Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 03/11/2026 18:50

BeLemonMoose · 03/11/2026 18:46

And civil court can often lead to evidence being disclosed e.g. testimony, that makes a criminal case more likely to be successful

The Nikita Hand civil action against Conor McGregor has been very helpful in having him named publicly as someone who was found to have raped her by a Civil court even though there has not been a criminal trial. So even that is helpful.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 03/11/2026 20:00

allthingsinmoderation · 03/11/2026 10:15

The thing is the Britsh legal system fundamentally built on the idea(Blackstone's ratio) that it would rather see a guilty man go free than convict an innocent man...hence the principle of beyond a reasonable doubt.(conveyed to the jury as being "sure").It would require a change in the law and i doubt that will happen. People fear Salem style false accusations too much.
Rape seems so difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt particularly when time has lapsed and it is basically asking the jury to decide whose word they believe. I can understand why so many rape allegations go to civil courts where the burden of proof is lower for being found liable eg: Connor Mcgregor case

It doesn’t have to be a law change. It doesn’t have to be Guilty until proven innocent. Just a tweak to the evidence threshold. 95% accused rapists go free. That’s unacceptable.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 03/11/2026 22:48

In the words of Dr House ...everyone lies.

When you're in a situation where no one but the two people involved know the truth then you have to presume innocence and go about proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

It's a flawed system because everyone lies and, therefore, getting to the truth is a journey in itself but you cannot go round locking people up on the say so of one person.

Everyone lies.

GreenGlassVases · 03/11/2026 23:00

NimbleTaupeTiger · 03/11/2026 22:48

In the words of Dr House ...everyone lies.

When you're in a situation where no one but the two people involved know the truth then you have to presume innocence and go about proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

It's a flawed system because everyone lies and, therefore, getting to the truth is a journey in itself but you cannot go round locking people up on the say so of one person.

Everyone lies.

So we just accept that 95% of men accused of sexual assault and rape go unprosecuted?

We are putting the minuscule risk of a man being wrongly accused and prosecuted over and above the huge and historical risk of women (and men) being sexually assaulted and raped?

You can shift the threshold for evidence to be lower and based on research.

Men are far more at risk of being raped themselves than being falsely accused of rape and they can protect themselves from false allegations by not being alone with strange women, staying together, making sure they always have an alibi, being careful where they go, not being too flirty.

Then if they are falsely accused and the evidence threshold is lowered and they are prosecuted then they can work hard to show that this isn’t in their nature and that they didn’t do it.

If the tiny tiny tiny risk of being wrongly found guilty then they can appeal and fight that wrongful conviction.

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 04/11/2026 08:24

I think that within reason previous convictions and history should be taken into account in these sort of cases

it maybe one word against another in every case but if there are previous cases that should be evidence of a behaviour and an attitude

dd was touched inappropriately years ago, it was scary for her as she was 12 even though it wasn’t something the vast majority of us would do anything about if it happened to us, but i thought it was important to report it to the police in case the man had done it before ir was going to do it again or escalate etc

NimbleTaupeTiger · 04/11/2026 12:28

No, once you lower the level of evidence required for one type of crime where does it stop? Do we then say that GBH has a lower evidence level, or manslaughter or murder? Can we claim ADHD plays a part or other mental health issues, do these form part of the defence? If you start playing around with a proven judicial system to sway the balance one way or another it could backfire spectacularly.

The CPS manages to convict around 63% of cases passed to it, however, this is a very small percentage of rape cases overall because victims fail to see the process through. If they could be encouraged to both report it immediately to get DNA and forensic samples and stay with the process there would be more convictions.

GarlicNothing · 04/11/2026 17:00

NimbleTaupeTiger · 04/11/2026 12:28

No, once you lower the level of evidence required for one type of crime where does it stop? Do we then say that GBH has a lower evidence level, or manslaughter or murder? Can we claim ADHD plays a part or other mental health issues, do these form part of the defence? If you start playing around with a proven judicial system to sway the balance one way or another it could backfire spectacularly.

The CPS manages to convict around 63% of cases passed to it, however, this is a very small percentage of rape cases overall because victims fail to see the process through. If they could be encouraged to both report it immediately to get DNA and forensic samples and stay with the process there would be more convictions.

Alternatively, are we saying that crimes committed without witnesses and with minimal forensic or documentary evidence aren't real crimes?

You can have bruises and DNA, your assailant can still claim you were willing. This is impossible with other types of assault - even boxers in the ring can be guilty of ABH.

It's not necessarily about reducing the threshold of evidence, but could be about different kinds of evidence and/or tweaking the judicial process for 'intimate' crimes.

GarlicNothing · 04/11/2026 17:06

or manslaughter or murder

Well, these are never going to be the victim's word against the accused's, are they 😂

VioletsTale · 04/11/2026 17:30

GarlicNothing · 04/11/2026 17:00

Alternatively, are we saying that crimes committed without witnesses and with minimal forensic or documentary evidence aren't real crimes?

You can have bruises and DNA, your assailant can still claim you were willing. This is impossible with other types of assault - even boxers in the ring can be guilty of ABH.

It's not necessarily about reducing the threshold of evidence, but could be about different kinds of evidence and/or tweaking the judicial process for 'intimate' crimes.

Rough sex defence can’t actually be used anymore. It wasn’t heavily publicised I don’t think. That’s an example of “lowering the evidence threshold “ I suppose. It can happen. It would have never happened without a lot of work and effort and active campaigning (shout out to We Can’t Consent To This). I bet 5/10 years ago posters were saying that it’s impossible and what about the poor innocent blokes and the women who lie.

GreenGlassVases · 04/11/2026 18:29

NimbleTaupeTiger · 04/11/2026 12:28

No, once you lower the level of evidence required for one type of crime where does it stop? Do we then say that GBH has a lower evidence level, or manslaughter or murder? Can we claim ADHD plays a part or other mental health issues, do these form part of the defence? If you start playing around with a proven judicial system to sway the balance one way or another it could backfire spectacularly.

The CPS manages to convict around 63% of cases passed to it, however, this is a very small percentage of rape cases overall because victims fail to see the process through. If they could be encouraged to both report it immediately to get DNA and forensic samples and stay with the process there would be more convictions.

You base it on the evidence. What does the research say? You follow the science.

It happened with prosecutions for CSA around 30 years ago.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 04/11/2026 18:35

GreenGlassVases · 04/11/2026 18:29

You base it on the evidence. What does the research say? You follow the science.

It happened with prosecutions for CSA around 30 years ago.

You're entitled to your opinion, I disagree but it's not worth debating.

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 19:00

Legally speaking, a person must be treated as innocent unless proven guilty. But socially speaking, there's no such requirement to do so, so I don't know why people parrot that phrase outside of context.

Hugasaurusrex · 04/11/2026 19:15

GreenGlassVases · 04/11/2026 18:29

You base it on the evidence. What does the research say? You follow the science.

It happened with prosecutions for CSA around 30 years ago.

I agree.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 04/11/2026 19:15

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 19:00

Legally speaking, a person must be treated as innocent unless proven guilty. But socially speaking, there's no such requirement to do so, so I don't know why people parrot that phrase outside of context.

Absolutely agree with you.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 04/11/2026 19:20

GreenGlassVases · 04/11/2026 18:29

You base it on the evidence. What does the research say? You follow the science.

It happened with prosecutions for CSA around 30 years ago.

It also happened with stop and search, look how long that lasted.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page