Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

536 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:37

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 23:24

With all due respect, you have no idea of my income and there’s no need for you make a personal attack. Uta Frith is 85, I hope to be long retired if I get to that age.

She is retired...I don't think that her age should mean her work is discounted. If Lorna Wing had lived longer in good mental health,I'd have liked to know what she thought also. Judith Gould is still alive and seems to disagree.

I do think Frith made some sweeping statements. Questioning individuals like Packham rather than making more general statements only was a mistake, I think. I also don't agree that masking is just what everyone does : the accounts I've read do not sound like that. Otoh I agreed with some of her other points.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:39

grindergirl · Yesterday 23:02

To be blunt, I think that children who cannot cope in a mainstream school without all these extra supports should not be there at all. I doubt that there would be so much clamour for diagnoses if it meant the child being sent to a special school.
Lived experience. I went to a grammar school in the last 60s/early 70s. It had its share of oddballs, but nobody was expected to fit in the same one-sized straitjacket. However, rules were expected to be obeyed. Bad behaviour had consequences---usually the cane.
I only ever encountered one child with special needs, and that was in junior school. People might not like it nowadays, but he was sent to what was then called a school for the educationally subnormal. Some children, you just can't educate in mainstream schools. My view is that the rest need to learn to fit in. It should not be down to society to fit in with them
I can't be arsed to get a diagnosis, but I suspect I would be on the spectrum with what used to be called Aspergers. I have very little empathy, no wish to socialise, enjoy routine and abhor small talk. It doesn't bother me.

Thank you, interesting post. Btw do you think caning was a good way of keeping discipline?

OP posts:
BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:39

As a brown woman born in UK to Indian immigrant parents, specifically Sikh.

This is anecdotal based on upbringing, experience and what I’ve witnessed personally - there will never be any data on this because the majority of people will refuse to be associated with it, even if anonymised. I don’t mean any offence, whatsoever.

  1. They don’t like being identified as “different”, “needing extra support” and “label”.
  2. Moving to a new country takes a lot of work and commitment, leaving behind family and friends, the culture and country you bought up.. Some people sell land and properties to move abroad!
  3. You want your child to desperately fit in. You will refuse anything that will dis encourage that e.g. SEN. On top of all this, mothers are usually primary carer and some of them can’t speak coherent English. So any type of label will frighten them and will refuse it.
  4. If a child is labelled with any kind of diagnosis be it SEN or illness, whatever.. It will always be the woman’s fault. Because she carried the baby for 9 months, what did she do wrong? How did she cause this? What did she eat during pregnancy?
  5. If a woman lives with in laws, then they will blame her for birthing a child who has a “defect”.
  6. HEAVY emphasis on getting a good education and degree. Tuition fee could be £50k a year, there is still expectation their child will get a degree, e.g. bachelors minimum. Masters and PhD is optional.
  7. In some families there’s expectations of birthing a son, keep having children until you have a son - if you have a girl, it’s your fault. Clearly, need a man to carry the family name.
  8. Lastly, Sikhs don’t like to be on the receiving end of benefits or anything that. They think it’s embarrassing.
Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:41

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 22:29

This article is quite interesting. Basically the people who invented autism are moving towards being in favour of distinguishing between the seriously impaired and those who just aren't. Hopefully this view will gain traction.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/the-term-is-becoming-unrecognisable-have-the-experts-who-believed-in-a-single-autism-spectrum-changed-their-minds

Edited

This section is directly relevant to what we've been discussing: 'The big issue she spends her spare time on is the lack of autism awareness in her own community. “After I was diagnosed, I went on YouTube, trying to find something in Urdu that would explain autism to my mum. And there was nothing. In the Asian-Muslim community, with a lot of people, if a child is autistic, you take him or her to an Imam and an amulet or something is going to cure them.”

Her dad, she tells me, left the family home in his 50s (“He was one of those people who should have never got married – he couldn’t deal with family life”) and moved to Manchester. He died of Covid-19 in 2021, and she and her sister were given the keys to his flat, where they found apparent proof that Shaikh’s autism had genetic roots. “That’s when we realised he had special interests: there were 13 bikes there, and toolboxes, and collections of albums we couldn’t even have imagined.” They also found a pile of medical paperwork. “I realised they were his autism diagnosis. He’d been diagnosed in his late 50s, after he left.”'

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:43

BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:39

As a brown woman born in UK to Indian immigrant parents, specifically Sikh.

This is anecdotal based on upbringing, experience and what I’ve witnessed personally - there will never be any data on this because the majority of people will refuse to be associated with it, even if anonymised. I don’t mean any offence, whatsoever.

  1. They don’t like being identified as “different”, “needing extra support” and “label”.
  2. Moving to a new country takes a lot of work and commitment, leaving behind family and friends, the culture and country you bought up.. Some people sell land and properties to move abroad!
  3. You want your child to desperately fit in. You will refuse anything that will dis encourage that e.g. SEN. On top of all this, mothers are usually primary carer and some of them can’t speak coherent English. So any type of label will frighten them and will refuse it.
  4. If a child is labelled with any kind of diagnosis be it SEN or illness, whatever.. It will always be the woman’s fault. Because she carried the baby for 9 months, what did she do wrong? How did she cause this? What did she eat during pregnancy?
  5. If a woman lives with in laws, then they will blame her for birthing a child who has a “defect”.
  6. HEAVY emphasis on getting a good education and degree. Tuition fee could be £50k a year, there is still expectation their child will get a degree, e.g. bachelors minimum. Masters and PhD is optional.
  7. In some families there’s expectations of birthing a son, keep having children until you have a son - if you have a girl, it’s your fault. Clearly, need a man to carry the family name.
  8. Lastly, Sikhs don’t like to be on the receiving end of benefits or anything that. They think it’s embarrassing.

Thank you, this is valuable information.

'If a child is labelled with any kind of diagnosis be it SEN or illness, whatever.. It will always be the woman’s fault. Because she carried the baby for 9 months, what did she do wrong? How did she cause this? What did she eat during pregnancy?
If a woman lives with in laws, then they will blame her for birthing a child who has a “defect”.'- that's really unfair- very sad.

Re pressure to have a boy, does this mean if the child with SN were a girl especially, there might be less attention paid?

OP posts:
augustuss · Yesterday 23:44

Not sure if it’s been mentioned but the White British numbers will also include children of (white) immigrants born here.

If you had a number for white+ (English, etc) ethnicity you’d probably get a higher percentage diagnosed.

SkyBlueTopper · Yesterday 23:44

JHound · Yesterday 18:07

Culture taboo where? There are multiple different culture within various black and asian groups?

I would say that many cultures have a discrimination and is still very prevalent in all cultures dominant in the UK. I work in a healthcare environment with lots of colleagues from alm over the world treating a very multicultural patient group.
Attitudes towards disability and sen differs greatly cross groups. It's not as simple as saying, asian people think or black people. There's also levels of class and education involved. And the many sub areas that people come from.
Certain groups of people even within england have very different attitudes depending on where you are in the country and the class you're from.
I think it is relevant to look at attitudes of different cultures to ensure that it's not just the pushy middle class, they end up getting treatment and diagnosis. (And fair play to them, not a diss on them at all). But you need to have confidence and exposure and a safe space in order to talk about these things. And these differ from place to place and culture to culture.

BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:45

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:43

Thank you, this is valuable information.

'If a child is labelled with any kind of diagnosis be it SEN or illness, whatever.. It will always be the woman’s fault. Because she carried the baby for 9 months, what did she do wrong? How did she cause this? What did she eat during pregnancy?
If a woman lives with in laws, then they will blame her for birthing a child who has a “defect”.'- that's really unfair- very sad.

Re pressure to have a boy, does this mean if the child with SN were a girl especially, there might be less attention paid?

Re pressure to have a boy, does this mean if the child with SN were a girl especially, there might be less attention paid?

No, they don’t like any labels for either gender. There is just an expectation to birth a son, hence multiple pregnancies until they have a son. For example, if a girl is labelled as disabled then this will affect her prospects of getting married and setting down etc. Whereas, a son can’t be disabled as he needs to carry on the family name and be independent. Thus, pension scheme for the parents. As traditionally, women moved out and lived with their in laws e.g. dowry etc.

CloveRinse · Yesterday 23:47

JHound · Yesterday 16:33

Why do you think men are “more in charge in those households”?

I can only speak for Black African experience (not Asian) but yes absolutely - the men can be very much more "in charge" of family decisions than the women. It is not that I "think" this - it is facts. It is economics, it is also cultural.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:54

BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:45

Re pressure to have a boy, does this mean if the child with SN were a girl especially, there might be less attention paid?

No, they don’t like any labels for either gender. There is just an expectation to birth a son, hence multiple pregnancies until they have a son. For example, if a girl is labelled as disabled then this will affect her prospects of getting married and setting down etc. Whereas, a son can’t be disabled as he needs to carry on the family name and be independent. Thus, pension scheme for the parents. As traditionally, women moved out and lived with their in laws e.g. dowry etc.

Thank you, that makes sense. So either way, lots of pressure on an SN child to achieve academically, especially a boy. I suppose that would work better with some forms of SN than others : eg. ASD hyperfocus and need for clear expectations could work better if the focus were on an academic subject..

OP posts:
Slimtoddy · Yesterday 23:55

What does the data say when you compare people from similar financial backgrounds? Is there a difference? Or if you cut the data by social class? Are you more likely to get a diagnosis if you are middle class and financially comfortable?

One of my DC has a diagnosis via NHS. It's a long process and it's difficult to navigate. My DC are not white but I am. I probably did more of the engagement with NHS.

Devonshiregal · Yesterday 23:57

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Could that be because they have adhd? Hence why they even were going for an assessment in the first place? But actually I have actually met two people who haven’t got that diagnosis from private. I came away with adhd (obviously) and a suggestion to go to the doctors to investigate another potential diagnosis. It’s not nice to be sarcastic about a disability

grindergirl · Yesterday 23:57

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:39

Thank you, interesting post. Btw do you think caning was a good way of keeping discipline?

It worked. As did the blackboard rubber thrown at the head---always at boys, though. I don't know of anyone who was expelled.
I also think many of us lived a more structured (and educationally focused) life back then. For me, it was piano practice when I got home, then at least 2 hours of homework. I enjoyed learning, so I didn't feel deprived. My own 'screen time' amounted to about an hour of TV!
It's only on what I've observed, but it seems that most Indian and Chinese families still maintain that structured culture. They expect respect and hard work from their children instead of trying to be their best mates

Idontknownowwhat · Yesterday 23:59

My friends of African heritage have all told me that Autism, ADHD, and Mental Health are all something that older members of their families would find unacceptable.
One of my friends husbands wouldn't let her get help for anxiety, and told me to not mention my sons Autism- her husband is a GP. Its very clear that my son is Autistic. We are selectively invited to places because of my sons inability to speak.

BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:59

I do personally believe in western culture, there’s a tendency to over diagnose everything. Like, it’s always someone else’s fault. School or lack of sure start etc, lack of funding.

My parents never hit me or were violent etc, they’re generally quite modern compared to my extended family. My parents actually had a love marriage, but that’s another story.

One example, I always had a tv in my room growing up and it was expected I would share it with my sister. It was set to a timer and it would turn off automatically, the time was set by my mother and to save money on electricity.

She never once had to put a password on it and we never disobeyed her. She would have this look, we knew to basically shut up and behave. She was firm and strict, never did gentle parenting but she also showed care, love and warmth.

We were given Nintendo DS’s and Wii’s, with games we chose and wanted to play. My parents respected our choices. But, we had limits. We never demanded or behaved aggressively.

Whereas, parents today always blame iPads or screens etc. Screens always existed in some form or another.

It’s the parenting that’s the problem, not the iPad or screen imo.

Jane3212 · Today 00:01

grindergirl · Yesterday 23:57

It worked. As did the blackboard rubber thrown at the head---always at boys, though. I don't know of anyone who was expelled.
I also think many of us lived a more structured (and educationally focused) life back then. For me, it was piano practice when I got home, then at least 2 hours of homework. I enjoyed learning, so I didn't feel deprived. My own 'screen time' amounted to about an hour of TV!
It's only on what I've observed, but it seems that most Indian and Chinese families still maintain that structured culture. They expect respect and hard work from their children instead of trying to be their best mates

Interesting. I don't agree with corporal punishment but have a Gen X mother who says similar re rubber throwing at her girls' secondary school (in maths). She was a good student so didn't happen to her!

'I also think many of us lived a more structured (and educationally focused) life back then. For me, it was piano practice when I got home, then at least 2 hours of homework.' - that's interesting too. A lot of people on here say differently : that they roamed around free range much more & did fewer extracurriculars than kids these days. My mother certainly did fewer than my friends & I did. Would be interesting to know which was more common.

OP posts:
BarbieinBloom · Today 00:01

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:54

Thank you, that makes sense. So either way, lots of pressure on an SN child to achieve academically, especially a boy. I suppose that would work better with some forms of SN than others : eg. ASD hyperfocus and need for clear expectations could work better if the focus were on an academic subject..

Thank you, that makes sense. So either way, lots of pressure on an SN child to achieve academically, especially a boy. I suppose that would work better with some forms of SN than others : eg. ASD hyperfocus and need for clear expectations could work better if the focus were on an academic subject..

