Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

We need to change the conversation around breastfeeding

251 replies

pisces5891 · 18/10/2026 21:28

I am writing this post knowing that it will potentially kick off a bit of hornet's nest. I'm just really fed up with how much pressure there is on women to breastfeed, when all the evidence suggests that a significant number of women simply cannot exclusively breastfeed. I would even hazaard a guess that more than 50% of women cannot exclusively breastfeed. Its making women miserable and is the number one cause of post natal depression. Enough!!!

When I tried to breastfeed, I had real trouble providing enough supply for my baby. I was told that with the right support, almost every woman can breastfeed. I received help from 3 different lactation consultants. the first told me, less than 5% of women have actual low supply, and if low supply was really true of a lot of women, then the human race would have died out. This is objectively speaking totally false. Historically, women would share feeding of babies with other lactating women, and even then, lots of babies died. So the fact that the human race still exists is absolutely not evidence that the majority of women have enough supply. the second lactation consultant told me that if there was no formula, I would have found a way to exclusively breastfeed. this is also not true. My mother grew up in a tiny village overseast, where there was no access to formula. And she told me that it was rare that one woman would exclusively feed their own child, it was normal that it would be shared amongst the group and in the case that there were not enough other lactating women, they would put the baby at the teet of a goat in order to feed it because it was understood that it would be rare that a mother could exclusively feed her child from her breast. In my nct group, there are 10 women. One chose to formula feed from birth. The other 9 all wanted to exclusively breastfeed. only 2 of them are. and every single one of those 9 had the support of private lactation consultants, so we cannot say they are unsupported. A variety of issues from latch to supply to mastitis- so many problems that we all tried desperately to resolve, and we couldnt.

The third lactation consultant actually watched and listened to me breastfeeding and told me that my baby was not transferring enough milk. She was the only one of the 3 lactation consultants who had actually worked in a nicu ward and was able to recognise the signs of hunger. my baby thankfully was not starving but had I listened to the first 2 Lactation consultants, I think she would have been . This lactation consultant told me that it is very common on the Nicu ward to find very thin very hungry babies of mother's who are desperate to exclusively breastfeed, the babies are literally starving, drawn, crying and lethargic, because they are not being fed enough.

mixed feeding needs to be a system that is properly introduced to mothers. Mother's need to also be shown what an actual wet nappy looks like. I was told 6 to 8 wet nappies were a sign that my baby was getting enough food. Now that she is getting enough food because she's mixed fed, I can see what an actual wet nappy looks like, and it's really heavy compared to what it looked like when I was breastfeeding her.

I think this is a real issue and mumsnet is partly to blame for it, because the amount of threads I see where someone posts that they're struggling with breastfeeding, and they're told to keep going even when their baby is dropping centiles. It's the latch! It's tongue tie! Try an osteopath! Breastfed babies always lose weight! Its ok to drop centiles! You'll get there! It gets easier! Please PLEASE stop advising women to keep going no matter what, because in some instances, those women and there babies will end up in emergency care. Of course, many breastfeeding problems can be overcome with the right support, but in my experience, it sometimes never resolves, and the absolutely right and moral thing to do is to introduce the bottle.

I'm not blaming women here; the fault is in the system. Breastfeeding needs to be properly researched, but like all womens health, it's ignored.

I am still breastfeeding my baby girl, we mix feed very successfully. For anyone reading this struggling with breastfeeding, know that you're not alone.

OP posts:
Oliveoy · 13/11/2026 17:37

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 15:57

There is nothing wrong with that.

however many women suffer with breastfeeding and pushed themselves to the point of depression and many women found it traumatic.

i also found “it’s what we’re meant to do” very harmful I have a chronic illness my body doesn’t always do “what it’s meant to do” and it doesn’t make me any less worthy. A woman who can’t or doesn’t want to breastfeed is doing what she is meant to do but regardless of how feeding is done a fed alive happy healthy baby is natural and is the goal. Happy mum happy baby exists for a reason and it’s true. Formula isn’t the devil. Breastfeeding nazis are the devil and the ones who hate women because we benefit from women’s suffrage in society.

Many women suffer with breastfeeding because of a lack of knowledge and support, not because there are great swathes of women who are biologically unable to breastfeed. And it becomes a vicious circle in a formula centric society...the less people breastfeed, the less knowledge and support there is.

Stating that with the correct support most women would be able to breastfeed shouldn't cause offence to the tiny majority who genuinely can't. My DH is diabetic, but he wouldn't be upset to hear that most people's pancreases work.

Obviously there are a lot of emotions at play when a mother wanted to breastfeed and it wasn't successful. But pointing the finger at "breastfeeding nazis" is completely backwards. If you feel for the women who didn't get on with breastfeeding, then get annoyed at the formula industry.

scoutzx · 13/11/2026 17:41

@Autisticradfem “Breastfeeding nazis are the devil and the ones who hate women because we benefit from women’s suffrage in society.”

I am not a breastfeeding nazi for breastfeeding my children. I also do not hate women. I am a woman!

Autisticradfem · 14/11/2026 01:43

Oliveoy · 13/11/2026 17:37

Many women suffer with breastfeeding because of a lack of knowledge and support, not because there are great swathes of women who are biologically unable to breastfeed. And it becomes a vicious circle in a formula centric society...the less people breastfeed, the less knowledge and support there is.

Stating that with the correct support most women would be able to breastfeed shouldn't cause offence to the tiny majority who genuinely can't. My DH is diabetic, but he wouldn't be upset to hear that most people's pancreases work.

Obviously there are a lot of emotions at play when a mother wanted to breastfeed and it wasn't successful. But pointing the finger at "breastfeeding nazis" is completely backwards. If you feel for the women who didn't get on with breastfeeding, then get annoyed at the formula industry.

The formula industry doesn’t discourage it

Autisticradfem · 14/11/2026 01:44

scoutzx · 13/11/2026 17:41

@Autisticradfem “Breastfeeding nazis are the devil and the ones who hate women because we benefit from women’s suffrage in society.”

I am not a breastfeeding nazi for breastfeeding my children. I also do not hate women. I am a woman!

You can still hate women lmao

Oliveoy · 14/11/2026 07:36

Autisticradfem · 14/11/2026 01:43

The formula industry doesn’t discourage it

Oh dear god

MikeRafone · 14/11/2026 07:45

I have 2 daughter who have 2 children

bith have breast feed one child to 6 months

both formula feed the other child as breastfeeding didn’t work out.

with one dd it was the first baby they feed themselves and found easy after the first couple of weeks. Then they couldn’t feed their second die to illness, even though they stsrted and it was going well

the other didn’t succeed with first but did with second

O said it’s the initial few weeks and the baby

but yet again breast feeding is poorly researched, lacks funding as it’s a female attribute

valentinka31 · 14/11/2026 07:52

BigWig78 · 18/10/2026 22:46

Ignorance in the real sense of the word. BFing is not the norm so people don’t grow up seeing it and don’t learn about it. Breasts are sexualised and bottles are normalised (think baby cards, baby dolls etc all bottles etc), women are working outside of the home far more now and wanting to share the baby care with their partners etc. We have moved so far away from the biological norm…

Yes formula exists and no babies should not be starved. But neither should the undeniable differences in breastmilk and formula be ignored. The claim that some formulas are closer to breastmilk are like saying that standing on a chair makes you closer to the moon! Breastmilk is a changing substance suited directly to your baby at the time it is made in response to the germs and situation around you (weather etc). Formula is a one size fits all.

95% of women can breastfed biologically. Lack of education and support plus personal choices are the reasons they don’t. Dress it up how you like but those are the facts.

Honestly, I don’t think it’s kind to tell the OP she is ignorant.

Unless you have had bleeding nipples that are absolutely agony, and you’re still trying to get it right and breastfeed as you totally want to give her your natural goodness, you can’t say people stop because they aren’t trying hard enough. I actually carried on until it was better (4 months and I have scars on my nipples), but I was very stubborn. I wouldn’t have wanted my daughter to suffer that agony.

The OP is only speaking her personal experience, and has a right to do that, as all of us.

I do agree with some of what you say, but it would be good just to keep it nice. So many times in MN is see one person being open and sharing, and others just being unkind in how they couch their response.

scoutzx · 14/11/2026 08:01

Autisticradfem · 14/11/2026 01:44

You can still hate women lmao

You are coming across as someone who doesn’t like women!

Autisticradfem · 16/11/2026 00:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

scoutzx · 16/11/2026 07:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

”nipple Nazi” Your language is a disgrace!

I don’t care if women breastfeed or not. I wanted to breastfeed and so I did. I’m not going to apologise for that.

HairsprayBabe · 16/11/2026 09:26

@Autisticradfem the formula companies are STILL doing evil shit for one small example: lobbying against paid maternity leave in the US and against increasing paid parental leave in the UK. It's not a case of oh well that was in the past alalalala. If you would like more very recent examples of their shitty underhanded behaviour I am more than happy to give them but it would be a very long response.

All the studies we have show that breastfeeding reduces the instance of PDP so your anecdote of breastfeeding pushing women into depression is not evidence based and just speculative nonsense. If you actually read the data we have on how breastfeeding makes women feel, most women feel positively about it and don't feel like "milking machines" (very dehumanizing language for a feminist BTW)

In what world did I say women should not have "boundaries" around breastfeeding? Oh right that would be no world. I support your right to hate the idea of breastfeeding for yourself. I do not support your tirade of nonsense misinformation about breastfeeding and how it makes other women feel.

I don't believe anyone needs to suffer to be a good mother, in fact I am adamantly against it, we sleep trained, we don't have our children in our bed, we used baby reins and playpens and child care. All things that some claim are "cruel" but all great for my mental health.

As for "my body was made to do it" yes - it was, humans have evolved so that breasts are for breastfeeding, regardless of what health issues you have that is the primary function of tits. You have PCOS and endometriosis, your body is literally not doing what it is "supposed" to, that's why you have (presumably) seen a doctor about it. Humans are bipedal, you wouldn't change that accurate scientific terminology because some people have birth differences or have had amputations.

You seem really defensive about your position on breastfeeding, the reality is nobody, including me, actually cares how you, one individual chooses, to feed your child. You want to breastfeed till they are five great, you want formula for day one great. They all eat car seat crumbs and party rings in the end.

The wider conversation that most women DO want to breastfeed, and most women DO want more support, and on a public health level it would be better for women and babies in the UK to have a higher breastfeeding rate is separate to your individual preference, and you don't seem to be able to separate those things.

pisces5891 · 16/11/2026 21:10

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 16:29

Well my friendship group/ school mum group must be a huge outlier then, because the majority of babies were exlusively breastfed, many post 2 years, some tandem, one to 5 years, one set of twins to 3+ day & night. I ebf and continued on to 3yrs 4 months despite doing 12 hours shifts (admittedly and thankfull only part time).

Breastfeeding rates in the UK are low compared to comparable countries (Scandinavia) which is not biology it is social. There are biological causes that are associated with high tech health care which is why we need to look to western stats and not africa for example, but it is still the biological norm for a healthy well nourished mum to be able to exclusively breastfeed her own child solo.

Grieve the fact that you didn't get the success you hoped for, but don't expect the facts and evidence to change and don't undermine other mums-to-be.

The national statistics literally tell us that your group is an anomaly.

Its not undermining to prepare women for an objective reality. And i reiterate, i am still breastfeeding.

For those who've shared their difficulties with breastfeeding, I'm so sorry, i can completely sympathise, and may this one day get the research it deserves.

OP posts:
Periperi2025 · 16/11/2026 21:50

pisces5891 · 16/11/2026 21:10

The national statistics literally tell us that your group is an anomaly.

Its not undermining to prepare women for an objective reality. And i reiterate, i am still breastfeeding.

For those who've shared their difficulties with breastfeeding, I'm so sorry, i can completely sympathise, and may this one day get the research it deserves.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10870977/

Nordic women are not biologically different to british women, and my friends are not biologically different either, and neither is their maternity care significantly different to the UK, yet 60-80% of babies in nordic counties are still breastfed at 6 months compared to the UK where only 34% of babies recieve any breastfeeding at 6 months.

In Norway 97% of mother intiated some breastfeeding at birth compared to 81% in the UK.

In Iceland 20% of babies are exclusively breasfed at 6 months compared to 1% in the UK.

That is fundamentally a social problem not a biological one and generally not a medical one with the exception of poor access to tongue-tie services in the UK.

Infant feeding—a scoping review for Nordic Nutrition Recommendations 2023 - PMC

The 2012 edition of the Nordic Nutrition Recommendations (NNR) included recommendations on breastfeeding, based on the most recent guidelines and recommendations from major national food and health authorities and organizations, systematic reviews, ...

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10870977/

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 14:00

Autisticradfem · 13/11/2026 15:57

There is nothing wrong with that.

however many women suffer with breastfeeding and pushed themselves to the point of depression and many women found it traumatic.

i also found “it’s what we’re meant to do” very harmful I have a chronic illness my body doesn’t always do “what it’s meant to do” and it doesn’t make me any less worthy. A woman who can’t or doesn’t want to breastfeed is doing what she is meant to do but regardless of how feeding is done a fed alive happy healthy baby is natural and is the goal. Happy mum happy baby exists for a reason and it’s true. Formula isn’t the devil. Breastfeeding nazis are the devil and the ones who hate women because we benefit from women’s suffrage in society.

Yes. I never ever understand the ‘it’s natural so best’ or ‘it’s what we’re meant to do’ argument. We’re also meant to die and we usually do all we can to circumvent nature and avoid that !

Nature is neither good nor bad - it just is. Many of us prefer civilisation.

I breast fed successfully each tim. But I wouldn’t have worried too much if I hadn’t and I certainly wouldn’t presume to judge others.

pisces5891 · Yesterday 16:29

Periperi2025 · 16/11/2026 21:50

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10870977/

Nordic women are not biologically different to british women, and my friends are not biologically different either, and neither is their maternity care significantly different to the UK, yet 60-80% of babies in nordic counties are still breastfed at 6 months compared to the UK where only 34% of babies recieve any breastfeeding at 6 months.

In Norway 97% of mother intiated some breastfeeding at birth compared to 81% in the UK.

In Iceland 20% of babies are exclusively breasfed at 6 months compared to 1% in the UK.

That is fundamentally a social problem not a biological one and generally not a medical one with the exception of poor access to tongue-tie services in the UK.

Edited

But the article you linked shows the exclusive breastfeeding numbers in Norway dwindling hugely as the weeks go on and by 4 months 39% are ebf, by 6 months 2%. And these figures do not say whether they include women who exclusively pump. But i agree women are clearly much better supported in other countries, and that this is vital to increasing numbers.

My issue is that the idea that only 5% of women physically cannot breastfeed comes from research that states that 5% of women statistically have conditions that affect breastfeeding, like pcos, thyroid issues etc. But we all know that pcos is massively under diagnosed, as are thyroid issues. In fact, womens health generally is deeply misunderstood.

I also agree with pp about the word natural being unhelpful. The worst advice i got when i was breastfeeding was 'trust your body'. Our bodies are living changing organisms, affected by everything from stress levels to our diet to our genetics and everything inbetween. What i could trust was my babies cues.

OP posts:
pisces5891 · Yesterday 16:33

And one last thing- it seems to me that breast is best is an essential idea in developing countries, where babies would be at higher risk from dirty water being used to make formula than they would from a breastfeeding mother with a low or insufficient supply. But in the UK? Its just not the most usrful terminology at all.

OP posts:
Periperi2025 · Yesterday 17:05

pisces5891 · Yesterday 16:29

But the article you linked shows the exclusive breastfeeding numbers in Norway dwindling hugely as the weeks go on and by 4 months 39% are ebf, by 6 months 2%. And these figures do not say whether they include women who exclusively pump. But i agree women are clearly much better supported in other countries, and that this is vital to increasing numbers.

My issue is that the idea that only 5% of women physically cannot breastfeed comes from research that states that 5% of women statistically have conditions that affect breastfeeding, like pcos, thyroid issues etc. But we all know that pcos is massively under diagnosed, as are thyroid issues. In fact, womens health generally is deeply misunderstood.

I also agree with pp about the word natural being unhelpful. The worst advice i got when i was breastfeeding was 'trust your body'. Our bodies are living changing organisms, affected by everything from stress levels to our diet to our genetics and everything inbetween. What i could trust was my babies cues.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6021099/

In 2018 Norwegian health authorities were still recommending introduction of solids between 4 and 6 months which explains the sudden drop between 4 & 6 months.

Timing of complementary feeding and associations with maternal and infant characteristics: A Norwegian cross-sectional study - PMC

Norwegian Health authorities recommend solid food to be introduced between child age 4–6 months, depending on both the mother´s and infant’s needs. The aim of this paper is to describe timing of complementary feeding in a current sample of Norwegian .....

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6021099/

pisces5891 · Yesterday 17:30

Yes but without knowing how many women are pumping or supplementing with formula, these statistics do nothing but show us a large number of women start trying to exclusively breastfeed and a small number of women actually end up still doing that months later.

And anyway, it's pointless to get into a back and forth about statistics, because the underlying point you're making is that me and my group are the anomaly, that we don't fit the biological norm. I'm less offended by that proposition than you'd imagine, i get it- if you've been able to ebf, and devoted months / years of your life to it, i can imagine it would be hard to fathom a situation where breastfeeding was difficult if not impossible. That's fine, that's your world view. Neither of us can definitively prove our point- only the research will eventually tell us whose right

OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · Today 10:22

pisces5891 · Yesterday 16:29

But the article you linked shows the exclusive breastfeeding numbers in Norway dwindling hugely as the weeks go on and by 4 months 39% are ebf, by 6 months 2%. And these figures do not say whether they include women who exclusively pump. But i agree women are clearly much better supported in other countries, and that this is vital to increasing numbers.

My issue is that the idea that only 5% of women physically cannot breastfeed comes from research that states that 5% of women statistically have conditions that affect breastfeeding, like pcos, thyroid issues etc. But we all know that pcos is massively under diagnosed, as are thyroid issues. In fact, womens health generally is deeply misunderstood.

I also agree with pp about the word natural being unhelpful. The worst advice i got when i was breastfeeding was 'trust your body'. Our bodies are living changing organisms, affected by everything from stress levels to our diet to our genetics and everything inbetween. What i could trust was my babies cues.

I also dispute the suggestion that maternity care is not markedly different from eg in Norway or other European countries to the U.K.

Really? So the fact that we have less staff per head of population than any of these other places is irrelevant to the patient experience and care? And have official reviews in eg Norway found that a majority of maternity units are ‘failing’ as found in the U.K? U.K. maternity care is clearly worse.

HairsprayBabe · Today 11:06

@pisces5891 I don't know where you are getting your data from but in Norway 11% of babies are EBF at 6 months - However their govt recommend introducing solids between 4 and 6 months so that skews the data as even one bottle of formula or one spoon of porridge will discount a baby from EBF statistics so that isn't particularly helpful.

At 6 months, roughly 78% to 80% of babies are still receiving breast milk in Norway but most of these have started weaning with solids already.

If you look at babies aged 3 months - before the gov recommendation to introduce solids 70% of Norwegian babies are EBF. With 90% receiving breastmilk in some form.

CurlewKate · Today 11:13

The 50% figure is obviously bonkers-are you suggesting that before the 20th century 50% of babies died of starvation? Or 50% of other baby mammals die? What about, for example, Finland, where the vast majority of babies are breastfed?

pisces5891 · Today 11:25

Lots of baby's were historically fed by more than one woman, because many women struggled with breastfeeding. I absolutely don't believe that only 5% of women can't breastfeed, i think it's definitely more, and the problem can either be the mothers biology or having a baby that simply won't latch. The 50% was anecdotal, based on the women around me, i very clearly said it was a guess- I'm allowed to interpret the world around me!. The nordic country statistics don't account for women who pump, but honestly, i haven't spent hours looking at that research so i wont pretend to be an expert, but for whoever asked, i was getting my statistics from the link given by the previous poster.

Im quite proud that i started a chat with this many replies, but i am officially logging off, with gratitide to those who engaged, i know it's an emotive subject

OP posts:
HairsprayBabe · Today 11:38

@pisces5891 You are making up data again.

We do have some historical records that exist, for the Netherlands around 1860 showed roughly 67% of babies being breastfed in some capacity by their mothers between 6 and 12 months. This was in a time where weaning at 3 months was common due to financial pressures and "getting back to the factory".

The estimates for informal kinship wet nursing is between 3-10% for preindustrial times. This estimate is confirmed by the data we have for kinship wet nursing in current modern rural agricultural communities across low-income nations. Roughly 1% to 5% of infants rely on a relative or neighbour for extended feeding due to maternal death in childbirth, severe illness, or acute lactation failure.

Oliveoy · Today 12:49

HairsprayBabe · Today 11:38

@pisces5891 You are making up data again.

We do have some historical records that exist, for the Netherlands around 1860 showed roughly 67% of babies being breastfed in some capacity by their mothers between 6 and 12 months. This was in a time where weaning at 3 months was common due to financial pressures and "getting back to the factory".

The estimates for informal kinship wet nursing is between 3-10% for preindustrial times. This estimate is confirmed by the data we have for kinship wet nursing in current modern rural agricultural communities across low-income nations. Roughly 1% to 5% of infants rely on a relative or neighbour for extended feeding due to maternal death in childbirth, severe illness, or acute lactation failure.

Maternal death is an important point. In Victorian Britain there were approx 500 maternal deaths per 100,000 births. Nowadays it's about 10. The fact that wet nursing was prevalent in the past isn't proof that swathes of women were biologically unable to BF, it's because they were dead.

HairsprayBabe · Today 13:05

@Oliveoy Sorry I think you misunderstand my statistics - OP is claiming that "many many" mothers used wet nurses (alive or not) when the sats show it was still - in non elite circles, rare only a few % even with maternal and infant mortality taken into consideration.

Maternal mortality in preindustrial times was not as high as people might think, around 1% it is a really common misconception that "one in three women died in childbirth," while childbirth was hazardous, it was never the single most common cause of death for all adult women. It is the infant mortality rate that was much higher (around 30%) and most of these occurred in the first month of life. Largely down to birth trauma/lack of oxygen, and neonatal sepsis.