Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

it's not a tiny minority is it

364 replies

noddyington · Yesterday 15:09

I do not know any women who have not had something bad or intimidating happen to them in their lifetime. Whether that be cat calling, followed, talked down to, pushed out of spaces, pushed over for promotion, assaulted, stalked, raped or murdered.

I do not know any women who have not changed their behaviour to try and keep themselves safe. It might be walking with keys between their fingers, getting a taxi when they'd rather walk, covering their drink when they are at a bar, not responding when a guy intimidates/heckles at them because it's safer, run or jog in groups, don't wear headphones walking late a night.........

AIBU to say that it's not a tiny minority of men is it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:07

@noddyington have you thought about having this thread moved over to the Feminism board? You might get more input rather than just having the AIBU vote.

It doesn’t matter how small the majority of bad faith actors there are they spoil it for women and they spoil it for other men. I’m way past middle age now but it depresses me that in 2026 we are still having weeks like this and last week hearing about women having been abused and silenced.

I do think the Russell Brand conviction and David Walliams allegations may have men of a certain age sat looking back and considering their behaviours. Not to derail but I noticed on my (old) LinkedIn that 4 men I have known over the past 45 years but not spoken to in over 30 years have sought me out and looked at my profile in the past 3 days.

All of them know they behaved appallingly bad towards me back in the 1980s. I have now closed my account as my stomach dropped when I saw they had searched and viewed me all over the weekend. Call me a cynic but I do not think I suddenly sprung back into their memories all of a sudden.

Back to your thread now @noddyington but I will add I think porn has been a massive reason as well.

Additup · Yesterday 16:07

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

WTAF. You've jumped the shark with this comment, or is it irony? I can't tell anymore.

noddyington · Yesterday 16:09

TempestTost · Yesterday 15:58

I don't think your idea that many women have changed behaviour to be careful shows that a lot of men are dangerous.

That many women have had something actually happen to them could show that, but not necessarily. Because the other possibility is that there is a smaller number of men doing that kind of thing quite often.

I believe there is some statistical evidence that suggests that might be the case, and in fact for a lot of different kinds of crimes. There is a smaller number who are responsible for a lot of social chaos and bad behaviour.

I thought that until the Gisele Pelicot case (and further cases in the UK)

The stats speak for themselves about how many men were willing from a pretty small area and those who didn't go ahead didn't report it.

OP posts:
SmokeyRidge · Yesterday 16:09

Yes, it is a minority which is why if I tell another man that a man has abused me, in any way, he does not sit there and nod and say that I'm a woman so I deserve it, or I'm less than, or who cares you silly woman....every man I know would take action against an abusive man. So, yes, it's a minority.

nomas · Yesterday 16:10

Wonderful to see cancelling of misogynistic views and those posters who make them being cancelled on this thread.

brownbootsandhats · Yesterday 16:10

It was the adjective tiny that was relevant

it’s a minority but not by any stretch a TINY minority

noddyington · Yesterday 16:11

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 16:02

It's very hard to get good quality data on this type of thing. But very rough guesstimates suggest around perhaps 20% of men.

A sizeable minority.

roughly 20% rape but more catcall, heckle, turn a blind eye etc.

OP posts:
LauderSyme · Yesterday 16:11

I think what society needs to do is severely punish the 20% (if it is) of men who behave violently and illegally. Crimes driven by misogynistic beliefs should incur long jail sentences. If men won't change, the least communities can do is protect women and children from the worst of them.

Metalmotha · Yesterday 16:11

I also think we have a massive overpopulation of men. Historically many died in warfare, we just don’t have that.

noddyington · Yesterday 16:12

LauderSyme · Yesterday 16:02

Coulditbesam Why is your tone so smug and dismissive? What are you getting out of denying the oppressive reality we can all see we live in?

MESSAGE READ THIS SO THE THREAD DOESN'T GET DERAILED

I wouldn't respond to Coulditbesam

They are on 2 threads now making silly, diminishing posts around sexual assault.

OP posts:
Coulditbesam · Yesterday 16:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 16:16

I think there are a few factors at play:
Testosterone - levels vary and I don't think we pay enough attention to how it affects boys, learning, body image, sexual deviancy rates
Drug use - steroid linked to the above - men who want to get ripped and drug themselves up to the eyeballs and then have all of the side effects eg increasing jealousy and violent tendencies
Mental heath issues - Men are less likely to be diagnosed with personality disorders such as bipolar than women, seemingly because they don't report mood swings. Maybe because these are more "masculine traits" and so not seen as wild as when women have them. Either way I suspect many in prison get diagnosed for the first time with a lot of disorders their family and friends thought were their personality.

All of this adds up to low attainment in education which makes them easy targets and prime audience for the manosphere and misogynistic rubbish that tells them they deserve everything with minimal effort because they are MEN.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · Yesterday 16:16

Coulditbesam · Yesterday 15:29

I don’t think they do.

I do think some men - typically the more inadequate ones - do hate women, maybe because they’ve been rejected/women have refused to have sex with them and they imagined that they should have been entitled to it.

Metalmotha · Yesterday 16:17

noddyington · Yesterday 16:11

roughly 20% rape but more catcall, heckle, turn a blind eye etc.

And the way men can really turn on women who are more intelligent is unbelievable until you see it. It basically boils down to wanting to keep women in their place. Having said that, there are lots of men who are very active in supporting women

noddyington · Yesterday 16:17

DeedlessIndeed · Yesterday 16:03

There are a certain portion of men who are absolute cunts. They are a risk to women. They are a risk to children. But they are also a risk to other men.

Most murder victims are men. Most murderers are men.

Speaking from my personal experience, a few men have been shits to me. Most men have acted neutrally or positively.

VAWG is vitally important and we need to take it seriously. But very divisive culture war spiel of all men are a problem doesn't do anything other than shut down debate. It hurts progress. In the same way not all migrants are bad, not all millenial/boomers are bad, not all trans/GC people are bad, not all right/left views are bad, not all benefits claimants/high earners are bad. The absolutism and division we are all pushed towards every day doesn't help anyone.

I respectfully disagree.

Men are a problem in society not just assaulting women and men but also the whole corporate glass ceiling, wars and politics.
Having that kind of power and money perpetuates the problem.

Men could not be so controlling in some ways if women earned the same or, shock horror, earned more than men or held more positions of power.

OP posts:
Coulditbesam · Yesterday 16:17

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · Yesterday 16:16

I do think some men - typically the more inadequate ones - do hate women, maybe because they’ve been rejected/women have refused to have sex with them and they imagined that they should have been entitled to it.

Of course some men hate women. There is literally no doubt about that.

Thecatspantaloons · Yesterday 16:17

noddyington · Yesterday 16:11

roughly 20% rape but more catcall, heckle, turn a blind eye etc.

It's the turning a blind eye, that shouldn't be ignored either, because by now we should all know that men listen to other men more than they listen to women.

Even the decent ones I follow on SM know this and make videos shaming awful wankers of the manosphere - because they know that if women influencers were to make the same video, they will be hounded in the comments by said wankers.

BMW6 · Yesterday 16:18

noddyington · Yesterday 16:09

I thought that until the Gisele Pelicot case (and further cases in the UK)

The stats speak for themselves about how many men were willing from a pretty small area and those who didn't go ahead didn't report it.

The fact that many more men who saw the "offer" but didn't take it BUT didn't report it to the Police either leads me to believe most men are culpable by turning a blind eye.

Now there's a case being tried exactly the same here in the UK. How many men knew this was going on and kept schtum. Boyfriends, husbands, fathers. Nice "ordinary" men.

If YOUR DH saw this advertised are you so sure he would report it let alone take up the invitation?

I'm 68 and never been more sure that it's the majority of men.

itsnearly2027 · Yesterday 16:18

I think it’s the majority I’m afraid. So many men truly despise women and, to be frank, want to hurt them.

lifeisgoodrightnow · Yesterday 16:19

noddyington · Yesterday 15:21

Why though? Why do men hate women so much.

I think the testosterone urges override sense

Prekoc2 · Yesterday 16:20

I've lost count of the men I've met who wouldn't take no for an answer; men who would clearly want to be viewed as professional, well-educated, middle-class, intelligent, upstanding, moral and decent. And these were not men in their teens or twenties, either.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 16:23

lifeisgoodrightnow · Yesterday 16:19

I think the testosterone urges override sense

I think it gives false belief they won't be caught or will outsmart or somehow "win".

TheThirteenthFairy · Yesterday 16:23

seahorsessky · Yesterday 15:34

That's like the comments about people from certain religions or about immigrants; no one is denying some people do things, but blame the individuals, not groups. Yes, some women (definitely not all!) have been hurt by men, but many have been hurt by women too, but that isn't taken as seriously by many. Victims of women can be scared to report it.
Just like when someone is attacked by a dog, don't blame all dog ownerss-and don't blame all men-or all women!-because some people assault you. Having a go at the whole group is only going to upset decent men, and the women who love them.

Edited

There's always one.

OK, I'll bite. Hands up those of us who have raped or gang raped by women.

Tiddlywinks63 · Yesterday 16:23

noddyington · Yesterday 16:17

I respectfully disagree.

Men are a problem in society not just assaulting women and men but also the whole corporate glass ceiling, wars and politics.
Having that kind of power and money perpetuates the problem.

Men could not be so controlling in some ways if women earned the same or, shock horror, earned more than men or held more positions of power.

I agree @noddyington . At 73 I’m jaded and very disillusioned with the depressing reality that a majority of men think it’s funny and normal to deride, abuse and use women in whatever way they feel like.
I’ve never had a decent male figure in my life besides my DS (who is who he is because of my determination to raise a good man)
My father was cold, financially and emotionally abusive to my mother and cold towards his children.
My husband and his brother have turned out to be addicted to alcohol and sex.
It’s sad and depressing.

GoodGirlFaith · Yesterday 16:26

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

The most ridiculous comment I have read today! And I've read plenty of ridiculous comments today...