Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
NotAnotherScarf · 31/10/2026 23:01

Strangely ive recently changed pubs i drink in. Im a bloke. There was a guy in there who was up for rape...i refused to speak to him and just listened when it was discussed.

Refreshingly the view was wait for the jury but feel for his partner.

He got 8. So he really was a despicable cunt. And thats the pubs view. He won't be welcome back. Thats for sure

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:02

JLou08 · 31/10/2026 22:59

How does anyone know they're guilty if it isn't proven in a court of law?

If you have commited the crime and you lie then you are still guilty of committing the crime?

Almost all people who are defending a case in a courtroom who have actually committed the crime lie, surely, unless they plead guilty.

There is a separate legal code and moral code.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:04

NotAnotherScarf · 31/10/2026 23:01

Strangely ive recently changed pubs i drink in. Im a bloke. There was a guy in there who was up for rape...i refused to speak to him and just listened when it was discussed.

Refreshingly the view was wait for the jury but feel for his partner.

He got 8. So he really was a despicable cunt. And thats the pubs view. He won't be welcome back. Thats for sure

I’m pretty impressed with you doing that. Were other men of the same view or would they have felt he had to be prosecuted before they could decide?

OP posts:
LauderSyme · 31/10/2026 23:04

JLou08 · 31/10/2026 22:59

How does anyone know they're guilty if it isn't proven in a court of law?

The woman who was raped knows.

The problem is that we as a society have created a system which dismisses her experience.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:05

LauderSyme · 31/10/2026 23:04

The woman who was raped knows.

The problem is that we as a society have created a system which dismisses her experience.

Absolutely.

OP posts:
sprigatito · 31/10/2026 23:07

LauderSyme · 31/10/2026 23:04

The woman who was raped knows.

The problem is that we as a society have created a system which dismisses her experience.

Quite. It’s disturbing to think that there are millions of women out there who know they have been raped, who live with the memory and carry the trauma of a crime that “technically didn’t happen” according to society, because it wasn’t rubber-stamped by a patriarchal justice system. Sickening, actually.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:09

sprigatito · 31/10/2026 23:07

Quite. It’s disturbing to think that there are millions of women out there who know they have been raped, who live with the memory and carry the trauma of a crime that “technically didn’t happen” according to society, because it wasn’t rubber-stamped by a patriarchal justice system. Sickening, actually.

Yes I could not agree more. I have been reading a specific tonight and honestly it is quite sickening to read the comment underneath it. We have a long, long way to go.

OP posts:
RufustheFestiveReindeer · 31/10/2026 23:11

I have a friend who was completely convinced that if someone was found not guilty in a court of law it means that they deffo did not commit the crime 😳

LuckyHazelFox · 31/10/2026 23:13

I've often been led on a guilty until proven innocent basis, if I'm using women's intuition.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:14

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 31/10/2026 23:11

I have a friend who was completely convinced that if someone was found not guilty in a court of law it means that they deffo did not commit the crime 😳

Honestly nothing in life surprises me. There are plenty who still believe the man when he is found guilty too.

OP posts:
IPeggedABandana · 31/10/2026 23:14

Frustratingly it isn't necessarily that the man didn't do it, but that it cannot be proven beyond reasonable doubt that he did.

I know of 2 cases where he definitely did it but was found not guilty because the prosecution/police did an absolutely abysmal job of evidence gathering.

I'm happy to reserve judgement in cases where I have no idea either way but someone being found nor guilty is not necessarily the get out of jail free card everyone thinks it is.

NotAnotherScarf · 31/10/2026 23:15

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:04

I’m pretty impressed with you doing that. Were other men of the same view or would they have felt he had to be prosecuted before they could decide?

Prosecuted. Because he span a good yarn. I didn't here it so not influenced. But I got the impression he was held at arms length. But his partner was a local girl so she had more respect/acknowledgement/status/friends if that makes sense...i just felt he was "wrong " before I heard the story

Crosspatchmum · 31/10/2026 23:17

Fred West and Jimmy Saville were never found guilty for many crimes. Hardly makes them innocent.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:17

NotAnotherScarf · 31/10/2026 23:15

Prosecuted. Because he span a good yarn. I didn't here it so not influenced. But I got the impression he was held at arms length. But his partner was a local girl so she had more respect/acknowledgement/status/friends if that makes sense...i just felt he was "wrong " before I heard the story

I think the yarn spinning is all part of their modus operandi unfortunately.

OP posts:
mumumental · 31/10/2026 23:24

I’m sick of all sorts of people being tried by social media. It’s especially stupid when the bloody case is in court. I sometimes wonder whether some people are just trying to get it dismissed. Why on earth would anyone else do this?

Crushed23 · 31/10/2026 23:25

JLou08 · 31/10/2026 22:38

I believe it's rare, but some people do lie. A false accusation of sexual crimes absolutely destroys someone, even without them being seen as innocent until proven guilty in the eyes of the law.
I think when we're talking about someone with multiple accusations from people who have no connection to each other common sense says they're guilty. But for one accusation I think innocent until proven guilty is the right way to go about things.

I don’t think it’s rare for people to lie. I have lived a life completely removed from crime thankfully and even I know someone who lied in court. She completely made up claims of domestic violence in order to get a Green Card. There is a special category for abused women so she didn’t have to stay married to the person she used to get a GC and could live with her boyfriend and have his baby (leaving her ‘husband’ and having another man’s baby would have meant her GC application getting declined). She completely destroyed the man’s reputation and sent his mental health spiralling. This is an otherwise ‘normal’, law-abiding citizen with a good job and who is now a mother. So no, I wouldn’t say lying in a court of law is rare at all.

Fortuity · 31/10/2026 23:32

You seem to be mistaking what "presumed innocent" means. Of course in objective terms a criminal is guilty as soon as they have committed the crime, but they are presumed innocent until they have been convicted because that is the only way to give fair trial and avoid miscarriages of justice as far as possible.

Far too often when someone is arrested by the police a load of people start assuming they must be guilty even before any charge is made. There has to be some control over that, otherwise we risk causing irreparable damage to innocent people and allowing the guilty to go free. Joanna Yeates' murder is a classic example.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:34

Crushed23 · 31/10/2026 23:25

I don’t think it’s rare for people to lie. I have lived a life completely removed from crime thankfully and even I know someone who lied in court. She completely made up claims of domestic violence in order to get a Green Card. There is a special category for abused women so she didn’t have to stay married to the person she used to get a GC and could live with her boyfriend and have his baby (leaving her ‘husband’ and having another man’s baby would have meant her GC application getting declined). She completely destroyed the man’s reputation and sent his mental health spiralling. This is an otherwise ‘normal’, law-abiding citizen with a good job and who is now a mother. So no, I wouldn’t say lying in a court of law is rare at all.

I absolutely agree but I do think the lying usually goes in the other direction in court cases. Someone who wants to get away with a crime lies through their teeth,

Journalists noticed that Jeffery Donaldson was busy writing his press statement, the one he still believed he would be making having being found not guilty, in the courtroom before he was found guilty of raping those two young girls.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:38

Fortuity · 31/10/2026 23:32

You seem to be mistaking what "presumed innocent" means. Of course in objective terms a criminal is guilty as soon as they have committed the crime, but they are presumed innocent until they have been convicted because that is the only way to give fair trial and avoid miscarriages of justice as far as possible.

Far too often when someone is arrested by the police a load of people start assuming they must be guilty even before any charge is made. There has to be some control over that, otherwise we risk causing irreparable damage to innocent people and allowing the guilty to go free. Joanna Yeates' murder is a classic example.

I don’t think I am misunderstanding “presumed innocent” I just think the concept really only belong in a courtroom but it gets extrapolated into the wider community. I mean the police for example don’t presume innocent or they would not charge anyone with a crime, the CPS does not presume innocence or they would not expect the trial to be in the public interest but yet the wider public have pulled a legal presumption into a domain beyond the court where it belongs.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 31/10/2026 23:40

JLou08 · 31/10/2026 22:38

I believe it's rare, but some people do lie. A false accusation of sexual crimes absolutely destroys someone, even without them being seen as innocent until proven guilty in the eyes of the law.
I think when we're talking about someone with multiple accusations from people who have no connection to each other common sense says they're guilty. But for one accusation I think innocent until proven guilty is the right way to go about things.

I wish we could stop this lie. Men found guilty or found to be rapists or domestic abusers by balance of probabilities are currently film stars and oscar winners and presidents and music stars and sports stars and on and on.

Even being found by a court to be a danger to women doesn't ruin lives, let alone an accusation.

Men are more likely to be raped themselves than falsely accused.

Fortuity · 31/10/2026 23:42

sprigatito · 31/10/2026 23:07

Quite. It’s disturbing to think that there are millions of women out there who know they have been raped, who live with the memory and carry the trauma of a crime that “technically didn’t happen” according to society, because it wasn’t rubber-stamped by a patriarchal justice system. Sickening, actually.

The fact that no-one has been convicted of a crime clearly doesn't mean that technically it didn't happen, and no-one actually believes that to be the case. No-one would claim that Suzy Lamplugh or Rose Johnston were not murdered, for instance; I don't think it's in any way helpful to suggest that rape cases re any different.

Heyhoherewego23 · 31/10/2026 23:44

But what about situations where it’s impossible to know the truth. I experienced this (no evidence) I experienced this (also no evidence). Would you automatically convict the man as this was statistically more likely? That is insane to label someone a rapist unsubstantiated.

LBFseBrom · 31/10/2026 23:44

Everyone is entitled to a fair trial and there have to be boundaries. If there is insufficient evidence, it's possible for someone to get away with a crime - on that occasion - but the law keeps an eye on people when there is a strong possibility of them being guilty.

That applies to all crimes, not just violent or sexual. Let's not get bogged down by the nasties.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:45

Fortuity · 31/10/2026 23:42

The fact that no-one has been convicted of a crime clearly doesn't mean that technically it didn't happen, and no-one actually believes that to be the case. No-one would claim that Suzy Lamplugh or Rose Johnston were not murdered, for instance; I don't think it's in any way helpful to suggest that rape cases re any different.

But rape trials and murder trials are not remotely conducted in the same way. The dead body means a person is dead, a contested rape trial is always conducted the same way by the defence, always, with the assumption that the rape did not happen.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 31/10/2026 23:45

Legally, the presumption of innocent is a foundational principle. The burden of proof has to be on the state.

Does it mean that someone found not guilty didn’t commit the crime of which they were accused? No, of course not. If you suspect someone is guilty then you are free to have that opinion, think poorly of them, and distance yourself socially.

If an allegation is made against someone, I do not blindly trust it. Evidence matters. I may have opinions based on what information is available to me.