Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Inheritance one - what’s morally correct

520 replies

Threebear · 14/09/2026 10:30

My MIL 70 has just inherited 1.85M net. She was given another house when in her twenties which due to where it was in the world ended up having to be abandoned, though means she has never paid rent or mortgage in her life. She did only have 50k to her name previous to this big windfall. She doesn’t have access to a pension (mistakes in her life / living in the wrong places).

She has 2 children, 37M, 43M. The youngest has a 5yr old child (her only GC). Relationship positive with both.

37M owns a property but in reality only owns the mortgage (340k mortgage). He doesn’t struggle but retains 2 jobs at once in order to live a nice life and have a nice property.

43M is mentally ill, has never retained a proper job, cannot access many benefits where he lives and has a wife who comes from a very poor country with no career herself. They live on the breadline if not lower.

MIL has declared that she is going to keep the full inheritance for herself however will gift each child with 50k as a present.

Firstly I’m fully aware there is a huge difference in thinking between the generations. As a millennial I cannot morally understand the decision. I would never in a million years do this to my beautiful child. I’m so aware of the struggles we have had and can only imagine the struggles in his thirties to get on the property ladder. My hope is we can buy him a small property when he’s older so he can be mortgage free from starting point, all of this to be done with our own investments and money.

The moral question has actually nothing to do with money. If she had none no one would care, if she only got 100k and wanted to keep it, it wouldn’t be questionable as she needs it.

However and big however, she’s just been lumped with 1.85M tax free, and it just doesn’t compute that she believes the relationship with her children and GC will continue if she chooses to do this. The decision is hers and hers only but for anyone who believes she’s morally correct, why I ask would you think your children would ever be ok, forgive you or want to spend anytime ever again with you?

It’s hers to make, but it’s selfish without a doubt. Keeping 95% of that money for her to spend Willy nilly seems crazy while thinking she can retain a relationship with the people she has hurt in this equation.

Personally I think she deserves a nice home, a good investment portfolio but that can all be done within 1.5M no problem at all. If she shared just 350k between her 2 children she would change their lives, they would forever be incredibly grateful, and it would promote to showing how much she cares for them and for a very positive relationship until her death.

The question is simply anyone who agrees with her, are you aware of the rupture and consequent lonely rest of life you would live in your million dollar home as your kids will now likely abandon you?

thanks!

OP posts:
Mirrorlolo · 15/09/2026 16:57

OP this is one of the most obnoxious threads I've ever read- your entitlement is astounding!
Wealth passes from generation to generation over time it's the norm. I didn't expect my parents to give me fortunes from their money while they were alive- it's important to make your own way in the world. Your MIL is likely to pass more along as she ages to avoid IHT.
I inherited a significant amount in cash and business assets. My DD also received £50k which she used for a house deposit. Additionally over the past 5 years I bought her a £20k car and a rolex and gave her about another £20k to help her with wedding costs and to take a year's mat leave. I had to twist her arm to take that much as she and SIL are good with money and save well. She recognises that she's very lucky and will inherit significantly one day but has no expectations in the here and now. I'd be so horribly disappointed if she behaved like you ( and your husband?).

When I turn 70 I'll start to reduce the size of my estate and give her more but for now she's making here own way with a reasonable amount of help.

MintyBadgerPrincessCheese · 15/09/2026 16:57

I was trying to make the point that OP has one set of standards for her not-even-MIL, and has imperiously decreed exactly how much the woman should live on, and a different set of standards for herself. The OP has repeatedly said a mother should do everything possible for their children.

She's a hypocrite.

It doesn't matter if the not-even-MIL lives in a fecking castle, no-one is entitled to a penny of her money, legally OR morally.

The OP could make MORE sacrifices and live more frugally but chooses not to. That makes her a hypocrite when she's insisting that someone else makes sacrifices and lives more frugally.

IT ISN'T YOUR MONEY. How many ways can we say it? I hope the woman takes the £50k back from her ungrateful son and partner.

Threebear · 15/09/2026 17:13

bridgetreilly · 15/09/2026 16:35

Immoral ways the MIL could spend the money

  1. Start a drugs cartel
  2. Invest in human trafficking
  3. Bribe officials
  4. Build a secret system to siphon gas/oil/electricity and sell it back to the mains companies at a profit
  5. Put out a hit on her DIL.

Does that help, OP?

Much more entertaining, thank you!

OP posts:
Taytosambo · 15/09/2026 17:43

Mirrorlolo · 15/09/2026 16:57

OP this is one of the most obnoxious threads I've ever read- your entitlement is astounding!
Wealth passes from generation to generation over time it's the norm. I didn't expect my parents to give me fortunes from their money while they were alive- it's important to make your own way in the world. Your MIL is likely to pass more along as she ages to avoid IHT.
I inherited a significant amount in cash and business assets. My DD also received £50k which she used for a house deposit. Additionally over the past 5 years I bought her a £20k car and a rolex and gave her about another £20k to help her with wedding costs and to take a year's mat leave. I had to twist her arm to take that much as she and SIL are good with money and save well. She recognises that she's very lucky and will inherit significantly one day but has no expectations in the here and now. I'd be so horribly disappointed if she behaved like you ( and your husband?).

When I turn 70 I'll start to reduce the size of my estate and give her more but for now she's making here own way with a reasonable amount of help.

So you inherited significantly and you passed that onto your daughter...but you're berating OP for saying she wishes the same for her husband? Had to twist your daughter's arm to take the money, yeah right! She took it all the same, but OP's husband shouldn't be looking for anything? Rules for thee, but not for me comes to mind.

bigboykitty · 15/09/2026 18:05

If I inherited a similar amount now, I'd give the kids half a mil each, stop work, and they'd know it wouldn't be too long until they got the rest because of my health.

AmnesiacsDream · 15/09/2026 18:25

Threebear · 14/09/2026 13:45

That’s the funny part. To answer your first paragraph which is a fair point to raise. We did, oh we did. She continuously complained and was upset about it and we supported her throughout, on her side at all times. Her mother did not need to live in a 4M value property until 102 when she died. It was unfair on her daughter my MIL and her brother. They struggled having to live with a mother they didn’t like. And as happens oh too often, she’s become her mother. Not exactly the same I’ll give you that but it looks like it’s going in that direction.

she hated her mother so no grief, she was ecstatic when she died after about 30 minutes of upset. As I hope is clear, as much as I might have my morals set differently, she’s not exactly an angel herself and then goes and repeats the same story again within months.

Whatever culture you’re from that you seem to feel is superior - it’s not sounding very palatable. People “having” to live with a mother they dislike (so they can live in a £4M house?). Obligations but poor parenting, resentment and waiting for inheritances. The whole set up sounds designed to structurally support controlling parents dictate children’s lives and children live in thrall being obligated to invite and spend time with people they resent and don’t like.

if I inherited £1.85M at 70 I’d be investing a fair amount of it in my children though, if I had no pension nor any other assets to speak of, it wouldn’t be the better part of it. Life at 70+ can require significant support and they’ll get what’s left when I’m dead. But I don’t think that’s a matter of morality. It would be just as moral to give it to charity. It’s a lot of money - far, far more than most people have in assets. There’s no moral obligation to make your children richer than most people.

Mirrorlolo · 15/09/2026 18:40

Taytosambo · 15/09/2026 17:43

So you inherited significantly and you passed that onto your daughter...but you're berating OP for saying she wishes the same for her husband? Had to twist your daughter's arm to take the money, yeah right! She took it all the same, but OP's husband shouldn't be looking for anything? Rules for thee, but not for me comes to mind.

No I have given my DD less than 1% of my estate the OP is considering cutting off MIL for ONLY giving her sons 2% EACH of her estate. Its so greedy.
I personally think it's useful for the young to forge their own path (as I did) which is why
( with the exception of the watch) I have given money to DD as needs arise. I also paid for her to do her Masters - still less than 1% of my estate I've been generous but not enough to turn her head. She will be wealthy one day and in the meantime can support herself with occasional gifts.
Op sounds morally dubious rather than the MIL IMO

Threebear · 15/09/2026 18:57

Mirrorlolo · 15/09/2026 18:40

No I have given my DD less than 1% of my estate the OP is considering cutting off MIL for ONLY giving her sons 2% EACH of her estate. Its so greedy.
I personally think it's useful for the young to forge their own path (as I did) which is why
( with the exception of the watch) I have given money to DD as needs arise. I also paid for her to do her Masters - still less than 1% of my estate I've been generous but not enough to turn her head. She will be wealthy one day and in the meantime can support herself with occasional gifts.
Op sounds morally dubious rather than the MIL IMO

At 10-12M, you are talking about an entirely different level of wealth and lifestyle. I would also be extremely wary of sharing much more than 2–3% of that amount with my own child while they were young for the very reasons you infer. I’m assuming your child is somewhere between 25–35, so is still settling into adulthood and building her own career, as we are. Gifting 2M - I use this figure as that would be the same percent I discuss for my MIL (20%) on your estate as per your post - could very easily remove a great deal of their motivation and, frankly, turn them into a rather spoilt and entitled individual. (And yes, jokes aside, I genuinely am saying this hehe)

It is all relative to the amount involved, and the "morality of the decision" has to be considered in proportion to the wealth available.

If MIL had received 100k, this thread wouldn't exist. If she had received 500k, it probably wouldn't exist either. At 1.5M and above, the situation starts to change. At 10M, it changes again into a whole new territory.

The absolute figure and the percents in this scenario means very little without the context of the total wealth.

At no point have I inferred my partner should be bought his life or lifestyle, 175k is a lovely dent into the mortgage, nothing more. No new car, no wealth, no investment portfolio, no crazy figure that will completely change his direction in life or outlook. He'll still need a job (or 2) to raise our child (jointly financially with me) and build a comfortable retirement. It would simply give him a meaningful financial advantage at a stage of life when 175k genuinely makes a difference, without fundamentally changing the trajectory of his life.

OP posts:
Taytosambo · 15/09/2026 19:00

Mirrorlolo · 15/09/2026 18:40

No I have given my DD less than 1% of my estate the OP is considering cutting off MIL for ONLY giving her sons 2% EACH of her estate. Its so greedy.
I personally think it's useful for the young to forge their own path (as I did) which is why
( with the exception of the watch) I have given money to DD as needs arise. I also paid for her to do her Masters - still less than 1% of my estate I've been generous but not enough to turn her head. She will be wealthy one day and in the meantime can support herself with occasional gifts.
Op sounds morally dubious rather than the MIL IMO

Your daughter benefitted from at least 90,000 from you (excluding the rolex).

The other son is in his 40's, hardly 'young'. How did your daughter "make her own way in the world" when you gave her:

My DD also received £50k which she used for a house deposit. Additionally* over the past 5 years I bought her a £20k car and a rolex and gave her about another £20k to help her with wedding costs and to take a year's mat leave*
When I turn 70 I'll start to reduce the size of my estate and give her more

OP's partner and his brother have never received anything from their mother, not even birthday presents and you think they're greedy?

When I turn 70 I'll start to reduce the size of my estate and give her more

So you're going to do for your DD exactly what the OP thinks her MIL should do for her children... yet you're berating the OP and her partner. As I said, rules for thee, not for me. The hypocrisy is astonishing.

anyolddinosaur · 15/09/2026 19:16

Op believes MIL thinks she is loved. I suspect MIL knows she isnt, certainly not by DIL as this amount of hostility could hardly be hidden.

Rather hope MIL blows as much of it as she can so that the 50% she has to leave her sons by law turns into a very small amount indeed.

What we give our own children has nothing to do with what MIL does. If parents have loving children they'll want to share with them, when the children are entitled brats with no love for their parent why should they.

Threebear · 15/09/2026 19:19

@Taytosambo and @LifeOnEnceladus and to any others I haven’t noted their name tags of, thank you for your extremely logical, intelligent and eloquent replies.

This thread began as a moral question, and for some reason become instead a vote of am I or am I not a vile person. There is a huge cohort on mumsnet that feel threatened by my thoughts (I’ve definitely enjoyed pushing their buttons however). I honestly ask why are they so scared and threatened by such a basically logical question that until now I believe I am completely argumentatively right on… fascinating to read the replies of course just a shame no one has actually presented me with a full cover story as to why 50k is the correct amount.

So far not one person in agreement with MIL has gone to the grain to give me a logical argument to the morals. Rather the replies are just full of emotional verbal diarrea, hypocritical and accusatory speech (where so far they have got it 100% wrong when guessing and concluding facts around my life).

There was never an emotional question on the table, and yet it appears only a few of us can understand that.

OP posts:
hangingplant742 · 15/09/2026 19:22

Moral or not aside, she’s a tight arse. Threat level of greed is really yucky. If inherited they sort of money through no effort of my own and luck, my first joy would be lifting the financial dress off my children by giving them a huge chunk of money. She’s awful.

Taytosambo · 15/09/2026 19:24

Threebear · 15/09/2026 19:19

@Taytosambo and @LifeOnEnceladus and to any others I haven’t noted their name tags of, thank you for your extremely logical, intelligent and eloquent replies.

This thread began as a moral question, and for some reason become instead a vote of am I or am I not a vile person. There is a huge cohort on mumsnet that feel threatened by my thoughts (I’ve definitely enjoyed pushing their buttons however). I honestly ask why are they so scared and threatened by such a basically logical question that until now I believe I am completely argumentatively right on… fascinating to read the replies of course just a shame no one has actually presented me with a full cover story as to why 50k is the correct amount.

So far not one person in agreement with MIL has gone to the grain to give me a logical argument to the morals. Rather the replies are just full of emotional verbal diarrea, hypocritical and accusatory speech (where so far they have got it 100% wrong when guessing and concluding facts around my life).

There was never an emotional question on the table, and yet it appears only a few of us can understand that.

Sure one of the people who is saying how awful you are is doing for her child(ren) exactly what you think MIL should do. 😂

They're just putting the boot in. It's the same on most threads now, anything to disagree with an OP.

anyolddinosaur · 15/09/2026 19:30

@Taytosambo No every thread does not "put the boot in" to the OP. This OP has deliberately been offensive.

Sewingbeedamned · 15/09/2026 19:58

OP, you are being disingenuous here. Your MIL has a mother who lived to be 102. Which means your MIL may need to fund another 30 years of life. Older people experience a great deal of anxiety about this, and not having enough money to support themselves through a time of likely escalating needs.

Taytosambo · 15/09/2026 20:04

anyolddinosaur · 15/09/2026 19:30

@Taytosambo No every thread does not "put the boot in" to the OP. This OP has deliberately been offensive.

I think you'll find they do. There's even been threads about it.

bigboykitty · 15/09/2026 20:13

anyolddinosaur · 15/09/2026 19:30

@Taytosambo No every thread does not "put the boot in" to the OP. This OP has deliberately been offensive.

Yes they do, and OP just gave it back.

PensionPTake · 15/09/2026 20:18

Threebear · 15/09/2026 19:19

@Taytosambo and @LifeOnEnceladus and to any others I haven’t noted their name tags of, thank you for your extremely logical, intelligent and eloquent replies.

This thread began as a moral question, and for some reason become instead a vote of am I or am I not a vile person. There is a huge cohort on mumsnet that feel threatened by my thoughts (I’ve definitely enjoyed pushing their buttons however). I honestly ask why are they so scared and threatened by such a basically logical question that until now I believe I am completely argumentatively right on… fascinating to read the replies of course just a shame no one has actually presented me with a full cover story as to why 50k is the correct amount.

So far not one person in agreement with MIL has gone to the grain to give me a logical argument to the morals. Rather the replies are just full of emotional verbal diarrea, hypocritical and accusatory speech (where so far they have got it 100% wrong when guessing and concluding facts around my life).

There was never an emotional question on the table, and yet it appears only a few of us can understand that.

It's her money, she gets to decide what to do with it. That's all the logic required.

PensionPTake · 15/09/2026 20:18

Taytosambo · 15/09/2026 20:04

I think you'll find they do. There's even been threads about it.

Care to link?
im pretty sure threads about threads aren't allowed.

backformoreofthesame · 15/09/2026 20:29

There is a moral obligation on parents to try and raise their children to be fully independent

, and there is a moral requirement not to create a divided society where some people get wealth simply because of their birth

therefore she should not have given them any money

PinkCactusPink · 15/09/2026 20:47

I would be buzzing my tits off with £50k

Morecoffeeneedef · 15/09/2026 21:13

You obviously feeling strongly that moral imperatives kick in at different levels of inheritance. You're entitled to hold this position, but not everyone will agree with you, including your MIL. It's not an absolute truth, just your opinion, and MIL is not breaking the relationship with her children. You are planning to break the relationship.

Anyahyacinth · 15/09/2026 21:57

Vigorousroots · 15/09/2026 14:20

So Mil is not daft...we know now why she limited the gift to £50k each - they were lucky to get anything!

I think this, I think it's a test and its being failed miserably. This sounds like a good and sensible mother testing how they manage and react to a gift ...a very large financial gift (which presupposes the larger amount is even fluid enough to gift and held as cash - it may not be)

Vigorousroots · 15/09/2026 22:18

It’s interesting that the op feels she sits outside the emotions because that’s not how she has come across. There’s some game playing of course but what was the point of that - this is her family’s emotions she’s been having fun with, musing about how much money it would take to pay off the sons before she’d push for non contact.
The well off son must be feeling very hurt amongst all this drama that has no doubt been egged on by the op. Does he feels bad about not paying his share - is he feeling a little bit emasculated too, does the Op bring up her paying her share often and him having to play catch up by working two jobs. His mum’s inheritance would have made things more equal.

There just something unpleasant brewing here, I’m sensing trouble in paradise and it’s not the Mil who’s caused it but her cash might have delayed things for a while.