Funny you mentioned Dear Polly as I tried this today for the first time, having picked up a 10ml sample size in a kit. It's lovely, I do like tea scents and haven't tried Vilhelm before but always wanted to.
I have also tried ambre chromatique by Maison Crivelli. Wasn't sure at first, as his scents are not easy to like at first in my opinion, but tend to grow on you, and I'm not historically an amber fan but I'm trying these more for the 'olfactory experience' and to widen my perfume horizons. I have to say now I've let it settle in I am quite enjoying it. It's ambery (obviously!) and smokey and definitely giving it a run for its money!
Testing a few this morning, the other one I have put on is Herrera very good girl elixir. This has more mass market appeal but is lovely and fruity, in a cherry/berry way.
They are all nice in different ways - I'm going out for Sunday Lunch in a bit and will probably wear just one so I'm not smelling like a confusing bunch of randomness - I will have a hard time deciding which to pick.