Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To believe that Parents must have the right to tell their children they are not “in the wrong body” and children cant be “transgender”?

378 replies

DoubleMM · 22/10/2026 08:57

The government wants to bring in a law that threatens anyone including parents with up to five years in prison for denying a child’s or an adult’s “transgender identity” -. The draft Bill is in Committee stage. Labour have committed to making it law. Surely this is just bringing back the Scottish Parliament’s vote that everyone has to agree? That men are women if they say they are? This time parents are in the firing line if they dont agree to their child being “transed” at school or elsewhere? The Bill proposes that the courts should be able to make an order to enforce compliance on parents. Surely this can’t be allowed to go through without a fight?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 11:46

Please would someone list the ways in which the law already protects people? And be honest about any missing laws meaning there are loopholes for conversion practices to get through?

What are the conversion practices being cited? Exorcisms? Who are the religious groups with gay or trans identifying members being affected? Any other conversion methods?

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 13/11/2026 13:53

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 11:46

Please would someone list the ways in which the law already protects people? And be honest about any missing laws meaning there are loopholes for conversion practices to get through?

What are the conversion practices being cited? Exorcisms? Who are the religious groups with gay or trans identifying members being affected? Any other conversion methods?

Hi - This is a list of all the laws that already protect people from the sort of abuse and violence cited by people who say that a Conversion Practices Bill is needed.

Very much worth noting that if someone were to be prosecuted under existing laws then the penalties would be much higher than if they were to be prosecuted under the proposed Bill.

List of Offences already on the Statute Book or in Common Law

Conduct falling into these categories is already unlawful in England and Wales, thereby rendering the draft Bill unnecessary:

  1. Physical violence, assault, beatings or physical punishment Offences Against the Person Act 1861 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/24-25/100/introduction

s16 Threats to kill
s18 Wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm(“GBH”)
s20 Inflicting bodily injury, with or without weapon (“ABH”)
s21 Attempting to choke etc. in order to commit any indictable offence
s22 Using chloroform or other to commit any indictable offence
s23 Maliciously administering poison so as to endanger life or inflict GBH
s24 Maliciously administering poison etc with intent to injure, aggrieve or annoy any other person
s42 Persons committing any common assault or battery [penalties]
s47 Penalty for conviction on indictment of ABH

  1. Sexual touching, sexual assault or coerced sexual activity disguised as counselling, therapy, prayer or treatment Sexual Offences Act 2003 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/introduction/enacted

s1 Rape
s2 Assault by penetration
s3 Sexual assault
s4 Causing a person to engage in sexual activity without consent
s5 Rape of a child under 13
s6 Assault of a child under 13 by penetration
s7 Sexual assault of a child under 13
s8 Causing or inciting a child under 13 to engage in sexual activity

Child sex offences
s9 Sexual activity with a child
s10 Causing or inciting a child to engage in sexual activity
s11 Engaging in sexual activity in the presence of a child
s12 Causing a child to watch a sexual act
s13 Child sex offences committed by children or young persons
s14 Arranging or facilitating commission of a child sex offence
s15 Meeting a child following sexual grooming etc.

Abuse of position of trust:
s16 Sexual activity with a child
s17 Causing or inciting a child to engage in sexual activity
s18 Sexual activity in the presence of a child
s19 Causing a child to watch a sexual act
s20 Acts done in Scotland
Positions of trust (“PoT”)
s21 sets out meaning of PoT for the purposes of ss16 to 19
s22 interpretation

Other offences
s66 Exposure
s67 Voyeurism
s68 Voyeurism: interpretation

  1. Threats, intimidation and campaigns of harassment Protection from Harassment Act 1997 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1997/40/introduction

s1 Prohibition of harassment
s2 Offence of harassment
s2A Offence of stalking s3 Civil remedy
s3A Injunctions
s4 Putting people in fear of violence
s4A Stalking involving fear or violence or serious alarm or distress
s7 Interpretation applicable to sections 1 to 5A
s8 Harassment
s8A Harassment amounting to domestic abuse

  1. Persistent monitoring, following or unwanted contact → Protection from Harassment Act 1997 (stalking offences)[see above] Children and Young Persons Act 1933 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Geo5/23-24/12/section/12

s1 Cruelty to persons under sixteen
s3 allowing persons under sixteen to reside in or frequent brothels
s4 causing or allowing child or young person under the age of 16 to be used for begging
s5 giving intoxicating liquor to children under five
s7 tobacco
s12 Failing to provide safety of children at entertainments

