Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

We need to change the conversation around breastfeeding

247 replies

pisces5891 · 18/10/2026 21:28

I am writing this post knowing that it will potentially kick off a bit of hornet's nest. I'm just really fed up with how much pressure there is on women to breastfeed, when all the evidence suggests that a significant number of women simply cannot exclusively breastfeed. I would even hazaard a guess that more than 50% of women cannot exclusively breastfeed. Its making women miserable and is the number one cause of post natal depression. Enough!!!

When I tried to breastfeed, I had real trouble providing enough supply for my baby. I was told that with the right support, almost every woman can breastfeed. I received help from 3 different lactation consultants. the first told me, less than 5% of women have actual low supply, and if low supply was really true of a lot of women, then the human race would have died out. This is objectively speaking totally false. Historically, women would share feeding of babies with other lactating women, and even then, lots of babies died. So the fact that the human race still exists is absolutely not evidence that the majority of women have enough supply. the second lactation consultant told me that if there was no formula, I would have found a way to exclusively breastfeed. this is also not true. My mother grew up in a tiny village overseast, where there was no access to formula. And she told me that it was rare that one woman would exclusively feed their own child, it was normal that it would be shared amongst the group and in the case that there were not enough other lactating women, they would put the baby at the teet of a goat in order to feed it because it was understood that it would be rare that a mother could exclusively feed her child from her breast. In my nct group, there are 10 women. One chose to formula feed from birth. The other 9 all wanted to exclusively breastfeed. only 2 of them are. and every single one of those 9 had the support of private lactation consultants, so we cannot say they are unsupported. A variety of issues from latch to supply to mastitis- so many problems that we all tried desperately to resolve, and we couldnt.

The third lactation consultant actually watched and listened to me breastfeeding and told me that my baby was not transferring enough milk. She was the only one of the 3 lactation consultants who had actually worked in a nicu ward and was able to recognise the signs of hunger. my baby thankfully was not starving but had I listened to the first 2 Lactation consultants, I think she would have been . This lactation consultant told me that it is very common on the Nicu ward to find very thin very hungry babies of mother's who are desperate to exclusively breastfeed, the babies are literally starving, drawn, crying and lethargic, because they are not being fed enough.

mixed feeding needs to be a system that is properly introduced to mothers. Mother's need to also be shown what an actual wet nappy looks like. I was told 6 to 8 wet nappies were a sign that my baby was getting enough food. Now that she is getting enough food because she's mixed fed, I can see what an actual wet nappy looks like, and it's really heavy compared to what it looked like when I was breastfeeding her.

I think this is a real issue and mumsnet is partly to blame for it, because the amount of threads I see where someone posts that they're struggling with breastfeeding, and they're told to keep going even when their baby is dropping centiles. It's the latch! It's tongue tie! Try an osteopath! Breastfed babies always lose weight! Its ok to drop centiles! You'll get there! It gets easier! Please PLEASE stop advising women to keep going no matter what, because in some instances, those women and there babies will end up in emergency care. Of course, many breastfeeding problems can be overcome with the right support, but in my experience, it sometimes never resolves, and the absolutely right and moral thing to do is to introduce the bottle.

I'm not blaming women here; the fault is in the system. Breastfeeding needs to be properly researched, but like all womens health, it's ignored.

I am still breastfeeding my baby girl, we mix feed very successfully. For anyone reading this struggling with breastfeeding, know that you're not alone.

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 07/11/2026 20:49

Autisticradfem · 07/11/2026 20:34

im sorry but breastfeeding is a full time job im never doing it

Do you think formula feeding is quicker? All that bottle prep?
Looking after a baby is a full time job. Feeding is a part of it.

Autisticradfem · 07/11/2026 20:49

HairsprayBabe · 21/10/2026 13:23

@OtterlyAstounding the whole thing is a neatly wrapped package of misogyny

You must be the perfect mother but also perfectly presentable and available for men to look at
You must breastfeed but get fucked if you want us to spend money on researching and supporting women's health
You must be ready to give your body back to the patriarchy as soon as possible so don't breastfeed one day past 12m

etc. on a personal level we cannot win, personal choice will always have its place but it is hard to encourage public health initiatives while still honouring bodily autonomy.

We at a population level should have as high levels of breastfeeding as possible, 70% is possible and has been seen in other HICs 80% of women start breastfeeding in this country - we should be supporting this beyond 6 weeks, not using breastfeeding as another stick to beat each other with.

If a woman wants to then she deserves support but it should never be pushed or lectured.

MrsKateColumbo · 07/11/2026 20:52

My general advice to new mums is "do whatever the fuck you want because whatever you do you'll be judged"

I actually planned to FF but (I was lucky enough to be on a private wing) had a lot of help from the healthcare assistants on the ward for DCS' first night and found BF a realtive breeze. I did however get a lot of pressure to FF due to jaundice and centile dropping. ds was on thr bottom line at one point, guess what, he is an extremely high metabolism, skinny but healthy older child. Same with DD, i seem to make big babies in the womb but small humans (I am also skinny so it shouldn't have been a shock).

I think there's more of a push to mix than BF

MrsKateColumbo · 07/11/2026 20:53

oviraptor21 · 07/11/2026 20:49

Do you think formula feeding is quicker? All that bottle prep?
Looking after a baby is a full time job. Feeding is a part of it.

FF definitely looks like more work to me when you're in the kitchen at 3am making a bottle. I dont think I am cut out for that level of coordination at night!

Autisticradfem · 07/11/2026 23:10

Oliveoy · 07/11/2026 20:48

Calling a nipple a human dummy is like calling a leg a human prosthetic limb. You sound ridiculous 😂

It’s true.

so many women don’t just breastfeed for feeding they use it as a dummy for comfort and for some children it’s constant. So no I’m not gonna be used as a human dummy

Autisticradfem · 07/11/2026 23:12

oviraptor21 · 07/11/2026 20:49

Do you think formula feeding is quicker? All that bottle prep?
Looking after a baby is a full time job. Feeding is a part of it.

Have you seen how time consuming breastfeeding is? It’s literally draining for many women.

Oliveoy · 07/11/2026 23:23

Autisticradfem · 07/11/2026 23:10

It’s true.

so many women don’t just breastfeed for feeding they use it as a dummy for comfort and for some children it’s constant. So no I’m not gonna be used as a human dummy

You're missing the point.

A nipple isn't a human dummy; a dummy is an artificial nipple.

If you don't want to breastfeed because it's also for providing comfort then that's your decision. Just say that, don't twist language backwards.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 07/11/2026 23:44

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 19/10/2026 09:34

I know and maternity care needs a massive overhaul, I have birth trauma from my second baby. I understand, I really do.

But midwives are becoming more and more deskilled, and risk aversion higher and higher with inductions; and even then we are having worse outcomes than less risk averse countries.

We need to be honest about why women’s bodies are struggling to conceive; maintain a healthy pregnancy; give birth and then breastfeed. I suspect hormonal disruption, age, obesity among other things.

Why blame the high rate of IVF on women? It is well known sperm counts have dropped over the years.

TheBirdintheCave · 08/11/2026 08:19

I was in the minority at my mum and baby class. Only two out of 16 of us bottle fed. Everyone else breastfed and the guilt I put upon myself was immense. I felt like a failure. I wished I could join in with their conversations about breastfeeding.

I desperately wanted to do it both times but the pain… It was like a bread knife sawing at my nipples and I couldn’t take it for longer than ten seconds. No one wanted to help me, not at the hospital and not even when I tried to hire a lactation consultant the second time. I let her know the baby had been born and that it was still awful so we had started bottle feeding as obviously my daughter needed milk, but that I still wanted help to start breastfeeding. She told me not to bother. I was so upset. I’m still upset years later. My mum couldn’t relate as she’d found it easy and breast fed me and my brother for months.

Here I’ve been told all sorts. When I explained I couldn’t do it because of the pain I was made to feel like I gave up too easily, that it was my own fault that I’d failed, that I was lying about how bad it was and that I was making excuses should just admit that I actually didn’t want to do it :(

I’m no stranger in regard to pain. I gave birth twice with no pain relief and both births were 48 hours from start to finish. But surely not everyone is enduring endless blinding pain that makes them writhe and scream every time the baby latches?

Autisticradfem · 08/11/2026 19:44

Oliveoy · 07/11/2026 23:23

You're missing the point.

A nipple isn't a human dummy; a dummy is an artificial nipple.

If you don't want to breastfeed because it's also for providing comfort then that's your decision. Just say that, don't twist language backwards.

I mean yes but I don’t think anyone would want a baby hanging off their tit 24/7 and then have to wean, with dummies and bottles you can bin them boobs you can’t and some children help themselves

scoutzx · 08/11/2026 19:58

Autisticradfem · 08/11/2026 19:44

I mean yes but I don’t think anyone would want a baby hanging off their tit 24/7 and then have to wean, with dummies and bottles you can bin them boobs you can’t and some children help themselves

I fed on demand and loved it. From an evolutionary and biological standpoint, human infants are biologically hardwired to feed frequently and on cue rather than according to a clock.

Oliveoy · 08/11/2026 20:20

Autisticradfem · 08/11/2026 19:44

I mean yes but I don’t think anyone would want a baby hanging off their tit 24/7 and then have to wean, with dummies and bottles you can bin them boobs you can’t and some children help themselves

Not that it was ever 24/7 but I loved BFing.

Given your username perhaps you'd be interested in my feminist take on it. Using my breasts for what they were designed for felt like two fingers up to every man who had ever talked to my chest rather than my face. And sustaining my child myself also felt like two fingers up to the male dominated formula industry. It was quite empowering.

ThatLoudCat · 08/11/2026 21:14

Autisticradfem · 08/11/2026 19:44

I mean yes but I don’t think anyone would want a baby hanging off their tit 24/7 and then have to wean, with dummies and bottles you can bin them boobs you can’t and some children help themselves

I don't know any breastfeeding mother that has a baby "hanging off their tit 24/7".

I definitely haven't and I've loved breastfeeding. They've also never "helped themselves".

YelliwFinnTuner · 08/11/2026 21:28

@ThatLoudCat you know you can breastfeed and also use a dummy right?
ive just weaned my one year old from being exclusively breastfed and it was surprisingly easy! They obviously didn't just ‘help themselves’ 🙄 because thats easily prevent and now also means I didn’t have to introduce formula or a bottle; they just have a normal cup of cows milk. Easy peasy.
Also, I breastfed the last 2 of my 3 children and I absolutely loved it. It was convenient, miles cheaper than formula and felt like a natural thing that my body was made to do (it wasn’t always easy at first, but it was worth it for me in the end)

ThatLoudCat · 08/11/2026 21:35

@YelliwFinnTuner yes, I know that? My babies haven't been dummy fans personally though.

HairsprayBabe · 09/11/2026 09:13

@Autisticradfem so don't breast feed. I have said in many post I don't care if people don't want to breast feed on an individual level, crazy of you to call me a Nazi for saying at a population level breastfeeding is better across the board for mothers and babies in short and long term outcomes, and as a population we should aim for higher rates.

Formula companies are pretty much evil conglomerates across the board wild of a self proclaimed feminist to defend them. They use underhanded marketing to make profit from something that can be free - for most women and families. Unless you want to start defending Nestle and Danone?

Most women when surveyed do want to breast feed, that is what we are talking about when we are saying they should offer more support, and the environment in general should be more supportive to breastfeeding. Not the 15% (approx.) of women who decide it isn't for them, as it their absolute right to do. Not very "radfem" of you to not support what a large proportion of other women need.

But I have a feeling you are so insistent that your feelings are the correct ones that anyone who feels differently, about something subjective must be wrong. I don't care if you think breastfeeding isn't for you but suggesting it turns a woman into a 24/7 milking machine / dummy that her baby is hanging off her tit all year is literally the opposite of feminism.

I am sure you will shout at me now, but you did resurrect a three week dead thread and reply individually to every single person you disagreed with so enjoy wasting your own time I guess.

gurptinkerbell · 09/11/2026 09:59

I breastfed two kids for over two years each - I am very lucky because I found it easy (if painful at first). It’s a skill that both participants have to learn, and it’s really unfortunate that mothers have to learn it at the same time as they’re recovering from a pretty gruelling process.

For me, the thing that made the biggest difference was DH, who basically made it so that I could spend the first three weeks sitting around, being brought food and feeding the babies. It hurt a LOT with DC1 - I had ulcers on one nipple and an oversupply as well so I was waterboarding my poor baby as well, but I wanted to BF and he supported me totally. Women who don’t for whatever reason have someone who can or will do that for them will struggle, I think. I also think I was better prepared the second time because I knew it would hurt at first and I knew it would be a few days before my milk came in so I was generally a bit more relaxed. It would have helped me hugely the first time round to be told that yes, it does hurt but it gets better. It feels pretty infantilising, to be honest, the way it’s presented at antenatal classes. At ours they made some ludicrous concoction out of water, washing up liquid, and glitter, to show all the magic goodnesses in breast milk and I remembered thinking it was childish bollocks at the time. What women need is honesty, but the judgement is that they then won’t even try it so instead the truth is kept from them and they think there’s something wrong with them when actually what they’re experiencing is normal.

alomath · 11/11/2026 19:58

Here is an interesting radio programme aired just yesterday about exactly this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0033z63

OP, I could’t agree more with you. My body didn’t produce enough milk and the multiple “experts” who “supported” me all told me what I was going through was normal. My daughter ended up in hospital with 25% weight loss at 5 days old. She was so unwell she had to do a lumbar puncture (among other invasive interventions) to rule out an infection. Turns out she was just underfed.

If anyone had been truthful to me about my options for feeding my baby, I would not have chosen to exclusively breastfeed.

And just to address the point about bonding: I couldn’t bond with my daughter in those first five days. They were awful and to this day (she’s 3) I can’t look at pictures of her of that time. Once I started giving her formula, my relationship with her completely changed and I started feeling so close to her. So to everyone who says breastfeeding is the best way to bond, they don’t know what they’re talking about.

BBC Radio 4 - File on 4 Investigates, Feeding - are babies getting the best start?

Why are so many young babies being readmitted to hospital with feeding difficulties?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0033z63

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 15:57

Oliveoy · 08/11/2026 20:20

Not that it was ever 24/7 but I loved BFing.

Given your username perhaps you'd be interested in my feminist take on it. Using my breasts for what they were designed for felt like two fingers up to every man who had ever talked to my chest rather than my face. And sustaining my child myself also felt like two fingers up to the male dominated formula industry. It was quite empowering.

There is nothing wrong with that.

however many women suffer with breastfeeding and pushed themselves to the point of depression and many women found it traumatic.

i also found “it’s what we’re meant to do” very harmful I have a chronic illness my body doesn’t always do “what it’s meant to do” and it doesn’t make me any less worthy. A woman who can’t or doesn’t want to breastfeed is doing what she is meant to do but regardless of how feeding is done a fed alive happy healthy baby is natural and is the goal. Happy mum happy baby exists for a reason and it’s true. Formula isn’t the devil. Breastfeeding nazis are the devil and the ones who hate women because we benefit from women’s suffrage in society.

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 16:06

HairsprayBabe · 09/11/2026 09:13

@Autisticradfem so don't breast feed. I have said in many post I don't care if people don't want to breast feed on an individual level, crazy of you to call me a Nazi for saying at a population level breastfeeding is better across the board for mothers and babies in short and long term outcomes, and as a population we should aim for higher rates.

Formula companies are pretty much evil conglomerates across the board wild of a self proclaimed feminist to defend them. They use underhanded marketing to make profit from something that can be free - for most women and families. Unless you want to start defending Nestle and Danone?

Most women when surveyed do want to breast feed, that is what we are talking about when we are saying they should offer more support, and the environment in general should be more supportive to breastfeeding. Not the 15% (approx.) of women who decide it isn't for them, as it their absolute right to do. Not very "radfem" of you to not support what a large proportion of other women need.

But I have a feeling you are so insistent that your feelings are the correct ones that anyone who feels differently, about something subjective must be wrong. I don't care if you think breastfeeding isn't for you but suggesting it turns a woman into a 24/7 milking machine / dummy that her baby is hanging off her tit all year is literally the opposite of feminism.

I am sure you will shout at me now, but you did resurrect a three week dead thread and reply individually to every single person you disagreed with so enjoy wasting your own time I guess.

Get a grip it was 50 odd years ago a formula advert on the telly isn’t evil neither are toy adverts for poor children.

its feminist to allow women to have boundaries to breastfeed or not, many women find it draining many say they feel like a milk machine they found it traumatic. It has drove many women into postnatal depression but none of you bf nazis don’t care because women need to suffer to be good mums. My mum had 3 c sections and formula fed from birth and she’s a bloody good mum because she puts her mental health first to be a good mum she refuses to suffer unlike many women who don’t realise they breast milk won’t get their child into Oxford.

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 16:08

YelliwFinnTuner · 08/11/2026 21:28

@ThatLoudCat you know you can breastfeed and also use a dummy right?
ive just weaned my one year old from being exclusively breastfed and it was surprisingly easy! They obviously didn't just ‘help themselves’ 🙄 because thats easily prevent and now also means I didn’t have to introduce formula or a bottle; they just have a normal cup of cows milk. Easy peasy.
Also, I breastfed the last 2 of my 3 children and I absolutely loved it. It was convenient, miles cheaper than formula and felt like a natural thing that my body was made to do (it wasn’t always easy at first, but it was worth it for me in the end)

can we stop with the “my body was made to do it”

tell my PCOS and endometriosis to behave itself because clearly my body isn’t doing what it’s meant. It’s offensive and harmful to many women feeding a baby is natural and what you’re meant to do regardless of how it’s done.

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 16:11

scoutzx · 08/11/2026 19:58

I fed on demand and loved it. From an evolutionary and biological standpoint, human infants are biologically hardwired to feed frequently and on cue rather than according to a clock.

most People feed on demand breastfed or not lmao. But breastfeeding on demand day and night can be absolutely exhausting for many women it’s rare for me to see a non Judgy woman who breastfed and actually enjoyed it and enjoyed motherhood.

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 16:29

Well my friendship group/ school mum group must be a huge outlier then, because the majority of babies were exlusively breastfed, many post 2 years, some tandem, one to 5 years, one set of twins to 3+ day & night. I ebf and continued on to 3yrs 4 months despite doing 12 hours shifts (admittedly and thankfull only part time).

Breastfeeding rates in the UK are low compared to comparable countries (Scandinavia) which is not biology it is social. There are biological causes that are associated with high tech health care which is why we need to look to western stats and not africa for example, but it is still the biological norm for a healthy well nourished mum to be able to exclusively breastfeed her own child solo.

Grieve the fact that you didn't get the success you hoped for, but don't expect the facts and evidence to change and don't undermine other mums-to-be.

YelliwFinnTuner · 13/11/2026 17:14

@Autisticradfem I’m sorry if you feel that way, but I respectfully disagree. I wasn’t able to successfully breastfeed my first baby so I do understand it can be emotive for some people and that not everyone can successfully breastfeed for whatever reason, but biologically and functionally speaking, that is what breasts are supposed to do; to feed a newborn baby.

‘The primary biological function of the female breast is lactation—producing, storing, and secreting milk to nourish and provide immune protection to a newborn infant.’

scoutzx · 13/11/2026 17:19

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 16:11

most People feed on demand breastfed or not lmao. But breastfeeding on demand day and night can be absolutely exhausting for many women it’s rare for me to see a non Judgy woman who breastfed and actually enjoyed it and enjoyed motherhood.

I’m a non-judgy woman who enjoyed breastfeeding (fed both my children for 3 years) and I enjoy motherhood.

I had two home births, carried my babies in a sling all day and slept with them at night. They fed on demand and ‘helped themselves.’

I don’t care what other women do. This way of parenting suited me.