Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:49

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:32

Im not sure. I think there has been other crimes in the history of mankind though that have been fabricated! Its not unknown that humans can be liars and can be toxic and can enjoy ruining other people's lives by making things up. I mean if someone reported their house being burgled but the was no evidence of breaking in or nothing missing they would probably be accused of making it up no?

Would you say that on balance you are more inclined to believe women when they report crimes other than rape or would you say you equally disbelieve all women reporting all crimes?

There are men particularly, but many women too, who routinely disbelieve sexually based crimes have been committed, would you say you fit in that category? Much more importantly if you do fit in that category have you ever explored with yourself why you feel that way?

OP posts:
MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:59

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:49

Would you say that on balance you are more inclined to believe women when they report crimes other than rape or would you say you equally disbelieve all women reporting all crimes?

There are men particularly, but many women too, who routinely disbelieve sexually based crimes have been committed, would you say you fit in that category? Much more importantly if you do fit in that category have you ever explored with yourself why you feel that way?

I don't believe women lie more than men, I believe SOME humans lie and I believe in the justice system.

Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 17:00

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:46

I don't know what 6 women you are referring to i didn't know this was about a specific case im just responding to the original OP AIBU.

Oh gosh sorry been flicking between this and RB thread and got mixed up - they seem to be arguing about the same principle!

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 17:03

Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 17:00

Oh gosh sorry been flicking between this and RB thread and got mixed up - they seem to be arguing about the same principle!

Ah is see! I haven't been following that thread but for the record RB seems like a slimeball and most likely guilty to some if not all the crimes.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 17:08

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:59

I don't believe women lie more than men, I believe SOME humans lie and I believe in the justice system.

But the stats for prosecution for rape have been quoted so how can you believe in that as a system in its current incarnation.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 17:10

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:59

I don't believe women lie more than men, I believe SOME humans lie and I believe in the justice system.

But the facts show that the justice system is flawed when it comes to sexual assault. So your belief in it is unfounded. And there is no reason it can’t be tweaked based on research. For example because in cases of CSA memories have faded and no physical evidence is around, lots of child abusers walked free. The law was changed so that if there were more than one victim that disclosed, that was viewed as more solid evidence and cases were prosecuted. This was around 30 years ago. I haven’t heard anything about any wrongful sentences yet.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 17:11

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 17:03

Ah is see! I haven't been following that thread but for the record RB seems like a slimeball and most likely guilty to some if not all the crimes.

Honestly MyLimeGuide I think we agree far more than we disagree. That was one of the cases that inspired this thread but this is a far more reaching issue than this single case. I know of two more cases going on where people are saying on repeat that the man is innocent until proven guilty all over social media/ comments sections and in the bloody pub when yes that principle is fine as a legal principle but is not applicable outside of court.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 17:14

I admire your stamina, @Hugasaurusrex! You must be a good engineer, as well as a fine advocate of justice for women.

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 17:15

In my view society has a duty to view somebody as innocent until proven guilty, if guilt is presumed when an allegation is made or when someone is charged that is not fair or morally right. There are cases where people deny heinous crimes and they are guilty, there are also cases where people are prosecuted for crimes and they are innocent. Each case is different, I want to live in a society where we do not presume guilt.

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 17:18

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 17:15

In my view society has a duty to view somebody as innocent until proven guilty, if guilt is presumed when an allegation is made or when someone is charged that is not fair or morally right. There are cases where people deny heinous crimes and they are guilty, there are also cases where people are prosecuted for crimes and they are innocent. Each case is different, I want to live in a society where we do not presume guilt.

In the case of sexual assault the bias is skewed well towards the perpetrators though. So it’s not working. And could be tweaked. See examples above.

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 17:25

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 17:18

In the case of sexual assault the bias is skewed well towards the perpetrators though. So it’s not working. And could be tweaked. See examples above.

We still need to treat those accused of sexual assault fairly - not all are guilty. If a relative or friend of mine was accused falsely and assumed to be guilty I can't imagine how upset they and I would feel, their life would be wrecked, I know that some would say "no smoke without fire" even when they were found not guilty and the comments here about not guilty is not the same as innocent show that once an allegation is made for some that means guilt. I don't want to live in a society like that.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 17:26

@Mrsbirdwatcher

There are cases where people deny heinous crimes and they are guilty

Is that not the absolute norm as in the vast majority of people who commit heinous crimes lie about doing so, certainly in court and during the investigation.

The thread is confronting that people apply the principle of innocent until proven guilty outside of the courtroom setting.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 17:43

In my view society has a duty to view somebody as innocent until proven guilty

This is insane. I bet you don't apply it in your own life, @Mrsbirdwatcher.

Shops share photos of habitual shoplifters between themselves, banning the thieves from their premises when possible. Shoplifters are rarely brought to trial due to resource pressures. Your principle would have them rampaging freely, as 'society has a duty to view them as innocent'.

You could actually witness a real crime taking place and your principle says there's nothing to report because the criminal is innocent!

How do you think anyone even gets to court if society's duty is to presume innocence??

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 17:58

@GarlicNothing

How do you think anyone even gets to court if society's duty is to presume innocence??

Exactly and there is the issue that this is usually specifically targeted at women and adults who were abused as children accusing sexual crimes.

It is a deep seated misogyny and the internet and comments sections are exposing how prolific the issue is these days and the fact that these are cultural issues that should be mitigated somewhere along the way in the criminal justice system.

I read an article recently about a woman in the UK who was “the cause of the rise in domestic violence issues”. What had she done? She had opened the very first women’s refuge - until then the abuse was very much behind closed doors.

OP posts:
RufustheFestiveReindeer · 01/11/2026 18:06

So what if (god forbid) a female relative of yours is raped?

he is innocent til proved guilty according to you isn’t he? After all she could be fibbing…

cps say they aren’t going to prosecute? So he didn’t do and your relative is lying

or she retracts cos she just can’t take the pressure of a trial or having the entire town talking about her (or so she feels) he still innocent?

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 01/11/2026 18:07

Or he is found not guilty even though he did it? Deffo innocent is he?

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 01/11/2026 18:11

Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 16:14

No they are not - they are treated “as if” innocent for the purpose of the trial

the outcome the jury give is guilty or not guilty - no one is declared innocent - not guilty means the prosecution didn’t reach the threshold of evidence at the time

Edited

This

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 01/11/2026 18:16

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 17:25

We still need to treat those accused of sexual assault fairly - not all are guilty. If a relative or friend of mine was accused falsely and assumed to be guilty I can't imagine how upset they and I would feel, their life would be wrecked, I know that some would say "no smoke without fire" even when they were found not guilty and the comments here about not guilty is not the same as innocent show that once an allegation is made for some that means guilt. I don't want to live in a society like that.

Apologies I did not attach the quote

my questions were to mrsbird

doh!

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 18:25

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 17:43

In my view society has a duty to view somebody as innocent until proven guilty

This is insane. I bet you don't apply it in your own life, @Mrsbirdwatcher.

Shops share photos of habitual shoplifters between themselves, banning the thieves from their premises when possible. Shoplifters are rarely brought to trial due to resource pressures. Your principle would have them rampaging freely, as 'society has a duty to view them as innocent'.

You could actually witness a real crime taking place and your principle says there's nothing to report because the criminal is innocent!

How do you think anyone even gets to court if society's duty is to presume innocence??

Edited

I don’t work in retail so am not involved in that. If I either witnessed a crime and indeed have done so I have reported it. Yes if I felt uneasy about an individual for whatever reason I would steer clear of them ( and have done so). That is very different from openly defaming them or making comments and ostracising them on social media. We are free to make those choices, we should in my view be ostracising and maligning those who are not found guilty

lljkk · 01/11/2026 18:26

Yay... Mob Rule. Let's have more of that. Awesome.
I accuse every single poster on this thread of a heinous sexual crime.
All the posters on this thread should be locked up forever.
They should all have to face accusations in court and be convicted and shunned forever.

See how easy that was? You're all guilty evil people.
Must be true because I wrote it in black and white.
Enjoy living a society that operates like that.

Cuttertheduck · 01/11/2026 18:28

There is innocent until proven in court
When it is about sexual assault cases: fair enough
As a woman my self preservation is more important so I don't associate with men accused of those crimes.
If it hurts them they can just move to the US and become president
( as if "false" rape accusations have ever destroyed someones life)

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 18:28

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 01/11/2026 18:06

So what if (god forbid) a female relative of yours is raped?

he is innocent til proved guilty according to you isn’t he? After all she could be fibbing…

cps say they aren’t going to prosecute? So he didn’t do and your relative is lying

or she retracts cos she just can’t take the pressure of a trial or having the entire town talking about her (or so she feels) he still innocent?

I would hope there would be enough evidence to bring a prosecution but I would not then take to social media or malign someone openly.

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 18:36

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 18:25

I don’t work in retail so am not involved in that. If I either witnessed a crime and indeed have done so I have reported it. Yes if I felt uneasy about an individual for whatever reason I would steer clear of them ( and have done so). That is very different from openly defaming them or making comments and ostracising them on social media. We are free to make those choices, we should in my view be ostracising and maligning those who are not found guilty

So if someone assaulted you (or someone close to you) and was found not guilty you wouldn’t “malign” them by warning your friends, family, daughters etc. You’d simply accept he’s innocent now?

Or is it just on public forums that we should keep quiet?

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 18:37

lljkk · 01/11/2026 18:26

Yay... Mob Rule. Let's have more of that. Awesome.
I accuse every single poster on this thread of a heinous sexual crime.
All the posters on this thread should be locked up forever.
They should all have to face accusations in court and be convicted and shunned forever.

See how easy that was? You're all guilty evil people.
Must be true because I wrote it in black and white.
Enjoy living a society that operates like that.

You’re being deliberately obtuse and you know it.

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 01/11/2026 18:43

That is very different from openly defaming them or making comments and ostracising them on social media

has anyone actually said this is what should be done? Honest question I may have missed it

posters are coming out with absolute statement of innocent til proven guilty….quite obviously this can’t be true in all cases

Swipe left for the next trending thread