Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

268 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
MrEdwardElizabethHitler · Today 19:04

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:55

I do agree with the amount of entertainment you get out off it £60 isn't horrific. Maybe I'm just tight making my kids wait or earn their money

With something like this, I don't really get the enforced waiting if a child is old enough that one might realistically consider getting it for them. If I were in that situation it would just be an early Christmas present, and they'd need to be mature enough to understand it means less on the day itself.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:06

Maisymouse2 · Today 19:02

Well it is.
Some of us choose to buy things for our children becajse we can afford it and do not see it as only bday or xmas.
I think that is stingy and mean.
Clothing only twice a year? Get real.
We craft and I rather spend on my family or nice sruff for the house than be out drinking it away like some parents.
People who game are gamers I pay for a subscription for my child..it is called living.
Enjoy your life Op have a happy day.

Who said anything about clothes or things they actually need

OP posts:
TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:06

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:04

My kids would never ask me for a £60 computer game as they would know the answer. Im asking what other families do. Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

Well I would imagine they'd say 'Please may I have' for a start.

If your kids are likely to walk up to anyone and say 'I want', then that in itself is a problem.

blackpooolrock · Today 19:07

I don't think £60 is a lot really. I listen to my colleagues on a Monday saying they got a takeaway from somewhere like Domino Pizza and it was £80 then they had a bottle of wine or two on top or them going for chinese and it was £120 or look at the smokers who go through 20 a day.

We tend not to do these things so i wouldn't mind £60 on a game - i wouldn't buy that game though.

Crushed23 · Today 19:07

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:41

I genuinely curious how normal it is for kids to ask for things randomly throughout the year and their parents just buy it for them. Or whether more parents say no wait for Christmas or birthday or give them jobs to earn money for things

I don’t have children but I have 2 nephews. Their parents do indeed buy them presents all throughout the year (they are both only children with two parents working full-time in good jobs, if relevant). They are still very sweet boys and not at all spoilt-acting amazingly. So good parenting must be more than saying no to your kids even when you can easily afford something.

My siblings’ view is that life is for living and not about denying yourself for the sake of it when you can afford comfort and joy. I tend to agree!

FKAT · Today 19:07

GTA has been long expected. It's 13 years since GTA5, it's been pushed back twice and been on pre-order for 2 years. It's not like its a shock expense to those who have been after it.

As PPs have said, £60 is not a lot for entertaining teenagers. £60 for a game that will give 100s of hours of gameplay and social rewards or £60 for a family game of bowling that lasts 40 minutes - GTA wins in terms of value.

Also, a lot of people do like spending money on children and if their children want something, take pleasure in buying it for them. DH is one of them - what else is going to spend his money on? Both him and I grew up poor so we have slightly different takes on this but he lost his father at 14 years old so he takes a 'enjoy life now' approach. I don't know why you would sit on £60 cash if you had it just to teach a lesson about the 'value of money'. Obviously if you want that money for something else, fair enough.

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:07

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:04

My kids would never ask me for a £60 computer game as they would know the answer. Im asking what other families do. Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

That's not what you asked though Hmm.
If my child says they would like something then yes sometimes I randomly say yes throughout the year because I like my child and value doing nice things for them and sometimes it's nice to treat other people for no other reason than just because. Isn't that part of the joy of being a parent.

Canape · Today 19:09

£60 is the cheap version, it was about £90, I checked so we could give DS the right money.

GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 19:09

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:04

My kids would never ask me for a £60 computer game as they would know the answer. Im asking what other families do. Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

We used to buy our kids most of what they asked for throughout the year. I remember when Call of Duty was all the rage. DS wanted it, so I bought it for him. I didn't start a thread on here asking what other parents would do, because, well why would I? Maybe I wasn't " curious" enough...

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:10

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

My kids get a monthly allowance that is theirs to spend as they please. If they wanted me to pay for a new game I’d tell them to put it on their Christmas list, if they wanted to buy it with their own money, that’s up to them.

Hotflushesandhobnobs · Today 19:10

My teens are absolutely not spoilt in anyway. But I don’t make myself wait for two random dates in the year for nice things so why would I make them? @JustFrustrated this is exactly how I feel.
My kids have an excellent understanding of money and are hard working in their own right. If I can treat them, as I do myself, then I’m not waiting for two specific days to do that.

MsSquiz · Today 19:10

I’ll say the thing OP clearly wants,

sometimes I buy my kids a gift for around £50 when it’s not their birthday or Christmas, because I can, because I want to and because we can afford to…

and I don’t feel guilty about it. My kids aren’t spoilt brats because they might get an occasional gift.
they also help donate regularly to a local food bank, including taking selection boxes in at Christmas, rather than just necessities.
they help sort out their stuff and know the toys and clothes they grow out of are donated to charity.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:11

What is the actual point off mumsnet ive had 5 different posters ask me why I have started this thread. I thought we could start threads about anything

OP posts:
Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:12

I wouldn’t buy them a toy or a computer game outside of Christmas or birthday, but I’d let them spend their own money. GTA is absolutely banned from my house regardless of who pays.

I do buy bikes, laptops, sports equipment etc as needed though rather than waiting for Christmas or birthday. On the flip side their Christmas and birthday gifts are modest.

Snorlaxo · Today 19:12

GTA is rated 18 so kids shouldn’t be playing it never mind asking for it.

As someone will have pointed out, the last game came out 10 years ago so that’s £6pa of entertainment. Not much else you can do for that amount.

The price and release date was announced a long time ago so it would be possible to save birthday and Christmas money for the purchase assuming that the child is old enough to earn money.

We live in a world where social media will spoil any film/game/event so we are conditioned to buy/watch quickly if we don’t want things spoiled.

Have you bought Marvel Doomsday tickets for next month because I think that’s the next big event?

JLou08 · Today 19:12

No, I don't buy them what they want. They do get pocket money and if they were interested in GTA they probably would have saved and had it on pre-order. I've always been quite strict on not giving them everything they want, I think it's important for children to learn they don't always get what they want as well as the value of saving and the need to earn things.

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:12

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:11

What is the actual point off mumsnet ive had 5 different posters ask me why I have started this thread. I thought we could start threads about anything

Mumsnet is a discussion forum. You don't actually seem to want a discussion.Hmm

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:13

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:10

My kids get a monthly allowance that is theirs to spend as they please. If they wanted me to pay for a new game I’d tell them to put it on their Christmas list, if they wanted to buy it with their own money, that’s up to them.

This is what i do

OP posts:
GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 19:13

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:13

This is what i do

Yeah, you've said.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:13

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:12

Mumsnet is a discussion forum. You don't actually seem to want a discussion.Hmm

Are you serious im trying to

OP posts:
Canape · Today 19:14

Parents are obviously buying it for their 10 year olds though and it isn't really suitable for primary school age children. Maybe that is the problem rather than the cost.

ChairmanMeowsMinion · Today 19:14

IME there are a lot of parents who haven't fully recovered from being a teen in uncool trainers, who will be buying it now so their DCs don't get left out/left behind. I think about 1/4 of parents I know are projecting this onto their kids and I'm not sure it's healthy.

I also suspect you have young kids and a lot of answers are from parents of teens.

I technically buy things throughout the year, but not really at birthdays and Christmas, maybe because both are dec/Jan birthdays. It won't be things like a Lego set they see, but things like bikes, headphones, shoes etc are replaced when needed. For less necessary things, like Lego, they wait or save up, but that's more because I think deferred gratification is important rather than learning about money.

My eldest is a nightmare to buy things for because she doesn't really want anything but she competes at a highish level for some expensive sports, it would be weird not to replace her road bike until her out of season birthday.

MammaTo · Today 19:14

But you’re insinuating that the kids who have been bought GTA are demanding it. Maybe some of the kids have said “there’s a new game coming out that I’d really like to play, is there any chance I could have it please?” and then it’s up to the parents if they want to spend their money.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 19:14

Depends what it is.

Drugs: no.

Socks: yes.

Waitingfordoggo · Today 19:14

I’ve never been in the habit of just randomly buying stuff for my kids, no (obviously aside from things they actually needed like clothes, shoes, toiletries, school supplies). Sometimes we’d have a family trip to the cinema/bowling/pizza as a treat during the year, and we’d often buy them a little souvenir on a holiday or weekend away, but when they have wanted a specific thing, it’s usually a case of waiting for birthday or Christmas.