Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

"Don't put me in a home" (Jo Brand)

238 replies

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 08:28

Did anyone hear the interview with Jo Brand on 'Off Air with Jane and Fi' (Podcast with Jane Garvey and Fi Glover).

Here's a link Jane Garvey interview with Jo Brand (this bit is at about 46 mins in)

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My dad has dementia is not coping with his daily carers and is increasingly unsafe at home, so the burden of caring (and it is a burden) is increasingly falling onto me and my brother. It is a hugely stressful situation with impacts on our own health. We've thought long and hard about what is best for him and are starting conversations with him about moving him to a care home where he will get the care he needs, a steady routine, company, activities, stimulation etc. He's very lonely and isolated at home and it is awful to see him living his life like that. The one we have in mind looks wonderful, and specialises in dementia care.

I think it will be the best place for him but I still can't quite shake off the "don't put me in a home" stigma. I would love to ban the phrase "put him/her in a home" as it completely minimises the huge amount of planning, the tightrope of delicate negotiations with the EP and the emotional turmoil that are involved in such a seemingly simple decision. If only "putting someone in a home" was as easy as the phrase suggests.

So I found Jo Brand's comment very disheartening and it immediately triggered feelings of guilt and made me question myself again. Jane Garvey's father died recently and she has talked very movingly about this. She gave a very good defence of care homes, which i was very happy to hear.

OP posts:
IdleGossip · 10/11/2026 08:33

Oh I totally agree. I didn't hear it either and I'm surprised as Jo Brand is usually very stoic and sensible.

My parents were the same. No experience of care homes, just what they had read in the newspapers and seen on TV and formed their own opinion that they were just one step up from a Victorian "lunatic asylum". So when my dad's dementia was deteriorating quickly and mum was struggling to cope, she wouldn't even discuss what may happen if dad couldn't be at home any more.

It's a very selfish point of view from the older person concerned. Sometimes it gets to the stage when you need more than just someone organising doctors appointments and popping to Tesco. It's very selfish to ask adult children to put their own lives on hold for years to be there as a constant carer because you are too ill, or not safe enough, to be left alone.

OffWith · 10/11/2026 08:35

It is hard because for some families that is the only realistic option.

But as someone who worked in the care system for decades, hell would have to freeze over before I allowed any of my loved ones to go into a home. We have planned as such.

Additup · 10/11/2026 08:39

I would have assumed Jo Brand would have meant don't put me in a home, finish me off instead rather than she was criticising families whose loved ones live in a care home.

Lexibletheflexible · 10/11/2026 08:40

I'd assume she means she has the money for care at home if it is needed so she can feasibly say that to her family.

RaraRachael · 10/11/2026 08:43

I don't know what the alternative is though.

My MiL has dementia and was living with my SiL. We are 200 miles away and other SiL is abroad.
It was OK at first as SiL worked from home and MiL sat on the couch watching TV as she worked.
Then she stated having falls, becoming incontinent and the family were getting little sleep. My SiL was close to a breakdown.

MiL has now been in a home for a year. I don't see what else they could have done.

dodgercity · 10/11/2026 08:45

Jo Brand can probably afford 24 care at home. I’m sure that would be the preferred option for a lot of people if they could afford it.
If she can’t, then yes she’d being pretty selfish.

AnnaMagnani · 10/11/2026 08:46

She can likely afford 24 hour care at home, even with more than one carer.

It's not a helpful statement given 99.9% of the population can't.

TemporarilyCantDoMyself · 10/11/2026 08:48

Much as I love Jo Brand, she's just a person with a personal opinion.
As am I - my personal opinion, based on close contact with a number of elderly people in recent years, both friends and family, is that it's possible to be happy and well cared for and safe in a home if that's the right thing for the capability and circumstances of the person concerned. And that's what matters and can only be decided on a case by case basis. And it sounds as though it's very much the right decision for your family.
Best of luck @Hangryhorace and try not to beat yourself up for doing the best but difficult thing, 🫂

Negantiger · 10/11/2026 08:48

OffWith · 10/11/2026 08:35

It is hard because for some families that is the only realistic option.

But as someone who worked in the care system for decades, hell would have to freeze over before I allowed any of my loved ones to go into a home. We have planned as such.

I work as a carer and same. I take my service users to visit their relatives in care homes and no care homes are good. One of my families is trying to move a man I used to care for, he’s in a high needs dementia home (he’s not actually high needs so not even sure how he ended up there) with actual nurses on site and it’s fucking dire. He loved his food going into the home and now he’s skeletal as he needs help eating and no one will feed him. After paying thousands a month for care they’re still having to rotate to go in at least twice a day to make sure he’s been fed. And multiple times now me or the family have gone in and found him slumped and clearly seriously ill to the point we’ve had to call 999 and he’s had a stay in hospital. He’s been in for about 2 weeks now with pneumonia that the care home didn’t pick up on, his daughter again found him slumped in a wheelchair in a doorway grey and barely breathing. Some homes I’ve worked in have been badly staffed, which while doesn’t excuse, certainly explains the poor care. I’m not sure what’s going on in this home though as there are staff everywhere. And I’ve never been in a home that didn’t have that stench of stale piss. I know most people are in pads or have catheters, but it’s very clear the smell is coming from minimal cleaning and poor hygiene, I hate even walking into the places

Seeingadistance · 10/11/2026 08:49

Additup · 10/11/2026 08:39

I would have assumed Jo Brand would have meant don't put me in a home, finish me off instead rather than she was criticising families whose loved ones live in a care home.

But "finish me off instead" isn't a viable or legal option!

I'm not really in a position to criticise because I've been saying to my DS for years now that if I end up incapacitated that he's to hit me over the back of the head with a shovel! However, I'm also now looking at the more practical and legal option of setting out my wishes in writing in an advance directive.

I've also, privately, set my own best before age as 80 - based on how my grandparents and parents have aged. Taking action myself is better than asking others to do it for me.

It's very unfair of Jo Brand, or anyone else, to put the burden of finding an alternative to residential care onto the shoulders of others. If she's set in her wishes, then it's up to her to find the alternative.

Lexibletheflexible · 10/11/2026 08:52

Seeingadistance · 10/11/2026 08:49

But "finish me off instead" isn't a viable or legal option!

I'm not really in a position to criticise because I've been saying to my DS for years now that if I end up incapacitated that he's to hit me over the back of the head with a shovel! However, I'm also now looking at the more practical and legal option of setting out my wishes in writing in an advance directive.

I've also, privately, set my own best before age as 80 - based on how my grandparents and parents have aged. Taking action myself is better than asking others to do it for me.

It's very unfair of Jo Brand, or anyone else, to put the burden of finding an alternative to residential care onto the shoulders of others. If she's set in her wishes, then it's up to her to find the alternative.

Well one can get to a point where they can't oversee their care and ensure they are getting the best care they can. At that point, she will be reliant on others to find another carer/care company rather than put her in a nursing home.

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 08:52

I would guess that Jo Brand has sufficient resources to mean that 24 hour care would be affordable if it became necessary.

Some people cant conceptualise the idea that they could develop dementia and what that would be like for themselves and the people around them. They cant imagine themselves becoming irrationally angry, violent, fearful. They cant imagine themselves becoming totally dependent on carers to deal with their every need.

DMIL and later, DM both had to go into carehomes for their care and safety. There was no viable alternative. DMIL wasnt aware of her surroundings so could have been anywhere. DM was, kind of aware, sometimes, at the start. Now she is bedbound living in a dreamworld populated by ghosts from the past.

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 08:53

Good grief surely the answer isn’t killing peolle but working out why UK care home are on average so shit and fixing that ?

other countries manage much better
my guess is we are on average a greedy selfish nation who would rather kill granny than sort out the taxation system. Gosh I mean we kill granny we make sure we get the juicy inheritance

Ilovemyshed · 10/11/2026 08:55

I beg to differ on care homes. I have a relative in one and its amazing. She has a big room with ensuite toilet. She has gone from not walking at all to managing with a frame. The lounge looks over a gorgeous view. They eat breakfast lunch dinner and supper in a restaurant set up with help where needed.
Most of all, there activities and events every single day designed to stimulate and exercise and all residents are actively encouraged to participate as much or as little as they can.

Fruityoranges · 10/11/2026 08:56

My mum in law sat me down last year (with my DH in the other room in earshot) and said “I don’t want to go in a home or have carers.” I was like “ ok and that means…..? I am a nurse, apparently it’s all down to me! And probably in my house!! 🙄 I’m “happy” /resigned to this of course but bloody cross it’s just assumed I will by all parties!

Seeingadistance · 10/11/2026 08:57

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 08:53

Good grief surely the answer isn’t killing peolle but working out why UK care home are on average so shit and fixing that ?

other countries manage much better
my guess is we are on average a greedy selfish nation who would rather kill granny than sort out the taxation system. Gosh I mean we kill granny we make sure we get the juicy inheritance

No matter how excellent the care home, the reality is that being very old, frail, demented and dependent on others for all aspects of functioning is shit. There's just no getting away from that.

My DF is being very well cared for in his home - so much so that he has lived at least 3 years longer than we really expected him to.

NorthXNorthWest · 10/11/2026 08:58

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 08:53

Good grief surely the answer isn’t killing peolle but working out why UK care home are on average so shit and fixing that ?

other countries manage much better
my guess is we are on average a greedy selfish nation who would rather kill granny than sort out the taxation system. Gosh I mean we kill granny we make sure we get the juicy inheritance

my guess is we are on average a greedy selfish nation who would rather kill granny than sort out the taxation system.

Spending more money, especially other peoples money, to line the pockets of profit maximising companies is not the solution you think it it.

Cyclebabble · 10/11/2026 08:59

I am the carer for DH with early onset Lewy body dementia. The aim will be to try and keep him at home as long as possible, but care for a dementia patient is an all consuming business. For many people with a family the only option would be residential care and I would not judge anyone who went for this option at a relatively early stage. My children are now adult, but were they younger the care of DH would have significantly impacted their lives and I do not think this would have been fair. I understand why if you are the sufferer you might want to remain exactly where you are, but where you are hallucinating, lack continence and frequently refuse to shower and dress the work of caring for a relative can be really difficult and care will be the only option.

researchers3 · 10/11/2026 09:02

Additup · 10/11/2026 08:39

I would have assumed Jo Brand would have meant don't put me in a home, finish me off instead rather than she was criticising families whose loved ones live in a care home.

This. I didn't read the article but people are allowed their personal opinions.

And some care facilities ARE appalling. Happily not all of them.

Also Jo (I'd imagine) will have the money for private care at home which not everyone will have.

It's an awful position to be in, whether you're the elderly/ill or the carer. I've not been in that situation so I'm not going to judge.

ElectricThrowAddict · 10/11/2026 09:05

My grandparents refused to 'go into homes' and made a point of emotionally black mailing my mother for years so that she cared for them I their own homes. They had carers at vast expense which necessitated dodgy equity release deals and my mum travelled to stay there every single weekend.

This meant we kids were basically abandoned a lot. My dad was a shift worker and not overly paternal.

My mum was exhausted and unavailable to us.

I will never ever put my dc in this position. My parents know this. If they cannot be safely cared for at home then they will need to be cared for in a residential setting. I will not be abandoning my dc and sacrificing my mental and physical health to care for them.

I have zero expectation if anyone doing it for me either!

ItsAQuandryAlright · 10/11/2026 09:07

Negantiger · 10/11/2026 08:48

I work as a carer and same. I take my service users to visit their relatives in care homes and no care homes are good. One of my families is trying to move a man I used to care for, he’s in a high needs dementia home (he’s not actually high needs so not even sure how he ended up there) with actual nurses on site and it’s fucking dire. He loved his food going into the home and now he’s skeletal as he needs help eating and no one will feed him. After paying thousands a month for care they’re still having to rotate to go in at least twice a day to make sure he’s been fed. And multiple times now me or the family have gone in and found him slumped and clearly seriously ill to the point we’ve had to call 999 and he’s had a stay in hospital. He’s been in for about 2 weeks now with pneumonia that the care home didn’t pick up on, his daughter again found him slumped in a wheelchair in a doorway grey and barely breathing. Some homes I’ve worked in have been badly staffed, which while doesn’t excuse, certainly explains the poor care. I’m not sure what’s going on in this home though as there are staff everywhere. And I’ve never been in a home that didn’t have that stench of stale piss. I know most people are in pads or have catheters, but it’s very clear the smell is coming from minimal cleaning and poor hygiene, I hate even walking into the places

Edited

I think this is very unfair and a sweeping generalisation. My mother's care home was very good, and she was very comfortable there. She had a lovely room and the staff on the whole were great. Mum had a strong character and had no problem letting us and them know if she was unhappy with anything. We simply couldn't care for her at home as she was bed bound and we couldn't lift or move her, and having carers coming in 4x a day just wasn't enough. She was lonely and vulnerable at home. She was much happier in the care home.

I heard the Jo Brand interview and it didn't bother me. Her choice at the end of the day, and I don't feel any guilt as I know that my mother was better off in her lovely care home.

SpiralSister · 10/11/2026 09:08

Fruityoranges · 10/11/2026 08:56

My mum in law sat me down last year (with my DH in the other room in earshot) and said “I don’t want to go in a home or have carers.” I was like “ ok and that means…..? I am a nurse, apparently it’s all down to me! And probably in my house!! 🙄 I’m “happy” /resigned to this of course but bloody cross it’s just assumed I will by all parties!

Why are you resigned? Why are you happy to sacrifice yourself for someone else’s lack of responsibility and entitled selfishness?

I dearly hope that my parents generation are the last to assume that their old age is everyone else’s problem, they merely need to sit back and issue their commands and the (mostly) women of the family will scurry about making it so.

Care in the UK needs a massive overhaul. And people need to take responsibility for their old age, in advance.

I’m aware that is all more nuanced than this, really, and I’m sure Jo Brand does too. But realistic conversations need to happen in families that are more than the older person saying ‘no’ to everything.

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 09:09

24 hour care at home would work for some people but for my dad it would not ease the issue of loneliness which i think is contributing to his decline.

Every case is unique, obviously, but I don't agree that care at home is necessarily better than care in a home.

We had a full time carer for my mum and it wasn't great. Mum resented her being in her housee all the time and she caused issues of her own. In the end we were manging the house, the carer and my mum.

Jo did like the idea of robot carers though so maybe that's the future she envisages. Just make sure your wishes are clearly expressed to your family, Jo!
.

OP posts:
Hadroncollideer · 10/11/2026 09:12

Jo B would be able to afford a live in carer and home adaptations to enable her to live at home. So for her personally it may be a possibility to avoid a care home.

One of my parents has said the same. Said they don't mind moving to the sheltered accommodation in the village. Trouble is, that sheltered accommodation is social housing and as parent has their own home plus savings that's unlikely to be a goer.

KitsyWitsy · 10/11/2026 09:12

She used to be a psychiatric nurse. She knows what they're like. That's probably why.

Swipe left for the next trending thread