Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 06:32

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 06:22

Reading your second paragraph, I do believe you understand the difference between 'not guilty in law' and 'innocent'. Nobody is ever found innocent in court, they can only be proved guilty / not guilty in the legal sense.

Unlike Scotland, we don't have a verdict of 'not proven' but it is the same thing. It feels different because of the way our language works - the opposite of guilty is innocent, so we intuitively hear 'not guilty' that way. The law's precise, though, not intuitive. Not guilty ONLY means not guilty - much as 'not hungry' doesn't mean full up.

As @Dimdam remarks, our judicial system only deals in law. Morals and human justice ideally come into it, but they don't if law isn't applied that way. Sometimes it actually can't be. In the UK, we have a very ancient and continually updated body of law - it's pretty responsive compared to other systems - but this does rely on all sides having equal access & knowledge, which often isn't the case. (I once got convicted of a small crime; years later, I realised I wasn't guilty in law but had a shit solicitor).

I'm not sure our adversarial system is the best way of administering the law. Other European countries use different systems, but they also have their weaknesses.

There is often a chasm between a verdict of 'not guilty' and the everyday meaning of 'innocent'.

And everyday discussion of someone's likely guilt (eg Russell Brand) shouldn't be constrained to legal definitions. There's something called the balance of probabilities: we use it all the time in making decisions, from whether to take an umbrella to financing a house purchase. This is what we should be discussing.

I sure as hell wouldn't encourage the young women in my life to be alone with Messrs Brand or Walliams. Don't need to wait for a court to tell me.

i agree that we make our decisions about whether we think or believe a crime has been committed - but that also applies to individuals where there has been no police action. For exampke we might have a feeling about an individual we can’t quite explain which may or may not be valid and that is our choice. Avoiding an individual is very different to character assignation in the press, on social media or even local gossip.

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 06:43

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 06:32

i agree that we make our decisions about whether we think or believe a crime has been committed - but that also applies to individuals where there has been no police action. For exampke we might have a feeling about an individual we can’t quite explain which may or may not be valid and that is our choice. Avoiding an individual is very different to character assignation in the press, on social media or even local gossip.

Balance of probabilities. I'm fairly confident that a man who's on video saying he pretends to be gay in order to gain women's trust - and then, in his own words, 'Bam! Pregnant! Bam! Pregnant! Bam, Pregnant!' - pretended to be gay in order to rape a young woman. Looking and listening to many things he's said in public, such as he'll shag any woman 'aged 16 to death' and writes his autograph in semen on the inside of women's uteruses, I see him as very much a sexual predator.

Jimmy Savile was equally open about his predatory activities. People kept protesting he'd never been found guilty of anything like that. They should've looked at the balance of probabilities.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 01/11/2026 06:49

My English teacher at school once pointed out that not guilty isn't the same as innocent. Such an important distinction.

TheignT · 01/11/2026 06:57

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 02:53

*My belief system is English Common Law, in which burden of proof is an integral concept that protects the rights of the individual.

I do not believe lowering the burden of proof is a price worth paying for increased conviction rates.*

So you are happy for rapists act with impunity because you see the current system as having no scope for improvement.

To me this response is extremely male centric because of the link of men being perpetrators of any crime but obviously specifically sexual crimes and it is not very protective of victims of crime particularly women and children.

Edited

So you've educated us all about how flawed the system is. Well done but that's the easy bit, now tell us how you think the system should be, you know a system where no one lies, where no one gets away with anything and no innocent person gets accused let alone convicted. That would be really interesting.

Mapletree1985 · 01/11/2026 07:03

How can we do better? A legal system set up to ensure that the guilty were always punished and the innocent was always exonerated - what would that look like?

Strawberrryfields · 01/11/2026 07:13

But I feel like most people do judge those accused of sexual crimes whether they’re found guilty or not? Surely the stakes are too high not to?

This might include a small number who’ve been wrongly accused but I don’t think you can erase even a seed of doubt once you’ve heard it. It’s shit for those who are wrongly accused because you can’t unhear it and it does change how people will look at/ treat you.

Whats the solution to any of this? I can’t think of a way round it if the evidence isn’t there that a crime has been committed? Even if it has. On an individual level we can believe what we want? We also can’t stop people saying a crime has been committed if it hasn’t? I don’t really get where you’re going with this.

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 07:25

Mapletree1985 · 01/11/2026 07:03

How can we do better? A legal system set up to ensure that the guilty were always punished and the innocent was always exonerated - what would that look like?

Maybe we should have experts in court - not acting for one side or the other, but furnishing juries and judges with insight on, for example, the meaning of consent and typical responses to traumatic threat. This would be useful in all areas of law, I should think - so many factors come into play from professional environments, through social & cultural considerations, to mental illness and the like (and more!) These issues are left to the two opponents to use & abuse as they see fit. Perhaps they shouldn't be.

Maybe a defendant's previous convictions should be made known to the court. May even charges they have faced but that were dropped.

Maybe the court should be told if a plaintiff has a prolific history of similar complaints. Maybe their previous convictions should be known as well.

I'm sure there's more. These are just things I've often thought when following trials. I mean, Judge Judy would not be fair process in real law, but there's quite a bit we could learn from it!

itsgettingweird · 01/11/2026 07:29

I don’t think you can apply the rule “insolvent until proven guilty” universally because there is many people arrested at the scene of the crime who have been witnessed committing the crime and still holding the murder weapon.

They aren’t innocent until a jury proves them guilty.

With other crime - non witnessed crime- I make personal judgements based on what I see and hear. Sexual and violent crime are more difficult to judge. But that doesn’t mean I think someone’s innocent because it wasn’t proven in a court of law they weren’t.

Other times I do wonder. However I also think no one puts themselves through a court case for fun and there’s no smoke without fire.

On the flip side though there are cases where people do make false accusations.

It’s an extremely complex topic and system.

HylianShroom · 01/11/2026 07:32

sprigatito · 31/10/2026 21:53

i don’t allow anyone to dictate how or when I use my own reasoning faculties. The evidentiary standard for a court case has nothing whatsoever to do with it.

Absolutely this. And it goes both ways, as in people who’ve been found guilty of a crime doesn’t mean they did it. Think of all the mothers convicted of killing their babies when it turned out it was SIDS or other factors. A court’s judgement means very little to me. People put too much faith in the system.

Strawberrryfields · 01/11/2026 07:37

HylianShroom · 01/11/2026 07:32

Absolutely this. And it goes both ways, as in people who’ve been found guilty of a crime doesn’t mean they did it. Think of all the mothers convicted of killing their babies when it turned out it was SIDS or other factors. A court’s judgement means very little to me. People put too much faith in the system.

Would you still report a crime that was committed against you?

Ethelspagetti · 01/11/2026 07:45

JLou08 · 31/10/2026 22:38

I believe it's rare, but some people do lie. A false accusation of sexual crimes absolutely destroys someone, even without them being seen as innocent until proven guilty in the eyes of the law.
I think when we're talking about someone with multiple accusations from people who have no connection to each other common sense says they're guilty. But for one accusation I think innocent until proven guilty is the right way to go about things.

Yes I have heard of people being taken to court over a lie which was exposed in court. Some people do lie out of revenge, because someone told them to, mistaken identity, to redirect blame etc. Most of it is caught before court but some make it through.

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 08:08

There is a difference between avoidance and care around someone you believe to have committed crime whether they have been prosecuted or not ti active character assassination. We can choose how to deal with somone on a personal level and if we feel uneasy or think on balance the risk association is too great then that is our choice. I believe that is very different to character assignation in the press, online or in person and think individuals famous or not should not be subjected to this, some may be guilty be “on the balance of probability” most will not be.

ThisMauveExpert · 01/11/2026 08:14

A young man i was very close to, was falsely and maliciously accused of rape. He committed suicide due to the social oatracisation and bullying he received from his peers due to it. The young lady who accused him retracted her statement a full 8 months before he took his own life, but the police never told him. They've admitted failings in this matter and have pledged to do better in future.

DrEllisGrey · 01/11/2026 08:58

ThisMauveExpert · 01/11/2026 08:14

A young man i was very close to, was falsely and maliciously accused of rape. He committed suicide due to the social oatracisation and bullying he received from his peers due to it. The young lady who accused him retracted her statement a full 8 months before he took his own life, but the police never told him. They've admitted failings in this matter and have pledged to do better in future.

That is a tragic situation, it really is.

Others have commented on the likelihood of a false allegation vs a rapist going to court and/or being convicted. I ponder on the statistics of female suicide following rape? I suspect it is high, and likely higher than those wrongly accused like your friend.

I am not dismissing this awful situation for you and his family, just highlighting that it is a potential anecdotal situation (eg failings of the police). It is a potential outcome for a rape victim (eg suicide, or a lifetime of trauma) as well.

Dollymylove · 01/11/2026 10:49

Everyone, who ever they are and whatever the allegations, is entitled to a fair trial, although nowadays that doesnt always seem to be the case 🙄

TheFriendlyPotato · 01/11/2026 11:33

There is a real issue here.

I am one for believing people are innocent. I have worked w serious offenders for decades and I still have that view. I do not want to live in a society where we assume someone is guilty because someone said they did something. That is an absolute horror show and opens society up to lawfare (accusing to get rid of people we dont like).

