Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:46

Tryagain26 · 01/11/2026 14:45

Yes of course but what other system do you suggest we have?
You can't have a system where everyone accused is always presumed guilty regardless of the evidence.

That has been addressed in the comments quite a bit.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:47

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:41

But women and children live with the risk of sexual assault constantly. Why is that risk acceptable to society but slightly increasing the currently minuscule risk of wrongful conviction isn’t?

I have a teenage son so I have skin in the game in that sense.

Blackstone’s principle. Because it is the standard of a free and fair legal system that protects the fundamental rights of each individual.

The lowering of the burden of proof would undermine the very foundations of English Common Law, and would be a dangerous precedent to set. It is too great a price to pay.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:52

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:47

Blackstone’s principle. Because it is the standard of a free and fair legal system that protects the fundamental rights of each individual.

The lowering of the burden of proof would undermine the very foundations of English Common Law, and would be a dangerous precedent to set. It is too great a price to pay.

I am an engineer we tend to look at systems and where there are flaws we work them out. We don’t see anything as needing to remain exactly as is especially if it is demonstrably not working.

You seem to be very wedded to maintaining a failed system as is.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 14:54

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:47

Blackstone’s principle. Because it is the standard of a free and fair legal system that protects the fundamental rights of each individual.

The lowering of the burden of proof would undermine the very foundations of English Common Law, and would be a dangerous precedent to set. It is too great a price to pay.

But the law was changed relatively recently around CSA - with more than one person disclosing the need for physical evidence reduces I think.

I think sexual assault is a special case and it would be possible to make tweaks that redress the balance without going too far the other way.

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 14:55

Tryagain26 · 01/11/2026 14:45

Yes of course but what other system do you suggest we have?
You can't have a system where everyone accused is always presumed guilty regardless of the evidence.

No but we could have a system where a lot of superflous and sometimes absolutely bonkers “evidence “ doesn’t matter . Where ridiculous defences shouldn’t be accepted. Where the victim isn’t the one that actually ends up being on trial. We know things can change, even if painfully slowly. Rough sex or rough sex gone wrong can’t be used as a defence anymore, even if in practice people are still catching up. Isn’t it mind boggling though that it was ever accepted and it took a lit of time, work, effort and campaigning to get here? But we did, just like raping your wife DID eventually become a crime. Just shrugging our shoulders and saying “oh well what can we do” isn’t enough. It doesn’t change anything.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:56

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 14:55

No but we could have a system where a lot of superflous and sometimes absolutely bonkers “evidence “ doesn’t matter . Where ridiculous defences shouldn’t be accepted. Where the victim isn’t the one that actually ends up being on trial. We know things can change, even if painfully slowly. Rough sex or rough sex gone wrong can’t be used as a defence anymore, even if in practice people are still catching up. Isn’t it mind boggling though that it was ever accepted and it took a lit of time, work, effort and campaigning to get here? But we did, just like raping your wife DID eventually become a crime. Just shrugging our shoulders and saying “oh well what can we do” isn’t enough. It doesn’t change anything.

Well said.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 14:59

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:52

I am an engineer we tend to look at systems and where there are flaws we work them out. We don’t see anything as needing to remain exactly as is especially if it is demonstrably not working.

You seem to be very wedded to maintaining a failed system as is.

Not at all. I do not believe in lowering the burden of proof and sacrificing the very values a free legal system is built upon.

That does not mean I do not think the system could be improved.

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 15:41

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 14:03

Yes I suspect that is true that most people accused of rape are guilty of committing rape because I don’t think people make up phone theft, car theft, murder, rape allegations that much.

Do you think there are lots and lots of women making up rape allegations?

Edited

Listen to yourself.
You cannot go around deciding someone who has been accused is guilty without a trial.
Not here anyway. Thankfully. And long may that remain.
Even if you have, yourself, the deepest suspicions they are. That sort of thinking leads to disorder, innocent people being harmed and killed.
There are plenty of examples of people accused by someone of being a paedophile, their home and belongings trashed, the person themselves hounded out or worse. Then everyone discovers they were innocent after all. “Sorry’. Not good enough.
If there are issues about women not reporting rape then that is something else. That needs exploring and attending to.
Your guilty before proven innocent is not okay. And long may it remain. I have no wish to see this country go backwards in time.

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 15:42

I do believe in a jury system as well. Not some archaic judge only.

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 15:44

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 13:24

Do you think that no rape has ever been committed unless a person has been found guilty in court?

No I don't think that.

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 15:47

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 15:41

Listen to yourself.
You cannot go around deciding someone who has been accused is guilty without a trial.
Not here anyway. Thankfully. And long may that remain.
Even if you have, yourself, the deepest suspicions they are. That sort of thinking leads to disorder, innocent people being harmed and killed.
There are plenty of examples of people accused by someone of being a paedophile, their home and belongings trashed, the person themselves hounded out or worse. Then everyone discovers they were innocent after all. “Sorry’. Not good enough.
If there are issues about women not reporting rape then that is something else. That needs exploring and attending to.
Your guilty before proven innocent is not okay. And long may it remain. I have no wish to see this country go backwards in time.

Well said.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 15:53

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 15:41

Listen to yourself.
You cannot go around deciding someone who has been accused is guilty without a trial.
Not here anyway. Thankfully. And long may that remain.
Even if you have, yourself, the deepest suspicions they are. That sort of thinking leads to disorder, innocent people being harmed and killed.
There are plenty of examples of people accused by someone of being a paedophile, their home and belongings trashed, the person themselves hounded out or worse. Then everyone discovers they were innocent after all. “Sorry’. Not good enough.
If there are issues about women not reporting rape then that is something else. That needs exploring and attending to.
Your guilty before proven innocent is not okay. And long may it remain. I have no wish to see this country go backwards in time.

I don’t think you’ve engaged with what I have said in the thread but thanks for your thoughts. You’ve made assumptions and added your own understanding of what I’ve said which is fine that is for you to do.

Again I think if a person committed a crime then they are guilty and in particular if they have committed sexual crimes which are notoriously failed by our criminal justice system then random commentators saying on social media or in newspaper comment sections that they are innocent unless proven guilty is taking a legal principle out of context.

I largely agree with your other views fwiw.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:00

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 15:42

I do believe in a jury system as well. Not some archaic judge only.

Edited

These are not archaic they are in use elsewhere in Europe, in Ireland for example, they were used to protect the UK by putting IRA members behind bars and more recently are still in use to prevent intimidation of jurors from organised criminals.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:05

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 15:44

No I don't think that.

Would you say you are inclined to believe women who report rape in the same way you believe a person who says they were mugged or their house was broken into?

There is a particularly good explanation for the mugging example up thread. What did you think when you read that example?

There have been plenty of posters who believe women routinely lie about sexual assault, that is a significant part of the cultural problem around rape allegation and prosecution.

OP posts:
Boomer55 · 01/11/2026 16:07

Over here, unless convicted by a jury, everyone is considered innocent.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:08

Boomer55 · 01/11/2026 16:07

Over here, unless convicted by a jury, everyone is considered innocent.

In a court, yes.

If they did the crime they are still guilty of it, no? they just got away with it no?

OP posts:
Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 16:12

LauderSyme · 31/10/2026 21:50

YANBU. Legally, within the criminal justice system, a person is innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

However, within our lived experiences, our cultural norms and our wider society - all
informed by the oppression of actual misogynistic violence or our awareness of it's potentiality - it is impossible to mistake "innocence" for absence of guilt.

They are not innocent until proven guilty - rather the principal that they should be treated “as if”
innocent” is what is applied - for example, they aren’t magically transformed into being innocent for the court room if they are in fact guilty

Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 16:14

Boomer55 · 01/11/2026 16:07

Over here, unless convicted by a jury, everyone is considered innocent.

No they are not - they are treated “as if” innocent for the purpose of the trial

the outcome the jury give is guilty or not guilty - no one is declared innocent - not guilty means the prosecution didn’t reach the threshold of evidence at the time

Itsasecretnow · 01/11/2026 16:14

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 15:53

I don’t think you’ve engaged with what I have said in the thread but thanks for your thoughts. You’ve made assumptions and added your own understanding of what I’ve said which is fine that is for you to do.

Again I think if a person committed a crime then they are guilty and in particular if they have committed sexual crimes which are notoriously failed by our criminal justice system then random commentators saying on social media or in newspaper comment sections that they are innocent unless proven guilty is taking a legal principle out of context.

I largely agree with your other views fwiw.

Isn’t it something like roughly only 2% even get to trial in the first place (sexual assault/rape) and even fewer of those return a guilty verdict? Possibly slightly out of date stats, but it’s a disturbingly low number anyway. And absolutely the other 98% of women are definitely not making it up, so I totally understand what op is getting at here.
Of course we need the justice and court system, but it is absolutely not up to scratch as far as violence against women is concerned, so it’s not that far off to think most men might be more likely to be guilty than innocent. That doesn’t mean I’m encouraging vigilantism though, but it is generally quite normal for someone to have their own thoughts and opinions as to whether they think someone is guilty of something.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:19

Itsasecretnow · 01/11/2026 16:14

Isn’t it something like roughly only 2% even get to trial in the first place (sexual assault/rape) and even fewer of those return a guilty verdict? Possibly slightly out of date stats, but it’s a disturbingly low number anyway. And absolutely the other 98% of women are definitely not making it up, so I totally understand what op is getting at here.
Of course we need the justice and court system, but it is absolutely not up to scratch as far as violence against women is concerned, so it’s not that far off to think most men might be more likely to be guilty than innocent. That doesn’t mean I’m encouraging vigilantism though, but it is generally quite normal for someone to have their own thoughts and opinions as to whether they think someone is guilty of something.

Thank you so well said and I completely agree with you.

OP posts:
Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 16:21

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:08

In a court, yes.

If they did the crime they are still guilty of it, no? they just got away with it no?

Yes they are guilty the moment they commit the crime not when a court process is applied to the person

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:32

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 16:05

Would you say you are inclined to believe women who report rape in the same way you believe a person who says they were mugged or their house was broken into?

There is a particularly good explanation for the mugging example up thread. What did you think when you read that example?

There have been plenty of posters who believe women routinely lie about sexual assault, that is a significant part of the cultural problem around rape allegation and prosecution.

Edited

Im not sure. I think there has been other crimes in the history of mankind though that have been fabricated! Its not unknown that humans can be liars and can be toxic and can enjoy ruining other people's lives by making things up. I mean if someone reported their house being burgled but the was no evidence of breaking in or nothing missing they would probably be accused of making it up no?

GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 16:35

Monty36 · 01/11/2026 15:41

Listen to yourself.
You cannot go around deciding someone who has been accused is guilty without a trial.
Not here anyway. Thankfully. And long may that remain.
Even if you have, yourself, the deepest suspicions they are. That sort of thinking leads to disorder, innocent people being harmed and killed.
There are plenty of examples of people accused by someone of being a paedophile, their home and belongings trashed, the person themselves hounded out or worse. Then everyone discovers they were innocent after all. “Sorry’. Not good enough.
If there are issues about women not reporting rape then that is something else. That needs exploring and attending to.
Your guilty before proven innocent is not okay. And long may it remain. I have no wish to see this country go backwards in time.

It’s not either or though.

It doesn’t have to be guilty until proven innocent. That’s just doing the opposite.

There are tweaks that can be made based on solid research that will mean more sexual assaults get prosecuted.

Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 16:36

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:32

Im not sure. I think there has been other crimes in the history of mankind though that have been fabricated! Its not unknown that humans can be liars and can be toxic and can enjoy ruining other people's lives by making things up. I mean if someone reported their house being burgled but the was no evidence of breaking in or nothing missing they would probably be accused of making it up no?

So 6 women independent of each other all thought “I’m going to make something up”
and subsequently put themselves through the most arduous and painful court process of giving evidence

MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 16:46

Tinydanceer · 01/11/2026 16:36

So 6 women independent of each other all thought “I’m going to make something up”
and subsequently put themselves through the most arduous and painful court process of giving evidence

I don't know what 6 women you are referring to i didn't know this was about a specific case im just responding to the original OP AIBU.

Swipe left for the next trending thread