Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 12:52

TheFriendlyPotato · 01/11/2026 11:33

There is a real issue here.

I am one for believing people are innocent. I have worked w serious offenders for decades and I still have that view. I do not want to live in a society where we assume someone is guilty because someone said they did something. That is an absolute horror show and opens society up to lawfare (accusing to get rid of people we dont like).

I do understand however that victims of crime feel incredibly let down when perps are deemed not guilty. Its horrific for those people, especially sexual assaults or families of those murdered.

I think that there is a tendency for people to get trial by aocial media though. If Russell Brand gets off his charge, he will still be seen as the rapey narcissist. That wont go away. Yes he wont go to prison, but social shunning and denigration is still very powerful. Look at Gary Glitter et al.

Its the best system we have and I cant think of a better version.

We can still work in the same framework of a justice system but it changes can be made. There are really good examples of possible changes given in other posts.

OP posts:
5128gap · 01/11/2026 12:55

everynowandthenifallapart · 31/10/2026 22:11

Nothing wrong with my reading comprehension, it’s an incoherent question.

Its perfectly clear what the OP means.
She is putting forward the premis that our CJS is stacked in favour of those accused of sexual crimes, which she believes leads to guilty men receiving not guilty verdicts. And given this, is it reasonable for us always to believe a person innocent unless a jury returns a guilty verdict.
To which I'd answer, no its not reasonable. Because we know that obtaining a guilty verdict relies on evidence of guilt, the absence of which does not always mean innocence.
As well as other factors including adherence to certain procedures and technicalities and subjective decisions by human beings to favour one conflicting account over another.

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 12:55

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 02:53

*My belief system is English Common Law, in which burden of proof is an integral concept that protects the rights of the individual.

I do not believe lowering the burden of proof is a price worth paying for increased conviction rates.*

So you are happy for rapists act with impunity because you see the current system as having no scope for improvement.

To me this response is extremely male centric because of the link of men being perpetrators of any crime but obviously specifically sexual crimes and it is not very protective of victims of crime particularly women and children.

Edited

That’s fine, you can of course believe that. I don’t expect us to agree.

That I do not support the lowering of the burden of proof, or believe that such an action would be an improvement, does not mean I do not believe there is no scope for improvement.

JHound · 01/11/2026 12:57

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

I believe actually being innocent of a crime and being innocent under the law are two different things (as OJ clearly demonstrated).

I think individuals can think what they like but I want the judicial system to see people as innocent unless the prosecution can clearly demonstrate otherwise.

justasking111 · 01/11/2026 12:57

TheFriendlyPotato · 01/11/2026 11:33

There is a real issue here.

I am one for believing people are innocent. I have worked w serious offenders for decades and I still have that view. I do not want to live in a society where we assume someone is guilty because someone said they did something. That is an absolute horror show and opens society up to lawfare (accusing to get rid of people we dont like).

I do understand however that victims of crime feel incredibly let down when perps are deemed not guilty. Its horrific for those people, especially sexual assaults or families of those murdered.

I think that there is a tendency for people to get trial by aocial media though. If Russell Brand gets off his charge, he will still be seen as the rapey narcissist. That wont go away. Yes he wont go to prison, but social shunning and denigration is still very powerful. Look at Gary Glitter et al.

Its the best system we have and I cant think of a better version.

Gary Glitter are you kidding, he kiddie fiddled until death.

JHound · 01/11/2026 12:59

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 22:55

Yeah it is a real challenge and I completely ageee with you. I have this real feeling that particularly in sex crimes there is this impossible bar that means so many men walk away from actually committing the crime with not guilty verdicts or even absolutely no attempt to prosecute at all that innocent until proven guilty is all but meaningless and yet so many people will write this is comment sections under reports of this type of crime.

Is the bar in sex crimes really anymore impossible than other crimes.

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 12:59

TheFriendlyPotato · 01/11/2026 11:33

There is a real issue here.

I am one for believing people are innocent. I have worked w serious offenders for decades and I still have that view. I do not want to live in a society where we assume someone is guilty because someone said they did something. That is an absolute horror show and opens society up to lawfare (accusing to get rid of people we dont like).

I do understand however that victims of crime feel incredibly let down when perps are deemed not guilty. Its horrific for those people, especially sexual assaults or families of those murdered.

I think that there is a tendency for people to get trial by aocial media though. If Russell Brand gets off his charge, he will still be seen as the rapey narcissist. That wont go away. Yes he wont go to prison, but social shunning and denigration is still very powerful. Look at Gary Glitter et al.

Its the best system we have and I cant think of a better version.

