Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:47

LBFseBrom · 31/10/2026 23:44

Everyone is entitled to a fair trial and there have to be boundaries. If there is insufficient evidence, it's possible for someone to get away with a crime - on that occasion - but the law keeps an eye on people when there is a strong possibility of them being guilty.

That applies to all crimes, not just violent or sexual. Let's not get bogged down by the nasties.

What do you mean the law keeps an eye on them if they suspect they are guilty? That sounds like an incredibly hopeful and naïve belief. There is no way the law has the resources to keep up with everyone they suspect are guilty but who got away with their crime.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 31/10/2026 23:48

I'm a woman, sex crimes against women anger me greatly so I may be biased.

Sex crimes involving minors I know I'm biased because there was one housed in our village. He didn't change his habits so the children couldn't go to the park any more because he hung around. Parents shut the gates to their gardens and watched closely. . Luckily he was moved on again

I'm not going to apologise for that..

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:48

InterIgnis · 31/10/2026 23:45

Legally, the presumption of innocent is a foundational principle. The burden of proof has to be on the state.

Does it mean that someone found not guilty didn’t commit the crime of which they were accused? No, of course not. If you suspect someone is guilty then you are free to have that opinion, think poorly of them, and distance yourself socially.

If an allegation is made against someone, I do not blindly trust it. Evidence matters. I may have opinions based on what information is available to me.

Absolutely agreed.

OP posts:
LauderSyme · 31/10/2026 23:51

Thankyou MrsTerryPratchett. I have always liked your take on life in your posts.

There are so many - exponentially - more examples of men who rape with impunity than there are liars who pretend to have been victimised. It blows my mind that these two scenarios are somehow viewed as equal evils by some people.

AmnesiacDream · 31/10/2026 23:52

Innocent until proven guilty is a legal fiction for the court. It isn't intended for anyone else, it is only about how the state will view someone in order to try not to prejudge them (and even then, doesn't apply to an investigation). Everyone else can (and should) think what they like.

Aussiemum87 · 01/11/2026 00:23

I personally know 3 adults who are preyed on children and are walking around free in the community. After going to court and being found guilty.
So no, if there’s an accusation , I’ll generally be more cautious. I’m not going to treat them poorly but someone whose been accused or convicted of something awful, won’t be left alone with my children

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:23

AmnesiacDream · 31/10/2026 23:52

Innocent until proven guilty is a legal fiction for the court. It isn't intended for anyone else, it is only about how the state will view someone in order to try not to prejudge them (and even then, doesn't apply to an investigation). Everyone else can (and should) think what they like.

Agreed.

OP posts:
PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · 01/11/2026 00:26

sprigatito · 31/10/2026 22:09

It’s a bit clumsily worded, but it’s not difficult to understand. Try reading it again more slowly.

Punctuation is a useful tool.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:28

Aussiemum87 · 01/11/2026 00:23

I personally know 3 adults who are preyed on children and are walking around free in the community. After going to court and being found guilty.
So no, if there’s an accusation , I’ll generally be more cautious. I’m not going to treat them poorly but someone whose been accused or convicted of something awful, won’t be left alone with my children

Absolutely as you should do.

Sexual abuse and rape were rife in the community around me growing up.

Scandal after scandal emerged and often there were multiple victims.

I still find it so hard to understand how people cannot integrate it as a very likely possibility given how prolific abuse/sexual assault and rape still are.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:30

PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · 01/11/2026 00:26

Punctuation is a useful tool.

There are umpteen posts engaging with the actual sensitive and serious topic I am discussing here. There is you and one other person who tried to make it about my writing style. Maybe this thread is not for you.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 01/11/2026 00:35

Crushed23 · 31/10/2026 23:25

I don’t think it’s rare for people to lie. I have lived a life completely removed from crime thankfully and even I know someone who lied in court. She completely made up claims of domestic violence in order to get a Green Card. There is a special category for abused women so she didn’t have to stay married to the person she used to get a GC and could live with her boyfriend and have his baby (leaving her ‘husband’ and having another man’s baby would have meant her GC application getting declined). She completely destroyed the man’s reputation and sent his mental health spiralling. This is an otherwise ‘normal’, law-abiding citizen with a good job and who is now a mother. So no, I wouldn’t say lying in a court of law is rare at all.

The justice system does have anti-women people but there's also the fact that rape is really hard crime to prove beyond reasonable doubt. The adversarial system doesn't help but I think it's hard abroad too though I would like to research more we can improve. We MUST improve!

The huge backlog in the UK doesn't help.
Edit : sorry, this was meant to be in reply to pp who wrote about the 'patriarchal justice system'.

WitchesBritches · 01/11/2026 00:35

everynowandthenifallapart · 31/10/2026 22:11

Nothing wrong with my reading comprehension, it’s an incoherent question.

No it's not.

BrickMaker · 01/11/2026 00:38

I think it's a pretty dangerous precedent to judge someone as guilty of a crime unless they have been found guilty of that unless there is some miscarriage of justice that means that process can't be followed. We can't just believe every allegation because false allegations although very rare, do happen. Feelings aren't facts and neither is 'intuition'; the Lindsay Clancy conspiracy theories about the husband's guilt is a good example.

I concede that many rapes and other crimes go unreported. But that is a separate issue to the issue of innocent until proven guilty.

In some select high profile cases with multiple people alleging the same (Russell Brand for example) it's hard not to judge him as predatory and of poor character, don't know if that means I find him 'guilty'. My opinion of him is pretty irrelevant anyway.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:41

Jane3212 · 01/11/2026 00:35

The justice system does have anti-women people but there's also the fact that rape is really hard crime to prove beyond reasonable doubt. The adversarial system doesn't help but I think it's hard abroad too though I would like to research more we can improve. We MUST improve!

The huge backlog in the UK doesn't help.
Edit : sorry, this was meant to be in reply to pp who wrote about the 'patriarchal justice system'.

Edited

There is a significant threat to life for witnesses and even jury members in some organised crimes criminal cases.

Some countries have moved to having judge only courts in order that witness and jury intimidation can be mitigated against.

I genuinely wonder if we need a new system for sexual offences too. The problem is that tolerance of this abusive culture towards women is present in the judiciary too as family courts have recently identified but it doesn’t mean that a more crime specific judicial practice could not be more effective.

OP posts:
grinandslothit · 01/11/2026 00:43

Weather someone has found guilty or not in a court of law has very little to do with a crime
Many crimes are committed but never even brought forward or reported. that doesn't mean they didn't happen

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:44

BrickMaker · 01/11/2026 00:38

I think it's a pretty dangerous precedent to judge someone as guilty of a crime unless they have been found guilty of that unless there is some miscarriage of justice that means that process can't be followed. We can't just believe every allegation because false allegations although very rare, do happen. Feelings aren't facts and neither is 'intuition'; the Lindsay Clancy conspiracy theories about the husband's guilt is a good example.

I concede that many rapes and other crimes go unreported. But that is a separate issue to the issue of innocent until proven guilty.

In some select high profile cases with multiple people alleging the same (Russell Brand for example) it's hard not to judge him as predatory and of poor character, don't know if that means I find him 'guilty'. My opinion of him is pretty irrelevant anyway.

I think where there is another problem is that even ones that rapes that are reported often don’t get prosecuted even if the crime has actually happened.

OP posts:
BrickMaker · 01/11/2026 00:48

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:44

I think where there is another problem is that even ones that rapes that are reported often don’t get prosecuted even if the crime has actually happened.

Edited

Yes that's true. The justice system is inherently adversarial in nature and so traumatic for abused women.

Clonakilla · 01/11/2026 00:53

The whole point of the presumption of innocence is that it’s a legal maxim that applies in one place only, a criminal court. It applies there because that’s the forum in which the state can apply its maximum penalty to an individual. It applies nowhere else.

Literally everywhere else you’re free to decide if someone’s guilty, and you’re free to say so subject only to the laws surrounding defamation and contempt.

None of that is interesting, it’s obvious to anyone of normal intelligence. What is interesting is the particular crimes that tend to drive people towards an impassioned but misguided defence of this maxim. It’s almost always crimes against women and children. None of the staunch defenders of this maxim bother bringing it up when the crimes involved relate to fraud or theft or similar property crimes. It’s rapists and paedophiles who always seem to deserve the most defence from random members of the public…..

The reality is that a man is so unlikely to go to jail for a rape he’s committed that you could almost say they have immunity from prosecution. The vast vast majority of men who rape a woman or a child will have zero legal consequences. The time women waste imagining that false accusations ruin men’s lives (actually committing rape rarely ruins a man’s life, let alone accusations) or insisting that a legal maxim THAT IS BEING APPLIED should be applied is just evidence of the damage done even to our own minds by misogyny.

FairCat · 01/11/2026 00:55

If you're happy to send someone to prison without ireffutable evidence of a crime because someone 'just knows' they're guilty, you must be happy for that to happen to you.

Are you happy to be jailed when there's no reliable evidence you've done anything wrong? Just to make sure no guilty person escapes justice.

Are you really?

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 00:57

Clonakilla · 01/11/2026 00:53

The whole point of the presumption of innocence is that it’s a legal maxim that applies in one place only, a criminal court. It applies there because that’s the forum in which the state can apply its maximum penalty to an individual. It applies nowhere else.

Literally everywhere else you’re free to decide if someone’s guilty, and you’re free to say so subject only to the laws surrounding defamation and contempt.

None of that is interesting, it’s obvious to anyone of normal intelligence. What is interesting is the particular crimes that tend to drive people towards an impassioned but misguided defence of this maxim. It’s almost always crimes against women and children. None of the staunch defenders of this maxim bother bringing it up when the crimes involved relate to fraud or theft or similar property crimes. It’s rapists and paedophiles who always seem to deserve the most defence from random members of the public…..

The reality is that a man is so unlikely to go to jail for a rape he’s committed that you could almost say they have immunity from prosecution. The vast vast majority of men who rape a woman or a child will have zero legal consequences. The time women waste imagining that false accusations ruin men’s lives (actually committing rape rarely ruins a man’s life, let alone accusations) or insisting that a legal maxim THAT IS BEING APPLIED should be applied is just evidence of the damage done even to our own minds by misogyny.

I completely agree with you.

OP posts:
Sosorryaboutthis · 01/11/2026 01:02

HelloFreshly · 31/10/2026 22:17

Presumed innocence is a legal principle, not a magic wand. If someone commits a crime, they are guilty from that moment. They don't morally get a free year when their crime ceases to exist because 12 randoms haven't judged it either way yet.

Exactly. And likewise if they didn't do it, they are innocent whether convicted or not.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:06

FairCat · 01/11/2026 00:55

If you're happy to send someone to prison without ireffutable evidence of a crime because someone 'just knows' they're guilty, you must be happy for that to happen to you.

Are you happy to be jailed when there's no reliable evidence you've done anything wrong? Just to make sure no guilty person escapes justice.

Are you really?

I’m happy to send any man who rapes someone to jail yes. If he did it and the evidence is the testimony of the woman, or child or sometimes the other man he raped I’m happy for him to go to jail. You refer to reliable evidence, the problem is how often the victims testimony is not considered reliable evidence.

If it was your sister, or mother, or daughter or brother or son - would you feel differently ? Would you prefer if a man raped them would get away with it like so many men do.

OP posts:
Fortuity · 01/11/2026 01:12

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:06

I’m happy to send any man who rapes someone to jail yes. If he did it and the evidence is the testimony of the woman, or child or sometimes the other man he raped I’m happy for him to go to jail. You refer to reliable evidence, the problem is how often the victims testimony is not considered reliable evidence.

If it was your sister, or mother, or daughter or brother or son - would you feel differently ? Would you prefer if a man raped them would get away with it like so many men do.

For that to work, you would have to extend the same principle to all other crimes of violence. If, say, I took a dislike to you and chose to accuse you wrongly of assault, how happy would you be to go to jail on the strength of my evidence alone?

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:20

Fortuity · 01/11/2026 01:12

For that to work, you would have to extend the same principle to all other crimes of violence. If, say, I took a dislike to you and chose to accuse you wrongly of assault, how happy would you be to go to jail on the strength of my evidence alone?

But what is happening now is men are raping women and children with almost no chance of prosecution. Are you happy with the current system or would you be happy for it to be changed at all?

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 01:22

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:06

I’m happy to send any man who rapes someone to jail yes. If he did it and the evidence is the testimony of the woman, or child or sometimes the other man he raped I’m happy for him to go to jail. You refer to reliable evidence, the problem is how often the victims testimony is not considered reliable evidence.

If it was your sister, or mother, or daughter or brother or son - would you feel differently ? Would you prefer if a man raped them would get away with it like so many men do.

An allegation alone is not reliable evidence, and should not be treated as such. The ends do not justify the means if the ends mean undermining the rule of law.