Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

"Don't put me in a home" (Jo Brand)

239 replies

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 08:28

Did anyone hear the interview with Jo Brand on 'Off Air with Jane and Fi' (Podcast with Jane Garvey and Fi Glover).

Here's a link Jane Garvey interview with Jo Brand (this bit is at about 46 mins in)

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My dad has dementia is not coping with his daily carers and is increasingly unsafe at home, so the burden of caring (and it is a burden) is increasingly falling onto me and my brother. It is a hugely stressful situation with impacts on our own health. We've thought long and hard about what is best for him and are starting conversations with him about moving him to a care home where he will get the care he needs, a steady routine, company, activities, stimulation etc. He's very lonely and isolated at home and it is awful to see him living his life like that. The one we have in mind looks wonderful, and specialises in dementia care.

I think it will be the best place for him but I still can't quite shake off the "don't put me in a home" stigma. I would love to ban the phrase "put him/her in a home" as it completely minimises the huge amount of planning, the tightrope of delicate negotiations with the EP and the emotional turmoil that are involved in such a seemingly simple decision. If only "putting someone in a home" was as easy as the phrase suggests.

So I found Jo Brand's comment very disheartening and it immediately triggered feelings of guilt and made me question myself again. Jane Garvey's father died recently and she has talked very movingly about this. She gave a very good defence of care homes, which i was very happy to hear.

OP posts:
Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 10:05

I think its prudent for elderly folk, while they have capacity, to put a DNAR in place, particularly if dementia is knocking at their door. My mother did this and was able to pass away peacefully without intervention when the natural end came x

Freemefromic · 10/11/2026 10:05

My dear departed MIL always said ‘don’t put me in a home’. She became very unsafe at home on her own but still insisted she wouldn’t be put in a home. My DH found it all very difficult and his way of coping was to minimise the danger she was in. I tried talking to her GP who was completely uninterested. DH’s sister had died years ago so I tried to involve her two grandchildren but they effectively passed it back to me.

In the end, a district nurse admitted her to hospital. It was a massive relief. From there she was sent to a really nice care home. When we visited her, she looked really well she had made friends and according to her, she was virtually running the place.

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:05

Additup · 10/11/2026 09:59

How was she being selfish? She was talking about herself and her family. She didn't say that she thought anyone else should do the same.

Because unless she is planning on committing suicide then she is expressing wishes that rely heavily on other people. If she has the kind of extremely high care needs where a home is often considered then even hiring in 24 hour care to be administered at home involves a lot of work. Someone will have to make sure maintenance is taking place, the garden is looked after, the cleaning is done etc. It's not just care that needs to be considered.

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 10:06

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 09:50

Maybe so, but I do think caring is by it's very nature a difficult and quite selfless vocation even if you are getting paid to do it. This is especially true if you want to do it well and in a way that vulnerable people deserve.

So many of us would be rubbish carers and be very unhappy in these roles. Sure, we could do it out of necessity and would do the basics but I would hate to be cared for by a reluctant carer. This is why I'm not even convinced it's just money. You could pay me £100k a year but I don't think I would be a fantastic carer. I simply don't have the temperament or natural skillset. Very few of my friends would objectively be amazing carers either and even fewer would choose to do it or even be semi satisfied with a job in this field.

Demand is going to escalate and there simply won't be enough cheerful, competent, engaged carers to meet demand.

Edited

Ah right, I see. Thank you. I had better look into euthanasia then.

PermanentTemporary · 10/11/2026 10:06

It takes an awful lot more than a DNAR to prevent over treatment. But I agree it’s the first step. TBH I think resuscitation should be opt in rather than opt out.

Keepingongoing · 10/11/2026 10:07

I have listened to that bit of the podcast with Jo Brand and she is more nuanced than some posters are assuming.

I don’t think she says ‘don’t put me in a care home’ but rather that she doesn’t want to end up in a care home and she’s asked her family to make alternative arrangements.

Of course the phrase ‘don’t put me in a care home’ is used a lot generally, and totally agree @Hangryhorace that it completely minimises the agonising, the work of finding somewhere suitable, and the negotiations with the elderly person. As if you could just ring up your local care home on a Monday and say: we’re popping Mum down to you tomorrow for an indefinite stay. And that Mum is compliant!

The reality is that it’s very, very difficult and often the care home point is reached only when it becomes impossible to keep the person safe at home, and family members have reached the point of total exhaustion/ health breakdown.

We went through all this with my MIL. She would guilt trip my SIL endlessly ( she’d made her promise that she would never ‘put her in a home’) and her favourite argument was ‘when I was young, daughters looked after their mums’.

As I would say to DP, the operative word was Daughters plural! And extreme old age and frailty didn’t usually stretch for so many years.

After much soul searching her family realised they were at the end of the line of meeting her needs as she had advanced dementia and several other conditions. She was moved into a care home which turned out to be brilliant with attentive and loving staff. She flourished there until she died.

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:09

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 10:06

Ah right, I see. Thank you. I had better look into euthanasia then.

This is my honest assessment of the situation but if you know loads of people that would make highly motivated and competent carers then you may well reach a different conclusion. Personally I would rather go for AD than be cared for by people that don't want to be carers and aren't particularly good at it.

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 10:11

The thing about a care home is that it is not your home. All your belongings you cannot take with you. A few only. And if you are sent to one because someone decides for you it isn’t even your choice. You never see your home again. It is a care facility. It is never your home.

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 10:13

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:09

This is my honest assessment of the situation but if you know loads of people that would make highly motivated and competent carers then you may well reach a different conclusion. Personally I would rather go for AD than be cared for by people that don't want to be carers and aren't particularly good at it.

Will you not have your children care for you though? As someone childless (not by choice) I often feel I will be a complete burden, whereas those with children have earned care. I am not saying this is right, it is just how I am made to feel.

MarcellaGrace · 10/11/2026 10:17

Jo Brand isn’t responsible for your guilt. I won’t be ‘going into a home’ either.

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:24

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 10:13

Will you not have your children care for you though? As someone childless (not by choice) I often feel I will be a complete burden, whereas those with children have earned care. I am not saying this is right, it is just how I am made to feel.

I have children and would be devastated if they had to care for me. I will do all I can to avoid this.

I think the reality is that when we get old and unable to care for ourselves then all of us become a burden. The only question is, who does the burden fall to? Personally I would least like to see it go to my children who have their own lives to live. They owe me nothing.

P00hsticks · 10/11/2026 10:25

Additup · 10/11/2026 08:39

I would have assumed Jo Brand would have meant don't put me in a home, finish me off instead rather than she was criticising families whose loved ones live in a care home.

Which unless and until we get an assisted dying bill passed in this country, places considerably more of a burden (and risk of criminal charges) on the family that putting them in a home.

If someone wants to finish themself off rather than go into a home. that's one thing, but don't ask it of your nearest and dearest.

Elliesbelly · 10/11/2026 10:25

After seeing the reality of some people’s lives towards the end, for me personally I don’t think assisted dying can come in soon enough.

If I got a diagnosis of dementia or another potentially drawn out degenerative disease I would hope in the future I would be allowed to chose a stage of the disease to die at while I’m still in my full mind.

Sometimes living is a fate far worse than death.

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:27

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 10:11

The thing about a care home is that it is not your home. All your belongings you cannot take with you. A few only. And if you are sent to one because someone decides for you it isn’t even your choice. You never see your home again. It is a care facility. It is never your home.

I think everyone understands this and feels this deeply within themselves. It's a human instinct to want a stable and familiar 'home', especially when you're vulnerable and in poor health. There comes a point though where you can't stay at home without creating an incredible amount of work and responsibility for others because you can't even care for yourself, let alone a property. At this point is it really everyone else's responsibility to keep you in your home forever when it becomes ever more impractical and taxing. I have seen adult children make themselves unwell attempting to support elderly and unwell people to stay in completely inappropriate homes.

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 10:28

Monty36 · 10/11/2026 10:11

The thing about a care home is that it is not your home. All your belongings you cannot take with you. A few only. And if you are sent to one because someone decides for you it isn’t even your choice. You never see your home again. It is a care facility. It is never your home.

Sometimes there is no choice. Even for those who do have family to care for them. If you are in your sixties and your parent is in the throes of advanced dementia, how would you cope with the relentlessness, and believe me it IS relentless. The constant demands, the wandering around all night, the toilet accidents. The lack of being able to go out even for half an hour while hoping the house isnt in flames

HotGrapefruit · 10/11/2026 10:29

Negantiger · 10/11/2026 08:48

I work as a carer and same. I take my service users to visit their relatives in care homes and no care homes are good. One of my families is trying to move a man I used to care for, he’s in a high needs dementia home (he’s not actually high needs so not even sure how he ended up there) with actual nurses on site and it’s fucking dire. He loved his food going into the home and now he’s skeletal as he needs help eating and no one will feed him. After paying thousands a month for care they’re still having to rotate to go in at least twice a day to make sure he’s been fed. And multiple times now me or the family have gone in and found him slumped and clearly seriously ill to the point we’ve had to call 999 and he’s had a stay in hospital. He’s been in for about 2 weeks now with pneumonia that the care home didn’t pick up on, his daughter again found him slumped in a wheelchair in a doorway grey and barely breathing. Some homes I’ve worked in have been badly staffed, which while doesn’t excuse, certainly explains the poor care. I’m not sure what’s going on in this home though as there are staff everywhere. And I’ve never been in a home that didn’t have that stench of stale piss. I know most people are in pads or have catheters, but it’s very clear the smell is coming from minimal cleaning and poor hygiene, I hate even walking into the places

Edited

Interested in your post because in this situation I would not want anything treated - do you think that's partly what the care home are doing? If he doesn't die from something else, he could live for years in a terrible state.

Additup · 10/11/2026 10:30

Itchthescratch · 10/11/2026 10:05

Because unless she is planning on committing suicide then she is expressing wishes that rely heavily on other people. If she has the kind of extremely high care needs where a home is often considered then even hiring in 24 hour care to be administered at home involves a lot of work. Someone will have to make sure maintenance is taking place, the garden is looked after, the cleaning is done etc. It's not just care that needs to be considered.

But that's the thing, I think she was alluding to suicide.

But even if she wasn't presumably the (carers) would be paid so I don't see how that is selfish.

I don't know Jo Brand but she strikes me as a practical woman who has no problem giving her opinion and I don't think she should be criticised for that.

Cresd · 10/11/2026 10:30

Well, I'm not crazy about the idea of going into a care home.

But when I compare it with the prospect of putting my kids through the stress of caring for me at home when I'm disabled and confused - for years on end - then I honestly couldn't face putting them through that. A care home would make more sense, sadly. I want my kids to have a better life than that.

Seeing (and dealing with) the old age of my parents and PIL has made me acutely aware of this. Their generation often cared for their own parents in old age - but normally for very much less time, because the medical treatments for keeping people alive just didn't exist to the same extent. Now the frail and unhappy elderly survive for decades, sometimes, whether they want to or not. It's a different landscape. I don't know what the answer is, but putting a huge burden on my own kids shouldn't be part of it.

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 10:32

HotGrapefruit · 10/11/2026 10:29

Interested in your post because in this situation I would not want anything treated - do you think that's partly what the care home are doing? If he doesn't die from something else, he could live for years in a terrible state.

Agreed. I would suggest that this poor old man should be allowed to pass peacefully without too much intervention

Gall10 · 10/11/2026 10:33

Ilovemyshed · 10/11/2026 08:55

I beg to differ on care homes. I have a relative in one and its amazing. She has a big room with ensuite toilet. She has gone from not walking at all to managing with a frame. The lounge looks over a gorgeous view. They eat breakfast lunch dinner and supper in a restaurant set up with help where needed.
Most of all, there activities and events every single day designed to stimulate and exercise and all residents are actively encouraged to participate as much or as little as they can.

Can you tell us the location of this facility….and the cost?

TonTonMacoute · 10/11/2026 10:34

My mother lived very contentedly in a care home for the last few years of her life. The home and the staff were brilliant, it was close to home and family could visit whenever they wanted. Her level of dependence, including needing to be turned twice during the night, couldn't possibly be managed in a domestic setting, unless you were enormously wealthy and lived in a huge house with a large staff.

Jo Brand was a nurse, she must know that everyone, or the vast majority, does the very best they can for their parents, and sometimes that's a care home. Being the age I am I see far more people being driven into the ground by demanding and uncooperative elderly parents than unhappy old people in care homes.

Mumtoabillion · 10/11/2026 10:36

Not all care homes are alike. Jo Brand has not seen them all and she hasn't experienced living in any and especially not at a time when her relatives would be struggling..Don't give her comments more time than you need to, OP

Elliesbelly · 10/11/2026 10:36

Dollymylove · 10/11/2026 09:15

I worked in a care home and then as a home carer for years. Many of these frail elderly folk are doing their best to pass away but the families/medical folk wont seem to let them.
I've witnessed tiny little skeletal dementia sufferers being blue lighted to hospital, pumped with antibiotics and sent home again ( probably after 3 days on a trolley in a corridor)
For the love of god just let nature take its course and let them go!!!

I completely agree. This is a real issue, treating people without any quality of life for things that would have given them a peaceful death at home 10 times over in previous generations is an enormous part of the problem.

Just because modern medicine can treat does not always mean it should treat.

There needs to be a discussion on when treatment stops with people and especially with family members.

catofglory · 10/11/2026 10:44

My mother had dementia for ten years. Fortunately she had inherited money so could pay for her own care. To start with I arranged carers coming in at home for her, which is what she wanted. After a while we got up to the point of five hours a day of carers and it still was not enough, because she needed someone with her 24/7. Family were not going to live with her, so the only option was a care home.

So I moved her to a care home where she lived for seven years. I don't feel even slightly bad about it, it was best option for her, and she was content there. She lived far too long, the last couple of years she was just existing. But she didn't agree with assisted dying so that would have made no difference to how her life ended up.

On the point of 'home'. By the time my mother left her home of 50 years she could not even remember which room was which, the carers had to put post it notes on the doors - 'bathroom, bedroom'. And she got lost on the high street. The care home did genuinely feel like it became her home. It was a place full of kindness.

(I don't know what Jo Brand meant, but possibly a trip to Switzerland, rather than expecting her family to care for her.)

AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 10/11/2026 10:47

I don’t want to go into a home but more importantly, I don’t want my adult children having to care for me so I might end up in a home.