Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

"Don't put me in a home" (Jo Brand)

239 replies

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 08:28

Did anyone hear the interview with Jo Brand on 'Off Air with Jane and Fi' (Podcast with Jane Garvey and Fi Glover).

Here's a link Jane Garvey interview with Jo Brand (this bit is at about 46 mins in)

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My dad has dementia is not coping with his daily carers and is increasingly unsafe at home, so the burden of caring (and it is a burden) is increasingly falling onto me and my brother. It is a hugely stressful situation with impacts on our own health. We've thought long and hard about what is best for him and are starting conversations with him about moving him to a care home where he will get the care he needs, a steady routine, company, activities, stimulation etc. He's very lonely and isolated at home and it is awful to see him living his life like that. The one we have in mind looks wonderful, and specialises in dementia care.

I think it will be the best place for him but I still can't quite shake off the "don't put me in a home" stigma. I would love to ban the phrase "put him/her in a home" as it completely minimises the huge amount of planning, the tightrope of delicate negotiations with the EP and the emotional turmoil that are involved in such a seemingly simple decision. If only "putting someone in a home" was as easy as the phrase suggests.

So I found Jo Brand's comment very disheartening and it immediately triggered feelings of guilt and made me question myself again. Jane Garvey's father died recently and she has talked very movingly about this. She gave a very good defence of care homes, which i was very happy to hear.

OP posts:
AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 10/11/2026 10:49

Fruityoranges · 10/11/2026 08:56

My mum in law sat me down last year (with my DH in the other room in earshot) and said “I don’t want to go in a home or have carers.” I was like “ ok and that means…..? I am a nurse, apparently it’s all down to me! And probably in my house!! 🙄 I’m “happy” /resigned to this of course but bloody cross it’s just assumed I will by all parties!

I would not have tolerated this. Just ask your mother what she is expecting to happen.

theemmadilemma · 10/11/2026 10:50

I'm so grateful my Mum has been very clear that she doesn't want her adult children to have to care for her.

She did for her father and the toll was evident to everyone. That made her VERY clear that she has no intention of putting that on any of us and will make every decision needed on that basis. ❤

That's unselfish, and gracious.

catofglory · 10/11/2026 10:50

Elliesbelly · 10/11/2026 10:36

I completely agree. This is a real issue, treating people without any quality of life for things that would have given them a peaceful death at home 10 times over in previous generations is an enormous part of the problem.

Just because modern medicine can treat does not always mean it should treat.

There needs to be a discussion on when treatment stops with people and especially with family members.

I agree with you. And that is what happened with my mother. The last two years of her life it was agreed by all that she would not leave the care home for any type of treatment. She was considered palliative care only. She was very underweight, immobile, doubly incontinent, had to be fed. But she still failed to die for two years. In the end she caught a cold and died within 24 hours.

MyManinCaracas · 10/11/2026 10:51

My 93 year old sits in his own filth, falls and spends hours on the floor, and walks hunched over because he refuses any help or care. And he’s racist so won’t have a brown nurse (lives in Florida so the excellent medical care will sometimes be administered by a brown person). He refused in-patient physio treatment because he didn’t want to be near black people. 🤷‍♀️

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 10:51

We should all be encouraged to complete Advance Directives. Legally binding if witnessed. Alzheimers Society have a template.

I'm working on mine now. Once I am no longer able to advocate for myself I want all medical treatment other than pain relief to stop.

Once complete I will send it to my GP and also to my adult DCs (already discussed with them).

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 10:54

@catofglory This is where I am with my DM. Advanced vascular dementia.

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:02

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:27

I think everyone understands this and feels this deeply within themselves. It's a human instinct to want a stable and familiar 'home', especially when you're vulnerable and in poor health. There comes a point though where you can't stay at home without creating an incredible amount of work and responsibility for others because you can't even care for yourself, let alone a property. At this point is it really everyone else's responsibility to keep you in your home forever when it becomes ever more impractical and taxing. I have seen adult children make themselves unwell attempting to support elderly and unwell people to stay in completely inappropriate homes.

Rather than get to a point where others consider me a burden I would prefer the choice not to be.
And yes, if someone prefers to be in their home, that should be respected. It is not presently.

If a person can afford to pay for carers that should be their choice. Not the choice of someone else who finds it more helpful to shuffle you off somewhere. Perhaps with one eye to work through your belongings and sell your home.

You can be locked in at a care home. But the law does not allow (at the moment) to lock a person inside their own. Even if they would have locked themselves in before they lost some capacity ! Even if you have neighbours who would look out for you, wear a pendant to call for 24 hr help, have a smoke alarm, burglar alarm etc. The care home can . Your own home no.

