Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To believe that Parents must have the right to tell their children they are not “in the wrong body” and children cant be “transgender”?

378 replies

DoubleMM · 22/10/2026 08:57

The government wants to bring in a law that threatens anyone including parents with up to five years in prison for denying a child’s or an adult’s “transgender identity” -. The draft Bill is in Committee stage. Labour have committed to making it law. Surely this is just bringing back the Scottish Parliament’s vote that everyone has to agree? That men are women if they say they are? This time parents are in the firing line if they dont agree to their child being “transed” at school or elsewhere? The Bill proposes that the courts should be able to make an order to enforce compliance on parents. Surely this can’t be allowed to go through without a fight?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
TheodoreisntBeth · Today 18:45

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · Today 10:23

That poor boy - that is terrible behaviour by the school. I can’t believe how badly some people have fallen for this.

I can’t see how they are so determined to support children confused about their so called ‘gender’ but are completely unable to acknowledge the opposing needs of this boy. Why can’t they see the harm they are causing him? Have they lost the power of rational thought?

Have they lost the power of rational thought?

Some have, yes. Some don't think too deeply and think they are #beingkind. Some think it sounds a bit odd but assume experts have studied it and worked out this is the proper thing to do (they haven't ), so they go along with it. Some are scared to voice any confusion or doubts they have, in case they get accused of being a fascist, far right, probably racist and homophobe. Some assume it's the same as gay rights. And some have shady motives.

Katemax82 · Today 18:59

My sister's oldest went through conversation therapy at the tavistock. Her son had a mastectomy but not full gender reassignment but is basically living as male. In the early days there was civil war in the family with her fiercely defending their trans status.
Not sure what my point is but being supportive was best in that situation

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 20:21

Katemax82 · Today 18:59

My sister's oldest went through conversation therapy at the tavistock. Her son had a mastectomy but not full gender reassignment but is basically living as male. In the early days there was civil war in the family with her fiercely defending their trans status.
Not sure what my point is but being supportive was best in that situation

"Being supportive" about a young woman having her healthy breasts removed isn't something I will ever think is the best in any situation.

97.5% of the patients seen at the Tavistock had other significant issues -see photo when it appears - and none of those were addressed.

Transition regret peaks several years post surgery iirc, and mental health in those who had surgery is worse several years post surgery. See here: https://statsforgender.org/category/medical-transition/

This period in medical history will rightly be judged on a par with lobotomies

To believe that Parents must have the right to tell their children they are not “in the wrong body” and children cant be “transgender”?
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread