Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

"Don't put me in a home" (Jo Brand)

239 replies

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 08:28

Did anyone hear the interview with Jo Brand on 'Off Air with Jane and Fi' (Podcast with Jane Garvey and Fi Glover).

Here's a link Jane Garvey interview with Jo Brand (this bit is at about 46 mins in)

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My dad has dementia is not coping with his daily carers and is increasingly unsafe at home, so the burden of caring (and it is a burden) is increasingly falling onto me and my brother. It is a hugely stressful situation with impacts on our own health. We've thought long and hard about what is best for him and are starting conversations with him about moving him to a care home where he will get the care he needs, a steady routine, company, activities, stimulation etc. He's very lonely and isolated at home and it is awful to see him living his life like that. The one we have in mind looks wonderful, and specialises in dementia care.

I think it will be the best place for him but I still can't quite shake off the "don't put me in a home" stigma. I would love to ban the phrase "put him/her in a home" as it completely minimises the huge amount of planning, the tightrope of delicate negotiations with the EP and the emotional turmoil that are involved in such a seemingly simple decision. If only "putting someone in a home" was as easy as the phrase suggests.

So I found Jo Brand's comment very disheartening and it immediately triggered feelings of guilt and made me question myself again. Jane Garvey's father died recently and she has talked very movingly about this. She gave a very good defence of care homes, which i was very happy to hear.

OP posts:
DierdreDaphne · 10/11/2026 09:13

Fruityoranges · 10/11/2026 08:56

My mum in law sat me down last year (with my DH in the other room in earshot) and said “I don’t want to go in a home or have carers.” I was like “ ok and that means…..? I am a nurse, apparently it’s all down to me! And probably in my house!! 🙄 I’m “happy” /resigned to this of course but bloody cross it’s just assumed I will by all parties!

Don't go along with this @Fruityoranges , for the love of God!

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 09:15

I worked in a care home and then as a home carer for years. Many of these frail elderly folk are doing their best to pass away but the families/medical folk wont seem to let them.
I've witnessed tiny little skeletal dementia sufferers being blue lighted to hospital, pumped with antibiotics and sent home again ( probably after 3 days on a trolley in a corridor)
For the love of god just let nature take its course and let them go!!!

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 09:17

Fruityoranges · 10/11/2026 08:56

My mum in law sat me down last year (with my DH in the other room in earshot) and said “I don’t want to go in a home or have carers.” I was like “ ok and that means…..? I am a nurse, apparently it’s all down to me! And probably in my house!! 🙄 I’m “happy” /resigned to this of course but bloody cross it’s just assumed I will by all parties!

You dont have to do this. You are allowed to say 'no'.

One of the things I have learned is that you have to work out which you can live with more easily: guilt or resentment.

Personally I knew I could live with guilt. In fact as my DM has declined while living in her CH I dont even feel that.

DierdreDaphne · 10/11/2026 09:18

And re "being cared for full time at home", if the elderly person has lost men tal capacity, somone else has to start running the household as well as overseeing the carers.

We were in this position wuth DM for a while even before she needed full time care, and it became more and more onerous as none of her dc was less than an hour away.

Don't underestimate the continuous toings and froi gs with correspondence from utilities, technology mysteriously not working, repairs, shopping for food and supplies blah blah blah.. Running a second household remotely is no picnic.

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 09:24

I am quite surprised at Jo Brand saying this too and I agree that it is quite selfish, because if it comes down to being the only option, it places a large burden of guilt on the family.

Personally I prey to god that I will be able to live in a decent care home when I am older, as I will have absolutely no family. Not all of us have the luxury of turning the option down.

karrapo · 10/11/2026 09:25

I don't have kids and my siblings know that if the time comes I am to go into full time care if it is unsafe for me to live alone anymore. I do not want anyone in my family to have to care for me. Maybe initially though (which they have agreed to) while being assessed, waiting for a place and so on but once the need for any kind of care on a daily basis arrives, it's off to Shady Pines for me!

I can be lighthearted about it as where I live (Ireland) there is a great (not perfect) system for the resident to fund full time care. It's called the Nursing Home Support Scheme and is open to everyone rich and not so rich. You can select from a list of NH in the catchment (or anywhere), pay 80% of your income and a max of 22.5% of assets (including home value) and that's it. You can (your estate) can pay the asset contribution after your death or it can be paid upfront. It falls due if the house is sold. Your house in the meantime can be rented out with the proceeds not reckonable for the Income contribution of 80%. There is no chance of the house needing to being sold to fund care. You can also pay the fee in full and not claim from the support scheme which is viable and works better sometimes if you have high income.

Anyway, I have asked that if I need full time care that I am on the ground floor with a french door to outside. They are having a great laugh looking for one already ha ha. I am nearly 70 and planning ahead!

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 09:27

There never used to be so many care homes. People died earlier but arguably far more naturally. Not left slumped in a chair propped up on drugs to die ten years later.

Waitingfordoggo · 10/11/2026 09:30

I’ve explicitly said to my children ‘please do put me in a home if I get to the point where I need a lot of help and you don’t want to or aren’t able to provide it’. (As long as you don’t mind getting less/no inheritance)

I would hate the thought of becoming a burden to them when they will be busy living their own lives.

wendywoopywoo222 · 10/11/2026 09:30

My parents are both in a care home. Yes they would rather be at home but practically I would have had to give up work to care for them and they would never of let me do that. They both have capacity, enjoy the social side and I sleep better knowing they are safe , warm, fed and cared for. I see them three times a week and All my visits to them are nice social events or a trip out for coffee or lunch when we can, no longer the stress of trying to keep them safe at home and all the shopping, meds etc which were wearing me out physically and emotionally.

yes it’s not ideal and not what they would of chosen but it’s a very freindly environment and best for our family.

Dormit · 10/11/2026 09:31

I made an agreement with my mum that she wouldn’t go into a home unless absolutely necessary. If we’d exhausted all possible options on the ladder between independent at home to needs a care home then we’d look into it. She’s 86 now and has 4 carers a day because her physical condition means she can’t safely do things like cook without someone with her. She’s hate to go in a home but some people would like it. I’ve told my dc to put me in a home in the Peak District where I’ve got a good view. The reality is that it’s not my local authority and I’ve no funds or a house to sell to pay for it. I don’t want to be anywhere that smells of urine and all the ones I’ve been to as a nurse or to visit, bar one that my grandma in law was in, smelt awful.
Everyone has to do their best with the options they have and these might not be very palatable.
I imagine Jo Brand being very finish me off or could afford a live in carer.

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 09:34

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 09:15

I worked in a care home and then as a home carer for years. Many of these frail elderly folk are doing their best to pass away but the families/medical folk wont seem to let them.
I've witnessed tiny little skeletal dementia sufferers being blue lighted to hospital, pumped with antibiotics and sent home again ( probably after 3 days on a trolley in a corridor)
For the love of god just let nature take its course and let them go!!!

This makes me so angry. The obsession with life is cruel and completely impractical.

We need to mature as a nation and have the difficult discussions that need to take place. Too few of us want to be carers, either paid or for loved ones. Many of us can't afford to be even if we want to be. If lots of old people want to avoid care homes but have very high needs then what are the options? I really think Assisted Dying needs to be discussed in these terms. It should be discussed as a viable alternative that many, including me, would seriously consider instead of receiving substandard care in a home we don't want to be in.

We aren't going to stumble across a load of motivated and competent carers that will care for us in our homes in exchange for the paltry sums of money many of us can afford to pay. The State has an enormous amount of debt and can't meaningfully subsidise this for us in the way we would like. Fewer children are being born so my generation will have lots of elderly people without adult children providing the informal care that currently takes place up and down the country. Who is going to do all of this caring work and how can we fund it? Why do we keep pretend the system can somehow be magically be fixed when all logic suggests it can't and it's only going to get worse?

Octavia64 · 10/11/2026 09:35

My mum said she never wanted to go into a home and we were to shoot her first

she is now elderly. Shooting her is not allowed.

i have been in a serious accident and am seriously physically disabled so she has reluctantly accepted that I can’t care for her (I have carers myself).

she’s now trying to stay as healthy as possible so she doesn’t have to go into one.

TimeAndTides · 10/11/2026 09:35

But "finish me off instead" isn't a viable or legal option!

It is where some of us live.

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 09:42

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 09:27

There never used to be so many care homes. People died earlier but arguably far more naturally. Not left slumped in a chair propped up on drugs to die ten years later.

And therein lies the problem. There seems to be a dogged determination to keep folk going forever. Flu used to take the frail and the elderly but now they have the flu jab.
A broken hip would generally end up with bed rest, pneumonia and death. Now there are people in their 90s having hip replacement surgery, as I recently witnessed, 95 year old lady had hip surgery. She was dead inside a week. As was oft said, pneumonia was an old mans friend.
Sadly that is no longer the case x

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 09:44

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 09:34

This makes me so angry. The obsession with life is cruel and completely impractical.

We need to mature as a nation and have the difficult discussions that need to take place. Too few of us want to be carers, either paid or for loved ones. Many of us can't afford to be even if we want to be. If lots of old people want to avoid care homes but have very high needs then what are the options? I really think Assisted Dying needs to be discussed in these terms. It should be discussed as a viable alternative that many, including me, would seriously consider instead of receiving substandard care in a home we don't want to be in.

We aren't going to stumble across a load of motivated and competent carers that will care for us in our homes in exchange for the paltry sums of money many of us can afford to pay. The State has an enormous amount of debt and can't meaningfully subsidise this for us in the way we would like. Fewer children are being born so my generation will have lots of elderly people without adult children providing the informal care that currently takes place up and down the country. Who is going to do all of this caring work and how can we fund it? Why do we keep pretend the system can somehow be magically be fixed when all logic suggests it can't and it's only going to get worse?

It's possible that more people will end up in practical roles like care giving as AI replaces many office jobs, however I agree the picture is bleak. I am only 40 but really focused on saving money for old age, as I think it's only those who can afford to pay who have a chance of decent care (and that isn't guaranteed either).

Tryagain26 · 10/11/2026 09:48

I didn't hear it. But yesterday I went to visit an elderly vulnerable friend to find her unconscious on her bathroom floor. I decided then that If my DH dies before me I want to go into residential accommodation where there are always people around or help at the push of a button. I don't want my children to care for me and I don't want to end up alone on the bathroom floor for goodness how long.

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 09:50

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 09:44

It's possible that more people will end up in practical roles like care giving as AI replaces many office jobs, however I agree the picture is bleak. I am only 40 but really focused on saving money for old age, as I think it's only those who can afford to pay who have a chance of decent care (and that isn't guaranteed either).

Maybe so, but I do think caring is by it's very nature a difficult and quite selfless vocation even if you are getting paid to do it. This is especially true if you want to do it well and in a way that vulnerable people deserve.

So many of us would be rubbish carers and be very unhappy in these roles. Sure, we could do it out of necessity and would do the basics but I would hate to be cared for by a reluctant carer. This is why I'm not even convinced it's just money. You could pay me £100k a year but I don't think I would be a fantastic carer. I simply don't have the temperament or natural skillset. Very few of my friends would objectively be amazing carers either and even fewer would choose to do it or even be semi satisfied with a job in this field.

Demand is going to escalate and there simply won't be enough cheerful, competent, engaged carers to meet demand.

Additup · 10/11/2026 09:54

Seeingadistance · 10/11/2026 08:49

But "finish me off instead" isn't a viable or legal option!

I'm not really in a position to criticise because I've been saying to my DS for years now that if I end up incapacitated that he's to hit me over the back of the head with a shovel! However, I'm also now looking at the more practical and legal option of setting out my wishes in writing in an advance directive.

I've also, privately, set my own best before age as 80 - based on how my grandparents and parents have aged. Taking action myself is better than asking others to do it for me.

It's very unfair of Jo Brand, or anyone else, to put the burden of finding an alternative to residential care onto the shoulders of others. If she's set in her wishes, then it's up to her to find the alternative.

Of course it isn't a legal option to finish someone off, hence the euphemistic 'find some way round that'.

Presumably in the interview JB wasn't trying to dictate what she thought others should do. She wax just talking about herself and her own family.

Happyjoe · 10/11/2026 09:54

Didn't Jo used to be a carer/nurse? She will have a fair idea of what she wants to avoid.

After both my in-laws going into a home I was astonished at the level of care, or lack of it. No dignity either. The care home basically killed off my FIL, while charging us £1,570 a week. We were in the process of bringing him back to his home when he died. Hopefully I will go down my parents route and die of cancer first tbh.

Additup · 10/11/2026 09:56

Octavia64 · 10/11/2026 09:35

My mum said she never wanted to go into a home and we were to shoot her first

she is now elderly. Shooting her is not allowed.

i have been in a serious accident and am seriously physically disabled so she has reluctantly accepted that I can’t care for her (I have carers myself).

she’s now trying to stay as healthy as possible so she doesn’t have to go into one.

I expect this will get some peoples backs up but I think everyone should try and stay as healthy as possible (within their means).

jelliebelly · 10/11/2026 09:58

it is obviously a very emotive subject and everybody has to make these decisions based on their own particular set of circumstances - it’s difficult but we have to ignore other peoples opinions and make the right choices for us. Please also bear in mind that people will share controversial opinions to create interest in their podcasts - that’s how they gain listeners and make money …

EleanorRigbyhat · 10/11/2026 09:59

Negantiger · 10/11/2026 08:48

I work as a carer and same. I take my service users to visit their relatives in care homes and no care homes are good. One of my families is trying to move a man I used to care for, he’s in a high needs dementia home (he’s not actually high needs so not even sure how he ended up there) with actual nurses on site and it’s fucking dire. He loved his food going into the home and now he’s skeletal as he needs help eating and no one will feed him. After paying thousands a month for care they’re still having to rotate to go in at least twice a day to make sure he’s been fed. And multiple times now me or the family have gone in and found him slumped and clearly seriously ill to the point we’ve had to call 999 and he’s had a stay in hospital. He’s been in for about 2 weeks now with pneumonia that the care home didn’t pick up on, his daughter again found him slumped in a wheelchair in a doorway grey and barely breathing. Some homes I’ve worked in have been badly staffed, which while doesn’t excuse, certainly explains the poor care. I’m not sure what’s going on in this home though as there are staff everywhere. And I’ve never been in a home that didn’t have that stench of stale piss. I know most people are in pads or have catheters, but it’s very clear the smell is coming from minimal cleaning and poor hygiene, I hate even walking into the places

Edited

That paints a very sober picture. My mother is going to need either residential care or my sister will have to take her on and my sister has no concept of what the demands will be like on her. It will last a year at most at my estimation. My sister wants to move her across the country where she knows no one to a house she has never visited, to live with them. She has a teenage daughter. It's a ridiculous idea. There isn't any other option but for her to go into a care home which my sister doesn't want.

My mother is nearly 90 and having falls, leaving fires on when she isn't in the house, setting fire to things and cognitive decline is rapidly accelerating.

Additup · 10/11/2026 09:59

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 09:24

I am quite surprised at Jo Brand saying this too and I agree that it is quite selfish, because if it comes down to being the only option, it places a large burden of guilt on the family.

Personally I prey to god that I will be able to live in a decent care home when I am older, as I will have absolutely no family. Not all of us have the luxury of turning the option down.

How was she being selfish? She was talking about herself and her family. She didn't say that she thought anyone else should do the same.

FancyKitten · 10/11/2026 10:01

KitsyWitsy · 10/11/2026 09:12

She used to be a psychiatric nurse. She knows what they're like. That's probably why.

Exactly what I was thinking. She knows the system.

PermanentTemporary · 10/11/2026 10:03

Just because Jo Brand was an adult psychiatric nurse for a while in the 80s doesn’t mean she knows everything about care decisions in the 2020s. I’ve no doubt she has more relevant experience than that from a personal standpoint, like many of us.

It’s fair to be clear about the fact that care homes are a minority need and are the last option for most of us but I agree 100% that people should be damn careful how they talk about these incredibly painful situations.