  1. Coercion, manipulation, isolation or controlling behaviour within a family or intimate relationship Serious Crime Act 2015 and Domestic Abuse Act 2021 Serious Crime Act 2015 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/9/section/66

Part 5 Protection of children and others
Protection of children
s66 Child cruelty offence
amends s1 of the Children and Young Persons Act 1933
s67 Sexual communication with a child
s68 Child sexual exploitation
s69 Possession of paedophile manual

  1. Domestic Abuse Act 2021 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2021/17

s1 Definition of domestic abuse
s2 Definition of personally connected
s3 Children as victims of domestic abuse
s22 Power to give a domestic abuse protection notice
s23 Provisions that may be made by notices
s24 Matters to be considered before giving a notice
s25 Further requirements in relation to notices
s26 Breach of notice
s27 Meaning of “Domestic Abuse Protection Order” (“DAPO”)
s28 DAPO on application [to the court]
s40 Arrest for breach of order

  1. Holding someone against their will, preventing them from leaving, or confining them Common law offence of false imprisonment (see screenshots in PDF)

From Blackstone’s Criminal Practice 2020 edition

  1. Taking someone abroad against their will for treatment, counselling or intervention
    Kidnapping, abduction and false imprisonment offences

  2. Forcing someone into a marriage as a means of changing or suppressing their sexuality
    Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014

  3. Physical, emotional or psychological abuse of a child
    Children Act 1989, Children Act 2004 and statutory safeguarding frameworks

  4. Neglecting a child or exposing them to significant harm
    Child Protection Law and safeguarding duties

  5. Emotional abuse or coercive treatment of vulnerable adults
    Care Act 2014 safeguarding provisions

  6. Fraudulent claims by practitioners offering cures, treatments or therapeutic interventions
    Fraud Act 2006 and Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008

  7. Misconduct by doctors, nurses, psychologists, counsellors, psychotherapists or social workers
    Professional regulatory frameworks including the GMC, NMC, HCPC, and Social Work England

  8. Harassment or discrimination because someone is gay, lesbian or bisexual in employment or service provision
    Equality Act 2010

  9. Victimisation of someone for asserting their sexual orientation rights
    Equality Act 2010

  10. Threatening behaviour intended to cause fear or alarm
    Public Order Act 1986

  11. Malicious or threatening communications sent online or electronically
    Communications Act 2003 and Online Safety-related offences

You can download a PDF version of the list, including relevant screenshots, from the "Stats and Facts" Link Collection on the Bin The Bill Linktree here:

https://tr.ee/reqfAU8GW9

LOOPHOLES

The main "loopholes" prioritised by pro-Bill witnesses in the Scrutiny Committee's Oral Evidence Sessions and of relevance to Mumsnet as a Parenting Forum are the current lack of provision for:

  • criminal prosecution of parents exercising their legal duties to parent their children responsibly, eg. neither negligently exposing them to harm nor colluding in criminality
  • criminal prosecution of children aged 10 or over should they fail to respect and affirm the sexual orientation and/or transgender identities of other children and adults, such as siblings, class mates, adult family members, teachers, etc.

🚨 REMINDER

⏳ Deadline for Submissions of evidence to the Scrutiny Committee on the Conversion Practices Draft Bill is Monday 16 Nov at 5pm

How anyone can make a submission to the committee in 15 minutes
https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 17:55

BinTheConversionPracticesBill ·Today 13:53
Thank you very much. I wanted to be ready for a letter.

If, possible please would you pin point how a person who felt they had been subject to conversion practices, with an enforced exorcism, might deal with it legally? I can imagine some parents, possibly evangelical, taking a child under 16 to be exorcised and the child not daring to object yet feeling humiliated and terrified. (I would not think it right to ‘affirm’ such a child but this would not be right either.)

ArthurFrampton · 14/11/2026 09:33

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 17:55

BinTheConversionPracticesBill ·Today 13:53
Thank you very much. I wanted to be ready for a letter.

If, possible please would you pin point how a person who felt they had been subject to conversion practices, with an enforced exorcism, might deal with it legally? I can imagine some parents, possibly evangelical, taking a child under 16 to be exorcised and the child not daring to object yet feeling humiliated and terrified. (I would not think it right to ‘affirm’ such a child but this would not be right either.)

That would be covered by points 10 and 11 above, possibly 8 if taken abroad, and a number of other offences depending on age, vulnerability, and other factors.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 14/11/2026 11:30

Second video by Black Belt Barrister about the Draft Bill!

Horrendous (and Frankly Ridiculous) Draft Law that could send you to prison

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=imH6H52vnW4

Perisalt · 14/11/2026 13:24

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 17:55

BinTheConversionPracticesBill ·Today 13:53
Thank you very much. I wanted to be ready for a letter.

If, possible please would you pin point how a person who felt they had been subject to conversion practices, with an enforced exorcism, might deal with it legally? I can imagine some parents, possibly evangelical, taking a child under 16 to be exorcised and the child not daring to object yet feeling humiliated and terrified. (I would not think it right to ‘affirm’ such a child but this would not be right either.)

Very helpful. Thank you. I haven’t looked in detail. Will submissions to this be public? I don’t want to share personal details if my name will be on it:

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 15/11/2026 05:31

Perisalt · 14/11/2026 13:24

Very helpful. Thank you. I haven’t looked in detail. Will submissions to this be public? I don’t want to share personal details if my name will be on it:

The Sex Matters guidance page links to this page which includes information about Anonymity and Confidentiality:

It is important that people can see what was said to a committee. For this reason, committees generally publish written evidence online. They can refer in their reports to information that they have published.

Once published, the document remains available on the internet permanently. Committees cannot usually remove evidence after it has been published.
The committee decides what information to publish and how. You can request anonymity or confidentiality when you send evidence, but it is for the committee to say whether it will agree.

  • Anonymity means that your evidence will be made public, but not under your name. You will need to remove other identifying details, like your job or other information about you, in the text or the document metadata if you want to request anonymity. Anonymity provides some protection but is not failsafe.
  • Confidentiality means that your evidence will inform the thinking of the members in private but neither your name nor your contribution will be made public.

If you would like to give written evidence to a committee but are concerned about being identified, then confidentiality is the safest way to do so.

https://www.parliament.uk/get-involved/committees/give-evidence-to-a-select-committee/

Sex Matters have also advised in videos that if anyone lucky enough to have an alternative, relatively anonymous name, like Maiden Name "Smith", could submit their evidence as, eg. Ms Smith.

Sex Matters Guidance:
https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Submit evidence to the Conversion Practices Bill committee

A parliamentary committee is scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill, and it wants to hear from people the bill would affect. The deadline for

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Perisalt · 15/11/2026 06:55

@BinTheConversionPracticesBill yes I thought so. Thank you for your detailed response.

There’s no way I’m going to submit my story (above) of my daughter’s struggles with “gender identity” (ugh) if there’s a chance my name would be attached. And alas I don’t have a bland maiden name.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 16/11/2026 11:51

Perisalt · 15/11/2026 06:55

@BinTheConversionPracticesBill yes I thought so. Thank you for your detailed response.

There’s no way I’m going to submit my story (above) of my daughter’s struggles with “gender identity” (ugh) if there’s a chance my name would be attached. And alas I don’t have a bland maiden name.

I have been asking around and it seems that people who want to be sure that their submissions remain anonymous are also using things like:

  • Their mother's Maiden Name (and not giving a First Name)
  • Their anonymous Social Media User Name
  • A completely made-up name (risky if the made-up name is unusual as there might actually be someone with that name who is then wrongly identified as the author; alternatively, if using "Mrs Smith" it might be tricky to identify your own Submission online if several people calling themselves "Mrs Smith" have submitted evidence)
The Committee does not ask for any form of identification when making a Submission but they do ask for an email address.

If your email address includes identifying information it would be best to create a new email account. This is very easy to do, eg.

Create a Google Account for Gmail
https://support.google.com/mail/answer/56256

------

5pm TODAY

Last day to submit your evidence to the select committee ‘scrutinising’ the Conversion Practices Draft Bill

How to submit without AI:

  1. Decide on your issue:
  • lack of clear definitions of abuse, intent, alarm and distress;
  • no carve out for parents;
  • activist teachers will abuse the;
  • conversion practice protection orders will be abused (no need to be in any relationship - formal or informal- and don’t cost anything;
  • men’s mental health etc
  1. Follow Sex Matters guide: How to answer the questions

  2. https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

  3. All paragraphs have to be numbered.

  4. Section headings don’t have to be numbered but should be in bold

  5. No footers or headers

  6. No more than 3,000 words

  7. AI can help by tidying up your words and letting you know which questions you have answered. Doing it this way is longer but has a more individual voice (and isn’t AI slop)

  8. Save as docx, odt, rtf or txt (not pdf)

  9. Go to https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence and start the submission process

  10. Submit your evidence here:

  11. https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence

  12. You don’t need give your first name. Your surname could be your maiden name. You can ask for anonymity, but it isn’t promised.

  13. An email address is needed. If you don’t want to use your regular email address create a new one in Gmail or live.co.ik (other email programs exist)

  14. Press submit

  15. Open the wine 🍷🍷

You can put on more than one submission!

If you use AI to write the whole submission you need to state that.

Dennis Kavanagh has provided a helpful guide:
https://x.com/jebadoo2/status/2121240749995942013

----

If you have a male relative please ask them to also send in a submission re how only being able to access mixed sex spaces will adversely affect them:

  1. there is an increase in women identifying as men who expect to be included in men’s spaces.

  2. Men have a higher risk of suicide than women

  3. Men’s sheds, and other male only spaces for men designed to help their mental health, will be compromised.

  4. Mens problems are always seen as more important than women’s.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2026 12:45

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 16/11/2026 11:51

I have been asking around and it seems that people who want to be sure that their submissions remain anonymous are also using things like:

  • Their mother's Maiden Name (and not giving a First Name)
  • Their anonymous Social Media User Name
  • A completely made-up name (risky if the made-up name is unusual as there might actually be someone with that name who is then wrongly identified as the author; alternatively, if using "Mrs Smith" it might be tricky to identify your own Submission online if several people calling themselves "Mrs Smith" have submitted evidence)
The Committee does not ask for any form of identification when making a Submission but they do ask for an email address.

If your email address includes identifying information it would be best to create a new email account. This is very easy to do, eg.

Create a Google Account for Gmail
https://support.google.com/mail/answer/56256

------

5pm TODAY

Last day to submit your evidence to the select committee ‘scrutinising’ the Conversion Practices Draft Bill

How to submit without AI:

  1. Decide on your issue:
  • lack of clear definitions of abuse, intent, alarm and distress;
  • no carve out for parents;
  • activist teachers will abuse the;
  • conversion practice protection orders will be abused (no need to be in any relationship - formal or informal- and don’t cost anything;
  • men’s mental health etc
  1. Follow Sex Matters guide: How to answer the questions

  2. https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

  3. All paragraphs have to be numbered.

  4. Section headings don’t have to be numbered but should be in bold

  5. No footers or headers

  6. No more than 3,000 words

  7. AI can help by tidying up your words and letting you know which questions you have answered. Doing it this way is longer but has a more individual voice (and isn’t AI slop)

  8. Save as docx, odt, rtf or txt (not pdf)

  9. Go to https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence and start the submission process

  10. Submit your evidence here:

  11. https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence

  12. You don’t need give your first name. Your surname could be your maiden name. You can ask for anonymity, but it isn’t promised.

  13. An email address is needed. If you don’t want to use your regular email address create a new one in Gmail or live.co.ik (other email programs exist)

  14. Press submit

  15. Open the wine 🍷🍷

You can put on more than one submission!

If you use AI to write the whole submission you need to state that.

Dennis Kavanagh has provided a helpful guide:
https://x.com/jebadoo2/status/2121240749995942013

----

If you have a male relative please ask them to also send in a submission re how only being able to access mixed sex spaces will adversely affect them:

  1. there is an increase in women identifying as men who expect to be included in men’s spaces.

  2. Men have a higher risk of suicide than women

  3. Men’s sheds, and other male only spaces for men designed to help their mental health, will be compromised.

  4. Mens problems are always seen as more important than women’s.

Thanks for your work and time on this @BinTheConversionPracticesBill I am looking at the site for submission.

Am I missing something or has Sex Matters only given outlines for a few questions? No matter I'm doing the others, and rewriting in my own words.

One problem I'm having is I just don't believe we should use trans for children to start with. They can wear whatever they want, do activities as they like. It's stereotyping and regressive to say that means you can't be a girl or boy.

I feel so at odds with current GRA legislation it stands out in my replies. Has anyone else tried to answer the questions? Feels quite hard.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 16/11/2026 14:04

TY @EasternStandard ❤️

Sex Matters has made suggestions for a handful of questions as the top priorities for short responses (Q1, Q2 and Q5) and then further down the page has suggested questions that would be relevant to specific interests for a longer response, eg. as parents, teachers, etc, that would likely be related to personal experience.

One long answer

Pick the question that fits you and describe your own experience.

  • PARENTS — Q15 Does the bill leave room for ordinary parenting?
  • TEACHERS, YOUTH WORKERS, OTHER PROFESSIONALS QUESTION — Q11 Would the bill change how you do your job? (For teachers, school staff, youth workers, therapists and other professionals)
  • THERAPISTS, CLINICIANS — Q14 How adequate or appropriate is the existing exemption for healthcare services and related organisations?
  • ANYONE — Q7 Could you tell in advance what would be a problem?
A simple shape for your longer answer
  1. Who you are. One sentence: “I am a parent of two teenagers”, “I am a primary school teacher”.
  2. What happens in your life. Describe a real situation, in plain words.
  3. What the bill could mean for that situation. Use “could” and “might”. If you do not know whether your actions in this situation might be caught by the proposed law, say so: “I would not know whether…” is powerful evidence against the definitions in the bill.
https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Submit evidence to the Conversion Practices Bill committee

A parliamentary committee is scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill, and it wants to hear from people the bill would affect. The deadline for

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Perisalt · 16/11/2026 16:37

Very helpful advice above. Thank you @BinTheConversionPracticesBill

EasternStandard · 16/11/2026 16:51

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 16/11/2026 14:04

TY @EasternStandard ❤️

Sex Matters has made suggestions for a handful of questions as the top priorities for short responses (Q1, Q2 and Q5) and then further down the page has suggested questions that would be relevant to specific interests for a longer response, eg. as parents, teachers, etc, that would likely be related to personal experience.

One long answer

Pick the question that fits you and describe your own experience.

  • PARENTS — Q15 Does the bill leave room for ordinary parenting?
  • TEACHERS, YOUTH WORKERS, OTHER PROFESSIONALS QUESTION — Q11 Would the bill change how you do your job? (For teachers, school staff, youth workers, therapists and other professionals)
  • THERAPISTS, CLINICIANS — Q14 How adequate or appropriate is the existing exemption for healthcare services and related organisations?
  • ANYONE — Q7 Could you tell in advance what would be a problem?
A simple shape for your longer answer
  1. Who you are. One sentence: “I am a parent of two teenagers”, “I am a primary school teacher”.
  2. What happens in your life. Describe a real situation, in plain words.
  3. What the bill could mean for that situation. Use “could” and “might”. If you do not know whether your actions in this situation might be caught by the proposed law, say so: “I would not know whether…” is powerful evidence against the definitions in the bill.
https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Thanks that was v useful, it’s submitted.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 17/11/2026 00:41

Some good news from the Oral Submissions Session at the Pre-Legislative Scrutiny Committee today!

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’
Telegraph 16 Nov 2026

Dr Hilary Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.
Baroness Cass – who led a review into the treatment of children with gender dysphoria – said the draft Conversion Practices Bill could have “serious unintended consequences”.

Under the proposed legislation, people face up to five years in jail for putting pressure on others to change their sexual orientation or gender identity. . . .

The draft bill states that doctors cannot be performing conversion therapy “unless the person acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position”.

However, Baroness Cass said the legislation did not sufficiently define what the expected standards for medical professionals in a contested area of medicine were.

“It’s very easy for a young person who is understandably distressed after what’s inevitably a painful discussion, and possibly angry and upset that they haven’t, for example, got onto the medication pathway that they want to, to feel and report that that person has behaved in what they deem to be a very negative way,” she told MPs.

The doctor warned that there were “malign actors” who were “looking to exploit young people” and use them to “pursue” medical professionals in the field.

She also sounded the alarm about parents being “caught up” in the legislation if they refused to refer to their child by their preferred pronouns.

“I know there’s absolutely not the intent for them to be caught up in this, but that is unavoidably potentially the risk of the way in which the bill is framed,” she said.

“Things like not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they’re going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones, and all of those things could fall within the reach of this bill.”

