Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A review on what people spend DLA/PIP for children on

172 replies

DoaBetterReview · Today 12:40

After seeing all the controversy over the Milburn review and knowing first hand through family and work exactly where the majority of people claiming for dc spend their DLA/PIP I think there actually needs to be a better review conducted where they gather info on what it’s spent on to then identify the weak areas where they need to concentrate funding and efforts.

What is being proposed now is just support in the wrong place at the wrong time ! By 18-24 anyone with ND or MH issues are really struggling so significantly that it could be useless.

Everyone I know getting DLA or PIP for a child / young person is spending it on timely access to diagnosis and/or therapies. This is where the focus needs to be.

Also I’m still shocked at the language around PIP - IT IS NOT AN OUT OF WORK BENEFIT!!! Why is being referred to as if it is a lot of the time.

OP posts:
ByGreenDeer · Today 12:42

Completely agree with you.

People love to benefit bash though, so brace yourself.

Positivepositron · Today 12:58

I think the difficulty with this is that support needs to fit a range of needs and support mechanisms which cash direct to the person/ family does. It also allows a person/ family to respond to changing needs over time.
You have identified therapy and diagnosis but more investment in that wouldn't help my son whilst it may help others. Diagnosis is often a one time cost. My son was diagnosed on the NHS at 3 and accesses various therapies in his school so greater investment in those areas is needed in general it isn't what my son needs at this point in time. I'm not sure how an investigation like this would work but having to jump through hoops or justify spending would be a negative in my eyes.

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

DoaBetterReview · Today 13:04

Positivepositron · Today 12:58

I think the difficulty with this is that support needs to fit a range of needs and support mechanisms which cash direct to the person/ family does. It also allows a person/ family to respond to changing needs over time.
You have identified therapy and diagnosis but more investment in that wouldn't help my son whilst it may help others. Diagnosis is often a one time cost. My son was diagnosed on the NHS at 3 and accesses various therapies in his school so greater investment in those areas is needed in general it isn't what my son needs at this point in time. I'm not sure how an investigation like this would work but having to jump through hoops or justify spending would be a negative in my eyes.

Not to justify but you think if they were serious about long term outcomes they’d put together large focus groups to work out where the failings are and what could be done to improve the situation rather than the current proposals for 18-24

OP posts:
DoaBetterReview · Today 13:06

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

If that was truly the case and written on the claim form then they would not get awarded? So there must be more to it. If you don’t send evidence with DLA forms they will contact school id say 99.9% of the time for more information

OP posts:
emuloc · Today 13:13

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

If there were no issues with the child, then she would not have been able to claim anything, for them. Again, what an outsider sees, is one thing, and living with said child, is another.

CheekyBlueKoala · Today 13:17

I definitely agree that the system needs to be fairer. The level of award seems to depend far too much on how well someone is able to articulate their circumstances and complete the application form, which is wholly unfair. Secondly, the assessment focuses on the amount of care a child needs each day, but this doesn't necessarily reflect the additional costs involved. A child with high care needs may not necessarily incur significant extra expenses, while another child may have relatively lower care needs but face substantial additional costs. I think these are two quite different things and should be recognised separately.

LetMeGoogleThat · Today 13:19

It can be very difficult to quantify! My son received it as a child, and life was just more expensive. Special foods, additional childcare costs, travelling to multiple hospital appointments and me having to take unpaid leave to get him there., not being able to do any group activities so 121 swimming lessons etc. And also, it doesn't sit right that its having to prove you have a disability, and why shouldn't they have privacy and dignity without having to share this with the world. Needing a diagnosis for EHCP, is a failure on the part of the LA. Im old enough to remember the previous system, where needs = support and LAs didn't haemorrhage the SEN budget on fighting parents and lawyers! The draft SEN code partially recognises this.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 13:22

Thing is, alot of the stuff is sort of hidden. Yet people think because it isn't 'obvious' the there is no impact.

So my child appears to be high functioning for example, but I'm not telling people about his weekly counselling sessions for OC an anxiety. Up until last week those were free as referred vi the NHS- but he has been discharged as his needs will go on for longer than they can give him and we will be paying from now on.

The additional costs for everyday items like fabric conditioner because he washes his clothes after one wear and uses enormous amounts of conditioner due to sensory issues (we spend about £11 a week on fabric conditioner alone).

The amount we spend on hair shampoo because he can only tolerate a certain brand (we go through a bottle every 3 days - £21 a week). The additional costs of heating as he cannot bear to wear clothes at home except underwear and a vest etc. The fact that he cannot tolerate a fear of pens running out of ink so he buys a new pack of biros twice a week at a rough cost of £10 (from TG JOnes only, as it has to be that shop- god knows what we do now its going out of business).

The fact he can't walk terribly far as the sensation of walking freaks him out so we have to use paid for parking often if we need to go somewhere etc etc etc. People will say 'But everyone has to wash their clothes, their hair, buy pens, pay for parking sometimes' etc. But it adds up. And that is for someone 'high functioning' with no obvious impacts on our finances. It's the more obvious things people point to and say 'well fair enough'. But his SEN comes with a very real cumulative cost - and although apparently trivial and minor in themselves it adds up to a significant impact on our finances and a corresponding knock on affect on his and our wellbeing as a family.

x2boys · Today 13:23

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

It goes off need not diagnosis
Its entirely possible your child wouldnt have met the criteria for DLA do there is no need to be a martyr.

Seawolves · Today 13:58

Physiotherapy. What the NHS provides wasn't fit for his needs. Private physio has pushed his development to a place we were told he'd never achieve. Physio now costs me more than his DLA is so I eat into my savings to provide the additional costs associated with needing extra continence pads, inco pads, adapted clothing, extra shoes for splints/no splints, extra heating, extra water costs, additional costs on holiday like hiring in a mobile hoist and hospital bed etc etc.

PocketSand · Today 15:09

@CheekyBlueKoalait is inconceivable that a child with high care needs can have those needs met with no or low additional care costs. Unless you are assuming that the actual care will be provided for free or by paying family CA at a pittance. I think that any review of care costs in the context of young people not being eligible to claim PIP and family carers not being eligible to claim CA needs to look at the cost of providing care if funding is removed and care has to be provided by paid carers.

So at a minimum family carers have to provide 35 hours of care. So the cost of care at a minimum is 35 hours a week at national minimum wage before additional costs of disability.

The cost of providing care is the largest element and there is no rational argument that parents of 18-24 year olds should provide this for free to a dependant adult child.

JennyForeigner · Today 15:14

I claim for my neurodiverse child because to give her any kind of comparable quality of life and safety to her brothers costs hugely. Everything out of the house is personalised and 2:1. She needs sensory equipment and clothes and food she can tolerate. Nothing is just shared around the family.

Not to mention that DLA paid for her assessment in the first place. Without it, we would have been on the waiting list for two more years for something that is and pretty much always have been, entirely obvious.

roundincircle · Today 15:40

Late teens dd uses most of their pip for transport. She’s a student and works part time. She has a physical disability and uses a wheelchair. She’s in uni three days a week and travels in from home. She pays to be taken and picked up by taxi on those days at a cost of 30 pounds per day. Getting a bus is literally impossible. There’s never room or they just drive right past her. She’s learning to drive and will use her mobility element to get an adapted car which is going to cost her an upfront fee if 4000 pounds that she won’t get back at the end of the hire term. And once she uses her mobility element in a car she will no longer be able to hire the wheelchair that she uses, you can’t have both. She does have a chair from wheelchair services but it’s huge, cumbersome and uncomfortable. So she has been hiring a more suitable one for the last year.

dd would much prefer better disabled transport on buses and trains (the reason motability scheme exists is because of the lack of accessible transport) so she can just simply go to work, study, attend appointments, socialise like everyone else.

FriggadyDiggady · Today 15:42

Fags and McDonalds.
Put your pitchforks down! The fags are for the kids.

Happyindevon · Today 15:44

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 13:22

Thing is, alot of the stuff is sort of hidden. Yet people think because it isn't 'obvious' the there is no impact.

So my child appears to be high functioning for example, but I'm not telling people about his weekly counselling sessions for OC an anxiety. Up until last week those were free as referred vi the NHS- but he has been discharged as his needs will go on for longer than they can give him and we will be paying from now on.

The additional costs for everyday items like fabric conditioner because he washes his clothes after one wear and uses enormous amounts of conditioner due to sensory issues (we spend about £11 a week on fabric conditioner alone).

The amount we spend on hair shampoo because he can only tolerate a certain brand (we go through a bottle every 3 days - £21 a week). The additional costs of heating as he cannot bear to wear clothes at home except underwear and a vest etc. The fact that he cannot tolerate a fear of pens running out of ink so he buys a new pack of biros twice a week at a rough cost of £10 (from TG JOnes only, as it has to be that shop- god knows what we do now its going out of business).

The fact he can't walk terribly far as the sensation of walking freaks him out so we have to use paid for parking often if we need to go somewhere etc etc etc. People will say 'But everyone has to wash their clothes, their hair, buy pens, pay for parking sometimes' etc. But it adds up. And that is for someone 'high functioning' with no obvious impacts on our finances. It's the more obvious things people point to and say 'well fair enough'. But his SEN comes with a very real cumulative cost - and although apparently trivial and minor in themselves it adds up to a significant impact on our finances and a corresponding knock on affect on his and our wellbeing as a family.

£30 a week on fabric softener and shampoo? Even putting a load through and washing hair daily it shouldn’t be that much?! Softener is also hideously bad for health & environment

quirkychick · Today 15:48

Lots of things:
Cover for wheelchair,
Extra washing, sensitive washing liquid,
Extra pads/nappies, as not enough provided,
Speech and Language Therapy, as not adequate,
Sensory Therapy, while waiting for Tribunal to award it,
Crelling harness for car (as unsafe),

I could go on.

BigBrownBoogyingBear · Today 16:04

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

It didn't even occur to us to claim DLA for autistic DS1, even though I had to give up work to look after him. He's 16 now and I'm back at work, but earning a lot less than I used to. DH earns a decent wage but not by MN standards 🤣

Boomer55 · Today 16:08

The government say they are looking as to why a ND child needs more money than any other parent dependent child.

I don't know the answers, but best leave it to the professionals. 🤷‍♀️

Stuckintheswing · Today 16:11

Breakages and repairs.
Energy and water costs (extra laundry and showering due to sensory needs).
Specific food and multiple options to make sure she eats something. I don't want to be dealing with an eating disorder on top of everything else.

Some was spent on counselling but as my teen is pretty much mute that only lasted a few sessions. I'm hoping she'll pick it up again when she's ready.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 16:24

Happyindevon · Today 15:44

£30 a week on fabric softener and shampoo? Even putting a load through and washing hair daily it shouldn’t be that much?! Softener is also hideously bad for health & environment

That's right. And you are right it shoudn't be that much. It wouldn't be for 'normal' usage, but it's not normal usage. These are sensory issues, so DS is in the shower 2 times a day and sometimes gets up in the middle of the night to shower again. He uses so much shampoo and hand soap that it clogs the shower regularly with soapy scum. He goes through a multi pack of Imperial leather hand soap every week. He is obsessed with cleanliness. He has OCD, autism, adhd, tourettes etc. He looks 'normal'. No-one would look at hm ad think there is such an issue. He washes so often his skin bleeds. This morning I had to mop up blood from the bahtroom because he has literally rubbed his skin raw.

He only uses certain types of shampoo and certain types of fabric conditioner.

So, yes. It DOES cost that much, and no it shouldn't. But that is our reality, and forms a small part of the hidden costs that we suffer each and every week.

And to be frank, I don't have the energy to care about how bad softener is for the environment. Its hard enough for my family to survive each day in working order.

x2boys · Today 16:26

Boomer55 · Today 16:08

The government say they are looking as to why a ND child needs more money than any other parent dependent child.

I don't know the answers, but best leave it to the professionals. 🤷‍♀️

Edited

Well its a massive spectrum for one thing
And some wont qualify
For my son hes 16 but cogntivly like a toddler
Hes very destructive and obsessed with waster so will reguletly flood the kitchen and bathroom given half the chanch
Im always bying new clothes as he strips off everywhere and drops food drink etc down them so they dont last long
He will pour anything he can get his hands down the sink
So soap toothpaste
Washing pods
Cleaning stuff etc he knows my hinding places and im running out of places to hide them
I do a lot of washing so washing machines dont last long
He broke my dryer as he constantly yanking the door the list is endless.

seahorsessky · Today 16:28

I know quite a lot of people who don't get it (despite very obvious physical disabilities-not that it should matter, but for those who say it's made up, you wouldn't need to be a doctor to see it), who spend hundreds a month on medical appointments, devices, and therapies not provided by the NHS. This should be made free, because if your argument is society says people are lying/spending PIP money on luxuries, then only those people who actually need the treatments would apply.

Budgiedrama · Today 16:35

Would people be in favour of a receipt system where they submit the receipts once a year when renewing their claim? Because this is the only way I can see of working out if the extra money goes on what it’s supposed to.

CatchALeaf · Today 16:38

Some parents may need it to pay bills, as one parent is caring for the disabled child, whereas if the child wasn't disabled they might both be able to work more