If anyone hasn't watched this yet, there is a helpful list of Chapters in the Video Description to dip in if you can't bear too much of Webberley all in one sitting - or want to systematically count the fibs, dubious claims and utter batshittery!
For example, in "Orgasm, fertility & other side effects": Webberley is not a practicing GP but claims that she is having detailed conversations with people about their sex lives and their orgasms pre and post genital surgery.
We know from previous Tribunal Findings that her contact with these patients as a GP was usually cursory and a mad dash to the cash register, so this does not ring true. If is is true, under what pretext would she be having these conversations?
Despite her attempts to portray everyone who has been involved in this series of interviews as both prudish and depraved at the same time, IMHO she comes over as having a prurient interest in other people's sex lives in the way she recounts the conversations she claims to have had.
Overall, I was left wondering if the response from her past and potential customers might be similar to the attack on Susie Green when she was deemed to be damaging to The Cause, ie. a call for Gender GP to be handed over to be "Trans Led" and the Webberleys to be put out to grass.
– Intro - Helen Webberley debate
– Why is she expanding to the US?
– Are critics of child transition “bigots”? + Riley Gaines dispute
– Men in women’s locker rooms
– “Some women have a penis” and clash over science, consent + language
– Do trans identities really exist?
– Is being transracial or trans species really different from transgender?
– Gender dysphoria vs. changing sex; chromosomes discussion
– Addressing Detransitioners
– Brain development for kids who decide to transition, impulse control and more
– Orgasm, fertility & other side effects
– Helen claims Robby’s views are harming trans people 🥴🙄
– Free speech vs. “hate” and should such views be banned?
– How can a child consent to this?
– Cass Review discussion and countries restricting or banning transitions for kids
– Can a Brazilian butt lift be gender affirming care? Where is the line drawn?
– Helen attempts elitist talking point
– Helen argues we must validate trans experiences, Robby asks how she applies that to 45 yr old men who identify as 6 years old
– What is a male/What is a woman?
– Biological differences and Helen compliments Robby’s appearance… 😳😬
– Are trans identifying people disadvantaged by society? + social contagions
– Why does this bother Robby so much?
– Protecting daughters, bathroom assaults at schools and the bathroom issue
– Autogynephelia
– How quickly does she believe drugs should be given and how parents should deal with a confused child…
– Argument over conversion therapy
– Debate over World Health Org, “mental illness” classifications, and COVID
– Helen’s stated goal for the US and Robby’s closing critique
– Robby’s final words on risk, evidence, and “protecting kids”
To get an idea of who Webberley was taking on when she decided it would be a good idea to debate Robbie Starbuck . . .
In October he sued Google. These are the opening paragraphs of the law suit:
- For nearly two years, one of the largest companies in the world – Google – has spread radioactive lies about Robby Starbuck through its AI products. When users submit queries to Google’s AI platforms about Mr. Starbuck, they receive a “biography” that is outrageously false, whereby Mr. Starbuck is portrayed as (among other things) a child rapist, a serial sexual abuser convicted of assault, one who engages in financial exploitation, one who engages in ‘black ops’ tactics such as illegal campaign finance practices, and a shooter – in short, as a monster. These lies continue today.
- The real Mr. Starbuck is a filmmaker, journalist, and activist. He is a devoted father, husband, and Christian with an impeccable public record, which is remarkable given the years he has spent in the public eye as an advocate, including on controversial matters.
- When asked to verify its wild outputs about Mr. Starbuck, Google’s AI fabricates “sources” out of whole cloth, including by inventing “articles” that were never written and attributing them to real journalists.
- Google’s AI freely concedes that “the false statements were presented as factual and could cause significant harm to Starbuck’s reputation, character, and potentially his safety.” Indeed, Google’s AI has admitted that “Google, as the developer and provider of this service, is likely the party that would be legally responsible for my defamatory statement. They could be sued for defamation by Robby Starbuck.”
Video on this page as well as the full document:
https://robbystarbuck.com/google/
Why would Google do that?? 🤔
What Robbie Starbuck and his wife, Landon, are known for is campaigning for child protection.
They made a documentary called "The War on Children"
https://thewaronchildren.com/
"The War on Children features whistleblowers, leftists caught on camera, survivors of child mutilation, trafficking victims, corporate executives exposing the plan to sexualize children, the creator of Libs of TikTok, Senator Rand Paul, Riley Gaines, a Drag Performer, Pornhub’s Sex Ed Instructor, and many more."
They have got a campaign website called "Freedom Forever".
freedomforever.us/
"Freedom Forever is an American non-profit organization dedicated to protecting children from abuse, trafficking and exploitation in all forms."
"The demand to abuse and exploit children has never been greater. There are many organizations dedicated to the rescuing of children but few working to stop this epidemic before a child needs to be rescued. While rescuing kids is good and necessary, it doesn’t address or solve the epidemic of child sexual abuse, exploitation and trafficking."
"Our prevention strategy work has reached 10+ MILLION Americans on social media and given them tangible actions they can take to prevent abuse and exploitation."
"FreedomForever.us partners with a number of organizations such as the Paradox Institute, an organization that teaches about the differences in biological and psychological differences between males and females as well as the myths of gender affirming care."
One of their Missions is to "End Child Mutilation"
"The medical exploitation of children, radical gender ideology and so called “gender affirmative care” have already devastated thousands of lives.
We’re committed to exposing the horrific truth about these dangerous, experimental and exploitive medical practices. We have been leading the charge to end child sex changes in Tennessee and at the national level. Our education and activism have helped save many children from the dangerous path of lifelong medical dependency, chemical castration, sterility and irreversible sex change operations. We work hard to combat the rampant disinformation by educating the public, mobilizing community activism and amplifying the voices of Survivors."
"The Social Contagion of Transitioning Children is not only undeniable, it’s Much Worse Than We Thought: Freedom Forever’s investigative team uncovered the alarming reality inside the largest online group of Trans Moms."
https://freedomforever.us/missions/child-mutilation/
Reporting other investigations:
Vanessa Sivadge Blows Whistle on Gender Clinic in Texas: Children Are Not Experiments
In an interview for Freedom Forever, Vanessa Sivadge—a former nurse at Texas Children’s Hospital (TCH)—shared her experiences and disturbing allegations about the hospital’s secretive gender clinic, a clinic that operated within the hospital’s endocrine clinic. Among the illegal practices she observed were deceptive diagnostic practices and fraudulent Medicaid billing, toward the goal of medically transitioning vulnerable children ages 13-17.
https://freedomforever.us/vanessa-sivadge-blows-whistle-on-gender-clinic-in-texas-children-are-not-experiments/
Robbie and Landon Starbuck are right wing Christians, which I understand means that they are supposed to be bankrolling UK TERFs but I've looked everywhere and I can't find a cent let alone a dollar!
If anyone is interested in some of their political work, this is an Act they are proposing for the State of Tennessee (I don't know what has happened to it):
CHILDHOOD PROTECTION & RESTORATION ACT (CPR ACT)
"These bullet points below are the key points that need to be addressed in a bill that will end the sexualization of children and attacks on childhood that so many Tennesseans are concerned about. This bill will set the standard for the nation! If you’re in another state, we encourage you to email it to your state legislators or print it and bring it to meet with them!"
https://freedomforever.us/missions/cpr/
Relevant bullet points wrt Webberley:
Problem 3: We have a major problem in America with children being transitioned with hormones, puberty blockers and even given mastectomies or hysterectomies to change their sex. This is wildly inappropriate, filled with potential dangers and downright abusive. Right here in Tennessee Vanderbilt is unfortunately at the cutting edge of this practice to destroy children’s futures by encouraging them to change their gender via Vanderbilt Pediatric Gender Clinic. Information on Vanderbilt’s gender clinic for kids can be found HERE.
Solution 3: The bill from last session banning hormone treatment for prepubescent children didn’t go far enough. In fact, almost no children if any were protected by it. The incidence of a child receiving hormones before Tanner stage II is almost non-existent. We must go further and set the standard. We can do that by using similar language to the last bill but amend the age to ban the following for anyone under the age of 18: puberty blockers or hormone treatments for the purpose of transitioning one’s sex or treating gender dysphoria, so called gender affirming care that actively encourages children to change their gender and surgeries that would be described by a reasonable person as being for the purpose of changing one’s sex.
Maybe this is why Webberley came out with her fists up, flailing the air from the very start of the interview?