Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whether he did it or not he is innocent until proven guilty

265 replies

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 01:23

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 23:38

I don’t think I am misunderstanding “presumed innocent” I just think the concept really only belong in a courtroom but it gets extrapolated into the wider community. I mean the police for example don’t presume innocent or they would not charge anyone with a crime, the CPS does not presume innocence or they would not expect the trial to be in the public interest but yet the wider public have pulled a legal presumption into a domain beyond the court where it belongs.

Edited

You're absolutely right.

People are especially keen to insist 'innocent until proven' when the case is a man accused of sex-related crimes.

Funny that. But let's look at something more easily understood (for some). Say I got mugged - a man pushed me off balance, grabbed my handbag and ran off. I got a good look at the assailant and can identify him. When the police check on him, there's no sign of my bag or its contents. He was in the area, as he demonstrably is every night, so that means nothing.

There's no evidence he did it. He clearly did mug me: I saw him, my bag is gone and my backside's bruised. I'm not sure everyone would be so damn quick to assert his innocence in this case. They'd sympathise that the law is what it is for good reason, but it's awful for me.

Yet if he'd raped me, those same people would be bleating about innocence and the poor man's reputation 😕

Ophy83 · 01/11/2026 01:29

It is like a Venn diagram.

You have the truth. Which only the people involved know, and even then they may have different but homest recollections. No one else, even their lawyers, knows this.

Then you have the legal truth, that which is proved in a court of law complying with procedure rules and rules on admissible evidence.

One hopes there is a considerable crossover between the two, but no one can know.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:30

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 01:22

An allegation alone is not reliable evidence, and should not be treated as such. The ends do not justify the means if the ends mean undermining the rule of law.

The rule of law that currently protects rapists and like any law can be changed by legislation to produce radically different outcomes to the existing system.

This is not just an imperfect system which any human system will be, this is a complete failure of a system.

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:33

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 01:23

You're absolutely right.

People are especially keen to insist 'innocent until proven' when the case is a man accused of sex-related crimes.

Funny that. But let's look at something more easily understood (for some). Say I got mugged - a man pushed me off balance, grabbed my handbag and ran off. I got a good look at the assailant and can identify him. When the police check on him, there's no sign of my bag or its contents. He was in the area, as he demonstrably is every night, so that means nothing.

There's no evidence he did it. He clearly did mug me: I saw him, my bag is gone and my backside's bruised. I'm not sure everyone would be so damn quick to assert his innocence in this case. They'd sympathise that the law is what it is for good reason, but it's awful for me.

Yet if he'd raped me, those same people would be bleating about innocence and the poor man's reputation 😕

Absolutely. A mugging based on witness testimony is entirely plausible. Rape a woman or a child, it is not plausible.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 01:38

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:30

The rule of law that currently protects rapists and like any law can be changed by legislation to produce radically different outcomes to the existing system.

This is not just an imperfect system which any human system will be, this is a complete failure of a system.

Is it a failing system or faulty implementation of an OK system?

We've seen cases where rapists are convicted through this system. We've also seen too many where the defence impugns/accuses the victim - no longer allowed, but still happens. We've seen judges and juries showing poor understanding of consent and being influenced by personal prejudices.

All of these could be corrected, and should be.

TooBigForMyBoots · 01/11/2026 01:44

I get the legal weight of a guilty verdict. But someone who commits a crime is guilty from the moment they do it.

Whether or not if they get done for it by the law.🤷‍♀️

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:45

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 01:38

Is it a failing system or faulty implementation of an OK system?

We've seen cases where rapists are convicted through this system. We've also seen too many where the defence impugns/accuses the victim - no longer allowed, but still happens. We've seen judges and juries showing poor understanding of consent and being influenced by personal prejudices.

All of these could be corrected, and should be.

Your suggestions are good and I largely agree with you however I think even of the system was implemented to its best possible outcome it is almost impossible to get jurors who are not absorbed in the culture that causes these issues in the first place. That is not true of burglary, murder, physical assault etc

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 01:56

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:45

Your suggestions are good and I largely agree with you however I think even of the system was implemented to its best possible outcome it is almost impossible to get jurors who are not absorbed in the culture that causes these issues in the first place. That is not true of burglary, murder, physical assault etc

Tragically true. I'd still like to see some mandatory training before each trial, though. Maybe even a special advisor to sit in on sex-related cases, with the authority to stop victim-blaming and other cultural misapprehensions.

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 01:58

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 01:30

The rule of law that currently protects rapists and like any law can be changed by legislation to produce radically different outcomes to the existing system.

This is not just an imperfect system which any human system will be, this is a complete failure of a system.

The rule of law protects us all, and lowering the burden of proof would hurt us all. It would also be entirely incompatible with established legal precedent.

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 02:07

InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 01:58

The rule of law protects us all, and lowering the burden of proof would hurt us all. It would also be entirely incompatible with established legal precedent.

How exactly in your belief system is the rule of law protecting victims of sexual crime?

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 01/11/2026 02:32

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 02:07

How exactly in your belief system is the rule of law protecting victims of sexual crime?

My belief system is English Common Law, in which burden of proof is an integral concept that protects the rights of the individual.

I do not believe lowering the burden of proof is a price worth paying for increased conviction rates.

Lemonapplepear · 01/11/2026 02:43

There are times when a famous person has been accused of sexual assault by many unconnected people over years and years and there is just no conceivable way they are not guilty. Of course officially society needs to treat anyone not yet convicted of a crime as innocent, but it's always obvious the person is guilty. It's never a surprise either.

OneCalmEagle · 01/11/2026 02:47

They may feel guilty they may not bit they are not proved guilty

Hugasaurusrex · 01/11/2026 02:53

*My belief system is English Common Law, in which burden of proof is an integral concept that protects the rights of the individual.

I do not believe lowering the burden of proof is a price worth paying for increased conviction rates.*

So you are happy for rapists act with impunity because you see the current system as having no scope for improvement.

To me this response is extremely male centric because of the link of men being perpetrators of any crime but obviously specifically sexual crimes and it is not very protective of victims of crime particularly women and children.

OP posts:
GreenGlassVases · 01/11/2026 03:07

everynowandthenifallapart · 31/10/2026 22:06

Your second paragraph makes no sense at all could you have another crack at forming a coherent question please op?

I understand it.

Dovecare · 01/11/2026 03:09

Its very obvious what second paragraph means.

Dimdam · 01/11/2026 05:18

It’s not.a justice system it’s a legal system, laws apply not justice, morality or right and wrong.

Justice and law are not related, law is just a sledge hammer to crack a nut

Mu cousin worked for the CPS at the Old Bailey and she stoped believing that there was such thing as justice. She worked on Grenfell tower as well, only time will tell if there is any justice administered in that case when the case goes to trial.

DotDotDoorDash · 01/11/2026 05:39

JLou08 · 31/10/2026 22:38

I believe it's rare, but some people do lie. A false accusation of sexual crimes absolutely destroys someone, even without them being seen as innocent until proven guilty in the eyes of the law.
I think when we're talking about someone with multiple accusations from people who have no connection to each other common sense says they're guilty. But for one accusation I think innocent until proven guilty is the right way to go about things.

Here’s a fun fact for you - a man is more likely to be raped himself than he is to be falsely accused. Let’s not hold that up as an excuse not to believe people whose allegations don’t get as far as being charged or the accused is found not guilty. Is a man raping his wife less guilty because there’s only one victim?

Supersimkin7 · 01/11/2026 05:48

Rape laws don’t work so we have to
rely on trial by media.

That’s not going well either.

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 05:51

I believe that people are innocent unless found guilty. I think that principle is important regardless of the crime in question, publicity bc and reporting about people who haven’t even been charged for a crime should be factual. There have been cases where reporting and social media and social media has been so defamatory to an individual and they are innocent - which I think is appalling and must have been so distressing.

Of course we can all have feelings about individuals regardless of any crimes and might choose to avoid them. If someone was prosecuted we might steer clear of them due to our concerns and that is acceptable, that is our choice, however they still have a right to be treated fairly as they are innocent unless found guilty

ExpectMore · 01/11/2026 06:08

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:36

How do you feel about people who only judge people who commit heinous crimes if a court can find them guilty?

Am I being unreasonable to say that especially in sexual crimes that innocent until proven guilty is meaningless in a society set up for people to get away with these types of crime.

Well it’s not meaningless, as many pp have pointed that out, and why do you think society for people to get away with these crimes? That’s quite a conspiracy theory in the making….

DotDotDoorDash · 01/11/2026 06:14

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 05:51

I believe that people are innocent unless found guilty. I think that principle is important regardless of the crime in question, publicity bc and reporting about people who haven’t even been charged for a crime should be factual. There have been cases where reporting and social media and social media has been so defamatory to an individual and they are innocent - which I think is appalling and must have been so distressing.

Of course we can all have feelings about individuals regardless of any crimes and might choose to avoid them. If someone was prosecuted we might steer clear of them due to our concerns and that is acceptable, that is our choice, however they still have a right to be treated fairly as they are innocent unless found guilty

They’re not though are they? If the evidence was contaminated or lost, leading to a not guilty verdict, or there was insufficient evidence to charge, or the crime is taken less seriously because of its nature (rape cases for example), it doesn’t mean the person was innocent and the accuser was making it up. It’s quite dangerous to think of it in such simplistic terms and apply it to your daily life.

GarlicNothing · 01/11/2026 06:22

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 05:51

I believe that people are innocent unless found guilty. I think that principle is important regardless of the crime in question, publicity bc and reporting about people who haven’t even been charged for a crime should be factual. There have been cases where reporting and social media and social media has been so defamatory to an individual and they are innocent - which I think is appalling and must have been so distressing.

Of course we can all have feelings about individuals regardless of any crimes and might choose to avoid them. If someone was prosecuted we might steer clear of them due to our concerns and that is acceptable, that is our choice, however they still have a right to be treated fairly as they are innocent unless found guilty

Reading your second paragraph, I do believe you understand the difference between 'not guilty in law' and 'innocent'. Nobody is ever found innocent in court, they can only be proved guilty / not guilty in the legal sense.

Unlike Scotland, we don't have a verdict of 'not proven' but it is the same thing. It feels different because of the way our language works - the opposite of guilty is innocent, so we intuitively hear 'not guilty' that way. The law's precise, though, not intuitive. Not guilty ONLY means not guilty - much as 'not hungry' doesn't mean full up.

As @Dimdam remarks, our judicial system only deals in law. Morals and human justice ideally come into it, but they don't if law isn't applied that way. Sometimes it actually can't be. In the UK, we have a very ancient and continually updated body of law - it's pretty responsive compared to other systems - but this does rely on all sides having equal access & knowledge, which often isn't the case. (I once got convicted of a small crime; years later, I realised I wasn't guilty in law but had a shit solicitor).

I'm not sure our adversarial system is the best way of administering the law. Other European countries use different systems, but they also have their weaknesses.

There is often a chasm between a verdict of 'not guilty' and the everyday meaning of 'innocent'.

And everyday discussion of someone's likely guilt (eg Russell Brand) shouldn't be constrained to legal definitions. There's something called the balance of probabilities: we use it all the time in making decisions, from whether to take an umbrella to financing a house purchase. This is what we should be discussing.

I sure as hell wouldn't encourage the young women in my life to be alone with Messrs Brand or Walliams. Don't need to wait for a court to tell me.

Mrsbirdwatcher · 01/11/2026 06:22

DotDotDoorDash · 01/11/2026 06:14

They’re not though are they? If the evidence was contaminated or lost, leading to a not guilty verdict, or there was insufficient evidence to charge, or the crime is taken less seriously because of its nature (rape cases for example), it doesn’t mean the person was innocent and the accuser was making it up. It’s quite dangerous to think of it in such simplistic terms and apply it to your daily life.

So if someone close to you was accused and you frlt/believed they were innocent (I use the words felt/believed rather than knew because it might be you weren’t with them at the specific time a crime was committed but maybesomeone else was and were for example willing to testify) would you be ok with the press coverage assuming guilt or people speaking about them assuming guilt?

Thewonderfuldollypartonsbra · 01/11/2026 06:25

RufustheFestiveReindeer · 31/10/2026 23:11

I have a friend who was completely convinced that if someone was found not guilty in a court of law it means that they deffo did not commit the crime 😳

Unfortunately,that's the attitude of 'my' rapists girlfriend

Myself and another woman came forward and where ripped to bits on the stand

We where both shaken by the fact they put him (and her) in a room opposite us and they did their best to intimate us and on breaks,they where allowed to folow us around while shouting that we where liars (it worked-we where both wrecks by the time we made the stand)

Found not guilty (at the very least,it was proved he'd cheated on her endlessly)

'Not guilty' meant (in her head) that it never happened rather than 'could have happened but can't be proved' which is different-it's been explained to her but she refuses to understand it

She's still out there,still calling us liars,still rubbing salt in a very large wound while clinging onto him

He'll do it again and she'll be there,standing by her man and doing her best to intimate the 'other' woman

Swipe left for the next trending thread