary school and maybe early secondary.

I don’t think I would buy my child an iPad, iPhone or gaming devices as granted, they will be expected to earn them. I will just claim I can’t afford it. They can save up and earn. If displaying poor behaviour, the longer I will delay.

JMSA · Today 01:01

Denial of mental health issues.

FrauPaige · Today 01:15

I suppose it is in cultural differences, mainly the level of self discipline practised and taught by Asian Tiger parents.

@user1492757084 Let's not import American caricatures to the UK. The term Asian Tiger is an American racialised stereotype of Chinese-American and Korean-American parenting styles compared with mainstream white-American parenting styles.

Not only is it a lazy caricature, it is inaccurate in suggesting that authoritative parenting with an education first mindset is somehow unique to East Asians. Every migrants group in the UK with aspirational parents from the global south operates from the same playbook. There is nothing unique about it.

Case in point: when we are referring to "Asian" people in the UK, that refers predominantly Indians, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis - so references to Asian Tigers would not include British Asians and would not explain why Indian and Bangladeshi girls routinely outperform White British girls with GCSE and A-level results.

The Asia Tiger caricature survives in the US because they live segregated lives and don't meet people from different ethnic groups. Whereas in the UK we have an integrated society and know that British Asians are represented in all sections of society from doctors to lawyers to teachers to retail to factory workers.

Makingham · Today 01:25

I think its down to the parenting styles.

Jane3212 · Today 01:30

FrauPaige · Today 01:15

I suppose it is in cultural differences, mainly the level of self discipline practised and taught by Asian Tiger parents.

@user1492757084 Let's not import American caricatures to the UK. The term Asian Tiger is an American racialised stereotype of Chinese-American and Korean-American parenting styles compared with mainstream white-American parenting styles.

Not only is it a lazy caricature, it is inaccurate in suggesting that authoritative parenting with an education first mindset is somehow unique to East Asians. Every migrants group in the UK with aspirational parents from the global south operates from the same playbook. There is nothing unique about it.

Case in point: when we are referring to "Asian" people in the UK, that refers predominantly Indians, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis - so references to Asian Tigers would not include British Asians and would not explain why Indian and Bangladeshi girls routinely outperform White British girls with GCSE and A-level results.

The Asia Tiger caricature survives in the US because they live segregated lives and don't meet people from different ethnic groups. Whereas in the UK we have an integrated society and know that British Asians are represented in all sections of society from doctors to lawyers to teachers to retail to factory workers.

Edited

'The Asia Tiger caricature survives in the US because they live segregated lives and don't meet people from different ethnic groups'

  • that's a big generalisation! A lot of Asian-Americans are highly integrated, many are intermarried too.

'it is inaccurate in suggesting that authoritative parenting with an education first mindset is somehow unique to East Asians. Every migrants group in the UK with aspirational parents from the global south operates from the same playbook. There is nothing unique about it.'

  • Amy Chua actually says this in her book. In the first chapter she says she's using the term 'Chinese/Tiger mother' loosely and the term could apply to lots of Ghanian/Jamaican/Indian & other groups too, and that many Chinese & other Asian parents are not stereotypical Tiger parents. She does make some odd generalisations in the book but that isn't one of them.
OP posts:
lxn889121 · Today 02:29

I live in Asia... and there is 100% an under-diagnosis of SEN conditions...

However, every time I go back to the UK, I feel like there is an over-diagnosis...

We like to imagine that diagnosis are black and white and objective, but that isn't how they work or are actually assessed, by medical professionals or teachers and parents.

From what I've seen working in education in both Asia and the UK. Both places recognize the "extreme" end of the needs spectrum, but Asian countries have a much higher bar for the grey areas in the middle of diagnosis. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.

lxn889121 · Today 02:34

It is also worth adding that there is a cultural difference between (east) Asian mothers and Western mothers in how they internalize their children's problems. (This is well established in academic literature)

Asian mothers internalize their own children's problems, successes and failures as their own to a much much greater degree. What this results in is that a western mother will blame themselves a bit for problems, but in the end if their child is struggling it is because their child is struggling, or if their child is naughty, its because the child is naughty. They are less likely to have view that every failure of their child is a failure of them.

On the other hand in Asian culture, your child reflects you to a much greater degree - if they are bad, you are bad, if they fail, you failed, if they are naughty, you have the same shame as them etc.

Of course this is an average difference, but it is one present in parental attitude research.

In terms of why this matters for SEN, its because for many Asian parents, SEN still isn't viewed as an innate natural issue that can't be avoided, its instead viewed as a failure of the parents. That is wrong, but I hear it all the time. "it must have been something I did while pregnant" or grandparents saying "they are like that because their mum...."

If you combine the two things - the idea that SEN is caused by something, and that any failure of the child is a failure of the parents. You end up with a recipe for denying problems.

normanstangersoninthebath · Today 03:03

25 years ago, when I nived to the middle east, I asked the same thing. But over the last 10 years, especially Autism has become a protected characteristic and positive discrimination has been in place. We have sensory spaces at airports and shopping malls, dedicated special bathrooms, shops have timings with no music and low lighting you can book a slot and there are laws about berating parents for noise etc. There is a dedicated children's hospital which seems to be exclusively staffed by UK staff which also has a menopause unit which is also specially managed, for example has a 24 hour mental health line and a daytime nurse specialist helpline. Suddenly you realise it wasn't because genetically there were no people with those conditions, they were just kept at home. It isn't perfect but it has opened my eyes.

EdithBond · Today 03:08

Probably a number of factors.

One likely to be intersectionality with social class, i.e. Asian, African, Caribbean heritage kids more likely to be working class and diagnoses more common among middle class?

An LSE study found specific learning difficulties (including dyslexia, dyspraxia, and ADHD) were recorded at a higher rate in affluent areas than in the most deprived areas. https://www.lse.ac.uk/news/latest-news-from-lse/k-november-2023/children-in-affluent-areas.
.

golosh · Today 03:31

distinctpossibility · Yesterday 16:27

I think there are potentially many and varied reasons.

Racism? Would there be a tendency for school staff to blame atypical behaviour in a Black boy on parenting, while being determined to find a 'reason' for a white child to struggle. Plus, system racism and injustice leading Black and Asian families to distrust the medical system so be reluctant to pursue a diagnosis?

I am just trying to think of a reason beyond "there are inherently lower rates in some communities" and "white parents push for diagnosis". In the FivesTimeMore campaigns investigating why Black mothers and babies were five times more likely than white mothers and babies to die in childbirth, it was largely due to systemic racism within the medical paradigm so to me, that's a variable that would need investigating first.

Edited

I remember studying a huge body of research on this for my phd. They used eye tracking software on teachers and gave them the brief “watch for the atypical child behaviours in this video”, resulting in significantly more glancing over to the black child.

That’s NOT to say we are all racist. But that, even if we don’t think it or want to admit it, we have internalised bias.

FrauPaige · Today 03:51

Jane3212 · Today 01:30

'The Asia Tiger caricature survives in the US because they live segregated lives and don't meet people from different ethnic groups'

  • that's a big generalisation! A lot of Asian-Americans are highly integrated, many are intermarried too.

'it is inaccurate in suggesting that authoritative parenting with an education first mindset is somehow unique to East Asians. Every migrants group in the UK with aspirational parents from the global south operates from the same playbook. There is nothing unique about it.'

  • Amy Chua actually says this in her book. In the first chapter she says she's using the term 'Chinese/Tiger mother' loosely and the term could apply to lots of Ghanian/Jamaican/Indian & other groups too, and that many Chinese & other Asian parents are not stereotypical Tiger parents. She does make some odd generalisations in the book but that isn't one of them.

You've referred to her book - not to the caricature and it's common use. When Americans and American media refer to Asian Tigers, they are referring to it's common accepted use as opposed to every caveat in Any Chua's book - that they may not even know exists. Or are you suggesting that when Americans and American media use the term Asian Tigers they are referring to Africans and Indians?

I did not say that Asian Americans are not integrated - I said that British society is more integrated than American society. In Britain we have a society where we live and work with people from different ethnicities whereas in America due to it's historical segregation, housing laws and very many other factors, they simply do not. Hence why Americans casually refer to sub-groups of Americans as having innate traits, lifestyles, and residential areas whereas we would not make such sweeping generalisations in the UK without being incredibly right wing. Mainstream white America simply has very few touchpoints with people of colour.

It's a fascinating subject and I invite you to read up on it.

FrauPaige · Today 04:32

I agree with PPs earlier that said that the mindset of the Asian and African migrants in the UK is quite different to many in wider British society in that they by default have an authoritative parenting model and believe that education is the key route to social mobility and success.

This, combined with respect for parents and adults, completing homework on time and to a high level, reducing distractions such as dating/social media/entertainment, delayed gratification, and ensuring free time is structured allows gifted children to excel but also helps less gifted children to do well due by having them learn the habits of success.

In my experience, authoritative parents are less likely to seek diagnosis for a child with mild ND as the home structure they enforce provides the executive function a child with mild ND may lack, such as doing homework at a set time with parental oversight, capping screen time, and having fixed bedtimes so the behaviours don't escalate.

Additionally, they view sitting still, focusing on a task to completion, and self regulation as skills much like literacy, so when a child finds that difficult, the parents first reaction is to reinforce behaviours at home viewing it as a training issue as opposed to an innate medical condition.

And as they view education as the primary engine of social mobility, they are reluctant to invite a label that may lower expectations of their child in the state school system, which a formal diagnosis may do.

1st generation Caribbean parents also shared this parenting model - as do most migrants from the global south - however, as Jamaicans and other Caribbeans speak English as a native language they did not have the advantage that Yoruba, Twi, Punjabi and Sylheti speaking migrants had with having a cultural and linguistic buffer to the distractions of mainstream culture from their parenting model.

And as @lxn889121 suggests, many of these families see their children as representatives of their families, so they are both heavily invested in their behaviour and outcomes, and also reluctant to accept an ND diagnosis as there is still stigma around such labels.

CentralStati0n · Today 06:21

lxn889121 · Today 02:29

I live in Asia... and there is 100% an under-diagnosis of SEN conditions...

However, every time I go back to the UK, I feel like there is an over-diagnosis...

We like to imagine that diagnosis are black and white and objective, but that isn't how they work or are actually assessed, by medical professionals or teachers and parents.

From what I've seen working in education in both Asia and the UK. Both places recognize the "extreme" end of the needs spectrum, but Asian countries have a much higher bar for the grey areas in the middle of diagnosis. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.

“. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.”

No they wouldn’t. For a start there is no high functioning autism.Autism has to have a significant impact on life to get a diagnosis. Anybody managing life fine would not meet the threshold . The same diagnosis manuals stating that are used.

MeshMesh · Today 06:59

BarbieinBloom · Today 00:12

I agree.

In my honest opinion, it all comes down to parenting. I find western culture panders to children way too much. Which leads to over diagnosing etc.

I disagree with abuse completely, but I do believe in firm and fair parenting alongside warmth, care, love and expectations. I don’t buy into the gentle parenting nonsense.

One example, if I cook my child regardless of gender food. I expect them to eat it or go to bed hungry. I will not be cooking another meal, I’m not a cook or maid. I’ll happily take requests, e.g. pizza fine I’ll incorporate it and think about when I can make that. But, for now you will eat what I put in front of you. And I don’t expect them to finish full plate if they’re full, I don’t want to over feed. But, similarly I’m not someone you can order around and dictate what to cook. You eat what you’re given, simple.

You do realize that none of this has any bearing on whether a child has SEN or not.

PottyBreak · Today 07:24

CentralStati0n · Today 06:21

“. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.”

No they wouldn’t. For a start there is no high functioning autism.Autism has to have a significant impact on life to get a diagnosis. Anybody managing life fine would not meet the threshold . The same diagnosis manuals stating that are used.

There are three diagnostic levels which relate to the severity of autism and its impact upon daily life.

CentralStati0n · Today 07:26

PottyBreak · Today 07:24

There are three diagnostic levels which relate to the severity of autism and its impact upon daily life.

No there aren’t.

One of the diagnosis manuals lists 3 levels of support needs and has a caveat that these levels can fluctuate throughout life.

Some autistic people may have differing levels of support needs within life.

CentralStati0n · Today 07:30

MeshMesh · Today 06:59

You do realize that none of this has any bearing on whether a child has SEN or not.

Exactly I did all that. Still have a child with an EHCP, several SENs and needing significant support needs.

PottyBreak · Today 07:32

CentralStati0n · Today 07:26

No there aren’t.

One of the diagnosis manuals lists 3 levels of support needs and has a caveat that these levels can fluctuate throughout life.

Some autistic people may have differing levels of support needs within life.

Edited

Which is what I just said.

FascinatingCapybara · Today 07:35

lxn889121 · Today 02:29

I live in Asia... and there is 100% an under-diagnosis of SEN conditions...

However, every time I go back to the UK, I feel like there is an over-diagnosis...

We like to imagine that diagnosis are black and white and objective, but that isn't how they work or are actually assessed, by medical professionals or teachers and parents.

