Frugal, if I dared raid my mother's bottle of Oscar, I would do it for you ;). I lack the courage (and suspect you would find the re formulation disappointing, alas). I dare say it wouldnt stand direct comparison to the original but it's become as familiar to me over the years.
Sotd is Jo Malone's Red Roses. I like it, it's slightly waxy, and it works for work, but I really prefer something a bit muskier with a little bit of spice to it. This could almost be rose water. I'll be sad when my sample has gone but don't think I'll be buying a bottle.