Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
RareGoalsVerge · 17/11/2026 09:19

Coatsoff42 · 16/11/2026 20:34

Yes, I think the problem with that was that only people with plenty of money and good underlying health can have some of the surgeries, so if you are a medicalist, you only allow the richest and healthiest people to live their fantasies, and the poor and sick people are stuck in reality.

Absolutely. Any threshold of minimum amount of surgeries or medication effects needed in order to be considered "woman" is intrinsically unethical, and ringfences rights to only be accorded to the afluent and articulate. It's discriminatory in a far more problematic way. It also railroads people towards surgeries and medications that might not be the right choice for any given individual, by creating an arbitrary "finish line" which therefore obviously becomes a goal.

One does not "become" a transwoman by a gradual process. One IS a transwoman - perhaps only recognised as such from the moment of declaring oneself trans, but that is a moment of discovering something that was always true, not a moment of becoming.

The rights of access to services spaces and opportunities that are accorded to transwomen must therefore be the same for the very wealthiest who can afford the most accurate facial feminisation plastic surgery as they are for someone with no access to surgery or medication and whose status as someone male is very obvious. It is clealy unjust and inequitable to reserve rights to some but not others within the category of transwomen.

Trans rights are the rights that are correctly given to all trans individuals. A "right" that is given only to those who (by some as yet indefinable and difficult to define standard) "pass" cannot be a "right".

There's a parallel with the struggle for Black Rights in the USA - thinking of films and stories I've seen about mixed race people with pale enough skin to "pass" hiding their origins and living "as if they were white" - that's not any kind of progress towards rights, it's abhorrent. Similarly for gay rights - being able to convincingly "appear" to be heterosexual in order to gain rights is no basis for liberation. There is nothing wrong with a trans person being trans, it should not need to be hidden or disguised.

This does mean that in circumstances where material sex is important, decisions must be based on the material physical facts of a person's sex, regardless of any body modifications they may or may not have chosen. The debate is not about the validity or humanity of trans people but about which circumstances this should apply to. Circumstances where the material physical facts of a person's sex is unimportant should not be divided into mens and womens versions at all.

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 09:30

2021x · 17/11/2026 06:33

TW must be seen as a group because women cannot assess risk based on individual characteristics. You are assessing this from the TW point of view and haven't thought about the female point of view.

Criterion 1: Upper Body Strength. It is theoretically - in fact easily - possible for a person born male to attain the upper body strength of a woman: a starvation muscle-unsparing diet (possibly with added fat?) should accomplish that, albeit with the risk of death (the heart is also a muscle) although some would consider that worth the risk. As for bone strength, osteoporosis can be induced with calcium gradually leached from the bone thru diet and - in extremis - time in orbit (osteoporosis is a problem with astronauts). That is achievable for the individual- this is incorrect. This is also pointless, as if a TW was starving, they would be in hospital.

Criterion 2: Crime. A trans woman who has committed no crime meets this criterion- most men have not committed any crime, but transwomen commit crime against women at the same rate as other men.

Criteria 3. and 4. Employment and assault/death. Trans women prostitutes, particularly in poorer countries, would meet these criteria easily. Poorer trans women also have a larger chance. For trans people in the real world, it isn't all lollygagging about getting asspats from woke activists ("so stunning and brave"), and getting the shit kicked out of you is a thing- not sure of your point at all with this. Transwomen are in leadership postitions closer to the rate of men, rather than the rate of women. Transmen experience the same level of violent death/assault the same rate as other women, rather than men.

Criteria 5. Suicide. No one can meet this criterion and survive. Although some may consider their death an acceptable cost if transition is recognised - ie "better dead than male"- Men experience a rate of fatal suicide attempts 7x higher than women. If a transman were really a man, I would expect the rate of fatal suicide attempts to be within the range of men, not the range of women.

Overall, I think you have misunderstood all my arguments. If gender really was an internalised identity not caused by environmental expectations, then it would be borne out in the behavioural data.

For women to feel safe with ANY males, they would need to not be significantly stronger and significantly more likely to commit violent crime. Until TW statistics are within the female range, sharing same sex spaces should not even be considered.

My point about upper body strength is not incorrect. Consider the following:

  • In the firm "The Machinist" in 2004, the 6-foot-tall actor Christian Bale dieted down to 120 pounds (8 stone 8 pounds in old money) and was not hospitalised
  • Trans women going through an anorexic/bulimic period in their teens or twenties happens so often it's a cliche, and are not hospitalised

Regarding your point about "misunderstanding all your arguments": well possibly (I genuinely don't know) but my argument is that it is perfectly possible for an individual trans woman to meet your criteria.

File:BaleMachine.jpg - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:BaleMachine.jpg

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 09:36

@RareGoalsVerge I note your point that "...There is nothing wrong with a trans person being trans, it should not need to be hidden or disguised...", but there appears to be a considerably large number of British people who believe that there is a lot wrong with people being trans and that at the least it should be hidden or disguised.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 09:50

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 09:36

@RareGoalsVerge I note your point that "...There is nothing wrong with a trans person being trans, it should not need to be hidden or disguised...", but there appears to be a considerably large number of British people who believe that there is a lot wrong with people being trans and that at the least it should be hidden or disguised.

People naturally want privacy - it doesn't mean they think there is anything wrong with being trans. It's like any other personal aspect to do with the body/ medical information, you don't necessarily share it with everyone and sundry!

Catiette · 17/11/2026 09:57

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 09:30

My point about upper body strength is not incorrect. Consider the following:

  • In the firm "The Machinist" in 2004, the 6-foot-tall actor Christian Bale dieted down to 120 pounds (8 stone 8 pounds in old money) and was not hospitalised
  • Trans women going through an anorexic/bulimic period in their teens or twenties happens so often it's a cliche, and are not hospitalised

Regarding your point about "misunderstanding all your arguments": well possibly (I genuinely don't know) but my argument is that it is perfectly possible for an individual trans woman to meet your criteria.

You seem to be equating loss of weight with loss of strength. It's very commonly known that a man and a woman at the same weight have starkly different strengths. In this respect, your muscly image speaks a thousand words.

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 10:32

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 09:50

People naturally want privacy - it doesn't mean they think there is anything wrong with being trans. It's like any other personal aspect to do with the body/ medical information, you don't necessarily share it with everyone and sundry!

Agreed, no one needs to disclose whatever plastic surgeries or medical treatments they have had. No one has to dress or present a particular way in general life.
When sex matters, that’s all that matters. It’s not complicated.

CassOle · 17/11/2026 10:35

Your actual sex which you shall always be isn't 'medical history'. What an odd way to frame it.

ETA - I should have typed 'medical information'.

bellinisurge · 17/11/2026 10:36

I don’t give a shit if a bloke had had his dick cut off and is better groomed than I am. He knows what sex he is. It is only his sex that matters. If he wants some additional male toilet provision to keep him safe from other men, maybe he shouldn’t have spent the last ten years bullying and gaslighting women into giving up their spaces. He could have lobbied for additional spaces for men. I might even have supported his battle.
Now, I don’t care as long as he stays out of my spaces. He can fight his own battles

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 10:39

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 09:50

People naturally want privacy - it doesn't mean they think there is anything wrong with being trans. It's like any other personal aspect to do with the body/ medical information, you don't necessarily share it with everyone and sundry!

And if a man who is trans identified doesn't force himself on women and thereby create a problem for others, his personal business can remain entirely his own. If he chooses to make it into an issue affecting others however...

FrippEnos · 17/11/2026 10:46

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 09:36

@RareGoalsVerge I note your point that "...There is nothing wrong with a trans person being trans, it should not need to be hidden or disguised...", but there appears to be a considerably large number of British people who believe that there is a lot wrong with people being trans and that at the least it should be hidden or disguised.

Do you have any evidence of this?
Or are you confusing people fighting for women's and children's rights with Trans propaganda?

Flickitspinittwistitbopit · 17/11/2026 10:47

A lobotomy.
🤯

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 10:52

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 10:32

Agreed, no one needs to disclose whatever plastic surgeries or medical treatments they have had. No one has to dress or present a particular way in general life.
When sex matters, that’s all that matters. It’s not complicated.

Thing is it is complicated. So is sex and so is when , how and why it matters.

Life isn't black and white.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 10:58

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 10:39

And if a man who is trans identified doesn't force himself on women and thereby create a problem for others, his personal business can remain entirely his own. If he chooses to make it into an issue affecting others however...

Problem is that you have defined "force himself on women" as being present in a public space when you've decided you don't want them there.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 11:00

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 10:58

Problem is that you have defined "force himself on women" as being present in a public space when you've decided you don't want them there.

Being present in a wrong sex single sex space not a 'public space' noone cares if there is a transwoman in the queue at the post office or having a coffee in Costa or on a bus.

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 11:38

If a space is excluding some people then by definition it's not 'public'.

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 11:49

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 10:52

Thing is it is complicated. So is sex and so is when , how and why it matters.

Life isn't black and white.

But sex does sometimes matter. I’m glad we agree.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2026 11:57

RedToothBrush · 16/11/2026 20:36

By climbing up onto the mantelpiece and going through a mirror to a world where reality is different and you can magically change sex.

Lewis Carroll wouldn't know where to start with this thread if he wanted to write about the issues. Talk about an abundance of basic material.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 12:29

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 11:00

Being present in a wrong sex single sex space not a 'public space' noone cares if there is a transwoman in the queue at the post office or having a coffee in Costa or on a bus.

It isn’t your private property. It’s a shared space,l. You’ve defined “forcing yourself on women” so broadly that it encompasses nothing more than someone’s presence in a space that doesn't belong to you yet you would prefer they didn’t occupy

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 12:30

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 11:49

But sex does sometimes matter. I’m glad we agree.

Sure. No one says otherwise.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 12:31

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 12:29

It isn’t your private property. It’s a shared space,l. You’ve defined “forcing yourself on women” so broadly that it encompasses nothing more than someone’s presence in a space that doesn't belong to you yet you would prefer they didn’t occupy

I wasn't the poster who said that (forcing yourself on women) I was merely correcting you on your public space claim when it's a women's spaces claim.

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 12:32

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 12:30

Sure. No one says otherwise.

When do you think sex matters?

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 12:33

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 12:30

Sure. No one says otherwise.

Can you enlighten us as to which spaces you think should be allowed to exclude men (regardless of how they identify)? You haven't answered when I've asked about sports.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 12:33

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 12:32

When do you think sex matters?

Jinx.

Clemdfandango · 17/11/2026 12:42

Nothing would change my mind - you can't argue with science and facts.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 12:47

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 12:32

When do you think sex matters?

For example , it may matter in the context of delivering healthcare related to sexual and reproductive anatomy.