Whoops, sorry ladies! I have been dealing with DS woes and resisting (just about) the urge to go full-blown mother swan. Ho hum...
Anyhoo, the perfume suitable for a highbrow Archer (very highbrow and Victorian by the way) was created by the same nose as my beloved Alien Essence Absolue...
And talking of smoky vanilla scents, the new 4160 Rhubarb and Custard is delicious. The tobacco in the vanilla tempers the sweetness and the rhubarb note adds the right amount of tartness. I wish I'd got a bigger bottle!
MrsMac your lovely surprise arrived, thank you so much. I'm not sure I'm up to guessing which is which, but I shall certainly have great fun trying. 
Kittens you do make Avignon sound even more irresistible. I'm keeping my fingers crossed for Christmas.