If you have POA for an older person. You have a legal duty to act in their interests. Not your own. The POA is shockingly weak tbh. And needs an overhaul.

But I do not automatically agree with your premise that it is everyone else’s heart wrenching though it might be scenario, to place someone against their will into a home.

drspouse · 10/11/2026 11:09

I'm curious as to where PP are where you can choose euthanasia/assisted suicide for dementia. Maybe Canada/the Netherlands.

TheRealMagic · 10/11/2026 11:12

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 08:53

Good grief surely the answer isn’t killing peolle but working out why UK care home are on average so shit and fixing that ?

other countries manage much better
my guess is we are on average a greedy selfish nation who would rather kill granny than sort out the taxation system. Gosh I mean we kill granny we make sure we get the juicy inheritance

When people say other countries do this better it always turn out they mean 'in other countries women accept that it is their fate to be unpaid carers for decades due to their sex'.

DBSFstupid · 10/11/2026 11:14

OffWith · 10/11/2026 08:35

It is hard because for some families that is the only realistic option.

But as someone who worked in the care system for decades, hell would have to freeze over before I allowed any of my loved ones to go into a home. We have planned as such.

Could you explain why a bit more please?

Sakura7 · 10/11/2026 11:17

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:02

Rather than get to a point where others consider me a burden I would prefer the choice not to be.
And yes, if someone prefers to be in their home, that should be respected. It is not presently.

If a person can afford to pay for carers that should be their choice. Not the choice of someone else who finds it more helpful to shuffle you off somewhere. Perhaps with one eye to work through your belongings and sell your home.

You can be locked in at a care home. But the law does not allow (at the moment) to lock a person inside their own. Even if they would have locked themselves in before they lost some capacity ! Even if you have neighbours who would look out for you, wear a pendant to call for 24 hr help, have a smoke alarm, burglar alarm etc. The care home can . Your own home no.

If you have POA for an older person. You have a legal duty to act in their interests. Not your own. The POA is shockingly weak tbh. And needs an overhaul.

But I do not automatically agree with your premise that it is everyone else’s heart wrenching though it might be scenario, to place someone against their will into a home.

Edited

Sometimes the level of care required simply cannot be provided at home. That's the reality.

Even if the person has the money for 24 hour care, who is going to arrange it all, and look after all the other everyday requirements like managing finances, maintaining the home, food shopping, paying bills, travel to medical appointments, etc?

I think there's an assumption that carers can just do absolutely everything. They can't.

LittlePetitePsychopath · 10/11/2026 11:20

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My DH's parents had this chat with him at 16. They were in their 40s. When we got together, they were still constantly reminding him of it. They're in their 70s now, DH is 40. They are VLC, and we have young children, and there's just no way at all that we could care for them. Just none. We are breaking under the capacity of everything else, there's just no way it'd balance with either of us being gone several times a day, or for long stretches.

I don't know what they think would happen. I presume they don't want their son cleaning them either, really, and they don't know their grandchildren, and barely talk to me. I don't think they'd be mad about carers... but there's only so long that works for, as you've said.

I don't think it's an unusual conversation but I do think it's just a guilt-trip, unless they've identified a different, actually possible way forward.

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:21

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 10:28

Sometimes there is no choice. Even for those who do have family to care for them. If you are in your sixties and your parent is in the throes of advanced dementia, how would you cope with the relentlessness, and believe me it IS relentless. The constant demands, the wandering around all night, the toilet accidents. The lack of being able to go out even for half an hour while hoping the house isnt in flames

I do have experience of it. Twice over.
But I resent that they are called care homes. They are not the persons home.

TheRealMagic · 10/11/2026 11:22

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:21

I do have experience of it. Twice over.
But I resent that they are called care homes. They are not the persons home.

They are where they live...?

Sakura7 · 10/11/2026 11:29

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:21

I do have experience of it. Twice over.
But I resent that they are called care homes. They are not the persons home.

You seem to be weirdly hung up on this. What else should they be called? It is to all intents and purposes their home at that point in time, as they live there.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 11:29

Additup · 10/11/2026 08:39

I would have assumed Jo Brand would have meant don't put me in a home, finish me off instead rather than she was criticising families whose loved ones live in a care home.

I think this too.

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:30

Sakura7 · 10/11/2026 11:17

Sometimes the level of care required simply cannot be provided at home. That's the reality.

Even if the person has the money for 24 hour care, who is going to arrange it all, and look after all the other everyday requirements like managing finances, maintaining the home, food shopping, paying bills, travel to medical appointments, etc?

I think there's an assumption that carers can just do absolutely everything. They can't.

Thanks. I do have experience of it. Twice over.
The care ‘world’ needs a huge overhaul. The POA does. Assisted dying needs to be allowed.
We should want things to improve. It will come.

sesquipedalian · 10/11/2026 11:31

I think people who “don’t want to go into a care home” don’t ever imagine that they will be the old, difficult, incontinent, demented old person who really can’t cope without massive intervention - they think they might be a bit frail, and will just require a bit of help. I think it’s utterly selfish to expect your DC to put their life on hold for you. Even if you have pots of money, there may come a time when you need help, and I certainly wouldn’t want my own DC having to look after me, because they have their own lives and families. Of course we all hope we will die quietly in the night but alas, that doesn’t happen to most people, and most nice parents most certainly wouldn’t want to be a burden to their children.

Elliesbelly · 10/11/2026 11:32

TheRealMagic · 10/11/2026 11:12

When people say other countries do this better it always turn out they mean 'in other countries women accept that it is their fate to be unpaid carers for decades due to their sex'.

Also in any of these other countries they don’t have health systems that prolong poor quality life.

There is no way in many poorer parts of India, or very poor rural China, where care is entirely provided by family, that people would be treated in hospitals with the regularity that happens here. Nature would be allowed to take its course.

Care homes are at least in some part a response to the over treatment of patients beyond any quality of life.

Octavia64 · 10/11/2026 11:33

I’m disabled.

i know quite a few people who have carers going in and a few who live in care homes.

i did myself look into the Switzerland option. I have lifetime membership of dignitas. It’s a long and complex procedure that takes over six months and requires multiple visits to Switzerland to be seen by various doctors and assessed. The cost these days is around 20k. It’s out of reach for most people both in terms of money and time. They don’t take you if you have dementia or there are any concerns at all that you don’t fully understand what you are doing.

i wanted it as a back up because care and treatment for my condition is notoriously poor and I felt I needed to know I had the option to stop the pain and suffering. Thankfully I have largely (with the help of some great physios and therapists) managed to create a livable modus vivendi.

i’m torn about assisted dying. Care in the uk for the newly disabled is so bad I think many would take it. But I don’t feel that they should have to - there should be better care.

my friends who are in care homes mostly are there because they do not want the burden to fall on family. There are aspects they do like and aspects they don’f but life is what it is and they don’f want their children to have a shit life caring for them. So they do the stiff upper lip.

as will I when my time comes (and it will)

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:33

TheRealMagic · 10/11/2026 11:22

They are where they live...?

They live in a box for a bedroom. With barely anything of their life within it. Some are allowed more than others. Often just the odd photo. They might have an en-suite. Everywhere else is communal. Even if you have a TV on a carer will turn it up too loud and have Channel they think you would watch, but it isn’t.

It is not a home. Your home is where you have your belongings, your memories, your things around you. Where you have independence to go to bed when you want, get up when you want, eat the food you want. When you fancy it.

They are care facilities. Not care homes.

DuchessofWinchester · 10/11/2026 11:34

I worked in a care home between school and uni.

Neither of my parents will ever go into care homes.

There is a stigma for a reason. They are not nice and no one deserves to go in one.

They're basically prison that you have to pay for and didn't earn the punishment for.

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:39

sesquipedalian · 10/11/2026 11:31

I think people who “don’t want to go into a care home” don’t ever imagine that they will be the old, difficult, incontinent, demented old person who really can’t cope without massive intervention - they think they might be a bit frail, and will just require a bit of help. I think it’s utterly selfish to expect your DC to put their life on hold for you. Even if you have pots of money, there may come a time when you need help, and I certainly wouldn’t want my own DC having to look after me, because they have their own lives and families. Of course we all hope we will die quietly in the night but alas, that doesn’t happen to most people, and most nice parents most certainly wouldn’t want to be a burden to their children.

Sorry but my mother was not selfish. Nor was my MIL.

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 11:39

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 10:54

@catofglory This is where I am with my DM. Advanced vascular dementia.

My mum had vascular dementia. She had heart problems and the consultant offered her surgery which could give her another 5 or so years of life. This was when she still had capacity and she declined, stating she didnt want to end up in nappies not knowing owing her own name.
She eventually went into a care home, they knew what her wishes were and some 3 months later she died peacefully in her sleep xx

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 11:40

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:39

Sorry but my mother was not selfish. Nor was my MIL.

That poster never specified that your mother or MIL were selfish but that it is undeniably selfish to expect anyone, especially your adult DC, to put their lives on hold to care for you. How is that not selfish?