Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:43

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 13:39

Not quite. It is clearly shown by the fact that overall , most other crimes have higher charging/prosecution/conviction rates.

Let’s put it this way.

You go on a date and he drives off in your car. He can try and say you gave it to him, but you word that you didn’t and the fact that he’s in the possession of your car is enough. Plus no one is buying it anyway. He can’t use the fact that you left your keys on the table as consent.

Someone defrauds you. They can’t say that well , you regularly give money to other people. It doesn’t fly.

7 people come into your house and absolutely wreck it. They can’t say you like having your house trashed by multiple people at once.

Someone steals money out of your purse. They can say , well I slipped and fell and accidentally grabbed it and ran away with it, but that won’t fly.

And so on.

Absolutely and that is why I believe we need to make changes to how rape cases are handled in comparison to other crimes. There are serious issues with allowing people to get away with raping with such regularity and these are largely coming from cultural assumptions around women and their propensity for making up rape accusations. You can see how much it has come up on this thread alone. It is a widely held belief.

OP posts:
Monty36 · 01/11/2026 13:53

What you are describing is a sort of mob rule.
Which existed before the laws were established.
Someone points a finger ‘ witch’ used to happen. And everyone believed it. And ‘locals’ decide the punishment. We cannot operate like that in 2026.
And ditto now.
The reason the death penalty was removed was because too many innocent people were hanged.
Miscarriages of justice occur.
You cannot decide without a court. People are entitled to a defence.
Imagine if someone pointed the finger at you for something you haven’t done ?

You can decide someone is guilty. People do. But a Court has to prove it.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:57

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 13:53

What you are describing is a sort of mob rule.
Which existed before the laws were established.
Someone points a finger ‘ witch’ used to happen. And everyone believed it. And ‘locals’ decide the punishment. We cannot operate like that in 2026.
And ditto now.
The reason the death penalty was removed was because too many innocent people were hanged.
Miscarriages of justice occur.
You cannot decide without a court. People are entitled to a defence.
Imagine if someone pointed the finger at you for something you haven’t done ?

You can decide someone is guilty. People do. But a Court has to prove it.

Edited

It really is not what I’m describing. That is your interpretation.

I’m describing a phenomenon that multiple women and men are commenting that a person is innocent until proven guilty of rape crimes in a context outside of a courtroom.

I find it hard to understand why people rush to that assumption given how low convictions for rape are.

OP posts:
Monty36 · 01/11/2026 13:59

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:57

It really is not what I’m describing. That is your interpretation.

I’m describing a phenomenon that multiple women and men are commenting that a person is innocent until proven guilty of rape crimes in a context outside of a courtroom.

I find it hard to understand why people rush to that assumption given how low convictions for rape are.

It is exactly what you are suggesting.
That most people accused will be guilty.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:03

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 13:59

It is exactly what you are suggesting.
That most people accused will be guilty.

Yes I suspect that is true that most people accused of rape are guilty of committing rape because I don’t think people make up phone theft, car theft, murder, rape allegations that much.

Do you think there are lots and lots of women making up rape allegations?

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 01/11/2026 14:08

I find it interesting that posters have essentially said that they are happy with trial by media.
Are these the same people that complained about Caroline Flack, Jason Arday and defended George Floyd?

Many procecutors have employed journalists to try and turn public opinion, Even the police have employed journalists.

There have also been groups of protestors outside of courts to try and sway the final judgement.

But with the onset of social media, it becomes very hard to control the narrative and hide information and evidence.

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:12

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:57

It really is not what I’m describing. That is your interpretation.

I’m describing a phenomenon that multiple women and men are commenting that a person is innocent until proven guilty of rape crimes in a context outside of a courtroom.

I find it hard to understand why people rush to that assumption given how low convictions for rape are.

“I’m describing a phenomenon that multiple women and men are commenting that a person is innocent until proven guilty of rape crimes in a context outside of a courtroom.”

I don’t think it’s a mystery. It’s used as a caution against jumping to conclusions when we quite simply do not know what may or may not have happened.

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 14:15

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:43

Absolutely and that is why I believe we need to make changes to how rape cases are handled in comparison to other crimes. There are serious issues with allowing people to get away with raping with such regularity and these are largely coming from cultural assumptions around women and their propensity for making up rape accusations. You can see how much it has come up on this thread alone. It is a widely held belief.

largely coming from cultural assumptions around women

I keep coming back to Brand's defence telling the court that if a woman invites a man into her hotel room, she must expect that sex may happen. (I don't have his exact words.) Lots of posters on that thread said the same.

On that particular occasion, she absolutely did not because she thought he was gay. But this type of defence astonishes me: it's basically a statement that all men are potential rapists and no woman should trust them. Same with all the other "You must have realised" defences - dancing with a man, drinking with a man, wearing a low-cut top ...

I bet no defence barrister has ever told a court "If a man wears a gold Rolex, he must expect a robbery may happen".

It goes hand-in-hand with the presumption of consent. Our legal system addressed this definitively several years ago: women are not in a constant state of availability, and consent must be explicit. Yet time and again, over and over, we hear stuff about blurred lines and arguments over 'reasonable belief' which start from the point of view that women are ready & willing unless they fiercely dissent.

Nobody assumes that a man with a gold Rolex is always ready to give it away!

TooBigForMyBoots · 01/11/2026 14:18

Years ago a child I know claimed to have been raped by his father. Turned out he had been raping all his sons. This man did not suddenly become guilty of rape when the court decided.

He was guilty of being a child rapist from the minute he first raped his eldest child.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:19

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 14:15

largely coming from cultural assumptions around women

I keep coming back to Brand's defence telling the court that if a woman invites a man into her hotel room, she must expect that sex may happen. (I don't have his exact words.) Lots of posters on that thread said the same.

On that particular occasion, she absolutely did not because she thought he was gay. But this type of defence astonishes me: it's basically a statement that all men are potential rapists and no woman should trust them. Same with all the other "You must have realised" defences - dancing with a man, drinking with a man, wearing a low-cut top ...

I bet no defence barrister has ever told a court "If a man wears a gold Rolex, he must expect a robbery may happen".

It goes hand-in-hand with the presumption of consent. Our legal system addressed this definitively several years ago: women are not in a constant state of availability, and consent must be explicit. Yet time and again, over and over, we hear stuff about blurred lines and arguments over 'reasonable belief' which start from the point of view that women are ready & willing unless they fiercely dissent.

Nobody assumes that a man with a gold Rolex is always ready to give it away!

I completely agree with you. I have avoided specifically mentioning Russell Brand because I’ve seen this as a much wider phenomenon and I don’t want to get bogged down in one case but yes I agree with everything you have said.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:20

TooBigForMyBoots · 01/11/2026 14:18

Years ago a child I know claimed to have been raped by his father. Turned out he had been raping all his sons. This man did not suddenly become guilty of rape when the court decided.

He was guilty of being a child rapist from the minute he first raped his eldest child.

Yes absolutely.

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 01/11/2026 14:22

everynowandthenifallapart · 31/10/2026 22:11

Nothing wrong with my reading comprehension, it’s an incoherent question.

it’s really not.

bababamama · 01/11/2026 14:25

Not all accusations are true, plenty of people are accused of crimes they didn’t commit for malicious reasons. Everyone is innocent until proven otherwise HOWEVER where appropriate I think keeping people on remand or strict house arrest should be used more. In many cases it isn’t actually as black and white but gossiping online can prejudice the trial. The old saying that there is no smoke without fire often does hold but we need to let the legal system to their work.

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 14:28

FrippEnos · 01/11/2026 14:08

I find it interesting that posters have essentially said that they are happy with trial by media.
Are these the same people that complained about Caroline Flack, Jason Arday and defended George Floyd?

Many procecutors have employed journalists to try and turn public opinion, Even the police have employed journalists.

There have also been groups of protestors outside of courts to try and sway the final judgement.

But with the onset of social media, it becomes very hard to control the narrative and hide information and evidence.

Let’s put it this way. Someone tells you the tutor you chose for your daughter is/might be a predator. Do you go “oh well innocent until proven guilty” and hope for the best or do you find another tutor?

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:28

bababamama · 01/11/2026 14:25

Not all accusations are true, plenty of people are accused of crimes they didn’t commit for malicious reasons. Everyone is innocent until proven otherwise HOWEVER where appropriate I think keeping people on remand or strict house arrest should be used more. In many cases it isn’t actually as black and white but gossiping online can prejudice the trial. The old saying that there is no smoke without fire often does hold but we need to let the legal system to their work.

Edited

I believe that rape has very specific cultural issues that make prosecution so much harder to achieve that need to be tackled much better within the criminal justice system.

I also believe these culture issues play out and are amplified by social media whereby women are constantly and consistently accused of lying about rape and the man is “innocent until proven guilty” in that domain as well as courtroom.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:32

JHound · 01/11/2026 13:15

I don’t really see what additional can be done without increasing the risk of innocent people being put behind bars.

That is a risk but balance that against the swathes of women managing post trauma symptoms from sexual assault - all those men getting off Scott free to keep doing it. Often in plain sight. We need to redress the balance. We can’t keep protecting men from the very rare and tiny risk of false allegation at the expense of women.

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:34

And those men that are particularly worried about false allegations can;

  • try not to be too flirtatious
  • think carefully before spending time with a woman on their own.
  • try and have a friend with them when out.
  • not get too drunk etc.
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:36

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:32

That is a risk but balance that against the swathes of women managing post trauma symptoms from sexual assault - all those men getting off Scott free to keep doing it. Often in plain sight. We need to redress the balance. We can’t keep protecting men from the very rare and tiny risk of false allegation at the expense of women.

Thank you so well said. I think there are many changes that could be made to redress this balance but there are many, many people invested in preserving the system as it is.

Institutions have required women and children to overcome extraordinary obstacles to prove that they have been harmed. Meanwhile, the people responsible have benefited from secrecy, social status, institutional protection, and the difficulty of producing evidence of crimes committed in private.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 14:37

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:34

And those men that are particularly worried about false allegations can;

  • try not to be too flirtatious
  • think carefully before spending time with a woman on their own.
  • try and have a friend with them when out.
  • not get too drunk etc.
Edited

Indeed. They should give one of these to each juror in a sex-related case.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty
InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:38

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:32

That is a risk but balance that against the swathes of women managing post trauma symptoms from sexual assault - all those men getting off Scott free to keep doing it. Often in plain sight. We need to redress the balance. We can’t keep protecting men from the very rare and tiny risk of false allegation at the expense of women.

It’s a sacrifice it’s easy to be willing to make when you believe it won’t impact you.

Fortunately that is not the principle the law is based upon.

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:39

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:36

Thank you so well said. I think there are many changes that could be made to redress this balance but there are many, many people invested in preserving the system as it is.

Institutions have required women and children to overcome extraordinary obstacles to prove that they have been harmed. Meanwhile, the people responsible have benefited from secrecy, social status, institutional protection, and the difficulty of producing evidence of crimes committed in private.

Did you see that Royal College of Psychiatry apologised recently for their part in how victims of CSA have been treated? It’s a step forward.

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:41

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:38

It’s a sacrifice it’s easy to be willing to make when you believe it won’t impact you.

Fortunately that is not the principle the law is based upon.

But women and children live with the risk of sexual assault constantly. Why is that risk acceptable to society but slightly increasing the currently minuscule risk of wrongful conviction isn’t?

I have a teenage son so I have skin in the game in that sense.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:41

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:38

It’s a sacrifice it’s easy to be willing to make when you believe it won’t impact you.

Fortunately that is not the principle the law is based upon.

You are correct the mainly men who commit rape and sexual assault would have to be concerned about perhaps getting caught if the culture changes around rape. It will be a serious concern for the rapists.

OP posts:
Tryagain26 · 01/11/2026 14:45

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 22:57

But surely if you commit a crime you are guilty of commiting that crime even if a court finds you not guilty?

Yes of course but what other system do you suggest we have?
You can't have a system where everyone accused is always presumed guilty regardless of the evidence.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:46

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:41

But women and children live with the risk of sexual assault constantly. Why is that risk acceptable to society but slightly increasing the currently minuscule risk of wrongful conviction isn’t?

I have a teenage son so I have skin in the game in that sense.

Yes and this culture really affects male victims too. It is all about protecting powerful predatory men.

OP posts: