Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
BeLemonMoose · 01/11/2026 18:47

Jimmy Saville was never found guilty in a court of law. Do you think we should still talk about him as if he was innocent?

Crudd99 · 01/11/2026 18:48

I was a witness in a SA case. The witness liason person an ex policeman said" ill be blunt it's who ever sounds the most convincing on the day". That's what it boils down to. In our case he was found guilty thank goodness but he'd done it before at least twice that we knew of and had gotten away with it.

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 18:52

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 17:25

We still need to treat those accused of sexual assault fairly - not all are guilty. If a relative or friend of mine was accused falsely and assumed to be guilty I can't imagine how upset they and I would feel, their life would be wrecked, I know that some would say "no smoke without fire" even when they were found not guilty and the comments here about not guilty is not the same as innocent show that once an allegation is made for some that means guilt. I don't want to live in a society like that.

In the U.K. men are far more likely to be the victims of rape or sexual assault than falsely prosecuted for rape.

Meanwhile;

In recent reporting periods, out of tens of thousands of recorded rapes, only a small fraction (roughly 3% to 5%) result in a suspect being charged.

So there are between 95-97% of rapes that are reported that don’t even make it to trial.

All of those victims won’t be lying. It’s about meeting the current threshold for evidence.

Therefore the threshold for evidence needs to shift.

So a water tight alibi is going ensure you won’t be falsely prosecuted. Men (the main perpetrators of rape) can protect themselves very easily by making sure they stay together, make sure they aren’t alone with someone they don’t trust, try not to be flirtatious or piss a woman off. There is lots they can do to set up their lives so that the risk of a false allegation or prosecution is further reduced.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 18:58

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 18:52

In the U.K. men are far more likely to be the victims of rape or sexual assault than falsely prosecuted for rape.

Meanwhile;

In recent reporting periods, out of tens of thousands of recorded rapes, only a small fraction (roughly 3% to 5%) result in a suspect being charged.

So there are between 95-97% of rapes that are reported that don’t even make it to trial.

All of those victims won’t be lying. It’s about meeting the current threshold for evidence.

Therefore the threshold for evidence needs to shift.

So a water tight alibi is going ensure you won’t be falsely prosecuted. Men (the main perpetrators of rape) can protect themselves very easily by making sure they stay together, make sure they aren’t alone with someone they don’t trust, try not to be flirtatious or piss a woman off. There is lots they can do to set up their lives so that the risk of a false allegation or prosecution is further reduced.

This is such an important point men and boys are significantly represented in victim status in rapes.This is not only a girls and women issue. Predatory men often are predatory to both sex’s.

The Epstein files highlighted a US culture around these issues. It is about protecting powerful and predatory men.

Too many people are comfortable with the status quo where victims bare the entire costs of rape.

They are unwilling to confront their own part in this issue and they are willing to forgo protection of victims to continue to protect perpetrators.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 18:59

lljkk · 01/11/2026 18:26

Yay... Mob Rule. Let's have more of that. Awesome.
I accuse every single poster on this thread of a heinous sexual crime.
All the posters on this thread should be locked up forever.
They should all have to face accusations in court and be convicted and shunned forever.

See how easy that was? You're all guilty evil people.
Must be true because I wrote it in black and white.
Enjoy living a society that operates like that.

The suggestion isn’t to do away with courts and a fair process though. Vigilante intervention isn’t the suggestion.

The suggestion, I believe, is that only 3-5% of reported rapes go to trial. So that’s 95-97% of potential rapists still out there! Walking free. And we wonder why women are so unsafe.

The suggestion is to change the evidence threshold. Like was done around 30 years ago (if I remember rightly) with CSA. Where more than one victim disclosed, it could be prosecuted regardless of other evidence meeting the threshold or not. This was because what research showed was that child abusers were not being prosecuted.

