Some good news from the Oral Submissions Session at the Pre-Legislative Scrutiny Committee today!
Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law
Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’
Telegraph 16 Nov 2026
Dr Hilary Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.
Baroness Cass – who led a review into the treatment of children with gender dysphoria – said the draft Conversion Practices Bill could have “serious unintended consequences”.
Under the proposed legislation, people face up to five years in jail for putting pressure on others to change their sexual orientation or gender identity. . . .
The draft bill states that doctors cannot be performing conversion therapy “unless the person acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position”.
However, Baroness Cass said the legislation did not sufficiently define what the expected standards for medical professionals in a contested area of medicine were.
“It’s very easy for a young person who is understandably distressed after what’s inevitably a painful discussion, and possibly angry and upset that they haven’t, for example, got onto the medication pathway that they want to, to feel and report that that person has behaved in what they deem to be a very negative way,” she told MPs.
The doctor warned that there were “malign actors” who were “looking to exploit young people” and use them to “pursue” medical professionals in the field.
She also sounded the alarm about parents being “caught up” in the legislation if they refused to refer to their child by their preferred pronouns.
“I know there’s absolutely not the intent for them to be caught up in this, but that is unavoidably potentially the risk of the way in which the bill is framed,” she said.
“Things like not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they’re going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones, and all of those things could fall within the reach of this bill.”
Full article:
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/
Archive: archive.is/rP3Np
Hilary Cass withdraws backing for Labour’s conversion therapy ban
The paediatrician has warned that the legislation could expose doctors to vexatious complaints for following a cautious approach to gender dysphoria
Times 16 Nov 2026
The paediatrician who led the review of children’s gender services has withdrawn her backing for Labour’s conversion therapy ban, warning that it risked serious unintended consequences for doctors and parents.
Baroness Cass, whose review led to an overhaul of NHS services, was cited by government officials as recently as Sunday night that there was evidence of strong safeguards in the Conversion Practices Bill after concerns were raised by teachers and doctors.
However, giving evidence to a parliamentary committee on Monday, she warned that the legislation put healthcare workers, parents, Wes Streeting, the former health secretary, and even herself at risk of being accused of criminality.
The Times understands that Cass had been angered by perceived attempts to use her endorsement as a defence of the bill.
She told MPs and peers that she had only had 15 minutes to read it before giving her previous support.
Cass said: “Maybe I should not have done that, but I am supportive of trying to do something about conversion practices.”
Having now examined the proposals, she said: “I unfortunately don’t think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.”
She added: “Having seen the bill, having spoken to many families [who have] emailed me and having spoken to my colleagues, I can’t support the bill in its current form.” . . .
“At the moment we don’t have clear standards, but moreover standards are highly contested in this area,” she told the joint committee.
She said: “It’s very easy for a young person who is understandably distressed after what is inevitably a painful discussion and possibly angry and upset that they haven’t, for example, got on to the medication pathway that they want, to feel and report that person has behaved in what they deem to be a very negative way.”
Cass argued that there were also “malign actors” looking to exploit young people who feel that they have had an adverse experience to pursue people working in the field of gender treatment.
She said: “Many people are being called conversion therapists — myself, the right honourable Wes Streeting, the clinicians working in the new gender services and other clinicians who you have heard from during the course of this committee who are just doing careful exploratory work with teenagers.”
Cass said that another area of significant concern was that parents were being put at risk of prosecution. She said: “Not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they are going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones could fall within the reach of this bill.”
Stephanie Davies-Arai, founder of Transgender Trend, a group which has campaigned against gender-questioning children being over-medicalised, urged the government to heed Cass’s warnings.
She said: “Along with clinicians, Baroness Cass also raised concerns about the impact on parents having difficult conversations with children which may cause alarm and distress.
“As the author of a four-year independent investigation into this area Baroness Cass is best placed to understand what the unintended consequences will be of this bill and the harm that will be caused to parents and professionals working with highly distressed and vulnerable children.”
Full article - Share Token:
https://www.thetimes.com/article/34fd493d-f763-4f36-b970-8fb25cdf6789?shareToken=c5626dd066999eb8da542529e2e80306&ver=article
(The Times blocks archiving sites)
Parliament TV
https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/639bab90-c676-40d1-b822-8590848568e3