Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

"Don't put me in a home" (Jo Brand)

239 replies

Hangryhorace · 10/11/2026 08:28

Did anyone hear the interview with Jo Brand on 'Off Air with Jane and Fi' (Podcast with Jane Garvey and Fi Glover).

Here's a link Jane Garvey interview with Jo Brand (this bit is at about 46 mins in)

I love Jo Brand but my heart really sank when she talked about ageing and said that she'd instructed her family that she didn't want to end up in an old people's home, so they would have to 'find some way round that'. I wonder what she had in mind.

My dad has dementia is not coping with his daily carers and is increasingly unsafe at home, so the burden of caring (and it is a burden) is increasingly falling onto me and my brother. It is a hugely stressful situation with impacts on our own health. We've thought long and hard about what is best for him and are starting conversations with him about moving him to a care home where he will get the care he needs, a steady routine, company, activities, stimulation etc. He's very lonely and isolated at home and it is awful to see him living his life like that. The one we have in mind looks wonderful, and specialises in dementia care.

I think it will be the best place for him but I still can't quite shake off the "don't put me in a home" stigma. I would love to ban the phrase "put him/her in a home" as it completely minimises the huge amount of planning, the tightrope of delicate negotiations with the EP and the emotional turmoil that are involved in such a seemingly simple decision. If only "putting someone in a home" was as easy as the phrase suggests.

So I found Jo Brand's comment very disheartening and it immediately triggered feelings of guilt and made me question myself again. Jane Garvey's father died recently and she has talked very movingly about this. She gave a very good defence of care homes, which i was very happy to hear.

OP posts:
BlackRoseBlue · 11/11/2026 17:53

I will add as well to the “your parents looked after you; so you should look after them” view: for most parents (and I absolutely am aware that not all children develop in the same way and some parents have to be lifelong carers for their children) the intensive care that a baby/toddler requires decreases as the child gets older. Yes tweens, teens, young adults bring their own challenges but overall most parents get increasing amounts of time where they are not intensively caring for a child. They’re also doing the full on caring bit in their 20s/30s or early 40s.

With ageing parents the trajectory is pretty much the opposite. With dementia in particular “today is the best they will ever be”.

Two years ago my mum could hold a conversation and whilst there was repetition as she forgot what had been said, if you got her onto her earlier life you probably wouldn’t notice she had dementia for an hour or so.

A year ago she had forgotten who her husband was and the house she lived in and was constantly trying to escape - exacerbated by sundowning and delusions.

Today she is scoring 8 on the frailty scale, is totally bed bound and incontinent and can only talk incoherently; she has seizures and needs turning regularly to ensure no bedsores. I thank god she is still calm and mostly peaceful - that is the only single positive thing right now. As I said above she is well looked after in a care home. I suspect that live in care would require at least three shifts of carers and would still need me to be doing a lot of behind the scenes management as well. And that’s without considering the impact on my dad who is still at home.

That is a huge amount of care to need and a heartbreaking progression of care needs. And if the children are providing it they are middle aged, menopausal and probably still providing emotional care and support for teens/young adults and almost certainly supporting them financially and so having to work themselves.

I have nothing but admiration for those who do care for ageing parents but the reality is that for many, many people it’s just not going to be realistic even if they wanted to.

BeWittyRobin · 11/11/2026 18:04

FelixRyark · 11/11/2026 14:21

I feel every bit of this discussion and am so disappointed that if you choose a care home, you don’t care!!
My mother (82) is a widow since our Dad died in Dec 2023. So as not to drip feed, she has a history of depression and an anxiety disorder.
She refuses to get any outside help into the house, she won’t hear talk of assisted living or such. So it’s all left to us two siblings.
My sibling and I ‘lived’ with her for nearly four months on a rota system, to try to get her out of bed and a fully functioning person after my Dad’s death. It nearly destroyed me and was similar for my sibling.
She has, since then, said she doesn’t want to be here (that is to say, she doesn’t want to live) and bemoans the fact that she can’t nip to Switzerland due to dwindling funds.

My sister and so are in the wreckage of this. My marriage is on the rocks, I would say nearly over, because of needing to be at her beck and call.
Honestly, my love for her has slowly and quietly been replaced with resentment over the last three years, as she is so ungrateful for the help we give but couldn’t live in her home if we didn’t do it, as she won’t have outside help.
I’ve told my own two children, I don’t want them to take care of my needs and I’ll choose my own assisted living ahead of time as well as my living will for medical purposes.

Sorry, I realise I’ve ranted, but I guess I needed to say that to someone outside my sibling!

I honestly feel for you, I have looked after people in similar situations over the years and I have seen how it ripples out into the clients children’s families and lives. Causes the exact feelings you are experiencing. You are not alone. If she really is unable to look after herself as it appears in your post, if you haven’t already get in touch with your local authority, adult social services they deal with this quite regularly and they will know what to do, advise and work with her and recommend what help and next steps could entail. Have you got power of attorney for health and wellbeing? Because that maybe something you should look at getting as sounds like she’s already well on her way on that downward spiral of not coping and not knowing what is best for her. Sending big hugs. As much as I’ve commented what I would or wouldn’t do with my parents if/when the time comes when they are more reliable on needing help/care that doesn’t mean I judge those that can’t look after their parents in old age. My sister wouldn’t be able too, and my mum openly admits she wouldn’t be able to do personal care if my nana (her mum) who is 94 needed it even cutting toe nails would be out her capabilities as a human let alone her daughter 🙈😂. But I do do this as a living and have done for a long time, doesn’t mean it’s for everyone nor should anyone judge. Xx

Deathspren · 11/11/2026 19:24

DuchessofWinchester · 10/11/2026 11:34

I worked in a care home between school and uni.

Neither of my parents will ever go into care homes.

There is a stigma for a reason. They are not nice and no one deserves to go in one.

They're basically prison that you have to pay for and didn't earn the punishment for.

Edited

I thought you were a stripper in Greece at 16?

DuchessofWinchester · Today 16:29
As a teen I was a stripper in Greece and it permanently changed my view of men.

DuchessofWinchester · 11/11/2026 19:35

Deathspren · 11/11/2026 19:24

I thought you were a stripper in Greece at 16?

DuchessofWinchester · Today 16:29
As a teen I was a stripper in Greece and it permanently changed my view of men.

Worked care at 18 and stripped at 19. Creepy stalker weirdo

Seeingadistance · 11/11/2026 22:18

rookiemere · 11/11/2026 14:57

@Seeingadistancetelling your DCs to hit you over the head with a shovel is even worse than telling them not to put you in a care home! Doing both is almost unforgivable.
Its obvious to me now having seen how it panned out for DPs and the collateral damage on my own career and mental health, if you definitely don’t want to go into a care home then make sure you have the means to end your own life. Yes I will also have a directive for no active medical treatment past a certain age and try and refuse flu jabs etc but that may not be enough and your DCs cannot have your death on their conscience.

Fortunately, my DS won't actually hit me over the head with a shovel, but he is fully aware that I have no desire to be kept alive with no quality of life being spoon-fed mush and pumped full of antibiotics with every sniffle. So I'll do my best to wield the metaphorical shovel myself with an advance directive - regularly reviewed.

My point being that I, and others, are quick with the grim requests for the shovel the head, pillow to the face etc, but it is vitally important that we actually take on the personal responsibility to express our wishes formally and legally in advance.

And yes, suicide is definitely an option.

And if it has to come to it, a nursing home with staff that won't hug me and a nice view. And no antibiotics or vaccines!

Italiangreyhound · 11/11/2026 22:21

My mum went into a home with dementia. It was the only place that could have cared for her and kept her safe.

GnomeDePlume · 11/11/2026 22:24

Even before my DM became bedbound she was wheelchair bound following a fall. To safely move her between bed/wheelchair/toilet required 2 trained carers plus equipment.

As DM's needs have increased so has the care and equipment provided by her CH.

Family providing care may work but there is a huge risk, both to the person receiving and giving care, in expecting that to be a longterm solution where there is physical frailty.

Now I have seen good practice in DM's CH I have realised how poor some of the practice was in hospital: getting DM to stand by pulling her up using her clothes, grabbing at her arms if she slipped. It is likely that HCPs simply werent trained and were doing what seemed best.

MysterOfwomanY · 11/11/2026 22:58

It's very common for healthy people to say they would do away with themselves if "they reached that stage".
What I've observed is, however, that even old, frail, sick people with very limited QOL, people who (also common , btw) say, "I shouldn't be here," or "kill me!" commonly...

  • Carry on eating and drinking
  • Accept medication and treatment
  • Can safely be left alone in a room with all manner of things which can be used for fatal self-injury

So it might be prudent to have a back-up plan to cover the contingency that you "get to that stage" but find that you still want to be alive tomorrow, despite all the many frailties and indignities you have.

I currently have an elderly relative who wants to stay in her own home and has the money to do so, and I absolutely understand her wanting to remain in her home of over 50 years! BUT it means her entire social contact is her carers, the cleaner, and the district nurses. I come visit regularly but now she has no mobility we can't take her out for cafe/concert/mild fun.
I live in a well-off part of the country with some excellent care homes which she could nonetheless afford. Luckily she has capacity and it's not my decision, but I suspect she would, well, have more fun if she moved to one of them.

Mosaic123 · 12/11/2026 11:02

People can't be locked into their own homes because of the fire risk.

So unless a live in carer sleeps across a front door how would you deal with a mobile person with dementia who wanders?

Sadly a care home is the only answer.

Sakura7 · 12/11/2026 11:21

Mosaic123 · 12/11/2026 11:02

People can't be locked into their own homes because of the fire risk.

So unless a live in carer sleeps across a front door how would you deal with a mobile person with dementia who wanders?

Sadly a care home is the only answer.

This was the tipping point with my dad, where my mother finally accepted that he couldn't be kept safe at home.

He wandered out of the house while she was asleep. Thankfully one of the neighbours was coming home from a night shift and saw him, otherwise it could have ended badly.

deveronvalley · 12/11/2026 11:33

Ask how many work on the night shift when you are looking for somewhere. Most places look great in the daytime, bustling, busy and caring. Night time is when staff cut corners with checks, hygiene or general kindness for elderly people who can be frightened at night but then make damn sure everything looks fine for when the busy day shift comes in.

WarmAleAndBlackLabrador · 12/11/2026 11:40

I looked after my dm recently in hospital. She has complex needs and was unwell mentally and physically and couldn't be left. I sat in a chair next to her bed for 12 hours helping her with everything. I always said my parents would never go in a home, but after that taster I know I wouldn't be able to cope. I have sisters, who I assumed would share the load, but they found even visiting for a couple of hours every other day difficult. I assumed they, like me, would temporarily rearrange work and family plans to share the load. I know now if my dad couldn't care for her then a home would be the only option.

dodgercity · 12/11/2026 13:34

Mosaic123 · 12/11/2026 11:02

People can't be locked into their own homes because of the fire risk.

So unless a live in carer sleeps across a front door how would you deal with a mobile person with dementia who wanders?

Sadly a care home is the only answer.

Sensor alarms can support with this when appropriate to help keep the person at home a little longer (emphasis on when appropriate, I’m very much not anti care homes).

PermanentTemporary · 12/11/2026 13:49

I have come across a wanderer where the eventual decision was that they should carry on at home despite the strong likelihood that they would end their days in a ditch dying of exposure in pain from a broken leg. It takes some pretty strong documentation of wishes plus a very determined person holding LPA to ‘achieve’ that. I have no doubt that a care home is nearly always a very reasonable choice in similar circumstances. I think tbh it’s also only reasonable where there isn’t a partner living with them - I do t think a partner should have to witness this or live with the constant fear.

aniloD · 12/11/2026 15:04

Seeingadistance · 11/11/2026 14:32

I'm similar to you in that I'm also an introvert and prefer my own company and my independence. However, although I have been saying to DS just to hit me over the back of the head with a shovel if and when that time comes that is not a viable option.

So, I'll be putting together an advance directive, expressing my wishes clearly in writing in advance.

I already have one logged.
If you go to 'compassion in dying' they have questionnaires that help you put together what you would like to happen if you are being cared for and are unable to communication your wishes. Including specific directives on medications etc. EG I want as much sedation and pain relief as possible AND I definitely don't want antibiotics or treatment that will keep my body breathing when I am no longer really there.
I do not want CPR under any circumstances. It's brutal and in most cases in the elderly ineffective any way.
If it becomes legal in my lifetime, I definitely want the right to die at a time of my choice and with dignity. In fact I want it any way - and if necessary and possible I will travel in order to have that right.

We don't have the right to die
AND
We don't have the right to dispose of our assets because if we have any we have to use them to pay for 'care' for an existence we do not want.

Big Brother tactics all the way

aniloD · 12/11/2026 15:42

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 10:51

We should all be encouraged to complete Advance Directives. Legally binding if witnessed. Alzheimers Society have a template.

I'm working on mine now. Once I am no longer able to advocate for myself I want all medical treatment other than pain relief to stop.

Once complete I will send it to my GP and also to my adult DCs (already discussed with them).

Totally agree

Compassion in Dying also has an excellent template

Gives you the opportunity to say what you do and don't want to happen.

And - as soon as we are allowed by the incompetent people making the decisions. To allow assisted dying -
The government is supposed to be the voice of the people. Far more than 50% of people are in favour of assisted dying - it can't come soon enough for me.
I'm 71 and currently fit and healthy and content with my life. Once that stops, then I don't want to be here

AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 12/11/2026 17:42

WarmAleAndBlackLabrador · 12/11/2026 11:40

I looked after my dm recently in hospital. She has complex needs and was unwell mentally and physically and couldn't be left. I sat in a chair next to her bed for 12 hours helping her with everything. I always said my parents would never go in a home, but after that taster I know I wouldn't be able to cope. I have sisters, who I assumed would share the load, but they found even visiting for a couple of hours every other day difficult. I assumed they, like me, would temporarily rearrange work and family plans to share the load. I know now if my dad couldn't care for her then a home would be the only option.

Edited

You can decide how much work you want to do but you can’t expect other people to do the same unless they want to. Most people would put their children and OH first. As I have previously said, I don’t want my adult children looking after me.

Barney16 · 13/11/2026 00:04

My very elderly parents don't have dementia but have poor mobility and failing health. Them living in their own home requires huge amounts of support and that's when they are both able to still walk short distances, cook a simple meal, do some household tasks. It's unbelievably wearing, stressful and just generally rubbish. They take up huge amounts of time. I am absolutely determined that I will not inflict this on my children. I will absolutely take myself off to a care home or supported living.

EnterQueene · 13/11/2026 07:55

I think Jo Brand was a mental health nurse for around 10 years in the 80s so I don't know why everyone keeps bringing it up - it was a relatively short period a long time ago and elder care looks very very different now. Not least because there are far more extremely elderly people with increasingly complex needs that can be treated than previously. Which means a higher prevalence of people succumbing to dementia who would previously not have lived so long.

When it comes to 'putting people in a care home' - it isn't always a choice. No matter how many doors you lock at home, it is amazing how they can get out and wander, to be picked up by the police. You have to sleep sometimes, it is amazing how many taps, gas rings, electrical appliances they can turn on in the early hours of the morning. How distressed they can get and beg to go home when they are home.

I'd like Jo Brand to ask my elderly mum why she 'chose' to put her husband in her care home. Stupid, insensitive comment.

GnomeDePlume · 13/11/2026 09:53

I dont want to castigate Jo Brand for what may well have been a throw away comment.

I get frustrated by the people who say or write 'I couldnt shove my lovely mum into a home, I'll care for her'. It's the sheer stupid, smug, ignorance of the comment which annoys me.

Nobody knows how dementia will affect their loved one or themselves. The kindly, slightly forgetful, grandparent could become angry, violent, spiteful, fearful. Not someone safe to be near DGCs.

As dementia progresses you may well be looking at needing to keep them secure, to prevent wandering. You may be needing to deal with someone who falls regularly. Managing continence can become an issue. Chewing and swallowing can become an issue. Mobility can fail so that the person becomes bedbound. Then you are looking at bedsore prevention.

We have had to face all of the above for my DM and DMIL before her.

To do this well needs a team with knowledge and skills and access to equipment. Not an amateur muddling along because a promise got extracted when nobody knew the reality.

My DM didnt say she would want to stay in her home, mainly I think, because she didnt believe she would get dementia. She thought it was something which happened to people who didnt try hard enough.

Even if she had done so she would be in a CH now anyway. Sometimes there isnt a viable alternative.

bigboykitty · 13/11/2026 10:02

Seeingadistance · 10/11/2026 08:49

But "finish me off instead" isn't a viable or legal option!

I'm not really in a position to criticise because I've been saying to my DS for years now that if I end up incapacitated that he's to hit me over the back of the head with a shovel! However, I'm also now looking at the more practical and legal option of setting out my wishes in writing in an advance directive.

I've also, privately, set my own best before age as 80 - based on how my grandparents and parents have aged. Taking action myself is better than asking others to do it for me.

It's very unfair of Jo Brand, or anyone else, to put the burden of finding an alternative to residential care onto the shoulders of others. If she's set in her wishes, then it's up to her to find the alternative.

Of course she can't come out and say 'help me to end it' when it's not legal in this country. And of course she didn't mean that everyone must have 24 hour care. It's not unfair of her. Y'all seem to be tying yourselves in knots to deliberately misunderstand what she said.

rookiemere · 13/11/2026 10:11

bigboykitty · 13/11/2026 10:02

Of course she can't come out and say 'help me to end it' when it's not legal in this country. And of course she didn't mean that everyone must have 24 hour care. It's not unfair of her. Y'all seem to be tying yourselves in knots to deliberately misunderstand what she said.

I don’t think anyone has misunderstood her, however she is an intelligent woman, if she means she would rather kill herself than end up in a care home then she does need to explicitly say that.

DF said he didn’t want to end up in a care home, unfortunately that desire seemed to outweigh his ability to understand that I could not support the pair of them living at home with dementia.

We need to have more open conversations in this country on what to do as more of our aged population get dementia. It’s a huge and growing issue and right now the burden seems to fall squarely on the shoulders of any relatives unfortunate enough to be involved.

I have mixed feelings about assisted dying, but anyone stating they refuse to go into a home come what may needs to understand the potential consequences of that for their nearest and dearest.

rookiemere · 13/11/2026 10:41

Oh and ironically DH quite likes the care home now he and DM are there. It’s warm, he gets well fed, we visit regularly and he’s not responsible for DM any more.

ClaudiaG · 13/11/2026 21:32

Have you any idea how unhappy these care homes can be? Unless you have the money to find, and vet the best on the market they can be the absolute end of life: people are treated simply as bodies, each one worth a lot of money to the company. The most soul-destroying end. I suspect Jo Brand meant that she would want an option to take a way out rather than be consigned to a living death. .

WarmAleAndBlackLabrador · 14/11/2026 00:11

AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 12/11/2026 17:42

You can decide how much work you want to do but you can’t expect other people to do the same unless they want to. Most people would put their children and OH first. As I have previously said, I don’t want my adult children looking after me.

Why do you have to twist the knife? I'm not trying to obligate anyone, and I certainly didn't. I just shared on a private forum something really upsetting, that I would not tell or hold against my family in a million years. I know their families and jobs are important, so is mine and so is my peace of mind.