There are different pressures for both genders and expectations, both of them are expected to get degrees and be independent. Western education is seen as a privilege, not a right. The boy is just expected to be a pension scheme for the parents really. They don’t approve of care homes and refer it to being abandoned.

Jane3212 · Today 00:07

BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:59

I do personally believe in western culture, there’s a tendency to over diagnose everything. Like, it’s always someone else’s fault. School or lack of sure start etc, lack of funding.

My parents never hit me or were violent etc, they’re generally quite modern compared to my extended family. My parents actually had a love marriage, but that’s another story.

One example, I always had a tv in my room growing up and it was expected I would share it with my sister. It was set to a timer and it would turn off automatically, the time was set by my mother and to save money on electricity.

She never once had to put a password on it and we never disobeyed her. She would have this look, we knew to basically shut up and behave. She was firm and strict, never did gentle parenting but she also showed care, love and warmth.

We were given Nintendo DS’s and Wii’s, with games we chose and wanted to play. My parents respected our choices. But, we had limits. We never demanded or behaved aggressively.

Whereas, parents today always blame iPads or screens etc. Screens always existed in some form or another.

It’s the parenting that’s the problem, not the iPad or screen imo.

Your parents sound very good- mine were similar (not Asian). I do think recently there has been some tendency (I think partly an extension of US post-1970s therapy culture) to blame external factors too much. A pp mentioned Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother and Amy Chua, while a person who makes very dramatic statements, does have some valid points there (though some apply more to US imo).
Chua has a sister with SN (Down's) and described in the book how Chinese people of her parents' generation often saw disabilities as shameful, but her parents adapted and channeled their focus into helping her draw, do puzzles etc. The sister eventually became a successful swimmer and led an independent life. Obviously this depends on the level of disability but the parents' focus on improving the skills she had (rather than sending her away to a home as doctors in the 1970s suggested) seemed to have good results.

OP posts:
SorrelSeaglass · Today 00:07

painswick · Yesterday 23:30

Ok weird response. Do you dispute that there is a large and growing industry of ASD experts and researchers? Apologies if you interpreted my post as meaning I thought you were financially motivated that wasn't my intention. it was a broader point about vested interests as a general principle.

I think there is currently much more research into autism, yes, and I welcome if it means that autistic people are better supported. I don’t doubt that there are some, perhaps many people motivated by profit, but that certainly isn’t exclusive to autism and ADHD.

I have concerns about some specialist schools claiming to offer autism “therapies” which may cause harm. However, I have no direct experience of these alternative providers because I have always worked in the public sector or HE.

The investigation into potential over-diagnosis proved that there is substantial under-diagnosis in some groups, including girls, women, and BAME people. I don’t think the answer is to ignore the findings and decide society can’t afford autism or ADHD.

This article is interesting regarding unmet need and NEET:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/nov/18/neet-childhood-neglect-needs-mental-health-milburn-review-britain

BarbieinBloom · Today 00:12

Jane3212 · Today 00:07

Your parents sound very good- mine were similar (not Asian). I do think recently there has been some tendency (I think partly an extension of US post-1970s therapy culture) to blame external factors too much. A pp mentioned Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother and Amy Chua, while a person who makes very dramatic statements, does have some valid points there (though some apply more to US imo).
Chua has a sister with SN (Down's) and described in the book how Chinese people of her parents' generation often saw disabilities as shameful, but her parents adapted and channeled their focus into helping her draw, do puzzles etc. The sister eventually became a successful swimmer and led an independent life. Obviously this depends on the level of disability but the parents' focus on improving the skills she had (rather than sending her away to a home as doctors in the 1970s suggested) seemed to have good results.

I agree.

In my honest opinion, it all comes down to parenting. I find western culture panders to children way too much. Which leads to over diagnosing etc.

I disagree with abuse completely, but I do believe in firm and fair parenting alongside warmth, care, love and expectations. I don’t buy into the gentle parenting nonsense.

One example, if I cook my child regardless of gender food. I expect them to eat it or go to bed hungry. I will not be cooking another meal, I’m not a cook or maid. I’ll happily take requests, e.g. pizza fine I’ll incorporate it and think about when I can make that. But, for now you will eat what I put in front of you. And I don’t expect them to finish full plate if they’re full, I don’t want to over feed. But, similarly I’m not someone you can order around and dictate what to cook. You eat what you’re given, simple.

Jane3212 · Today 00:13

BarbieinBloom · Yesterday 23:59

I do personally believe in western culture, there’s a tendency to over diagnose everything. Like, it’s always someone else’s fault. School or lack of sure start etc, lack of funding.

My parents never hit me or were violent etc, they’re generally quite modern compared to my extended family. My parents actually had a love marriage, but that’s another story.

One example, I always had a tv in my room growing up and it was expected I would share it with my sister. It was set to a timer and it would turn off automatically, the time was set by my mother and to save money on electricity.

She never once had to put a password on it and we never disobeyed her. She would have this look, we knew to basically shut up and behave. She was firm and strict, never did gentle parenting but she also showed care, love and warmth.

We were given Nintendo DS’s and Wii’s, with games we chose and wanted to play. My parents respected our choices. But, we had limits. We never demanded or behaved aggressively.

Whereas, parents today always blame iPads or screens etc. Screens always existed in some form or another.

It’s the parenting that’s the problem, not the iPad or screen imo.

Re screens though, I do think the ones now are quantatively different than previous TVs etc. Internet, SM are much more intense than programs (which also were not on 24/7 as much in previous decades). SM was engineered to be addictive in a way TV wasn't. I agree parental discipline is a problem- phones should probably have been refused en masse but it is difficult when nost children have them as then the last few will be left out, so I can see why some parents caved. The ban will hopefully prevent this.

Sorry, off topic!

OP posts:
BarbieinBloom · Today 00:17

Jane3212 · Today 00:13

Re screens though, I do think the ones now are quantatively different than previous TVs etc. Internet, SM are much more intense than programs (which also were not on 24/7 as much in previous decades). SM was engineered to be addictive in a way TV wasn't. I agree parental discipline is a problem- phones should probably have been refused en masse but it is difficult when nost children have them as then the last few will be left out, so I can see why some parents caved. The ban will hopefully prevent this.

Sorry, off topic!

I think with iPads, isn’t there a child account you can get with security and password etc? Can you put timer on it and restrictions? Can the email be set to the parents iCloud account? Tbh, I haven’t set up a child account recently so I’m unaware?

I don’t disagree with the intensity, but why are children allowed them for a significant amount of time? Why are they allowed to have all these apps?

If it were me, I can see this happening I would have sold the iPad etc. Get rid off the source. If they have a tantrum, tough. They can save up and buy one.

With a phone, I would buy them the most basic phone with no internet. Only phone call and messages, so they can contact me. Basically, a brick. If they want an iPhone, they can buy and save up themselves.

Jane3212 · Today 00:18

BarbieinBloom · Today 00:01

Thank you, that makes sense. So either way, lots of pressure on an SN child to achieve academically, especially a boy. I suppose that would work better with some forms of SN than others : eg. ASD hyperfocus and need for clear expectations could work better if the focus were on an academic subject..

There are different pressures for both genders and expectations, both of them are expected to get degrees and be independent. Western education is seen as a privilege, not a right. The boy is just expected to be a pension scheme for the parents really. They don’t approve of care homes and refer it to being abandoned.

Edited

Can I ask re care homes : how does this work now people have better healthcare than ever so may live for many years fairly physically healthy but mentally very ill, for example with dementia? Are DILs and other family expected to do all the care still? I suppose maybe more are SAHMs so available to care?
Sorry, I know it's not topic-related either, it's just something that interests me as I am a carer myself, but not to someone with dementia.

OP posts:
BarbieinBloom · Today 00:20

Jane3212 · Today 00:18

Can I ask re care homes : how does this work now people have better healthcare than ever so may live for many years fairly physically healthy but mentally very ill, for example with dementia? Are DILs and other family expected to do all the care still? I suppose maybe more are SAHMs so available to care?
Sorry, I know it's not topic-related either, it's just something that interests me as I am a carer myself, but not to someone with dementia.

Yup, usually DIL’s and SAHM do all the caring.

This is why more modern women refuse to live with in laws and be a SAHM. They’re more likely to work now.

Previously, it was hard for those women to get well paid job due to lack of English and education. Now, their daughters are well educated and have good jobs thus expected to continue working.

EarlofShrewsbury · Today 00:21

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Imagine you could only get treatment for broken bones with a diagnosis of broken bone and that diagnosis cost £2k.

Now imagine you have broken your leg, the bone is sticking out and at the wrong angle and needs resetting, you can't have that without the diagnosis but the waiting list is so long it will cause long term damage to leave it. You'll pay private if you can.

Now imagine you've just hurt it a bit, might be broken, might be a sprain. It's not going to cause major issues though, regardless. You paying the 2k then?

People aren't paying for a diagnosis unless they need it. The majority already know what the outcome will beforehand.

Swipe left for the next trending thread