Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

"Don't put me in a home" (Jo Brand)

239 replies

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 08:28

Did anyone hear the interview with Jo Brand on 'Off Air with Jane and Fi' (Podcast with Jane Garvey and Fi Glover).

Here's a link Jane Garvey interview with Jo Brand (this bit is at about 46 mins in)

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My dad has dementia is not coping with his daily carers and is increasingly unsafe at home, so the burden of caring (and it is a burden) is increasingly falling onto me and my brother. It is a hugely stressful situation with impacts on our own health. We've thought long and hard about what is best for him and are starting conversations with him about moving him to a care home where he will get the care he needs, a steady routine, company, activities, stimulation etc. He's very lonely and isolated at home and it is awful to see him living his life like that. The one we have in mind looks wonderful, and specialises in dementia care.

I think it will be the best place for him but I still can't quite shake off the "don't put me in a home" stigma. I would love to ban the phrase "put him/her in a home" as it completely minimises the huge amount of planning, the tightrope of delicate negotiations with the EP and the emotional turmoil that are involved in such a seemingly simple decision. If only "putting someone in a home" was as easy as the phrase suggests.

So I found Jo Brand's comment very disheartening and it immediately triggered feelings of guilt and made me question myself again. Jane Garvey's father died recently and she has talked very movingly about this. She gave a very good defence of care homes, which i was very happy to hear.

OP posts:
Monty36 · 10/11/2026 11:41

Sakura7 · 10/11/2026 11:29

You seem to be weirdly hung up on this. What else should they be called? It is to all intents and purposes their home at that point in time, as they live there.

I have had years of being within the care world I suppose. It is not one I particularly admire. I am not hung up on it. I just get frustrated by the sort of acceptance of a crap system people seem to have. We should want better. I am sure it can be.

fridaynightzzz · 10/11/2026 11:45

I have friends who’ve been in homes and it’s a positive experience. Our friends mother improved enormously when moved to a home with regular food and activities rather than the flat she was living in alone.
It’s like DHs family spend so long keeping a relative with downs syndrome out of the care system and being passed around relatives. She eventually did go into a care home and bloody loved it and had a great last 10 years of her life. They thought she would be locked in a cell, instead she went out shopping and on nice holidays and did crafts.

catofglory · 10/11/2026 11:45

@GnomeDePlume I'm sorry to hear that. I hope the end is peaceful and not too prolonged. My mother had Alzheimers which gave her a slow decline.

Re the assisted dying bill, it did not apply to dementia. Criteria was full mental capacity and death expected within 6 months. So even if/when it is passed those with dementia would still have to go to Switzerland, who do accept dementia but with strict criteria.

But in reality, many people do not understand they have dementia precisely because the dementia removes their ability to understand/accept it. And even for those who do know, dementia scrambles your executive function to the extent it's unlikely you'd be able to arrange a trip to Switzerland.

TheignT · 10/11/2026 11:50

OffWith · 10/11/2026 08:35

It is hard because for some families that is the only realistic option.

But as someone who worked in the care system for decades, hell would have to freeze over before I allowed any of my loved ones to go into a home. We have planned as such.

That's a shame. I've worked in the care sector and I've said if I need care then put me in the last home I worked in. Lovely place, very homely, very caring.

TheignT · 10/11/2026 11:50

fridaynightzzz · 10/11/2026 11:45

I have friends who’ve been in homes and it’s a positive experience. Our friends mother improved enormously when moved to a home with regular food and activities rather than the flat she was living in alone.
It’s like DHs family spend so long keeping a relative with downs syndrome out of the care system and being passed around relatives. She eventually did go into a care home and bloody loved it and had a great last 10 years of her life. They thought she would be locked in a cell, instead she went out shopping and on nice holidays and did crafts.

Sounds like the home I know.

RaraRachael · 10/11/2026 11:53

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 09:27

There never used to be so many care homes. People died earlier but arguably far more naturally. Not left slumped in a chair propped up on drugs to die ten years later.

Totally agree. Any photos I see of my MiL are of her sitting in a chair with her head tipped back and her mouth open while some entertainment or activity is going on.
Even in her room she was slumped with her false teeth hanging out.

I'd rather die at 78 than "live" like this at 88.

CloudPop · 10/11/2026 11:55

sesquipedalian · 10/11/2026 11:31

I think people who “don’t want to go into a care home” don’t ever imagine that they will be the old, difficult, incontinent, demented old person who really can’t cope without massive intervention - they think they might be a bit frail, and will just require a bit of help. I think it’s utterly selfish to expect your DC to put their life on hold for you. Even if you have pots of money, there may come a time when you need help, and I certainly wouldn’t want my own DC having to look after me, because they have their own lives and families. Of course we all hope we will die quietly in the night but alas, that doesn’t happen to most people, and most nice parents most certainly wouldn’t want to be a burden to their children.

Completely agree with you

BirmaBright · 10/11/2026 12:03

There never used to be so many care homes. People died earlier but arguably far more naturally. Not left slumped in a chair propped up on drugs to die ten years later.

The NHS used to fund long term elderly care and there were wards/hospitals that did exactly that, and when I say long term I mean until someone died, like an upgraded workhouse type situation. The shift to the care being provided by private companies really started to take hold in the 1990's when the responsibility shifted to local authorities. I think the figure for the amount of care provided by private companies is roughly around 80% both for residential care and domiciliary care.

OffWith · 10/11/2026 12:09

DBSFstupid · 10/11/2026 11:14

Could you explain why a bit more please?

In my experience there was a huge gulf between what was portrayed to families, and the reality of the day to day lives of the residents. I worked in both expensive and cheaper homes.

Activities would be put on for a few minutes, photos would be taken for inspections and families, then they would be left alone for hours. Personal care was sometimes not done until it had dried and caked on them (I often had to deal with this when coming on shift).

Every year there seemed to be more workers who just didn't care for the job, and did not have the emotional intelligence or patience for it. They would shout, mock and be nasty to the residents when they 'annoyed' them and there were no family around.

I would report marks on patients. Only once something was done about it when we actually witnessed one lady with dementia being struck, but other than that it was swept under the rug.

Our managers were always well aware of any inspections in advance, and would always put on a show/ cover up care gaps.

I just would not trust anything we were told or shown from experience, so I could never have a vulnerable family member cared for. Perhaps I would feel differently if they had all their faculties and wanted to go.

IcyPinkWasp · 10/11/2026 12:17

Speaking from very recent experience.

My Dad passed away a month ago and he was the sole carer of my Mum who has advanced vascular dementia. The week that followed for myself and my 2 sisters was pure hell. We simply couldnt cope with her needs. We all have families and full time jobs and were mourning our Dad as well as being thrown in the deep end with our Mum's needs. We made the heartbreaking decision to put her into a care home. This was our only option going forward. It broke our hearts and the guilt has been unbareable. BUT..... it has been the best decision. Mum is thriving. She is safe, looked after, sociable, joining in activities. She still asks to go home, although she was asking to go home in the week we spent with her at home :(

Its hard and i'm still struggling with the guilt but it really was the kindest thing to do for all involved

TheignT · 10/11/2026 12:29

OffWith · 10/11/2026 12:09

In my experience there was a huge gulf between what was portrayed to families, and the reality of the day to day lives of the residents. I worked in both expensive and cheaper homes.

Activities would be put on for a few minutes, photos would be taken for inspections and families, then they would be left alone for hours. Personal care was sometimes not done until it had dried and caked on them (I often had to deal with this when coming on shift).

Every year there seemed to be more workers who just didn't care for the job, and did not have the emotional intelligence or patience for it. They would shout, mock and be nasty to the residents when they 'annoyed' them and there were no family around.

I would report marks on patients. Only once something was done about it when we actually witnessed one lady with dementia being struck, but other than that it was swept under the rug.

Our managers were always well aware of any inspections in advance, and would always put on a show/ cover up care gaps.

I just would not trust anything we were told or shown from experience, so I could never have a vulnerable family member cared for. Perhaps I would feel differently if they had all their faculties and wanted to go.

So different I the home I worked in. Residents involved in real activities like making shopping lists and going to supermarket with staff. Helping with food prep, might just be helping a staff member to lay the table or helping to load the dish washer. Helping in the garden if they like gardening. Obviously staff doing most of it but the residents feeling involved. Holidays, trips to cinema or theatre or just out for a coffee. It is very much their home.

This isn't one of the expensive homes.

TheignT · 10/11/2026 12:34

IcyPinkWasp · 10/11/2026 12:17

Speaking from very recent experience.

My Dad passed away a month ago and he was the sole carer of my Mum who has advanced vascular dementia. The week that followed for myself and my 2 sisters was pure hell. We simply couldnt cope with her needs. We all have families and full time jobs and were mourning our Dad as well as being thrown in the deep end with our Mum's needs. We made the heartbreaking decision to put her into a care home. This was our only option going forward. It broke our hearts and the guilt has been unbareable. BUT..... it has been the best decision. Mum is thriving. She is safe, looked after, sociable, joining in activities. She still asks to go home, although she was asking to go home in the week we spent with her at home :(

Its hard and i'm still struggling with the guilt but it really was the kindest thing to do for all involved

Don't feel guilty, it sounds like you've found a good place for her. You can go back to a liovng mother daughter relationship instead of a stressed carer looking after someone who becomes a burden instead of a loved mother.

Your poor dad, it must have been hard for him.

OffWith · 10/11/2026 12:34

TheignT · 10/11/2026 12:29

So different I the home I worked in. Residents involved in real activities like making shopping lists and going to supermarket with staff. Helping with food prep, might just be helping a staff member to lay the table or helping to load the dish washer. Helping in the garden if they like gardening. Obviously staff doing most of it but the residents feeling involved. Holidays, trips to cinema or theatre or just out for a coffee. It is very much their home.

This isn't one of the expensive homes.

That sounds wonderful, my opinion would be very different if that had been my experience over the last twenty years.

Sadly, many of the homes I worked at were so understaffed that they would overlook unsuitable and problematic staff just to get bums on seats.

TheignT · 10/11/2026 12:41

OffWith · 10/11/2026 12:34

That sounds wonderful, my opinion would be very different if that had been my experience over the last twenty years.

Sadly, many of the homes I worked at were so understaffed that they would overlook unsuitable and problematic staff just to get bums on seats.

That's so sad. One thing that made a difference I think was the owners being very involved. They'd rather do shifts than have someone unsuitable working.

I remember in COVID and all the sadness of family not being there. One of our guys was dying. He'd been in the home for years. It was December and the night before he died staff and residents gathered outside his room and sang carols. Two staff who'd worked with him for years didn't go home at the end of their shift, they sat by his bed all night till he passed. He died in his home with people round him who knew him and cared for him. Can we ask for more?

FreyaJade · 10/11/2026 12:44

On one shift when I was redeployed to a different ward last year, I cared for a 99 year old man in a hospital side room who was suffering with flu, he was treated with anti virals but was still very ill with a respiratory rate of 40 breaths a minute, the drs were aware of this but he was only for ‘ward based level of care’..
The thing was, despite being nearly 100, with very poor mobility, mild dementia, & various chronic illnesses, he was very upset that he had the flu and was saying he absolutely did not want to die!
He lived in a nursing home and had unfortunately collapsed halfway through the Christmas dinner that he was enjoying with his wife & family in attendance.
In fact missing the rest of his dinner was actually the thing he was most aggrieved about!

I’ve met so many older people (late 80s up, often with some dementia) who are desperate to hang on to life, even when they have what others think is a poor quality of life.
Seriously there are many very elderly people who take to their beds & stay there for a variety of reasons, living extremely restricted lives but who are happy to do so.
Also regarding dementia, when you do not have it, it can seem like the worst thing in the world, but for many people it does develop gradually & they do often change behaviourally but can often be quite content in how they are.

Also I’ve met so many people who live in nursing homes or care homes, or who choose to go to them for respite. Also I have friends with relatives in them & friends / colleagues who have extra jobs working in them.. I started out working in a basic council run one in 2000, but it’s not worth even describing as the regulations & conditions have changed hugely since then. I mostly do hear positive feedback to be fair.
I think the issue that many have with home care is the loneliness between visits. Whereas in a home you can always be social.

Keepingittogetherstepbystep · 10/11/2026 12:49

My dad had dementia and had been threatened with a home by my sibling. We managed to keep him at home but it's certainly not the right choice for everyone.

You've just got to do what's best for your parent and your family and ignore what other people think as they aren't living you're reality.

I think whatever ever route is followed you always question whether you've done the right thing but as long as you've done your best then.find some peace in that decision. Other people aren't in your shoes

Seeingadistance · 10/11/2026 12:51

BirmaBright · 10/11/2026 12:03

There never used to be so many care homes. People died earlier but arguably far more naturally. Not left slumped in a chair propped up on drugs to die ten years later.

The NHS used to fund long term elderly care and there were wards/hospitals that did exactly that, and when I say long term I mean until someone died, like an upgraded workhouse type situation. The shift to the care being provided by private companies really started to take hold in the 1990's when the responsibility shifted to local authorities. I think the figure for the amount of care provided by private companies is roughly around 80% both for residential care and domiciliary care.

Yep.

My Grandfather lost speech and movement after a massive stroke in 1984. He spent 9 years in a geriatric hospital until his death.

FreyaJade · 10/11/2026 12:52

At the home where I worked 26 years ago, I do remember one resident who was 90, she only lived there for her own safety as she had schizophrenia which was well medicated but had no other issues, she chose to always do the tea rounds in the afternoons. The more mobile residents had quite a lot of freedom - one lady usually walked with her mobility aid into town each day, & one guy in his 90s had an alcohol problem, he didn’t want to give up alcohol so it was allowed as long as he didn’t appear drunk, I remember his room was always full of half empty bottles. I wonder if modern care homes would allow that.

Summeriscumin · 10/11/2026 12:53

My father decided when it was time. He'd struggled at home for so long even with a lot of carers and family support.

It gave him a new lease on life. Company when he wanted it and a lovely room when he didn't. Meals very tasty, as opposed to the meals on wheels he'd had on week days.

Washing done - which saved me a job. His own TV and bookcase.

Newspaper delivered daily.

It really did perk him up. We visited twice a week and on Sunday afternoons took him to the local park in his wheelchair.

He occasionally came to us for Sunday dinner but wasn't that bothered.

He had friends from the church and former pupils visiting without him having to struggle to open the door. And they were always offered tea or coffee.

They really did make his last 20 months more pleasurable and many of the staff came to his funeral.

I would have no fear in going into such a place.

Jo is out of touch with the reality, if you have the funds - which she does - it can be a good thing.

MidnightMeltdown · 10/11/2026 12:56

I wouldn’t put my parents in a home if I could avoid it, but it depends entirely on your circumstances. If you need to work then you can’t care for someone who is very ill and needs constant supervision (e.g. dementia patient). However, I suspect that Jo Brand has plenty of money so this wouldn’t be an issue.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:58

My friend and her mum tried really really hard to care for her gran, but gran fell asleep on the couch, rolled off and broke both hips. There was no choice. she needed more care and expertise than they could provide.
My own Gran lived in her home until she passed and only needed help with shopping, cleaning etc. Its really going to depend on the inidividual and we cant predict that!

TheignT · 10/11/2026 13:05

FreyaJade · 10/11/2026 12:52

At the home where I worked 26 years ago, I do remember one resident who was 90, she only lived there for her own safety as she had schizophrenia which was well medicated but had no other issues, she chose to always do the tea rounds in the afternoons. The more mobile residents had quite a lot of freedom - one lady usually walked with her mobility aid into town each day, & one guy in his 90s had an alcohol problem, he didn’t want to give up alcohol so it was allowed as long as he didn’t appear drunk, I remember his room was always full of half empty bottles. I wonder if modern care homes would allow that.

Reminded of my granddad, we always made sure the home had a supply of whisky and he had a glass every night. He did like a glass of whisky.

ilovepixie · 10/11/2026 13:06

My mum has dementia and my sister and I have moved into her house to look after her. It’s doable at the moment but it’s still hard. Maybe as she gets worse we will need more help but we just take it a day at a time.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2026 13:13

And yes, if someone prefers to be in their home, that should be respected. It is not presently.
If a person can afford to pay for carers that should be their choice. Not the choice of someone else who finds it more helpful to shuffle you off somewhere. Perhaps with one eye to work through your belongings and sell your home.

DM ran herself into the ground and exhausted herself giving her mother 24 hour care and doing everything for her (and I do mean everything) because the selfish old harridan refused outside carers and the thought of a home. She wouldn't even be looked after by my aunt (trained nurse) so DM could have a break. I suspect the reason the idea was never raised with her because any home would have sent her back, she was that bloody unpleasant.

And I find it a fucking insult to the years my DM spent as a carer and the love and devotion she gave that you assume she would want GM in a home 'to work through her belongings and sell her home.'

ginasevern · 10/11/2026 13:15

KitsyWitsy · 10/11/2026 09:12

She used to be a psychiatric nurse. She knows what they're like. That's probably why.

I was about to say the same thing. She's talking from personal experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread