Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 19:07

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 18:00

So it's your position that it is not conceivably possible to be transphobic?

So absolutely anything goes?

About what? people who claim be TW? they can do what they like as long as they don't claim they know what it's like to be a woman, they stay out of the single sex spaces meant for me as a biological woman and don't impinge on my rights as ditto.

Sorry if that's not the reply you were hoping to goad me into.

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 19:14

caringcarer · 16/11/2026 18:57

No penis. I'm perfectly happy to share female spaces with any person with no penis. In sports I don't think it's possible because men have higher levels of testosterone. Even if they take female hormones when they complete to suppress the testosterone it doesn't negate all the years of training they had while having g higher testosterone.

https://workersliberty.org/story/2023-11-07/victimisation-prison-doctor

'Sarah castrated herself when she was previously in prison.'

Even Sarah Jane Baker?

A man without a penis is still a man.

sjb

Victimisation by a prison doctor

Sarah Jane Baker, a jailed trans woman, has had her hormones stopped by her prison doctor, who is employed by the private company Practice Plus Group. Sarah was acquitted in court on 31 August on Public Order Act 1986 charges about an outburst in her s...

https://workersliberty.org/story/2023-11-07/victimisation-prison-doctor

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 19:19

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 19:04

So in what situations are you thinking mixed sex provision would be suitable?

If there were also a single sex facility available with facilities that meet the requirements

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 19:23

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 19:07

About what? people who claim be TW? they can do what they like as long as they don't claim they know what it's like to be a woman, they stay out of the single sex spaces meant for me as a biological woman and don't impinge on my rights as ditto.

Sorry if that's not the reply you were hoping to goad me into.

I don't understand the reply, you said you "don't recognise the term transphobia". What does this mean?

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 19:29

caringcarer · 16/11/2026 18:57

No penis. I'm perfectly happy to share female spaces with any person with no penis. In sports I don't think it's possible because men have higher levels of testosterone. Even if they take female hormones when they complete to suppress the testosterone it doesn't negate all the years of training they had while having g higher testosterone.

How do you think you’re going to tell who has a penis and who doesn’t?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 19:33

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 19:23

I don't understand the reply, you said you "don't recognise the term transphobia". What does this mean?

Your lack of comprehension is not my problem. Maybe lie down and have a rest, your brain must be fried.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 19:35

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 19:19

If there were also a single sex facility available with facilities that meet the requirements

Edited

I'm just trying to understand how you think this would work in practice.

Do you think employers should provide double the required changing space just incase some employees are happy to get changed in your mixed sex provision?

Assuming that all this excess space is available, do you honestly think it's a good idea? Would it not be better, as an employer, to protect yourself from potential claims that you failed to prevent harassment?

GriseldaandMike · 16/11/2026 20:03

The good news apparently sex segregation has nothing to do with safety so Transwomen arguing that the mens is not safe for them don't have a leg to stand on and the reason for separation is for dignity and privacy. As it is no more dignified for a woman to be in a state of partial undress etc in front of a man who feels like a woman than it is to be in the same state with a man who feels like a man we can solve this all by keeping TWs out of women's spaces and providing unisex provision in addition to single sex not gender spaces.

caringcarer · 16/11/2026 20:05

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 19:29

How do you think you’re going to tell who has a penis and who doesn’t?

They should get a certificate after surgery.

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 20:06

caringcarer · 16/11/2026 20:05

They should get a certificate after surgery.

And what, you’re going to ask to see it in a public toilet?

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 20:17

caringcarer · 16/11/2026 20:05

They should get a certificate after surgery.

You can't insist that gender recognition be dependent on sterilisation. Various cases have found that this contravenes human rights.

StealthTroublemaker · 16/11/2026 20:27

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 18:25

Don't be silly . I said it would be deeply innapropriate and embarrassing for a person who recognises himself to be a man - and is perceived by others as a man - to walk into a women's facility. Which is why they do not.
They don't do it because it's innapropriate so they choose not to, because why would they? not because there's someone guarding the door. This is how social norms work. Even small children are aware of these.

So if the only criteria to be a TIM is to be male, therefore à TIM will know he is male, why would they use a female space? They know they are not female so why would they think they are entitled to use a female single sex space?

Coatsoff42 · 16/11/2026 20:34

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 20:17

You can't insist that gender recognition be dependent on sterilisation. Various cases have found that this contravenes human rights.

Yes, I think the problem with that was that only people with plenty of money and good underlying health can have some of the surgeries, so if you are a medicalist, you only allow the richest and healthiest people to live their fantasies, and the poor and sick people are stuck in reality.

RedToothBrush · 16/11/2026 20:36

By climbing up onto the mantelpiece and going through a mirror to a world where reality is different and you can magically change sex.

Catiette · 16/11/2026 21:00

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:45

There is no need for policing, and indeed it is harmful to try.

This is managed through social convention as it always has been.

The main purpose of the previous social convention was to enable women to call out any male in their spaces, to maximise their safety. Am I right in understanding that the social convention you're proposing is that women should be deterred from calling out any male in those spaces, on the understanding that he knows where he should be and the presumption she should trust him?

If so, I find it hard to see how you can argue that this does not impact on women's autonomy, dignity and, ultimately, safety.

I say ultimately safety because your argument for this not being a risk to women appears to be a chancy numbers game. I doubt that you would argue that the situation you appear to propose wouldn't increase the likelihood of an unwanted and dangerous male interloper over time. How could it not? As such, even if there hasn't yet been documented evidence of an increase in risk, this does not mean that there is no increase in risk. You're asking women to play a waiting game in which there must be losers, suffering a lifelong impact, for women to be protected.

I personally feel very strongly that we should have evidence of there being no possible increase in risk before we run the experiment you're embracing.

Your arguments for disregarding the social convention and there being no risk both seem somewhat illogical and potentially unethical.

Catiette · 16/11/2026 21:26

GailBlancheViola · 16/11/2026 13:55

Trans women, however, occasionally do use female services, especially if they pass, because they understand themselves to be women, and also are aware that others reliably perceive them to be women.

Others DO NOT reliably perceive them to be women.

The overwhelming majority of transwomen do not pass, they fool themselves that they do.

Their 'understanding' of themselves is irrelevant they are requiring everyone else to validate the lie that they are women, they are not and no-one else should be required to go along with this falsehood.

they understand themselves to be women, and also are aware that others reliably perceive them to be women

Wow.

Was it Transperson who was lecturing us on theory of mind earlier?

Read the above, then reread it. Then read it again.

It leaves no room - none - for women to have their own minds.

We simply don't figure.

Everything - everything about us, what we are, what we think - is pre-determined in it by the male. There's not the slightest recognition of even the possibility of woman's separate, autonomous existence.

I find that quote genuinely frightening.

viques · 16/11/2026 23:25

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 09:40

Love Emeritus Professor Lord Robert Winston ❤. If there is anyone in the world who knows his genetics it is him. And the people who send him hate mail are only exposing their own ignorance to a wider audience.

viques · 16/11/2026 23:31

StealthTroublemaker · 16/11/2026 20:27

So if the only criteria to be a TIM is to be male, therefore à TIM will know he is male, why would they use a female space? They know they are not female so why would they think they are entitled to use a female single sex space?

Why? The one word answer is in your post.

Entitled

It is not about need, it is about want.

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 02:40

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.

Hmmm. Taking your point as a sincere one for a moment. You are laying down criteria for all TW as a group to meet before acceptance as the opposite sex. I suggest it would be better to consider criteria for the individual TW as an individual to meet before acceptance as the opposite sex.

So let's have a look

Criterion 1: Upper Body Strength. It is theoretically - in fact easily - possible for a person born male to attain the upper body strength of a woman: a starvation muscle-unsparing diet (possibly with added fat?) should accomplish that, albeit with the risk of death (the heart is also a muscle) although some would consider that worth the risk. As for bone strength, osteoporosis can be induced with calcium gradually leached from the bone thru diet and - in extremis - time in orbit (osteoporosis is a problem with astronauts). That is achievable for the individual

Criterion 2: Crime. A trans woman who has committed no crime meets this criterion

Criteria 3. and 4. Employment and assault/death. Trans women prostitutes, particularly in poorer countries, would meet these criteria easily. Poorer trans women also have a larger chance. For trans people in the real world it isn't all lollygagging about getting asspats from woke activists ("so stunning and brave"), and getting the shit kicked out of you is a thing.

Criteria 5. Suicide. It is not possible for any person to meet this criterion and survive. although some may consider their death an acceptable cost if transition is recognised - ie "better dead than male"

So while it may not be possible for a group to meet your criteria, it is certainly possible for an individual to do so.

StealthTroublemaker · 17/11/2026 05:18

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 02:40

Hmmm. Taking your point as a sincere one for a moment. You are laying down criteria for all TW as a group to meet before acceptance as the opposite sex. I suggest it would be better to consider criteria for the individual TW as an individual to meet before acceptance as the opposite sex.

So let's have a look

Criterion 1: Upper Body Strength. It is theoretically - in fact easily - possible for a person born male to attain the upper body strength of a woman: a starvation muscle-unsparing diet (possibly with added fat?) should accomplish that, albeit with the risk of death (the heart is also a muscle) although some would consider that worth the risk. As for bone strength, osteoporosis can be induced with calcium gradually leached from the bone thru diet and - in extremis - time in orbit (osteoporosis is a problem with astronauts). That is achievable for the individual

Criterion 2: Crime. A trans woman who has committed no crime meets this criterion

Criteria 3. and 4. Employment and assault/death. Trans women prostitutes, particularly in poorer countries, would meet these criteria easily. Poorer trans women also have a larger chance. For trans people in the real world it isn't all lollygagging about getting asspats from woke activists ("so stunning and brave"), and getting the shit kicked out of you is a thing.

Criteria 5. Suicide. It is not possible for any person to meet this criterion and survive. although some may consider their death an acceptable cost if transition is recognised - ie "better dead than male"

So while it may not be possible for a group to meet your criteria, it is certainly possible for an individual to do so.

Edited

Yeah., but we done make societal rules and laws based on individuals do we? There may be some lovely TIM out there somewhere., but we can’t say you're a woman because you're nice, but a TIM whi has committed a crime is not a woman can we?

2021x · 17/11/2026 06:33

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 02:40

Hmmm. Taking your point as a sincere one for a moment. You are laying down criteria for all TW as a group to meet before acceptance as the opposite sex. I suggest it would be better to consider criteria for the individual TW as an individual to meet before acceptance as the opposite sex.

So let's have a look

Criterion 1: Upper Body Strength. It is theoretically - in fact easily - possible for a person born male to attain the upper body strength of a woman: a starvation muscle-unsparing diet (possibly with added fat?) should accomplish that, albeit with the risk of death (the heart is also a muscle) although some would consider that worth the risk. As for bone strength, osteoporosis can be induced with calcium gradually leached from the bone thru diet and - in extremis - time in orbit (osteoporosis is a problem with astronauts). That is achievable for the individual

Criterion 2: Crime. A trans woman who has committed no crime meets this criterion

Criteria 3. and 4. Employment and assault/death. Trans women prostitutes, particularly in poorer countries, would meet these criteria easily. Poorer trans women also have a larger chance. For trans people in the real world it isn't all lollygagging about getting asspats from woke activists ("so stunning and brave"), and getting the shit kicked out of you is a thing.

Criteria 5. Suicide. It is not possible for any person to meet this criterion and survive. although some may consider their death an acceptable cost if transition is recognised - ie "better dead than male"

So while it may not be possible for a group to meet your criteria, it is certainly possible for an individual to do so.

Edited

TW must be seen as a group because women cannot assess risk based on individual characteristics. You are assessing this from the TW point of view and haven't thought about the female point of view.

Criterion 1: Upper Body Strength. It is theoretically - in fact easily - possible for a person born male to attain the upper body strength of a woman: a starvation muscle-unsparing diet (possibly with added fat?) should accomplish that, albeit with the risk of death (the heart is also a muscle) although some would consider that worth the risk. As for bone strength, osteoporosis can be induced with calcium gradually leached from the bone thru diet and - in extremis - time in orbit (osteoporosis is a problem with astronauts). That is achievable for the individual- this is incorrect. This is also pointless, as if a TW was starving, they would be in hospital.

Criterion 2: Crime. A trans woman who has committed no crime meets this criterion- most men have not committed any crime, but transwomen commit crime against women at the same rate as other men.

Criteria 3. and 4. Employment and assault/death. Trans women prostitutes, particularly in poorer countries, would meet these criteria easily. Poorer trans women also have a larger chance. For trans people in the real world, it isn't all lollygagging about getting asspats from woke activists ("so stunning and brave"), and getting the shit kicked out of you is a thing- not sure of your point at all with this. Transwomen are in leadership postitions closer to the rate of men, rather than the rate of women. Transmen experience the same level of violent death/assault the same rate as other women, rather than men.

Criteria 5. Suicide. No one can meet this criterion and survive. Although some may consider their death an acceptable cost if transition is recognised - ie "better dead than male"- Men experience a rate of fatal suicide attempts 7x higher than women. If a transman were really a man, I would expect the rate of fatal suicide attempts to be within the range of men, not the range of women.

Overall, I think you have misunderstood all my arguments. If gender really was an internalised identity not caused by environmental expectations, then it would be borne out in the behavioural data.

For women to feel safe with ANY males, they would need to not be significantly stronger and significantly more likely to commit violent crime. Until TW statistics are within the female range, sharing same sex spaces should not even be considered.

OP posts:
Mountainlarch · 17/11/2026 07:10

Catiette · 16/11/2026 21:00

The main purpose of the previous social convention was to enable women to call out any male in their spaces, to maximise their safety. Am I right in understanding that the social convention you're proposing is that women should be deterred from calling out any male in those spaces, on the understanding that he knows where he should be and the presumption she should trust him?

If so, I find it hard to see how you can argue that this does not impact on women's autonomy, dignity and, ultimately, safety.

I say ultimately safety because your argument for this not being a risk to women appears to be a chancy numbers game. I doubt that you would argue that the situation you appear to propose wouldn't increase the likelihood of an unwanted and dangerous male interloper over time. How could it not? As such, even if there hasn't yet been documented evidence of an increase in risk, this does not mean that there is no increase in risk. You're asking women to play a waiting game in which there must be losers, suffering a lifelong impact, for women to be protected.

I personally feel very strongly that we should have evidence of there being no possible increase in risk before we run the experiment you're embracing.

Your arguments for disregarding the social convention and there being no risk both seem somewhat illogical and potentially unethical.

Edited

Very nicely and clearly put!

cryupmykingdom · 17/11/2026 08:24

>>For women to feel safe with ANY males, they would need to not be significantly stronger and significantly more likely to commit violent crime. Until TW statistics are within the female range, sharing same sex spaces should not even be considered

That's pretty much it. Many of the comments on this thread come across like a German officer writing just after the D-day landings 'What would it take for you to change your mind on Nazi issues?'

The fight is on, all over the issue, and new arguments derailing trans talking points (TTPs) surface daily. It's been pushed back and that's only going to happen more.

Stonewall is in trouble. Clinics are closed. There will be fervent adherents but they will be a small and increasingly awkward minority as every day they are being forced to amend their positions to take into account people who think absolutely the reverse to them, and have no fear in saying so.

cryupmykingdom · 17/11/2026 08:27

>>Nor do you have any empirical basis on which to estimate the % of trans people who pass.

What objectively based data is there on this?

We know the number is skewed by lots of delusional males who think they pass.

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 08:35

Catiette · 16/11/2026 21:00

The main purpose of the previous social convention was to enable women to call out any male in their spaces, to maximise their safety. Am I right in understanding that the social convention you're proposing is that women should be deterred from calling out any male in those spaces, on the understanding that he knows where he should be and the presumption she should trust him?

If so, I find it hard to see how you can argue that this does not impact on women's autonomy, dignity and, ultimately, safety.

I say ultimately safety because your argument for this not being a risk to women appears to be a chancy numbers game. I doubt that you would argue that the situation you appear to propose wouldn't increase the likelihood of an unwanted and dangerous male interloper over time. How could it not? As such, even if there hasn't yet been documented evidence of an increase in risk, this does not mean that there is no increase in risk. You're asking women to play a waiting game in which there must be losers, suffering a lifelong impact, for women to be protected.

I personally feel very strongly that we should have evidence of there being no possible increase in risk before we run the experiment you're embracing.

Your arguments for disregarding the social convention and there being no risk both seem somewhat illogical and potentially unethical.

Edited

Excellent post.

Also important to remember, this has already been tried. This whole experiment was run for years.

The result was so much detriment to women that women took it all the way through the courts and got the law confirmed.

We don't need to run an experiment of any kind to see what happens - we know. Men use their access to women's spaces to behave very badly, some women have been seriously hurt in the process.

And some women are excluded from needed resources and services if men are there; it makes those services and provisions unusable and leaves people in society without provision or access.

And women lose awards and sports titles and sponsorship and actually being permitted anything of their own to men, from the group of resources specifically reserved for women to prevent the inequality and dominance of men.

We don't need to consider possibly running an experiment - we already did. We have the outcomes. Men made their choices as to how to behave in women's spaces and it wasn't pretty; it didn't work for women even if all said men were saintly; and it ended in the SCJ.

And really all the SCJ says is that women have rights too. That the interests of women cannot be trampled for the prioritisation of trans identified men. That is really what all this fuss is about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread