Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 16:38

Posted on X by Mia Hughes ……in response to a post from a trans person who says trans men and women should not all be lumped into one group as their journey to trans vary wildly.

Naturally I take this one giant step further. What actually needs to happen is the medical world needs to rid itself of "trans" as a concept.
Stop medicalising a political fiction. Stop treating a category of person that does not exist.
Take all the individuals who show up seeking these drastic medical treatments and find out why each one believes they need to destroy their healthy body.
If he's an autogynephilic man, try to help him manage his sexual urges.
If the person is a gender-nonconforming homosexual, help them find ways to cope that doesn't involve having body parts chopped off as a way to blend into society and be invisible.
If it's one of the ROGD cohort, give them the time and space they need to grow and mature and figure out who they are.
The medical world needs to face up to the fact that they were duped by a bunch of fanatics who created an alternate reality where the whole world had to live inside their mental disorder.
It's long past time for a return to actual reality.

cryupmykingdom · 17/11/2026 16:57

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 13:53

A patient can request a different health provider for any reason.

Obviously I reject your muddled use of language like "man who believes he's a woman", so I can't really help further.

'Man who believes he is a woman' is a very clear concept with plenty of tangible proofs supporting existence of the concept, in concrete form.

Feel free to unmuddle yourself.

It's adjacent to the transers who somehow believe they 'pass'. When of course they never do outside of an airbrushed image or very, very edited video.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 17:13

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 17/11/2026 16:38

Ditto, sports.
Ditto, prisons.
Ditto, refuges.
Cue obfuscating language, transwomen just as at risk as women, opportunities mean as much to transwomen as women, transwomen just as disadvanted as women.
Only at the very margins of the debate may there be any delineation.
Or so you'd think, but no.
Laurel Hubbard and Imane Khelif in women's sport.
Our assorted rapists in women's jails.
The consultant in the Darlington Nurses changing room.
Even then, there was no debate from TRAs.
So awaiting "when DOES it matter?" will be a very long wait.
Because if it didn't matter in those instances, then it won't anywhere else.

Just because our visitors will pick up on the one error to write the rest off too it was a (male) nurse in Darlington and junior Doctor (sorry can't remember what we they are called now) in Fife. Neither case was a consultant.

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 17:13

I think Lacksie is demonstrating very well that there is no possibility ever of agreement on this. There is no point to the argument, it is never resolvable.

Where activists insist that men are women and are absolutely blind to the realities of sex and the needs of women, gender critical women who want single sex spaces will never see a man as anything other than a man, and expect single sex spaces to not permit entry to him. Only one of these is based on actual fact, but whatever. If there was any real truth to this, no one would know what 'trans' meant and the word wouldn't matter. In this sense, it literally means 'man who identifies as' or 'is not actually a'.

The obvious only possible solution is to provide accessible spaces for men who believe they are women, and for women who require spaces free of any and all men. An accessible space for all, an agreement to disagree and to live in parallel. And this requires men accepting that not everything is for them.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2026 17:26

And this requires men accepting that not everything is for them.

Good luck with that.

The obvious only possible solution is to provide accessible spaces for men who believe they are women,

But for men who believe they are women pushing into the spaces of biological women is the whole point. Where's the fun in their own spaces when they can bully, intimidate and override the wishes of women to have their own spaces? ironically, of course, demonstrating they're the sort of men who need to be kept well away from those spaces in the first place.

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 17:34

Lacksie thinks we are all blobs blobbing around interchangeably and there’s no need to make any differentiation at any time for any reason. Unfortunately the world doesn’t work like that.

RedToothBrush · 17/11/2026 18:01

How can you tell transwomen are men? By the sheer amount they tell women to suck it up and put up and how they shouldn't be allowed to define themselves or their own needs.

Funny isn't it!

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2026 18:03

RedToothBrush · 17/11/2026 18:01

How can you tell transwomen are men? By the sheer amount they tell women to suck it up and put up and how they shouldn't be allowed to define themselves or their own needs.

Funny isn't it!

And very male.

GailBlancheViola · 17/11/2026 18:06

cryupmykingdom · 17/11/2026 16:57

'Man who believes he is a woman' is a very clear concept with plenty of tangible proofs supporting existence of the concept, in concrete form.

Feel free to unmuddle yourself.

It's adjacent to the transers who somehow believe they 'pass'. When of course they never do outside of an airbrushed image or very, very edited video.

Edited

It is unintentionally hilarious that @Lacksie is gettting irate at the the phrase Man who believes he is a woman when Lacksie has said this on this very thread:

Trans women, however, occasionally do use female services, especially if they pass, because they understand themselves to be women,

The contradictions, sheer illogicality and general twisting from TRAs and their acolytes in their 'arguments' proves just how ridiculous said 'arguments' are.

The sheer desperation to get men and boys into spaces used by women and girls, which is what all this boils down to, is illuminating. Not a single TRA or any of their acolytes will ever honestly answer why they want to force women and girls to remove their clothes in front of men and boys.

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:13

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 16:38

Posted on X by Mia Hughes ……in response to a post from a trans person who says trans men and women should not all be lumped into one group as their journey to trans vary wildly.

Naturally I take this one giant step further. What actually needs to happen is the medical world needs to rid itself of "trans" as a concept.
Stop medicalising a political fiction. Stop treating a category of person that does not exist.
Take all the individuals who show up seeking these drastic medical treatments and find out why each one believes they need to destroy their healthy body.
If he's an autogynephilic man, try to help him manage his sexual urges.
If the person is a gender-nonconforming homosexual, help them find ways to cope that doesn't involve having body parts chopped off as a way to blend into society and be invisible.
If it's one of the ROGD cohort, give them the time and space they need to grow and mature and figure out who they are.
The medical world needs to face up to the fact that they were duped by a bunch of fanatics who created an alternate reality where the whole world had to live inside their mental disorder.
It's long past time for a return to actual reality.

Any views @Lacksie ?

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:26

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 17:13

I think Lacksie is demonstrating very well that there is no possibility ever of agreement on this. There is no point to the argument, it is never resolvable.

Where activists insist that men are women and are absolutely blind to the realities of sex and the needs of women, gender critical women who want single sex spaces will never see a man as anything other than a man, and expect single sex spaces to not permit entry to him. Only one of these is based on actual fact, but whatever. If there was any real truth to this, no one would know what 'trans' meant and the word wouldn't matter. In this sense, it literally means 'man who identifies as' or 'is not actually a'.

The obvious only possible solution is to provide accessible spaces for men who believe they are women, and for women who require spaces free of any and all men. An accessible space for all, an agreement to disagree and to live in parallel. And this requires men accepting that not everything is for them.

Edited

Lacksie demonstrates something else. The absolute mental gymnastics and faux (presumably) ignorance needed to hold some kind of 'inclusive' position.

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW. They have also said, I believe, that transpeople know what sex they are. Therefore they know that a transwoman is neither a woman or female. Yet when the question is "if a woman asks for a woman to examine her can she mean a woman or should she accept a man who believes himself to be a woman?", rather than just answer the very obvious substance of the question - i.e. "is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician" - they come back with the "A patient can request a different health provider for any reason". They know that wasn't the question. Then move to examining the minutiae of the phrasing "Obviously I reject your muddled use of language blahdiblah".

Lacksie could have just said "I wouldn't phrase it as a 'man pretending to be a woman' , but if you mean is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician, then no", (because that is surely their position given their previous statements). Or alternatively maybe they would say "yes" because their position has no consistency or coherency. Who knows at this stage. Maybe they're just another of those debate perverts.

DeanElderberry · 17/11/2026 18:28

There was a post on a thread last week from someone obviously very pro trans stating that transmen should stay out of gay men's spaces to avoid making the men uncomfortable. I don't know whether there was further discussion, but I was fascinated by the proposition that not only should women accept invasion by men calling themselves transwomen, but women calling themselves transmen should refrain from invading men's spaces.

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:28

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:26

Lacksie demonstrates something else. The absolute mental gymnastics and faux (presumably) ignorance needed to hold some kind of 'inclusive' position.

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW. They have also said, I believe, that transpeople know what sex they are. Therefore they know that a transwoman is neither a woman or female. Yet when the question is "if a woman asks for a woman to examine her can she mean a woman or should she accept a man who believes himself to be a woman?", rather than just answer the very obvious substance of the question - i.e. "is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician" - they come back with the "A patient can request a different health provider for any reason". They know that wasn't the question. Then move to examining the minutiae of the phrasing "Obviously I reject your muddled use of language blahdiblah".

Lacksie could have just said "I wouldn't phrase it as a 'man pretending to be a woman' , but if you mean is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician, then no", (because that is surely their position given their previous statements). Or alternatively maybe they would say "yes" because their position has no consistency or coherency. Who knows at this stage. Maybe they're just another of those debate perverts.

Ooh I had forgotten the self admission from @Lacksie describing themselves as ’debate pervert’ well recalled @BackToLurk

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:32

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:28

Ooh I had forgotten the self admission from @Lacksie describing themselves as ’debate pervert’ well recalled @BackToLurk

Edited

I'm not sure that was them. I think that was the inveterate name changer - who I think is someone else. Again though, who knows.

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:34

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:32

I'm not sure that was them. I think that was the inveterate name changer - who I think is someone else. Again though, who knows.

Ah ok. Sorry.

solerolover · 17/11/2026 18:48

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:32

I'm not sure that was them. I think that was the inveterate name changer - who I think is someone else. Again though, who knows.

Yeah, the self proclaimed "debate pervert" is ChoppingGoodGretelAishaTottenhamaEmilyNorthernDevonshireBaileyCaprioskaHowseIcelandicnightsBeePattiesFairgoMagnetaSkyCoolforKats. Lacksie gives me strong Tandora vibes.

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:51

solerolover · 17/11/2026 18:48

Yeah, the self proclaimed "debate pervert" is ChoppingGoodGretelAishaTottenhamaEmilyNorthernDevonshireBaileyCaprioskaHowseIcelandicnightsBeePattiesFairgoMagnetaSkyCoolforKats. Lacksie gives me strong Tandora vibes.

Ah yes - thank you @solerolover and @BackToLurk

Still - ‘debate pervert’ is an addition to the bingo card of nonsense and verbal gymnastics

Tears0fTheMushroom · 17/11/2026 18:57

solerolover · 17/11/2026 18:48

Yeah, the self proclaimed "debate pervert" is ChoppingGoodGretelAishaTottenhamaEmilyNorthernDevonshireBaileyCaprioskaHowseIcelandicnightsBeePattiesFairgoMagnetaSkyCoolforKats. Lacksie gives me strong Tandora vibes.

I love how we all have a slightly different version of the amalgamation of usernames. I'm sure between us we manage to cover all of them 😁

RedToothBrush · 17/11/2026 19:07

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:51

Ah yes - thank you @solerolover and @BackToLurk

Still - ‘debate pervert’ is an addition to the bingo card of nonsense and verbal gymnastics

Edited

We are a society who watched Russell Brand violate sexual boundaries and boast about his sexual prowess for years.

I don't see why we shouldn't be 'debating pervert' in the context of the high number of sexual offenders who have declared themselves trans and the number of males who invade female spaces and then make a massive song and dance about it on social media. Or the males who wear highly sexualised clothes that no woman would even consider wearing in public.

It's almost as if we don't want to see what's staring us in the face as a society and not even being subtle about the sexualised motivations.

The face this gets panned as even a possibility by calling it transphobic is startling.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:26

Lacksie demonstrates something else. The absolute mental gymnastics and faux (presumably) ignorance needed to hold some kind of 'inclusive' position.

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW. They have also said, I believe, that transpeople know what sex they are. Therefore they know that a transwoman is neither a woman or female. Yet when the question is "if a woman asks for a woman to examine her can she mean a woman or should she accept a man who believes himself to be a woman?", rather than just answer the very obvious substance of the question - i.e. "is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician" - they come back with the "A patient can request a different health provider for any reason". They know that wasn't the question. Then move to examining the minutiae of the phrasing "Obviously I reject your muddled use of language blahdiblah".

Lacksie could have just said "I wouldn't phrase it as a 'man pretending to be a woman' , but if you mean is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician, then no", (because that is surely their position given their previous statements). Or alternatively maybe they would say "yes" because their position has no consistency or coherency. Who knows at this stage. Maybe they're just another of those debate perverts.

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:37

BlueLegume · 17/11/2026 18:51

Ah yes - thank you @solerolover and @BackToLurk

Still - ‘debate pervert’ is an addition to the bingo card of nonsense and verbal gymnastics

Edited

whats a "debate pervert"?
I've never said anything of the sort.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 19:40

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Edited

So Eddie-Su Izzard isn't trans then? Because his feeling of womanhood, ahh sorry 'girl mode' isn't constant, it disappears at the drop of casting call.

StealthTroublemaker · 17/11/2026 19:42

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Edited

But hold on, you have said TIM should be excluded from some women’s sports and spaces. If you believe TIM are women ,why would you exclude some women from Women’s spaces and sports? Either TIM are women and belong in all spaces women are allowed, or they are not women and do not belong in any female spaces. Which is it?

StealthTroublemaker · 17/11/2026 19:43

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:37

whats a "debate pervert"?
I've never said anything of the sort.

Describes you perfectly. So stealing that.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 19:49

StealthTroublemaker · 17/11/2026 19:42

But hold on, you have said TIM should be excluded from some women’s sports and spaces. If you believe TIM are women ,why would you exclude some women from Women’s spaces and sports? Either TIM are women and belong in all spaces women are allowed, or they are not women and do not belong in any female spaces. Which is it?

Lacksie has actually been very coy on where sex does matter (I.e. where women can expect male free spaces) so far we've had some medical situations but only where the patent doesn't have the anatomy required for a treatment , not the biological sex of the caregiver. In other words no smear tests for men, no prostate exams for women. How very generous to allow us to not share the unsharable!

Swipe left for the next trending thread