Barnia didn't impress me either
Sample sets I have tried - so many!
The wrose was fugazzi, I spend half of the time thinking who thought this smells good enough to put in bottle and sell it to people! They had largish set and the full amount goes against purchase but I did not have a single one I like even a tiny bit.
Dedcool didn't impress, so did Rosie Jane and Malin and Goetz. Great candles but didn't love the perfumes. I was expecting more from Phlur. I was also expecting more from room 1015.
Giardini di Toscana - I bought Bianco Latte full bottle but got tired of it after 2 uses. I did enjoy the sample set but didn't lead to any happy purchase.
Tocca is just ok, as well as 7 virtues. I enjoy the sets more then any of the above and have few 20ml Tocca and 1 50ml 7 virtues but wouldn't repurchase any of them.
I didn't buy any bottles after MFK either but I feel this is more preferance than anything - my son is huge fan.
Commodity is interesting but my skin chemistry didn't work with them too wel. Milk, Gold and Moss were my favorites form the range - they do good sales buy one get one for example
Floral street was good surprise for me as I had sample set years ago and hated all of them but the newest - Arizona Bloom, Sunflower Pop became full bottles. I have Sweet Almond Blossom too it's sweet floral.
Ellis Brookin had some gems, I like Florist (smells like you have just walked in flower shop, great for the spring) and Myth is great freshy.
Victoria Beckham has only 3 - now 4 end up loving one Portofino
Parfums de Marley - I did not like most but the one I loved - I LOVE!!
I enjoyed Killian with apple brandy, angel's share and intoxicated being favourites - they know how to do boozy scents! This was nice set
DS Durga I am still going through.
Byredo was one of the best, i end up wanting two full size and have few on the maybe list.
I have large Bon Parfumer set and I love it but more trying to learn notes then thinking of buying them. However the most recent one I would love to smell!
And of course advent calendars- I had Jo Malone and Penhaligon's 2023 and loved both.
I have BDK, Sana Jardin, Replica sample sets to try at home and Goldfield and Banks on my wishlist and maybe Frederic Malle too. Did someone say Ellis Harris is great too?
I love sample set, I get one very few months.