Full article:
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/
Archive: archive.is/rP3Np

Hilary Cass withdraws backing for Labour’s conversion therapy ban

The paediatrician has warned that the legislation could expose doctors to vexatious complaints for following a cautious approach to gender dysphoria
Times 16 Nov 2026

The paediatrician who led the review of children’s gender services has withdrawn her backing for Labour’s conversion therapy ban, warning that it risked serious unintended consequences for doctors and parents.

Baroness Cass, whose review led to an overhaul of NHS services, was cited by government officials as recently as Sunday night that there was evidence of strong safeguards in the Conversion Practices Bill after concerns were raised by teachers and doctors.

However, giving evidence to a parliamentary committee on Monday, she warned that the legislation put healthcare workers, parents, Wes Streeting, the former health secretary, and even herself at risk of being accused of criminality.

The Times understands that Cass had been angered by perceived attempts to use her endorsement as a defence of the bill.

She told MPs and peers that she had only had 15 minutes to read it before giving her previous support.

Cass said: “Maybe I should not have done that, but I am supportive of trying to do something about conversion practices.”

Having now examined the proposals, she said: “I unfortunately don’t think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.”
She added: “Having seen the bill, having spoken to many families [who have] emailed me and having spoken to my colleagues, I can’t support the bill in its current form.” . . .

“At the moment we don’t have clear standards, but moreover standards are highly contested in this area,” she told the joint committee.

She said: “It’s very easy for a young person who is understandably distressed after what is inevitably a painful discussion and possibly angry and upset that they haven’t, for example, got on to the medication pathway that they want, to feel and report that person has behaved in what they deem to be a very negative way.”

Cass argued that there were also “malign actors” looking to exploit young people who feel that they have had an adverse experience to pursue people working in the field of gender treatment.

She said: “Many people are being called conversion therapists — myself, the right honourable Wes Streeting, the clinicians working in the new gender services and other clinicians who you have heard from during the course of this committee who are just doing careful exploratory work with teenagers.”

Cass said that another area of significant concern was that parents were being put at risk of prosecution. She said: “Not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they are going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones could fall within the reach of this bill.”

Stephanie Davies-Arai, founder of Transgender Trend, a group which has campaigned against gender-questioning children being over-medicalised, urged the government to heed Cass’s warnings.

She said: “Along with clinicians, Baroness Cass also raised concerns about the impact on parents having difficult conversations with children which may cause alarm and distress.

“As the author of a four-year independent investigation into this area Baroness Cass is best placed to understand what the unintended consequences will be of this bill and the harm that will be caused to parents and professionals working with highly distressed and vulnerable children.”

Full article - Share Token:
https://www.thetimes.com/article/34fd493d-f763-4f36-b970-8fb25cdf6789?shareToken=c5626dd066999eb8da542529e2e80306&ver=article

(The Times blocks archiving sites)

Parliament TV
https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/639bab90-c676-40d1-b822-8590848568e3

To believe that Parents must have the right to tell their children they are not “in the wrong body” and children cant be “transgender”?
To believe that Parents must have the right to tell their children they are not “in the wrong body” and children cant be “transgender”?
Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 10:54

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 17:55

BinTheConversionPracticesBill ·Today 13:53
Thank you very much. I wanted to be ready for a letter.

If, possible please would you pin point how a person who felt they had been subject to conversion practices, with an enforced exorcism, might deal with it legally? I can imagine some parents, possibly evangelical, taking a child under 16 to be exorcised and the child not daring to object yet feeling humiliated and terrified. (I would not think it right to ‘affirm’ such a child but this would not be right either.)

You do realise that most churches would refuse to preform an exorcism on anyone under almost any circumstances. And certainly not for being gay or trans.
The hypothetical child in your question would just have to tell a teacher (under current laws) or dr etc and safeguarding procedures would kick including social services and/or police depending on what was disclosed

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/11/2026 11:03

I know of one, a girl of 14, who I’m quite sure suddenly decided she was a boy, largely because it was ‘fashionable’ and she knew it’d piss her parents off, but at the same time they wouldn’t feel able (a few years ago) to say anything.

Almost needless to say, it didn’t last very long.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 17/11/2026 12:39

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/11/2026 11:03

I know of one, a girl of 14, who I’m quite sure suddenly decided she was a boy, largely because it was ‘fashionable’ and she knew it’d piss her parents off, but at the same time they wouldn’t feel able (a few years ago) to say anything.

Almost needless to say, it didn’t last very long.

It was very fashionable when my lad was at secondary. He's quite a feminine male and he was approached to join the LGBT?+++ club at lunchtimes. He was mortified that they were guessing 'what he was' and 'how he felt'. He says he isn't gay or trans just a boy who has autism and adhd who presents a little different to many boys, doesn't like typical boy things but also doesn't like typical girl things. He said he wasn't into boys or girls and so they suggested he was 'non binary'. He was upset at them for suggesting a club that he had showed no signs of being interested in.

I was disgusted that others should put this on him and make suggestions of what he may/may not be rather than let him be who he is. He is happy, he enjoyed school and didn't invite this.

I'm hoping that these types of guessing games with young people has improved in schools, but I suspect not. It was very fashionable then and a number of the young people who thought they were 'trans' aren't now, just the one lad who is now using female terms although an adult now.

ScrollingLeaves · 17/11/2026 13:32

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 10:54

You do realise that most churches would refuse to preform an exorcism on anyone under almost any circumstances. And certainly not for being gay or trans.
The hypothetical child in your question would just have to tell a teacher (under current laws) or dr etc and safeguarding procedures would kick including social services and/or police depending on what was disclosed

That’s what I would have thought. It certainly would not happen in a church I know well.

I was wondering though where all the supposed ‘conversion practices’ that have been cited happened. Or even a fraction of them. Did I see 400,000 instances mentioned? Are they all more or less lies? It all needs debunking (or not) with a real investigation.

So, I thought instances of might have occurred in super evangelical congregations.

ScrollingLeaves · 17/11/2026 13:33

ScrollingLeaves · 17/11/2026 13:32

That’s what I would have thought. It certainly would not happen in a church I know well.

I was wondering though where all the supposed ‘conversion practices’ that have been cited happened. Or even a fraction of them. Did I see 400,000 instances mentioned? Are they all more or less lies? It all needs debunking (or not) with a real investigation.

So, I thought instances of might have occurred in super evangelical congregations.

A believing child might not tell.

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 17:49

ScrollingLeaves · 17/11/2026 13:32

That’s what I would have thought. It certainly would not happen in a church I know well.

I was wondering though where all the supposed ‘conversion practices’ that have been cited happened. Or even a fraction of them. Did I see 400,000 instances mentioned? Are they all more or less lies? It all needs debunking (or not) with a real investigation.

So, I thought instances of might have occurred in super evangelical congregations.

Well according to the survey that the government is relying on the church (didn't mention which branch) is providing 24000+ anti gay exorcisms in England and Wales every single year, which btw is 10× more exorcisms than the Catholic Church provideds globally for what they believe to be actual demonic possession after medical and psychological assessments.
Oh and their conversion therapy helpline that was expected to get 15000 calls per year but had only 29 actual viable cases over 3 years.
Personally I would take any government figures on this with a dump truck of salt

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 17/11/2026 19:06

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 17/11/2026 12:39

It was very fashionable when my lad was at secondary. He's quite a feminine male and he was approached to join the LGBT?+++ club at lunchtimes. He was mortified that they were guessing 'what he was' and 'how he felt'. He says he isn't gay or trans just a boy who has autism and adhd who presents a little different to many boys, doesn't like typical boy things but also doesn't like typical girl things. He said he wasn't into boys or girls and so they suggested he was 'non binary'. He was upset at them for suggesting a club that he had showed no signs of being interested in.

I was disgusted that others should put this on him and make suggestions of what he may/may not be rather than let him be who he is. He is happy, he enjoyed school and didn't invite this.

I'm hoping that these types of guessing games with young people has improved in schools, but I suspect not. It was very fashionable then and a number of the young people who thought they were 'trans' aren't now, just the one lad who is now using female terms although an adult now.

Edited

You and your son got off very lightly from the indoctrination in schools.

I have a friend with a son who is autistic and has learning difficulties.

A "non-binary" teaching assistant has persuaded several ("innumerable" might be a better word) children that they are really the opposite sex.

However, the way her son reacted to being told that you could wake up one morning and realise you were "really" not a boy but a girl (and vice versa) was to be too terrified to go to sleep in case he woke up and had turned into a girl. When he does eventually fall asleep he wakes up screaming in terror several times during the night because of nightmares that he has turned into a girl in his sleep.

This has been going on for years now. He is inconsolable and cannot be persuaded that it is not going to happen. This is because at school he sees the proof all around him: all those other autistic children who have been told, or say, that they are "really" girls or "really" boys and have changed their names, clothes and hair cuts.

He finds this very confusing and frightening. When he has sometimes got muddled up with the new pronouns they are using, he has been told off by teachers and threatened with being excluded for "bullying".

His mother has been raising these issues with the school and the school governors for years.

They take no responsibility for the harm they have caused and the mother has been called a "bigot", saying it is her fault that her son thinks that to be "trans" is a bad thing to be scared about. Ignoring the fact that he does not understand what "trans" even means, all he is scared about is waking up finding that he has changed into a girl in his sleep.

It is horrifying and astounding that schools seem to have forgotten, or are deliberately disregarding, everything that is known about how many children with autism process information, are very literal-minded and can be easily led by adults, and how willing they are to bully children and their parents when things go badly wrong and they want to avoid shouldering responsibility.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 17/11/2026 21:32

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 17/11/2026 19:06

You and your son got off very lightly from the indoctrination in schools.

I have a friend with a son who is autistic and has learning difficulties.

A "non-binary" teaching assistant has persuaded several ("innumerable" might be a better word) children that they are really the opposite sex.

However, the way her son reacted to being told that you could wake up one morning and realise you were "really" not a boy but a girl (and vice versa) was to be too terrified to go to sleep in case he woke up and had turned into a girl. When he does eventually fall asleep he wakes up screaming in terror several times during the night because of nightmares that he has turned into a girl in his sleep.

This has been going on for years now. He is inconsolable and cannot be persuaded that it is not going to happen. This is because at school he sees the proof all around him: all those other autistic children who have been told, or say, that they are "really" girls or "really" boys and have changed their names, clothes and hair cuts.

He finds this very confusing and frightening. When he has sometimes got muddled up with the new pronouns they are using, he has been told off by teachers and threatened with being excluded for "bullying".

His mother has been raising these issues with the school and the school governors for years.

They take no responsibility for the harm they have caused and the mother has been called a "bigot", saying it is her fault that her son thinks that to be "trans" is a bad thing to be scared about. Ignoring the fact that he does not understand what "trans" even means, all he is scared about is waking up finding that he has changed into a girl in his sleep.

It is horrifying and astounding that schools seem to have forgotten, or are deliberately disregarding, everything that is known about how many children with autism process information, are very literal-minded and can be easily led by adults, and how willing they are to bully children and their parents when things go badly wrong and they want to avoid shouldering responsibility.

Wow

Cherish707 · 17/11/2026 21:37

Yanbu

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Today 09:56

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · Today 10:23

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 17/11/2026 19:06

You and your son got off very lightly from the indoctrination in schools.

I have a friend with a son who is autistic and has learning difficulties.

A "non-binary" teaching assistant has persuaded several ("innumerable" might be a better word) children that they are really the opposite sex.

However, the way her son reacted to being told that you could wake up one morning and realise you were "really" not a boy but a girl (and vice versa) was to be too terrified to go to sleep in case he woke up and had turned into a girl. When he does eventually fall asleep he wakes up screaming in terror several times during the night because of nightmares that he has turned into a girl in his sleep.

This has been going on for years now. He is inconsolable and cannot be persuaded that it is not going to happen. This is because at school he sees the proof all around him: all those other autistic children who have been told, or say, that they are "really" girls or "really" boys and have changed their names, clothes and hair cuts.

He finds this very confusing and frightening. When he has sometimes got muddled up with the new pronouns they are using, he has been told off by teachers and threatened with being excluded for "bullying".

His mother has been raising these issues with the school and the school governors for years.

They take no responsibility for the harm they have caused and the mother has been called a "bigot", saying it is her fault that her son thinks that to be "trans" is a bad thing to be scared about. Ignoring the fact that he does not understand what "trans" even means, all he is scared about is waking up finding that he has changed into a girl in his sleep.

It is horrifying and astounding that schools seem to have forgotten, or are deliberately disregarding, everything that is known about how many children with autism process information, are very literal-minded and can be easily led by adults, and how willing they are to bully children and their parents when things go badly wrong and they want to avoid shouldering responsibility.

That poor boy - that is terrible behaviour by the school. I can’t believe how badly some people have fallen for this.

I can’t see how they are so determined to support children confused about their so called ‘gender’ but are completely unable to acknowledge the opposing needs of this boy. Why can’t they see the harm they are causing him? Have they lost the power of rational thought?

Swipe left for the next trending thread