So we use the research to point us towards why are so many rapists getting away with it and we change the system to redress that imbalance. That’s all.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 19:13

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 18:59

The suggestion isn’t to do away with courts and a fair process though. Vigilante intervention isn’t the suggestion.

The suggestion, I believe, is that only 3-5% of reported rapes go to trial. So that’s 95-97% of potential rapists still out there! Walking free. And we wonder why women are so unsafe.

The suggestion is to change the evidence threshold. Like was done around 30 years ago (if I remember rightly) with CSA. Where more than one victim disclosed, it could be prosecuted regardless of other evidence meeting the threshold or not. This was because what research showed was that child abusers were not being prosecuted.

So we use the research to point us towards why are so many rapists getting away with it and we change the system to redress that imbalance. That’s all.

Well said and some really good points.

OP posts:
ErinBell01 · 02/11/2026 02:09

LauderSyme · 31/10/2026 22:57

Building upon my previous comment, which may have proven excessively nuanced for you, "presumed innocent" is a concept relevant only in a court of law.

Less than 3% of reported rapes in the UK are prosecuted. About two thirds of prosecutions result in conviction.

That means 97% of reported rapes are never prosecuted. On top of that, most rapes are never even reported to the police.

Let's say only 1 in 100 are reported. I'm willing to bet this is no exaggeration and is probably an underestimate. But let's choose to say only 1% of rapes are reported. That means arithmetically, ultimately, only 0.02% of rapes are ever punished by the criminal 'justice' system.

Most women therefore understand that predatory men are rarely found legally guilty for their criminal transgressions against us.

That does not mean those crimes never happened.

Someone needs to invent a recording device that women can wear surreptisiously that will prove that they didn't give consent. They can then rely on this in court and men can be prosecuted with actual evidence being cited rather than just he said, she said. A necklace? Earings?

bythebanksof · 02/11/2026 08:22

People will always make judgements about guilt, regardless of any legal outcome. With respect to crimes of a sexual nature, as other posters mentioned, there is very little chance of a conviction due to a whole set of cascading proabilities that allow the offender to avoid conviction.

Having worked over 25 years in the area (and 5 more years in police) the most shocking cases I've seen are in fact where the person is convicted, overwhelming evidence, yet there will be his supporters who refuse to believe it regardless. A recent stranger rape case I worked on had an offender being a suspect in a number of cases over a decade, yet he still has very strong family support. Those earlier failures to prosecute (for a whole range of valid issues), together with his family support, resulted in more victims. On one level we failed the victims, on the other hand his family and friends enabled him.

Hugasaurusrex · 02/11/2026 08:56

bythebanksof · 02/11/2026 08:22

People will always make judgements about guilt, regardless of any legal outcome. With respect to crimes of a sexual nature, as other posters mentioned, there is very little chance of a conviction due to a whole set of cascading proabilities that allow the offender to avoid conviction.

Having worked over 25 years in the area (and 5 more years in police) the most shocking cases I've seen are in fact where the person is convicted, overwhelming evidence, yet there will be his supporters who refuse to believe it regardless. A recent stranger rape case I worked on had an offender being a suspect in a number of cases over a decade, yet he still has very strong family support. Those earlier failures to prosecute (for a whole range of valid issues), together with his family support, resulted in more victims. On one level we failed the victims, on the other hand his family and friends enabled him.

That is where I think the real work needs to happen.

For so long the monster conversation around rape happened but same as domestic violence, the men committing these crimes are ordinary regular men who have ordinary lives with ordinary jobs.

Some of them are prolific others are opportunistic but rape is much more often carried out by friends and family known to the victim.

Families and friends and even further choose to not confront the consequences of rape for rapists and expect victims to carry the load and stay silent.

OP posts:
bythebanksof · 02/11/2026 12:01

@Hugasaurusrex you mentioned "Some of them are prolific others are opportunistic but rape is much more often carried out by friends and family known to the victim."

The opportunist percentage is very small. That has a particular meaning in the field, if you are interested look up MTC. The vast majority are repeat offenders, and that's been my experience working in the field too, even if in those convictions where the headline case may be 1 assault; that person is almost always a suspect or has reports logged about him that proceed. The jury never knows this, but the defense often do!!

Itsasecretnow · 02/11/2026 13:25

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:19

Thank you so well said and I completely agree with you.

Let’s be honest here, the process right from the moment you decide to report, is gruelling, often dehumanising, always stressful and triggering (and I do not ever use that word lightly), and frequently goes nowhere. It could be months, and even years, and there are very, very few women who would put themselves through that in the first place (sadly). Yes, you hear about the very odd one where someone has made it up (for whatever reason that may be), such as the woman who faked that grooming scandal not so long ago. But the reasons that some of these cases come to our attention isn’t because it’s frequent, in fact it’s the opposite, it’s so astonishingly rare - statistically - that it’s so unusual for it to happen that it gets reported on. Do most men have it in them to commit assault? I don’t think so, and I hope not, but unfortunately many do. And it’s not unusual that it comes up that the man that does may also have had other complaints made, which usually go nowhere, so that it’s very unlikely all these women are lying. Or colluding (most never know, otherwise they wouldn’t even be anywhere around these men*), so to start out with the baseline of what is basically “I don’t believe her, unless he’s found guilty in a court of law”, which it appears some women (and god I hope that is a very small minority that think this way) seem to believe is pretty disgusting, tbh. Women not believing women is a hundred times more devastating than men not believing women. Both are pretty vile thinking, tbh, but I personally think it’s far worse when it’s a woman.
Somehow it’s a topic that has come up recently a few times in conversation in my real life, and just the general mess all around that. Somehow a female misogynist is far more sickening to me than your garden variety male misogynist. And believe me, when we’re talking about not believing women then I’m afraid this is what is happening here.
And let’s not forget, a “Not Guilty” verdict does not equal innocent. They are not the same thing.
*eta, I’m talking about situations where the woman knows her attacker, might have some kind of relationship with them, I’m not talking about “stranger” rape here. Just thought I’d make that bit clear, as these are the most common.

Itsasecretnow · 02/11/2026 13:34

Sorry, I didn’t think to fix the formatting of the paragraphs when I made my edit, so apologies about the wall of text above.

Hugasaurusrex · 02/11/2026 15:36

bythebanksof · 02/11/2026 12:01

@Hugasaurusrex you mentioned "Some of them are prolific others are opportunistic but rape is much more often carried out by friends and family known to the victim."

The opportunist percentage is very small. That has a particular meaning in the field, if you are interested look up MTC. The vast majority are repeat offenders, and that's been my experience working in the field too, even if in those convictions where the headline case may be 1 assault; that person is almost always a suspect or has reports logged about him that proceed. The jury never knows this, but the defense often do!!

It is horrifying isn’t it?

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 02/11/2026 15:43

Itsasecretnow · 02/11/2026 13:25

Let’s be honest here, the process right from the moment you decide to report, is gruelling, often dehumanising, always stressful and triggering (and I do not ever use that word lightly), and frequently goes nowhere. It could be months, and even years, and there are very, very few women who would put themselves through that in the first place (sadly). Yes, you hear about the very odd one where someone has made it up (for whatever reason that may be), such as the woman who faked that grooming scandal not so long ago. But the reasons that some of these cases come to our attention isn’t because it’s frequent, in fact it’s the opposite, it’s so astonishingly rare - statistically - that it’s so unusual for it to happen that it gets reported on. Do most men have it in them to commit assault? I don’t think so, and I hope not, but unfortunately many do. And it’s not unusual that it comes up that the man that does may also have had other complaints made, which usually go nowhere, so that it’s very unlikely all these women are lying. Or colluding (most never know, otherwise they wouldn’t even be anywhere around these men*), so to start out with the baseline of what is basically “I don’t believe her, unless he’s found guilty in a court of law”, which it appears some women (and god I hope that is a very small minority that think this way) seem to believe is pretty disgusting, tbh. Women not believing women is a hundred times more devastating than men not believing women. Both are pretty vile thinking, tbh, but I personally think it’s far worse when it’s a woman.
Somehow it’s a topic that has come up recently a few times in conversation in my real life, and just the general mess all around that. Somehow a female misogynist is far more sickening to me than your garden variety male misogynist. And believe me, when we’re talking about not believing women then I’m afraid this is what is happening here.
And let’s not forget, a “Not Guilty” verdict does not equal innocent. They are not the same thing.
*eta, I’m talking about situations where the woman knows her attacker, might have some kind of relationship with them, I’m not talking about “stranger” rape here. Just thought I’d make that bit clear, as these are the most common.

Edited

I know what you mean about women saying this stuff being so much harder to take.

I guess we are all brought up in the same cultural soup. None of us know anything when we are born, we learn everything we know through what we are taught and the life experiences we have.

If people don’t have a curiosity around these issues then they are only being taught by what surrounds them every day. That goes as much for women as it does men.

Sometimes people do have full awareness of the predatory behaviour going on around them, again men and women, and they are happy to tolerate it for their own motivations. Again the Jeffery Donaldson case, but his wife aided and abetted him.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 02/11/2026 17:39

Does Claire’s law include accusations of sexual assault?

Surely if there are say three accusations then that could be enough to prosecute?

GreenGlassVases · 02/11/2026 17:41

GreenGlassVases · 02/11/2026 17:39

Does Claire’s law include accusations of sexual assault?

Surely if there are say three accusations then that could be enough to prosecute?

Just looked it up and it does. So - and this might have been said before - surely that gathering information could be used to prosecute. Based on statistics - not many men (if any) are going to be accused three times by separate women. The odds of that must be low enough to be ‘beyond reasonable doubt’?

Hugasaurusrex · 02/11/2026 17:50

GreenGlassVases · 02/11/2026 17:41

Just looked it up and it does. So - and this might have been said before - surely that gathering information could be used to prosecute. Based on statistics - not many men (if any) are going to be accused three times by separate women. The odds of that must be low enough to be ‘beyond reasonable doubt’?

As far as I know if a person is being tried for multiple instances of rape/SA then other victims can be brought up but otherwise past behaviour is often not allowed to be brought up even if they have previously been found guilty.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 02/11/2026 22:06

Hugasaurusrex · 02/11/2026 17:50

As far as I know if a person is being tried for multiple instances of rape/SA then other victims can be brought up but otherwise past behaviour is often not allowed to be brought up even if they have previously been found guilty.

At least it’s all there for Claire’s law requests.

AmateurDad · 02/11/2026 23:53

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

I would start my response by saying that "innocent until proven guilty" is not in fact a maxim used in English law. Rather, juries - all juries - are told that the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt, and that the defendant does not need to prove anything.

GreenGlassVases · 03/11/2026 04:53

AmateurDad · 02/11/2026 23:53

I would start my response by saying that "innocent until proven guilty" is not in fact a maxim used in English law. Rather, juries - all juries - are told that the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt, and that the defendant does not need to prove anything.

And your view on sexual assault and the fact that only 3-5% ever get to prosecution? Your view on the fact that means that in the vast majority of cases the perpetrator walks free able to do it again? The fact that most women have experienced sexual assault of some kind - many never even bother to report it because there is no point?

Do you not think that this indicates an issue in how we deal with this problem?

Your user name suggests you are a father. How would you feel if it was your son or daughter that was assaulted and they were told that there is not enough evidence to make prosecution viable?

FrippEnos · 03/11/2026 09:42

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 14:28

Let’s put it this way. Someone tells you the tutor you chose for your daughter is/might be a predator. Do you go “oh well innocent until proven guilty” and hope for the best or do you find another tutor?

Wouldn't that depend on the context the surrounds the "someone" that tells you?
And your point is also the basis of safeguarding.

allthingsinmoderation · 03/11/2026 10:15

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 18:52

In the U.K. men are far more likely to be the victims of rape or sexual assault than falsely prosecuted for rape.

Meanwhile;

In recent reporting periods, out of tens of thousands of recorded rapes, only a small fraction (roughly 3% to 5%) result in a suspect being charged.

So there are between 95-97% of rapes that are reported that don’t even make it to trial.

All of those victims won’t be lying. It’s about meeting the current threshold for evidence.

Therefore the threshold for evidence needs to shift.

So a water tight alibi is going ensure you won’t be falsely prosecuted. Men (the main perpetrators of rape) can protect themselves very easily by making sure they stay together, make sure they aren’t alone with someone they don’t trust, try not to be flirtatious or piss a woman off. There is lots they can do to set up their lives so that the risk of a false allegation or prosecution is further reduced.

The thing is the Britsh legal system fundamentally built on the idea(Blackstone's ratio) that it would rather see a guilty man go free than convict an innocent man...hence the principle of beyond a reasonable doubt.(conveyed to the jury as being "sure").It would require a change in the law and i doubt that will happen. People fear Salem style false accusations too much.
Rape seems so difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt particularly when time has lapsed and it is basically asking the jury to decide whose word they believe. I can understand why so many rape allegations go to civil courts where the burden of proof is lower for being found liable eg: Connor Mcgregor case

PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · 03/11/2026 10:56

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:30

There are umpteen posts engaging with the actual sensitive and serious topic I am discussing here. There is you and one other person who tried to make it about my writing style. Maybe this thread is not for you.

Edited

@Hugasaurusrex,
I am rather surprised that you bothered to reply to me at all, as you thought I wasn't being helpful. If someone trys to get a rise out of you, I suggest that in future you ignore their post/s. Trouble makers like nothing better than to get a disgruntled reply, it is the fuel they need to further feed their own egos...

As you have so kindly fed mine, I will try to explain to you that I was merely attempting to draw your attention to the lack of punctuation in your OP, in the hope that if you just corrected that error, @everynowandthenifallapart should no longer be able to claim that your second paragraph makes it impossible for her to - presumably - understand. I am not exactly an expert in my own use of punctuation, as I tend to overuse it!

Hugasaurusrex · 03/11/2026 14:36

PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · 03/11/2026 10:56

@Hugasaurusrex,
I am rather surprised that you bothered to reply to me at all, as you thought I wasn't being helpful. If someone trys to get a rise out of you, I suggest that in future you ignore their post/s. Trouble makers like nothing better than to get a disgruntled reply, it is the fuel they need to further feed their own egos...

As you have so kindly fed mine, I will try to explain to you that I was merely attempting to draw your attention to the lack of punctuation in your OP, in the hope that if you just corrected that error, @everynowandthenifallapart should no longer be able to claim that your second paragraph makes it impossible for her to - presumably - understand. I am not exactly an expert in my own use of punctuation, as I tend to overuse it!

You are sanctimonious and tedious and not great at engaging with topic actually under discussion but to be fair your point here is spot on but because it is a response to you I’ll continue to disregard it.

OP posts:
BeLemonMoose · 03/11/2026 18:46

allthingsinmoderation · 03/11/2026 10:15

The thing is the Britsh legal system fundamentally built on the idea(Blackstone's ratio) that it would rather see a guilty man go free than convict an innocent man...hence the principle of beyond a reasonable doubt.(conveyed to the jury as being "sure").It would require a change in the law and i doubt that will happen. People fear Salem style false accusations too much.
Rape seems so difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt particularly when time has lapsed and it is basically asking the jury to decide whose word they believe. I can understand why so many rape allegations go to civil courts where the burden of proof is lower for being found liable eg: Connor Mcgregor case

And civil court can often lead to evidence being disclosed e.g. testimony, that makes a criminal case more likely to be successful