From what I've seen working in education in both Asia and the UK. Both places recognize the "extreme" end of the needs spectrum, but Asian countries have a much higher bar for the grey areas in the middle of diagnosis. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.

It makes sense and I agree - the same diagnostic criteria are interpreted differently, depending on local culture and dominating views, parental/education expectations etc. What's more, the same person assessed at different times in their life, by different teams, may recieve a different outcome.

People who insist there is a set, clear cut-off for being autistic/not autistic or say that there is no high functioning autism have little experience of the actual process...

CentralStati0n · Today 07:39

PottyBreak · Today 07:32

Which is what I just said.

Not exactly.

You didn’t say it is made clear that it is re support needs which can change throughout life. Ie those with autism aren’t pigeon holed into one level of autism or even support needs.

Monty36 · Today 08:25

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:45

Incorrect

Reported diagnosis for autism and ADHD are often higher in Japan than in the UK.Reported autism rates are generally higher, with some global estimates placing Japan around 1 in 55 children and rising diagnosis trends across both children and adults. A 2026 analysis of Japanese insurance claims projected that, at 2023 rates, 15.7% would receive an autism diagnosis by age 49—reflecting clinic diagnosis and support-access trends rather than true community prevalence.UK estimates commonly place autism prevalence at roughly 1- 1.7% of the general population (at least 700,000 autistic people),

Re ADHD community level surveys in Japan estimate ADHD prevalence around 5.8% to 7.7% in children and adolescents and roughly 1.65% yo 1.7% in adults. Global modelling data (GBD 2023) also shows a higher reported rate per 100,000 in Japan (1,216) than in the UK .UK adult ADHD estimates are often cited around 3% to 4% under NICE guidelines.

Well, I prefer to make decisions without having AI do it for me. I don’t consider it reliable. And I like to think for myself.
How numbers are calculated, assessed will all matter. And estimates are often fingers in the wind. Companies with vested interests produce ‘papers’ which AI lacks the ability to judge.

Japan has a work society that puts ours to shame. No, I am not advocating the over work. Nor all aspects. But they have a very strong work ethic. They are fabulous at organising, inventing, producing. There are aspects of Japanese way of things that we could well learn from. If they do have large numbers of people with neurological issues then they seem to have it cracked in a society don’t they? Their children go to school, their young people work.

I don’t use AI to think for me. Which worries me hugely. It will get so bad that people will ask AI how to bloody well vote. And Mr Musk will tell you.

I do find that there is a need to want to find a solution. To get things right. Although I do feel for some they prefer for that not to be so. Present a situation where something seems to work well, no, don’t look at that. It might work. We might learn from it.

painswick · Today 08:30

CentralStati0n · Today 06:21

“. For example someone with high functioning autism who struggles with a few things, but can generally manage life fine, won't get diagnosed here, but would in the UK.”

No they wouldn’t. For a start there is no high functioning autism.Autism has to have a significant impact on life to get a diagnosis. Anybody managing life fine would not meet the threshold . The same diagnosis manuals stating that are used.

The problem is the phrase 'a significant impact on life'. That is a subjective judgement that different people, different clinicians and different cultures will view differently. What you might consider a significant imoacy on life, I may consider a relatively minor bump in the road.

BarbieinBloom · Today 08:44

MeshMesh · Today 06:59

You do realize that none of this has any bearing on whether a child has SEN or not.

That isn’t relevant, Indians don’t like to diagnose their child with SEN. That’s why, there is such a lack of data. Parents especially Mums are just expected to cope and power through. There is an expectation to be resilient. If a child has SEN or illness, they would blame the mother.

LumberPainJackie · Today 08:46

painswick · Today 08:30

The problem is the phrase 'a significant impact on life'. That is a subjective judgement that different people, different clinicians and different cultures will view differently. What you might consider a significant imoacy on life, I may consider a relatively minor bump in the road.

But that is part of it, having SEN can mean that something that would seem minor to a neuro-typical brain is majorly impactful.

Kids are dealing with far more stressors than I did growing up in the 80/90s, constant demands for attention and the feeling they are competing with AI. Add on to that the shrinking jobs market and minimal mental health services, covid and austerity and you have a generation of kids who quite possibly do not have the resilience of a generation before. If you add SEN on to a system that is already failing kids, you can't be amazed when many of them do not have the skills to bounce back.

Pp said that in Asia kids like mine likely wouldn't be even diagnosed. So once girls hit around 14 and start struggling they would likely fall out of school (which we can see happens here in the state sector) and not achieve. That isn't progress.