I do understand however that victims of crime feel incredibly let down when perps are deemed not guilty. Its horrific for those people, especially sexual assaults or families of those murdered.

I think that there is a tendency for people to get trial by aocial media though. If Russell Brand gets off his charge, he will still be seen as the rapey narcissist. That wont go away. Yes he wont go to prison, but social shunning and denigration is still very powerful. Look at Gary Glitter et al.

Its the best system we have and I cant think of a better version.

G5000 · 01/11/2026 11:33

A false accusation of sexual crimes absolutely destroys someone

Some people are destroyed by accusations for sure. But there are tons of men who have had absolutely 0 consequences. I'm sure you can think of a few.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2026 11:41

Depends if you personally know anything about the situation.

If it’s a celebrity or something, all you really
know for sure is the jury’s verdict, so kind of have to go with that.

If you were there when the events took place, or you know the people involved sufficiently to make a judgment, then of course you can come to your own conclusion.

If it’s somewhere in between, you’ll have to judge whether you know enough to judge. But nothing wrong with giving someone a wide berth if you think it’s likely true.

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 12:12

In the legal sense , it’s fine(ish). You can’t punish someone and remove their rights if you can’t prove they’re guilty.

However , as individuals, we are not the legal system. We can form an opinion and act accordingly. We can refuse to interact/spend time with anyone, even more so with someone we suspect committed a crime. We can judge the behaviour. We can judge behaviours surrounding the crime (even if not illegal) as bad enough to not have those people in our lives. You can fire or not hire someone because it would bring the profession/company into disrepute if there are other things that are morally wrong surrounding the crime.And so on.

Innocent until proven guilty is for the law. Private citizens do not have to subscribe to it. They can choose to do so, and bury their head in the sand in many cases, but it’s not a requirement.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 12:14

ExpectMore · 01/11/2026 06:08

Well it’s not meaningless, as many pp have pointed that out, and why do you think society for people to get away with these crimes? That’s quite a conspiracy theory in the making….

Is it a conspiracy theory have you read other posts. It is explained very well in them how rarely rape is prosecuted.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 12:18

TheignT · 01/11/2026 06:57

So you've educated us all about how flawed the system is. Well done but that's the easy bit, now tell us how you think the system should be, you know a system where no one lies, where no one gets away with anything and no innocent person gets accused let alone convicted. That would be really interesting.

I have made suggestions about improving it. I have pointed out that in organised crime prosecutions in some countries and in family courts we have non jury courts.

OP posts:
zoeslim · 01/11/2026 12:36

You should never be allowed to be on a jury I am glad you are not friends of mine
Totally ignorant

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 12:45

zoeslim · 01/11/2026 12:36

You should never be allowed to be on a jury I am glad you are not friends of mine
Totally ignorant

Aw Zoe and there was I thinking you and I would make great friends. How sad for me.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 12:46

ThisMauveExpert · 01/11/2026 08:14

A young man i was very close to, was falsely and maliciously accused of rape. He committed suicide due to the social oatracisation and bullying he received from his peers due to it. The young lady who accused him retracted her statement a full 8 months before he took his own life, but the police never told him. They've admitted failings in this matter and have pledged to do better in future.

Retracted accusations happen all the time. It doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. I can’t know about your case, but children and women often retract because the process of seeking justice is retraumatising. Sometimes they lose confidence in the legal system, get worn out, can’t cope with reliving it again and again - getting further traumatised - need to get on with their lives and put it behind them. Even a trial and a ‘bit guilty verdict’ simply means that there wasn’t enough evidence to know beyond reasonable doubt. It doesn’t prove innocence because if there was evidence that he didn’t do it (like a solid alibi) then it would never get to trial.

So may be your friend (and I’m sorry for your loss) didn’t do it and that was as what he couldn’t cope with but in lots of cases it’s simply not the case.

Regardless, I’m so sorry that happened.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 12:47

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 07:25

Maybe we should have experts in court - not acting for one side or the other, but furnishing juries and judges with insight on, for example, the meaning of consent and typical responses to traumatic threat. This would be useful in all areas of law, I should think - so many factors come into play from professional environments, through social & cultural considerations, to mental illness and the like (and more!) These issues are left to the two opponents to use & abuse as they see fit. Perhaps they shouldn't be.

Maybe a defendant's previous convictions should be made known to the court. May even charges they have faced but that were dropped.

Maybe the court should be told if a plaintiff has a prolific history of similar complaints. Maybe their previous convictions should be known as well.

I'm sure there's more. These are just things I've often thought when following trials. I mean, Judge Judy would not be fair process in real law, but there's quite a bit we could learn from it!

There are a lot of great suggestions here. I particularly think it is crazy that patterns of behaviour are not allowed to be established unless crimes are being prosecuted simultaneously.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread