Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I didn’t let my husband eat the meatballs, AIBU?

606 replies

dancebabybee · 07/10/2026 18:21

My husband is an incredibly fussy eater. Basically, he will only eat beige foods and sugar. This makes going out to eat very difficult as well as cooking for him at home. There have been times in restaurants when he will complain there is NOTHING he likes on the menu (despite the menu being extensive) and he ends up eating a bread basket. I am giving you this history as it is important for what happened this evening…

I made meatballs, tomato ragu and spaghetti for dinner. Due to my husbands extreme fussy eating, I don’t usually cook for him and he is left to sort himself out. Me and the children had this for dinner. When I went into the kitchen afterwards, he had started picking at the sauce left in the pan, scooping the meatballs out, scraping the tomatoes and sauce off. I asked him whether he wanted me to make him some pasta, he said no he just wanted to eat the meatballs. I told him to please not, as it will just leave a load of sauce that nobody will want to eat without meatballs in it, and I wanted to save the spare for lunch or dinner tomorrow. He then got annoyed about this and sulked off…

AIBU?

OP posts:
SandyCastles · 12/10/2026 14:30

likelysuspect · 11/10/2026 10:35

Im thinking you just chuck them with some tuna, mackeral, ham, cheese and have them in the same format, theres no cooking involved. Im simply making suggestions, people are being very anal about this. Its not some big thing here, you wouldnt need to do a special shopping trip or special 'work'. Left over flavoured peppers are ideal for throwing in a salad for lunch the following day, putting as bruschetta topping, whizzing up and having as a sauce for something.

That would be a fair enough point if it was just a meal for her and she was actually happy to eat cold left over fajita peppers with tuna, ham or cheese (that's a big if). But in the meantime she now has to cook something else that the kids will want to eat.

If he wants plain chicken, he could have asked for her to make him some extra, rather than waste three leftover meals on one meal for himself.

LiveTheDream8998 · 14/10/2026 22:09

Ah! I'm struggling with this post.

I totally understand the idea that it wasn't tea that had been made for your husband and I appreciate that you would have wanted leftovers for the next day. I don't think there's anything wrong with these 2 facts.

BUT, I wouldn't have stopped him eating them.

There's 3 rules in our house with food:

Nobody is forced to eat something they don't like.

Nobody goes hungry.

Everyone tries their best.

If your husband had eaten meatballs (and sauce) with you as a family, would you have stopped him having seconds just because you wanted it for lunch the next day?

If he came home earlier from work than expected, would you have found food for him?

Maybe your husband was doing his best in what he was already eating.

I can understand why it might be frustrating but if it were your child genuinely struggling with food - would you not be proud of them for advocating their preferences and doing their best?

What's the difference with your husband?

If he had no problems with food- I could get on board with the idea of not wanting to generate waste - but is this, that? It doesn't sound it.

There's lots of people saying they couldn't be in a relationship with a fussy eater. That's sad. They probably don't like their fussy eating either!

(I'm not a fussy eater but I live with one)

kkloo · 15/10/2026 03:35

@LiveTheDream8998

I can understand why it might be frustrating but if it were your child genuinely struggling with food - would you not be proud of them for advocating their preferences and doing their best?

What's the difference with your husband?

He's not her child.

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 07:00

kkloo · 15/10/2026 03:35

@LiveTheDream8998

I can understand why it might be frustrating but if it were your child genuinely struggling with food - would you not be proud of them for advocating their preferences and doing their best?

What's the difference with your husband?

He's not her child.

I had a feeling someone might comment this.

Does he have to be a child to struggle with food and textures?

SouthLondonMum22 · 15/10/2026 09:35

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 07:00

I had a feeling someone might comment this.

Does he have to be a child to struggle with food and textures?

No. But OP isn't going to treat him like a child because he's her husband, not a child.

He's also an adult and knows that picking meatballs out of sauce, chicken out of fajitas and fish out of fish pie is selfish and will affect other people but does it anyway. As an adult, he is also capable of going to the shop and getting plain chicken or fish or whatever he wants.

That isn't doing his best, it's thinking of himself and only himself.

Somethinggg · 15/10/2026 09:39

LiveTheDream8998 · 14/10/2026 22:09

Ah! I'm struggling with this post.

I totally understand the idea that it wasn't tea that had been made for your husband and I appreciate that you would have wanted leftovers for the next day. I don't think there's anything wrong with these 2 facts.

BUT, I wouldn't have stopped him eating them.

There's 3 rules in our house with food:

Nobody is forced to eat something they don't like.

Nobody goes hungry.

Everyone tries their best.

If your husband had eaten meatballs (and sauce) with you as a family, would you have stopped him having seconds just because you wanted it for lunch the next day?

If he came home earlier from work than expected, would you have found food for him?

Maybe your husband was doing his best in what he was already eating.

I can understand why it might be frustrating but if it were your child genuinely struggling with food - would you not be proud of them for advocating their preferences and doing their best?

What's the difference with your husband?

If he had no problems with food- I could get on board with the idea of not wanting to generate waste - but is this, that? It doesn't sound it.

There's lots of people saying they couldn't be in a relationship with a fussy eater. That's sad. They probably don't like their fussy eating either!

(I'm not a fussy eater but I live with one)

If you have a rule that everyone tries their best, DH repeatedly ruining leftovers when asked not to whilst doing nothing towards cooking for the children is breaking it.

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 10:08

SouthLondonMum22 · 15/10/2026 09:35

No. But OP isn't going to treat him like a child because he's her husband, not a child.

He's also an adult and knows that picking meatballs out of sauce, chicken out of fajitas and fish out of fish pie is selfish and will affect other people but does it anyway. As an adult, he is also capable of going to the shop and getting plain chicken or fish or whatever he wants.

That isn't doing his best, it's thinking of himself and only himself.

Personally, I'd let it go. He obviously struggles with food and for someone who does struggle, sharing foods is difficult.

My point is that if this was someone who didnt have an issue with food and they wanted more food, you wouldn't stop them.

The husband was hungry, wanted food and ate it. He made it 'safer' for him to eat before he ate it.

Personally, I'd not be bothered if someone ate leftovers or not - at least they're eating but if OP is unhappy then yes she should talk to her husband about it.

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 10:09

Somethinggg · 15/10/2026 09:39

If you have a rule that everyone tries their best, DH repeatedly ruining leftovers when asked not to whilst doing nothing towards cooking for the children is breaking it.

Personally, I'd let it go. He obviously struggles with food and for someone who does struggle, sharing foods is difficult.

My point is that if this was someone who didnt have an issue with food and they wanted more food, you wouldn't stop them.

The husband was hungry, wanted food and ate it. He made it 'safer' for him to eat before he ate it.

Personally, I'd not be bothered if someone ate leftovers or not - at least they're eating but if OP is unhappy then yes she should talk to her husband about it.

CreativeGreen · 15/10/2026 10:17

LiveTheDream8998 · 14/10/2026 22:09

Ah! I'm struggling with this post.

I totally understand the idea that it wasn't tea that had been made for your husband and I appreciate that you would have wanted leftovers for the next day. I don't think there's anything wrong with these 2 facts.

BUT, I wouldn't have stopped him eating them.

There's 3 rules in our house with food:

Nobody is forced to eat something they don't like.

Nobody goes hungry.

Everyone tries their best.

If your husband had eaten meatballs (and sauce) with you as a family, would you have stopped him having seconds just because you wanted it for lunch the next day?

If he came home earlier from work than expected, would you have found food for him?

Maybe your husband was doing his best in what he was already eating.

I can understand why it might be frustrating but if it were your child genuinely struggling with food - would you not be proud of them for advocating their preferences and doing their best?

What's the difference with your husband?

If he had no problems with food- I could get on board with the idea of not wanting to generate waste - but is this, that? It doesn't sound it.

There's lots of people saying they couldn't be in a relationship with a fussy eater. That's sad. They probably don't like their fussy eating either!

(I'm not a fussy eater but I live with one)

Hmm, yes, what is the difference between your child and your husband?

My answer would be, quite a lot. But many posters on here seem to think it's the same thing. Which I find quite depressing.

CreativeGreen · 15/10/2026 10:19

"Maybe he was doing his best" 😂

By taking food from the side and picking bits out of it? Who was he 'doing his best' for exactly? Himself alone, I would say.

dentydown · 15/10/2026 10:26

I would ask him if he liked them, and then ask him if he wanted me to make extra next time so he could have plain meatballs.

CreativeGreen · 15/10/2026 10:47

dentydown · 15/10/2026 10:26

I would ask him if he liked them, and then ask him if he wanted me to make extra next time so he could have plain meatballs.

He clearly likes them! He nicked the ones that were for other people's meals! Bollocks to the 'would you like me to spend extra time preparing more for you', frankly.

This thread is like stepping back to the 1960s. In Stepford.

Somethinggg · 15/10/2026 11:15

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 10:09

Personally, I'd let it go. He obviously struggles with food and for someone who does struggle, sharing foods is difficult.

My point is that if this was someone who didnt have an issue with food and they wanted more food, you wouldn't stop them.

The husband was hungry, wanted food and ate it. He made it 'safer' for him to eat before he ate it.

Personally, I'd not be bothered if someone ate leftovers or not - at least they're eating but if OP is unhappy then yes she should talk to her husband about it.

Have you not read the posts about him making a habit of ruining leftovers despite being asked not to, and doing nothing towards cooking his children proper food? She has talked a lot to him and he doesn't give enough of a shit to listen. It can't be that hard for him to share food when he makes a habit of poking through things cooked by one person for several others. He'll share when it's convenient and do his own thing when it isn't.

You might not stop an adult doing this, but actually a great many of us would.

SouthLondonMum22 · 15/10/2026 11:18

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 10:08

Personally, I'd let it go. He obviously struggles with food and for someone who does struggle, sharing foods is difficult.

My point is that if this was someone who didnt have an issue with food and they wanted more food, you wouldn't stop them.

The husband was hungry, wanted food and ate it. He made it 'safer' for him to eat before he ate it.

Personally, I'd not be bothered if someone ate leftovers or not - at least they're eating but if OP is unhappy then yes she should talk to her husband about it.

Other food in the house was available and again, as an adult, he was also capable of going to the shop for more food. There was absolutely no need to take the meatballs or eat fish out of a fish pie or the chicken out of the fajitas and ruining meals for others.

Again, he's a grown man. You act like he was a starving child with no other option but to eat the meatballs which wasn't the case.

OP has already asked him not to do it but he does it anyway.

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 17:54

CreativeGreen · 15/10/2026 10:17

Hmm, yes, what is the difference between your child and your husband?

My answer would be, quite a lot. But many posters on here seem to think it's the same thing. Which I find quite depressing.

No. Some people really struggle with food. The OP has said he only eats beige food. Now you might say well that's very childlike (and there are many children who do eat beige and plain foods... they then go on to eat a more rounded diet and it isn't a problem)

Some people REALLY struggle to eat foods that have different textures or flavours and despite what anyone says this is a true lifelong struggle. It sounds to me like this grown man is genuinely struggling with textures and flavours and so yes if he wanted to eat meatballs and no sauce in my house then I personally wouldn't have an issue with it.

If he was capable of eating fishpie or meatballs in sauce and decided to disect it for the sake of it then this is a totally different story but the OP said herself that he generally prefers beige foods. You either support someone with that - or you don't. I'd rather support.

Now - if a child was to eat a new food you wouldn't discourage, would you?

kkloo · 15/10/2026 20:22

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 07:00

I had a feeling someone might comment this.

Does he have to be a child to struggle with food and textures?

No, but he'd have to be a child for me to think ah bless him I'm so proud of him advocating for his food preferences while he rooted around in a fish pie to take the fish out.

CreativeGreen · 16/10/2026 11:14

LiveTheDream8998 · 15/10/2026 17:54

No. Some people really struggle with food. The OP has said he only eats beige food. Now you might say well that's very childlike (and there are many children who do eat beige and plain foods... they then go on to eat a more rounded diet and it isn't a problem)

Some people REALLY struggle to eat foods that have different textures or flavours and despite what anyone says this is a true lifelong struggle. It sounds to me like this grown man is genuinely struggling with textures and flavours and so yes if he wanted to eat meatballs and no sauce in my house then I personally wouldn't have an issue with it.

If he was capable of eating fishpie or meatballs in sauce and decided to disect it for the sake of it then this is a totally different story but the OP said herself that he generally prefers beige foods. You either support someone with that - or you don't. I'd rather support.

Now - if a child was to eat a new food you wouldn't discourage, would you?

If a child wandered into the kitchen and picked out one bit of something that wasn’t for them, I’d tell them not to because that’s rude and selfish, fussy or not.

Since this man isn’t a child, I’m not sure why that’s relevant though

I’m not an entirely unfussy eater myself (though my kids weren’t and aren’t fussy), but I would never do what this man did, because it’s rude and selfish.

LiveTheDream8998 · 16/10/2026 11:18

kkloo · 15/10/2026 20:22

No, but he'd have to be a child for me to think ah bless him I'm so proud of him advocating for his food preferences while he rooted around in a fish pie to take the fish out.

If he ate fish pie with sauce and had no issues previously- then yes, I'd agree.

But I'd have no issues with him taking a fish or meatballs and eating that if he fancied it and genuinely struggled with the sauce.

I think if I was in OP's shoes I'd be having a chat along the lines of - we're having fishpie today, would you like deconstructed fishpie or prefer a different meal altogether?

You either accept the issues around foods and work with him or work against him. I wouldn't want him feeling like he can't access food he wants to eat or that he can't adapt foods he dislikes.

It's quite obvious that people are finding this a difficult concept but it's really quite simple to me.

As I said, I live with someone who really genuinely struggles with textures and flavours. I see their struggle, I know it's not exaggerated or dramatised and I'm proud of how they gently challenge themselves and LOVE it when they try something new and realise they like it. I see the struggle it took to even try it in the first place but to enjoy the food too - absolutely gold!

You're never going to convince me that allowing someone with these difficulties a safe space and environment is not a good idea.

So, yes, if he's previously eaten it with the sauce and had no issues - fair cop that picking out the meatballs or fish is kind of uncalled for... but if that's not the case and he struggles with sauces for goodness sake just let him eat the food the way he wanted.

Now - if you've saved food for tomorrow and told him and then he ate it - yes, he shouldn't have taken it.

But honestly, my take is to just let him eat the food. Communicate better. Discuss meals.

CreativeGreen · 16/10/2026 11:20

You either accept the issues around foods and work with him or work against him. I wouldn't want him feeling like he can't access food he wants to eat or that he can't adapt foods he dislikes.

She has accepted it and they have a policy that he'll see to his own meals (except when what's on the side for later catches his eyes and he decides to snaffle it). He can 'access food' and the policy is for him to enable that access and have agency over it. That is not the same as just taking stuff that's for someone else.

CreativeGreen · 16/10/2026 11:22

It just keeps coming back to people infantilising this man and suggesting the OP should dedicate loads of time to asking him exactly what special thing he'd like, or what parts of what she's made he would like to pick out and leave the spoils for the rest of them. She's not his mother, and even if she were, I'd argue that would be going rather far.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/10/2026 11:46

LiveTheDream8998 · 16/10/2026 11:18

If he ate fish pie with sauce and had no issues previously- then yes, I'd agree.

But I'd have no issues with him taking a fish or meatballs and eating that if he fancied it and genuinely struggled with the sauce.

I think if I was in OP's shoes I'd be having a chat along the lines of - we're having fishpie today, would you like deconstructed fishpie or prefer a different meal altogether?

You either accept the issues around foods and work with him or work against him. I wouldn't want him feeling like he can't access food he wants to eat or that he can't adapt foods he dislikes.

It's quite obvious that people are finding this a difficult concept but it's really quite simple to me.

As I said, I live with someone who really genuinely struggles with textures and flavours. I see their struggle, I know it's not exaggerated or dramatised and I'm proud of how they gently challenge themselves and LOVE it when they try something new and realise they like it. I see the struggle it took to even try it in the first place but to enjoy the food too - absolutely gold!

You're never going to convince me that allowing someone with these difficulties a safe space and environment is not a good idea.

So, yes, if he's previously eaten it with the sauce and had no issues - fair cop that picking out the meatballs or fish is kind of uncalled for... but if that's not the case and he struggles with sauces for goodness sake just let him eat the food the way he wanted.

Now - if you've saved food for tomorrow and told him and then he ate it - yes, he shouldn't have taken it.

But honestly, my take is to just let him eat the food. Communicate better. Discuss meals.

But they have discussed it, at length, and it was decided that he would sort out his own food and for him to not pick at food not meant for him. He has ignored this multiple times.

Why wouldn't he be able to access food when other food is available (the microwave meals he generally lives on) or because he's an adult, he can go to the shop and get chicken or whatever himself? I don't understand why you seem to think his only option to eat is to pick out chicken, meatballs or fish?

LiveTheDream8998 · 16/10/2026 12:23

CreativeGreen · 16/10/2026 11:20

You either accept the issues around foods and work with him or work against him. I wouldn't want him feeling like he can't access food he wants to eat or that he can't adapt foods he dislikes.

She has accepted it and they have a policy that he'll see to his own meals (except when what's on the side for later catches his eyes and he decides to snaffle it). He can 'access food' and the policy is for him to enable that access and have agency over it. That is not the same as just taking stuff that's for someone else.

I can see that we're going to disagree here.

There needs to be communication with the OP and her husband as to what they wish and want meals and meal times to look like.

Random people on the Internet can only offer their opinion.

Personally, if someone who generally struggles with eating new / different foods wanted to try some of what I had made then I wouldn't be upset, I'd be encouraging and supportive whether they were a child or an adult and regardless of any "policy".

That's my opinion.

If the OP is unhappy at how frequently this is happening then she needs to talk to her husband about how to go forwards and make it work for everyone.

It sounds like mum and kids sort themselves out and dad is left to sort himself out- I'd want to be including Dad as much as possible and making that my new "policy".

Again, I live with someone who struggles with food textures so I also understand the "freedom " of eating your own desired foods and not sticking to someone else's preferences ALL the time. Balance.

Communication is needed. And a bit of patience, inclusion and understanding. 🙂

CreativeGreen · 16/10/2026 12:33

No need for the quotes around 'policy' - if you prefer, substitute 'plan' or 'way of going on', whatever.

They have communicated. The husband has communicated that he is happy with a limited range of food and will sort that out himself. OP has communicated that she'd rather he not pick the protein element out of a dish that is for everyone and leave them the rest.

He didn't 'want to try' some of what she'd made, he just took it. It would be different if he'd said, 'hey, I feel like expanding my palate, would it be alright if I bravely took a meatball and wiped the sauce off, or do you have plans for them?' But he just took it, having previously included himself right out of the meal.

Maybe he needs to practice his own communication and understanding? He's not a baby and OP is not his mother. If you're adult enough to get married and have children, you're adult enough not to behave like this around other people's food, no matter how you behave about your own.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/10/2026 12:51

LiveTheDream8998 · 16/10/2026 12:23

I can see that we're going to disagree here.

There needs to be communication with the OP and her husband as to what they wish and want meals and meal times to look like.

Random people on the Internet can only offer their opinion.

Personally, if someone who generally struggles with eating new / different foods wanted to try some of what I had made then I wouldn't be upset, I'd be encouraging and supportive whether they were a child or an adult and regardless of any "policy".

That's my opinion.

If the OP is unhappy at how frequently this is happening then she needs to talk to her husband about how to go forwards and make it work for everyone.

It sounds like mum and kids sort themselves out and dad is left to sort himself out- I'd want to be including Dad as much as possible and making that my new "policy".

Again, I live with someone who struggles with food textures so I also understand the "freedom " of eating your own desired foods and not sticking to someone else's preferences ALL the time. Balance.

Communication is needed. And a bit of patience, inclusion and understanding. 🙂

It's as if you haven't even read any of OP's comments and are just automatically defending DH because your DH is also a picky eater.

OP's DH complained when she did the cooking which is how the current agreement came about. Just taking food when that isn't the agreement isn't communication, it's taking what you want with no regards to anyone else including his own children.

LiveTheDream8998 · 16/10/2026 13:15

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/10/2026 12:51

It's as if you haven't even read any of OP's comments and are just automatically defending DH because your DH is also a picky eater.

OP's DH complained when she did the cooking which is how the current agreement came about. Just taking food when that isn't the agreement isn't communication, it's taking what you want with no regards to anyone else including his own children.

It isn't my husband who struggles with food.

You miss my point. It's ok 🙂