But no conviction is not the same as innocence. He’s openly admitted to lots of pretty predatory rape adjacent behaviours. He IS a sexual predator. There is no doubt about that. He’s very open about that. If he doesn’t get convicted for rape it’s is highly likely it will be just be because the evidence wasn’t enough for ‘beyond reasonable doubt’. So any extra negative consequences are deserved.

Surveys show that a very high proportion of women have been sexually assaulted. I have numerous times when I was younger. I didn’t report a single one. Most women have similar stories. I hope it’s improving the generations coming up after me. But those figures compared with the number of successful prosecutions mean that those unsuccessful prosecutions are likely to have been truthful victims. Very few women would put themselves through that just out of vengefulness.

Why do we as a society focus so much on protecting men from the very rare occasions they are falsely accused rather than holding them to account and ensuring that women are less at risk. Something isn’t right there and the words ‘generational impacts of patriarchy and misogyny’ come to mind.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:01

JHound · 01/11/2026 12:57

I believe actually being innocent of a crime and being innocent under the law are two different things (as OJ clearly demonstrated).

I think individuals can think what they like but I want the judicial system to see people as innocent unless the prosecution can clearly demonstrate otherwise.

I very much agree but I think for some crimes we can have a decent bit of faith in the justice system but for others the way the crime is dealt with is less deserving of public confidence.

Police services have improved vastly over time in terms with how they deal with the reporting of rape but the rest of the way of dealing with it within the justice system is still very problematic.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:03

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 12:59

But no conviction is not the same as innocence. He’s openly admitted to lots of pretty predatory rape adjacent behaviours. He IS a sexual predator. There is no doubt about that. He’s very open about that. If he doesn’t get convicted for rape it’s is highly likely it will be just be because the evidence wasn’t enough for ‘beyond reasonable doubt’. So any extra negative consequences are deserved.

Surveys show that a very high proportion of women have been sexually assaulted. I have numerous times when I was younger. I didn’t report a single one. Most women have similar stories. I hope it’s improving the generations coming up after me. But those figures compared with the number of successful prosecutions mean that those unsuccessful prosecutions are likely to have been truthful victims. Very few women would put themselves through that just out of vengefulness.

Why do we as a society focus so much on protecting men from the very rare occasions they are falsely accused rather than holding them to account and ensuring that women are less at risk. Something isn’t right there and the words ‘generational impacts of patriarchy and misogyny’ come to mind.

So well said and I’m very sorry about your experiences.

OP posts:
VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 13:03

JHound · 01/11/2026 12:59

Is the bar in sex crimes really anymore impossible than other crimes.

Yes, because often, whatever proof there is, can only prove sex happened, which is not a crime. Proving rape is the difficult bit. Mainly because everything goes as “defence” … what the victim was wearing, her underwear, how friendly she was, her past sexual history, she liked it rough and so on.

People don’t really get off other crimes with defences such as “i slipped and fell” as an explanation.

Fortuity · 01/11/2026 13:05

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:20

But what is happening now is men are raping women and children with almost no chance of prosecution. Are you happy with the current system or would you be happy for it to be changed at all?

If you are seriously saying that the system should change so that there is a presumption of guilt whenever an allegation of sexual assault is made then no, I'm not happy with that. I think it would be incredibly dangerous, and the start of a very slippery slope. Before you know it, that principle would start being extended to other offences, and we would be in something perilously close to a dictatorship.

Before you come up with false correlations, that absolutely does not mean that I am happy for rapists to get away with their crimes, just as I am not happy for violent thugs, murderers, robbers, thieves, fraudsters etc etc get away with their crimes either. I don't think that non-jury courts are the answer, and I suspect that over time technology will help - for example, in tying up reports of similar crimes, the availability of more CCTV and bodycam evidence, and more sophisticated use of DNA. If we ever manage to develop reliable lie detection equipment, that would be a major help. I don't have a magic wand, and I don't believe that removal of the presumption of innocence will remotely come clear to providing one.

scalt · 01/11/2026 13:07

We already have trial by Mumsnet. Lots of DHs have been sentenced to “LTB” before the opening speeches are even thought of.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:10

Fortuity · 01/11/2026 13:05

If you are seriously saying that the system should change so that there is a presumption of guilt whenever an allegation of sexual assault is made then no, I'm not happy with that. I think it would be incredibly dangerous, and the start of a very slippery slope. Before you know it, that principle would start being extended to other offences, and we would be in something perilously close to a dictatorship.

Before you come up with false correlations, that absolutely does not mean that I am happy for rapists to get away with their crimes, just as I am not happy for violent thugs, murderers, robbers, thieves, fraudsters etc etc get away with their crimes either. I don't think that non-jury courts are the answer, and I suspect that over time technology will help - for example, in tying up reports of similar crimes, the availability of more CCTV and bodycam evidence, and more sophisticated use of DNA. If we ever manage to develop reliable lie detection equipment, that would be a major help. I don't have a magic wand, and I don't believe that removal of the presumption of innocence will remotely come clear to providing one.

Yeah I agree with a lot of what you have written and you have some good suggestions.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 13:10

I think the law changed about 30 years ago so that if there was more than one allegation of CSA against someone it could be prosecuted with no evidence.

I do think that’s good and in situations like Brand - the fact that so many women have come forward should be used as evidence. As with the as yet unnamed celebrity case currently being discussed on another thread.

allthingsinmoderation · 01/11/2026 13:11

if a court finds a defendant not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of heinous alleged crimes should we judge them guilty or not?
How do we know if a person committed the crimes if a court finds them not guilty? Should we assume a person has committed the crimes if someone alleges they have ? Just point and shout witch Salem style?

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:11

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 13:10

I think the law changed about 30 years ago so that if there was more than one allegation of CSA against someone it could be prosecuted with no evidence.

I do think that’s good and in situations like Brand - the fact that so many women have come forward should be used as evidence. As with the as yet unnamed celebrity case currently being discussed on another thread.

That is a good thing but I think in individual cases patterns of behaviour which have been previously established (a previous guilty verdict) should be allowed too.

OP posts:
JHound · 01/11/2026 13:13

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 13:03

Yes, because often, whatever proof there is, can only prove sex happened, which is not a crime. Proving rape is the difficult bit. Mainly because everything goes as “defence” … what the victim was wearing, her underwear, how friendly she was, her past sexual history, she liked it rough and so on.

People don’t really get off other crimes with defences such as “i slipped and fell” as an explanation.

But that’s the same bar not an impossibly new one.

JHound · 01/11/2026 13:15

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:01

I very much agree but I think for some crimes we can have a decent bit of faith in the justice system but for others the way the crime is dealt with is less deserving of public confidence.

Police services have improved vastly over time in terms with how they deal with the reporting of rape but the rest of the way of dealing with it within the justice system is still very problematic.

I don’t really see what additional can be done without increasing the risk of innocent people being put behind bars.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:16

allthingsinmoderation · 01/11/2026 13:11

if a court finds a defendant not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of heinous alleged crimes should we judge them guilty or not?
How do we know if a person committed the crimes if a court finds them not guilty? Should we assume a person has committed the crimes if someone alleges they have ? Just point and shout witch Salem style?

A person commits the crime if they commit the crime not if they are found guilty though.

In sexual crimes particularly the chance of being found guilty of rape is vanishingly rare compared to the amount of rape committed so having the belief that a person is innocent of rape outside of the legal principle applied in the courtroom is what I questioning.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:17

JHound · 01/11/2026 13:15

I don’t really see what additional can be done without increasing the risk of innocent people being put behind bars.

There are lots of suggestions in other posts.

OP posts:
MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 13:20

I disagree with you and believe in innocent until proven guilty. Anyone can make false claims and completely ruin lives and reputations.

MissingMeadow · 01/11/2026 13:24

I don't know much about the Scottish system.

They have not proven? So if someone gets found innocent then it's more clear that they actually did not commit the crime?

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:24

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 13:20

I disagree with you and believe in innocent until proven guilty. Anyone can make false claims and completely ruin lives and reputations.

Do you think that no rape has ever been committed unless a person has been found guilty in court?

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:29

MissingMeadow · 01/11/2026 13:24

I don't know much about the Scottish system.

They have not proven? So if someone gets found innocent then it's more clear that they actually did not commit the crime?

I’d be very interested in seeing how the Scottish system applies too. I don’t know much about it either.

OP posts:
VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 13:39

JHound · 01/11/2026 13:13

But that’s the same bar not an impossibly new one.

Not quite. It is clearly shown by the fact that overall , most other crimes have higher charging/prosecution/conviction rates.

Let’s put it this way.

You go on a date and he drives off in your car. He can try and say you gave it to him, but you word that you didn’t and the fact that he’s in the possession of your car is enough. Plus no one is buying it anyway. He can’t use the fact that you left your keys on the table as consent.

Someone defrauds you. They can’t say that well , you regularly give money to other people. It doesn’t fly.

7 people come into your house and absolutely wreck it. They can’t say you like having your house trashed by multiple people at once.

Someone steals money out of your purse. They can say , well I slipped and fell and accidentally grabbed it and ran away with it, but that won’t fly.

And so on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread