Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

268 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
Ineedanewsofa · Today 19:17

Depends what it is, we tend to say big purchases need to be birthday/xmas or saved up for by DC and I’d include video games for £60 in that category but we spend a lot on a very expensive hobby throughout the year (clothing, equipment, entry fees). DC are very grateful though and understand that other things aren’t in budget due to hobby.
Clothes/footwear are bought as and when and we always try to buy quality. Expensive branded items would be a birthday/xmas purchase.

Boymum776 · Today 19:17

I have younger kids but if I had a teen that was mad for GTA like some people seem to be then yes - I’d probably buy it for them. £60 generally would be too much for a just because gift but this game seems to be a big deal to some people.

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:18

It's also interesting how some parents who are adamant no-one gets anything outside of Christmas and birthdays because 'spoilt', can change their tune if they come into money.

A friend of mine was very much like this when she was on benefits, but this completely changed after receiving a large inheritance.

So these 'principals' aren't always set in stone.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:21

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:18

It's also interesting how some parents who are adamant no-one gets anything outside of Christmas and birthdays because 'spoilt', can change their tune if they come into money.

A friend of mine was very much like this when she was on benefits, but this completely changed after receiving a large inheritance.

So these 'principals' aren't always set in stone.

I've not found that. Everyone in my circle can afford a computer game or the new home and away football kit or Charlotte Tilbury skin care but none off them just buy their kids stuff because they've asked

OP posts:
Crushed23 · Today 19:21

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:18

It's also interesting how some parents who are adamant no-one gets anything outside of Christmas and birthdays because 'spoilt', can change their tune if they come into money.

A friend of mine was very much like this when she was on benefits, but this completely changed after receiving a large inheritance.

So these 'principals' aren't always set in stone.

Of course it’s sour grapes. It’s not easy to admit you’ve been priced out of something, it’s much easier to just denigrate it.

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:21

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:13

This is what i do

I would say that applies for November/December, my DS birthday is in January - if I stuck to just buying for birthdays and Christmas he’d have a long wait.

Outside of those days, if there’s something either child wants I’ll add it to their list for Christmas or birthday if that’s reasonable, they’ll buy it either way their allowance or I’ll just get it for them. I like my kids, I enjoy buying them things they’ll love, they both have a good work ethic and appreciate what they have. I don’t waste money, I can afford to treat them from time to time so why not do that.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:22

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:21

I would say that applies for November/December, my DS birthday is in January - if I stuck to just buying for birthdays and Christmas he’d have a long wait.

Outside of those days, if there’s something either child wants I’ll add it to their list for Christmas or birthday if that’s reasonable, they’ll buy it either way their allowance or I’ll just get it for them. I like my kids, I enjoy buying them things they’ll love, they both have a good work ethic and appreciate what they have. I don’t waste money, I can afford to treat them from time to time so why not do that.

Do you give them pocket money?

OP posts:
FKAT · Today 19:22

Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

Mine usually come with a bargain - if you get me this, I will do this and this (eg clean the car, get grades, pay me back).

FWIW DS12 has asked for GTA5 and been told 'no' for content related reasons. We actually get it free through work but he won't be able to play it until we have played it and then not for a year or two. DS1 was allowed GTA from about 14. My nephews all played GTA growing up and are now respectable, responsible professional adults - one of them is even a politician. Grin

Kittkats · Today 19:22

I would buy a refurbished replacement iPhone for £80 if one broke. I’d buy branded trainers from vinted if others wore out. I’d buy non branded clothes as needed. I’d buy books as asked for, ditto stationery for school etc. Nicer than normal toiletries on request if I’ve the spare cash. A bag of sweets every so often. Sports equipment as needed. Family days out as and when I can afford.
otherwise it’s birthday, Christmas or pocket money!

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:24

I also think it might be different if you don’t have kids with winter birthdays. If I only bought my children things at birthday and Christmas they’d have to wait 11 months between occasions. That’s a long time to wait for a kid. I alleviate it now by giving them money now they’re older, but when they were little kids yeah I bought them the odd Barbie doll or Lego set in the summer.

AlphabetMole · Today 19:24

So my kids and I have magpie syndrome. We're very taken by shiny new stuff that we see in shops. We have a rule that we won't buy something the first time we see it and want it, but we might buy it the 10th time we see it and want it, depending on what it is. If it's definitely a 'no', I talk to my kids about why this is... too big, too expensive, too old for them, load of plastic junk, whatever the reason is.

But I do buy stuff for them outside of birthdays and Christmas. I buy stuff for myself sometimes as well. It's ok to get something just because you really want it.

Sometimes I buy something for one child and not the other. Because that child really wants something and the other child doesn't. My kids are ok with this. We talk about it.

G1ngerbread · Today 19:26

It was £90 not £60 but yes mine regularly gets things throughout the year. Do you, as an adult, restrict yourself to only purchasing things for yourself twice a year?

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:27

G1ngerbread · Today 19:26

It was £90 not £60 but yes mine regularly gets things throughout the year. Do you, as an adult, restrict yourself to only purchasing things for yourself twice a year?

I have a job and work for my money. If my kids want to earn money and save up for things then thats great but life isn't free

OP posts:
yogzig · Today 19:27

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:21

I've not found that. Everyone in my circle can afford a computer game or the new home and away football kit or Charlotte Tilbury skin care but none off them just buy their kids stuff because they've asked

Can you, or any of your circle, explain why?

Canape · Today 19:27

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:24

I also think it might be different if you don’t have kids with winter birthdays. If I only bought my children things at birthday and Christmas they’d have to wait 11 months between occasions. That’s a long time to wait for a kid. I alleviate it now by giving them money now they’re older, but when they were little kids yeah I bought them the odd Barbie doll or Lego set in the summer.

DS's birthday is November so when was younger if he wanted summer toys we would buy them for him as birthday and Christmas was in the winter

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:28

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:22

Do you give them pocket money?

Yes they get a decent allowance that allows them to save for things, and to see their friends. There are things we negotiate on eg they’ll save up for a particular thing, sometimes they’ll do extra chores and be paid for them, sometimes they’ll save half and I’ll match their savings, sometimes I’ll just pay for the whole thing because I can.

They’re too young for a job, the only way they have to get stuff is through their parents, so we negotiate. I love them, I want them to see the value of work but I also want them to see the value in being generous, so I’m occasionally generous with them.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:28

yogzig · Today 19:27

Can you, or any of your circle, explain why?

Because money needs to be earnt if I bought my kids everything they asked for what would their incentive be to get a minimum wage job at 16.

OP posts:
Allowingthebreeze · Today 19:29

It’s an interesting one. I wouldn’t pay 50p for any of the children for tat. I know someone who managed to spend £30 as we were waiting for the kids to finish a class on utter rubbish and it genuinely utterly baffled me. But a month ago I spent over £1,500 for something that would add value to their lives that they deserved. So to me it’s not about the money it’s the value add.

AlphabetMole · Today 19:30

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:27

I have a job and work for my money. If my kids want to earn money and save up for things then thats great but life isn't free

It depends on the age of your kids and whether there are part time jobs available in your area, but if you have children who are too young to work or can't, for whatever reason, this argument is pointless.

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:31

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:28

Because money needs to be earnt if I bought my kids everything they asked for what would their incentive be to get a minimum wage job at 16.

Why are you painting it as they are bought everything? Very emotive language for someone apparently open to discussion...

Buying your children the occasional thing throughout the year will not turn them into young people who have no desire to work or ethic to earn. If your children turn out that way it will be because of a much wiser issue in your parenting.

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:31

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:24

I also think it might be different if you don’t have kids with winter birthdays. If I only bought my children things at birthday and Christmas they’d have to wait 11 months between occasions. That’s a long time to wait for a kid. I alleviate it now by giving them money now they’re older, but when they were little kids yeah I bought them the odd Barbie doll or Lego set in the summer.

Yes I was thinking this when the OP mentioned football kits.

They're released between May-August as a rule so it's a bit miserable to have to wait until December, unless of course the parents can't actually afford it.

But if a child is generally a good kid, helpful/kind/hardworking it's nice to treat them now and then.

underthehawthorntree · Today 19:31

We don't buy things for our kids outside of birthdays or Christmas other than the odd small thing like a toy car or squishy but it really is very unusual. I thought that was normal.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:32

AlphabetMole · Today 19:30

It depends on the age of your kids and whether there are part time jobs available in your area, but if you have children who are too young to work or can't, for whatever reason, this argument is pointless.

No child is to young to do extra jobs around the house for money. They have their actual chores that they get pocket money for but if they want to earn extra i can always find jobs

OP posts:
AlphabetMole · Today 19:32

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:28

Because money needs to be earnt if I bought my kids everything they asked for what would their incentive be to get a minimum wage job at 16.

Surely this only works when your child is actually 16 though, and can get a job. My 9yo can't wait to leave school and earn loads of money, so telling him he can only have nice things when he can work for it would be counterproductive.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:33

underthehawthorntree · Today 19:31

We don't buy things for our kids outside of birthdays or Christmas other than the odd small thing like a toy car or squishy but it really is very unusual. I thought that was normal.

So did I thats why I started the thread as I was curious but its annoyed multiple people for some reason

OP posts: