Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A review on what people spend DLA/PIP for children on

173 replies

DoaBetterReview · Today 12:40

After seeing all the controversy over the Milburn review and knowing first hand through family and work exactly where the majority of people claiming for dc spend their DLA/PIP I think there actually needs to be a better review conducted where they gather info on what it’s spent on to then identify the weak areas where they need to concentrate funding and efforts.

What is being proposed now is just support in the wrong place at the wrong time ! By 18-24 anyone with ND or MH issues are really struggling so significantly that it could be useless.

Everyone I know getting DLA or PIP for a child / young person is spending it on timely access to diagnosis and/or therapies. This is where the focus needs to be.

Also I’m still shocked at the language around PIP - IT IS NOT AN OUT OF WORK BENEFIT!!! Why is being referred to as if it is a lot of the time.

OP posts:
BeLemonMoose · Today 17:33

Also in the milburn review the most disabled children will get a higher lifetime award than nowl

Kirbert2 · Today 17:34

Budgiedrama · Today 16:49

@CatchALeaf they might, but they might not even if their child didn't have a disability. If your child regularly goes to school 9-3 there is no reason you shouldn’t work.

Depends what you mean by regularly.

My son goes to mainstream 9-3 in theory but has regular appointments including therapy, school meetings, hospital appointments and hospital admissions aren't unusual either, especially during this time of year.

No one in their right mind would give me a job. Especially when many others are available and don't need the huge amount of flexibility I would.

I was let go from my last job due to all the time off I had.

I'm also a human being and need to sleep sometimes which more likely happens during the day when he's at school.

Budgiedrama · Today 17:35

I don’t think DLA is going on fags and Mac Donald’s btw. Most people need it. But my argument is that if you didn’t need it, you could get it anyway. It’s not rigorously assessed like PIP. Maybe it should be, everything else is.

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 17:36

Budgiedrama · Today 17:02

@hibernatinghedgehogif an employer didnt let you have time off for school meetings, they could quickly be found guilty of discrimination. My boss has children with multiple disabilities herself.

That's rubbish. Do you think a ward nurse can just take time off in the middle of a shift for a school meeting/ care meeting/therapy appointment 1 1/2 hour round trip away? Or a bus driver or a teacher? They'll get sacked. No employer is ever 'quickly' found guilty of discrimination, the courts have massive backlogs and tribunals cost money, energy and time that families with disabled children do not have spare,plus what are they living off for the 18 months it takes to get to tribunal? And what section of the Equality Act do you think this discrimination comes under if the employee is the parent not the disabled person?

You don't have any idea what you are talking about.

SENsupportplease · Today 17:36

Art therapy
Talking therapy

Neither of which we have been able to get via NHS or CAMHS

Tutor for English and science to help her with ADHD strategies

Replacement tights almost daily as she rips through them but they are part of the school uniform

Imported melatonin gummies as GP withdrew prescription

Gummy iron supplements as she is anaemic and can’t cope with tablets or liquid

Her very limited diet costs more than a standard diet

The days she can’t cope with the school bus so I have to take her.

The hours I can’t work because she still needs me for her hair, her bedtime, getting ready, her homework, far more than another child her age. Even more hours I can’t work becuase I spend them fighting school and the NHS for basic support.

expand that to - my prescription needs for stress and anxiety meds.

it’s endless and DLA doesn’t cover it.

Whatalunatic · Today 17:37

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

But the criteria for claiming DLA isn't can your child eat well and attend childcare?

cupfinalchaos · Today 17:38

LetMeGoogleThat · Today 13:19

It can be very difficult to quantify! My son received it as a child, and life was just more expensive. Special foods, additional childcare costs, travelling to multiple hospital appointments and me having to take unpaid leave to get him there., not being able to do any group activities so 121 swimming lessons etc. And also, it doesn't sit right that its having to prove you have a disability, and why shouldn't they have privacy and dignity without having to share this with the world. Needing a diagnosis for EHCP, is a failure on the part of the LA. Im old enough to remember the previous system, where needs = support and LAs didn't haemorrhage the SEN budget on fighting parents and lawyers! The draft SEN code partially recognises this.

You don’t even think one should have to prove there’s a disability?

x2boys · Today 17:38

Budgiedrama · Today 17:35

I don’t think DLA is going on fags and Mac Donald’s btw. Most people need it. But my argument is that if you didn’t need it, you could get it anyway. It’s not rigorously assessed like PIP. Maybe it should be, everything else is.

Swings and roundabouts
I found The PIP form alot more straightforward then The DLA form.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · Today 17:39

Dd pip therapy and emdr for trauma from school and severe phobia She won’t get that from nhs. All that offer is talking therapy as not deemed critical

medication costs. Private prescription plus nhs prescription plan

plus I spend a lot of money on things like supplements. Special foods and so on.

carers allowance. A monthly massage for me and two week therapist for me to keep me sane having a agraphobic mentally ill autistic young adult.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · Today 17:41

Welfare Rights Advisor here:

IME low income families tend to put DLA into the general housekeeping money rather than ring fencing it for specific "disability related" costs.
This is legitimate because disabled children also need the rent to be paid and the lights to be kept on.
As PP said- there will be ways in which family life is more expensive because of that disabled child.

Going up the income scale you start to see things like:
Paying for diagnoses
Paying for private therapy
Specific activities and groups to help the child's development.

Putting money aside into a trust for the child's future. (Particularly important if the child's needs are likely to be lifelong.

Growing number of people use it to partially replace the mothers (almost always the mother!) wages, allowing her to home school. Often as a last resort because school has let the child down.

SENsupportplease · Today 17:41

Budgiedrama · Today 17:14

What I feel is that DLA is unfair. It’s unfair because life is so hard, for many parents, particularly single parents, and DLA is not a true reflection of whose needs are greater.
I see some families where the mum has three kids, who are traumatised from domestic abuse, and she doesn’t drive, and yet she has to get a bus too and from a supermarket job. Which she will get sacked from after all her kids have caught every bug going, as they’re living off crap food with no nutritional value. And then when shes sacked she’ll be back having to spend 30 hours a week job seeking.
Yet there are middle class families who don’t even need the money who apply, after getting a private diagnosis for their one highly academic child who goes to school every day and will probably go to guides and off on camp. And the mum was never going to work anyway but now she gets carers and no work commitments. Because the form is just an exercise in writing in a persuasive way, which luckily the mum is great at as she went to Cambridge…
They don’t even need the money and it goes on nice things. But unlike PIP you can write the answers in a way that emphasises certain things and hides others. And no one is ever declined, not that I’ve heard of.
And the money really should go to families who are barely existing, who are going to food banks and scraping by on Tesco wages and UC top ups.

A single mum with threes kids who is on minimum wage will be entitled to plenty of other benefits.

and if a traumatised kid has the need they would also get DLA

DLA isn’t unfair

a child who will NEVER reach their potential, who can never live a ‘normal’ life, who can’t have relationships, who’s siblings are secondary through no fault of their own

thats what’s unfair

Velumental · Today 17:41

We started claiming DLA for my son for 2 reasons, firstly I had to reduce my hours and change jobs due to frequent hospitalisations and difficulty a cessing childcare and education settings because he struggled to attend even nursery age 1 let alone school age 8. He grows faster than the average child now being 4foot 9 and 6 stone at 8 yrs old so it's constant buying of shoes and clothes. He struggles to sleep and has sensory needs so we access a play club and a trampoline park with an sessions. he was a runner so we had to run a. Second car (he doesn't get the mobility component despite this but sometimes he just can't be safely walked places so the car is necessary)

Parenting him DOES cost more than parenting his younger sister, I've always thought of her as neurotypicl but she's been referred for ASD assessment since starting school, she however manages so much better and the impact on our practical and financial aspects of our lives just hasn't been there. But then she accesses a lot of things because her brother does as she has been a tagalong.

We've not used it to access diagnosis etc because we've been fortunate to have enough neurology input to justify the services we access.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · Today 17:43

I work part time too and dh works as does my son who is 19. So we are not a family of malingerers It’s just my dd that’s very ill.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · Today 17:46

Just to point out have you got any idea how much money people on carers allowance actually save the government long-term because believe me it’s a lot

Happyindevon · Today 17:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TrainyWainy · Today 17:46

Budgiedrama · Today 16:57

In England and Wales the child DLA caseload rose from 333,000 in 2013 to 682,000 in 2023, a rise of 104%. By 2023 that was around one in sixteen of all children aged nought to fifteen, double the proportion ten years earlier. In England specifically, the Institute for Fiscal Studies puts the share of under-sixteens on DLA at 7.2% in 2025, up from 3.4% in 2016.

Can anyone explain the increase in these figures? We haven’t suddenly evolved to all be disabled, and DLA is based on need not diagnosis so the old ‘people are more aware’ argument doesn’t work here as it’s based on need. So how do roughly twice the amount of children have needs high enough to qualify for this now? Compared to in 2016?

Claiming is, intentionally, a faff. People are less likely to be deterred when the COL crisis means they need the money more.

Budgiedrama · Today 17:49

@TheodoreisntBetherr yeah actually. I’ve worked with many nurses with children with disabilities. I’ve also pulled over on the side of the road on the way to a community visit to join an EHCP review or to speak to the SENCO. If you don’t try, you don’t know. And if you don’t hold these employers accountable nothing will change. If you’re clear that you will need these adaptations and you might need to drop everything to go to your child, they can either accept it or not, but I think many know they’re on very dodgy ground to say ‘no’ straight away. Either you or your partner or even a grandparent need to be the point of contact, there is no reason the default has to be the woman. Too many women leave rather than be inconvenient and boundaried. If you know your worth, and work hard, employers will just have to deal with it. Harder when you have no support I understand that. But why in a two parent household does the woman always become the carer? There are higher divorce rates for parents of disabled children, so women should prioritise their financial independence at all costs. Get the husband to take on some of the admin!

x2boys · Today 17:51

Budgiedrama · Today 17:49

@TheodoreisntBetherr yeah actually. I’ve worked with many nurses with children with disabilities. I’ve also pulled over on the side of the road on the way to a community visit to join an EHCP review or to speak to the SENCO. If you don’t try, you don’t know. And if you don’t hold these employers accountable nothing will change. If you’re clear that you will need these adaptations and you might need to drop everything to go to your child, they can either accept it or not, but I think many know they’re on very dodgy ground to say ‘no’ straight away. Either you or your partner or even a grandparent need to be the point of contact, there is no reason the default has to be the woman. Too many women leave rather than be inconvenient and boundaried. If you know your worth, and work hard, employers will just have to deal with it. Harder when you have no support I understand that. But why in a two parent household does the woman always become the carer? There are higher divorce rates for parents of disabled children, so women should prioritise their financial independence at all costs. Get the husband to take on some of the admin!

An EHCP review is annual .

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 17:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Okay then. Hmm

Berniestavern · Today 17:56

This is the reason why some people are desperate to see a review…shampoo and fabric conditioner. Ye gods.

Happyindevon · Today 17:56

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 17:54

Okay then. Hmm

They are.

I have no doubt your son is mentally distressed but is the answer using taxpayers money to indulge his OCD? I would say no. I don’t see specific brands of laundry softener as something taxpayers money should be spent on.

TigerRag · Today 17:58

Berniestavern · Today 17:56

This is the reason why some people are desperate to see a review…shampoo and fabric conditioner. Ye gods.

Most of us aren't buying a bottle a week

DoaBetterReview · Today 17:58

BeLemonMoose · Today 17:33

Also in the milburn review the most disabled children will get a higher lifetime award than nowl

But no details whatsoever

OP posts:
Happyindevon · Today 17:59

Berniestavern · Today 17:56

This is the reason why some people are desperate to see a review…shampoo and fabric conditioner. Ye gods.

I know.

The problem is we are suddenly inundated with people insisting they ‘need’ very specific, arbitrary items which are far from actually necessary. And that they’ll actually self harm or something if they don’t get them.

Where do you draw the line.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:00

DoaBetterReview · Today 17:58

But no details whatsoever

Yep.

I'll believe it when I see it.